HNHacker News
TopNewBestAskShowJobs

Kerb_

283 karma · joined July 11, 2023

submissionscomments
Kerb_··on Aldous Huxley's Deep Reflection
I love GPT, but it's a robot, not a Buddhist. And it can just as easily argue the opposite:

1. *Mindfulness and Awareness*: - While mindfulness meditation promotes non-reactivity, it doesn't necessarily mean one shouldn't make judgments. It's about recognizing thoughts and feelings without becoming overwhelmed by them. In daily life, judgments are sometimes necessary for decision-making and discernment.

2. *Right Speech*: - The principle of Right Speech doesn't mean avoiding judgments altogether. Instead, it's about speaking truthfully and kindly. There are instances in Buddhist scriptures where the Buddha himself made judgments about the actions and intentions of others, but he did so with compassion and clarity.

3. *Metta (Loving-kindness)*: - Cultivating metta doesn't mean withholding judgments; it means approaching situations with an open heart. One can have loving-kindness and still recognize unwholesome actions in others or oneself.

4. *Dukkha (Suffering)*: - Recognizing suffering in all beings fosters compassion, but it doesn't negate the need for judgments. Compassion and judgment are not mutually exclusive. One can understand someone's suffering and still judge their actions as unskillful.

5. *The Nature of Thoughts*: - Although thoughts are temporary and fleeting, they can still have real-world consequences. Recognizing the impermanent nature of thoughts doesn't mean we shouldn't make judgments; it means we should do so with awareness and care.

6. *Non-self (Anatta)*: - Understanding the concept of anatta can indeed reduce fixed views and judgments. However, it doesn't mean that judgments based on observed actions and consequences are invalid.

7. *The Parable of the Poisoned Arrow*: - This parable encourages direct action over unnecessary speculation. But this doesn't mean one should never judge or evaluate situations. It's about prioritizing immediate needs over theoretical or philosophical debates.

In summary, while Buddhism encourages a non-judgmental attitude in many respects, it doesn't advocate for a complete absence of judgment. Instead, it emphasizes the importance of "wise judgment" or discernment. The goal is to strike a balance between understanding and compassion on one hand, and the necessity of making judgments in our daily lives on the other.

And to go even further, it is capable of seeing the second persons harsh response as a valid interpretation of Buddhism.

The second person's critique leans towards the idea that spiritual practices should not be used as an escape mechanism from the challenges of daily life, but instead as tools to confront and understand them. From a Buddhist perspective, there are teachings and examples that support Person 2's viewpoint:

1. *Mindfulness of Daily Activities*: - In the Satipatthana Sutta, the Buddha outlined the practice of mindfulness in everyday activities, such as walking, eating, and even breathing. This is not about escaping reality but being fully present in every moment, regardless of its nature.

2. *Engaged Buddhism*: - Thich Nhat Hanh, a Vietnamese Zen monk, introduced the concept of Engaged Buddhism. It emphasizes applying Buddhist teachings in social and political realms, confronting societal issues rather than retreating from them.

3. *Avoiding Spiritual Materialism*: - Chögyam Trungpa, a Tibetan Buddhist teacher, warned about "spiritual materialism", which is the use of spirituality to bolster one's ego or escape from real-life challenges. Truly embracing Buddhist teachings means confronting and understanding one's ego, not using practices to inflate or escape it.

4. *The Middle Way*: - The Buddha's teaching of the Middle Way is about avoiding extremes. While it's beneficial to experience deep calm, it's also essential to remain engaged with the world and not use this calm as an escape mechanism.

5. *Facing Mara*: - In Buddhist texts, before attaining enlightenment, the Buddha faced Mara, a demonic figure representing temptation, doubt, and fear. Instead of escaping or avoiding Mara, the Buddha confronted and acknowledged these challenges, showing the importance of facing difficulties head-on.

6. *The Parable of the Two Arrows*: - In the Sallatha Sutta, the Buddha describes the parable of the two arrows. The first arrow represents the unavoidable pain or discomfort we might experience, while the second arrow is the additional suffering we inflict upon ourselves through our reactions. Escaping or ignoring the pain (like "zenning out" during uncomfortable situations) might mean that we're not addressing the root causes of our suffering.

While Person 1's practices might offer personal relief and spiritual experiences, Person 2's critique, based on Buddhist teachings, suggests that using meditation solely as an escape can be a form of avoidance. True Buddhist practice encourages confronting and understanding the nature of suffering and reality.

All this considered, maybe we should craft our own thoughts instead of letting robots interpret complex social nuances so we can post drive-by hot takes online with minimal effort. At least bowsamic is posting their own thoughts instead of copypasting a wall of automated confirmation bias.

Kerb_··on Adverse Events Following the BNT162b2 mRNA Covid-19 Vaccine
Yours was the only comment they could have replied to, I think they were just excited to engage their own confirmation bias by pretending it answers questions. Look at the author on their website. "Tyler Durden". I don't think the Fight Club main character is an authority on this topic. And I'm gonna break HN etiquette a little to say anyone roleplaying Tyler or citing someone roleplaying Tyler isn't worth listening to either.
Kerb_··on Those trying to pick AI winners should remember the dotcom days
It's a little bit of both in my case
Kerb_··on Hexadecimal clock counting down to 2038 problem
>Why didn’t past generations consider these ramifications for future generations? 2000 must have seemed so far away, but now it’s so close I bet even in 2000 and beyond people will still be reading this comment. Maybe they will be cursing us for the tech debt they inherited!

~Not enough people in 1985, I guess. They seem more concerned with leap years than anything. https://groups.google.com/g/net.bugs/c/ZGlqGwNaq3I

Kerb_··on Ask HN: Have you had any of your work falsely detected as being generated by AI?
I've got a reddit history a decade back with "however", "likewise", "it's important to consider/remember". I have no doubt if I re-posted/commented some of my posts, I would be accused of being an AI. I think some of us just write in a way that people will assume is robotic, especially when given a chance to revise our works for efficient communication.
Kerb_··on Cannabis use disorder and subsequent risk of depression and bipolar disorder
My brother was almost denied clearance because he saw a therapist when he was mentally healthy yet personally struggling just to ensure that he didn't have any metal issues
Kerb_··on TSA officers accused of stealing from passengers
TSA are not what I would consider Airport Professionals
Kerb_··on Single-bladed floating wind turbine promises half the cost, more power
We can walk and chew gum ya know?
Kerb_··on Where did the Carter White House's solar panels go? (2010)
Source?
Kerb_··on Why has a useless cold medication been allowed on shelves for years?
It wasn't put behind the counter because meth makers were buying out the entire supply and leaving people with colds with none. It was put behind the counter to attempt to minimize meth makers buying it at all.
Kerb_··on Unity shuts two offices because of credible threats
If that were true we wouldn't have needed to make OSHA
Kerb_··on U.S. cancels program aimed at identifying potential pandemic viruses
China hiding evidence of a pandemic-grade virus is exactly why it spread globally before anyone was able to do Jack shit about it
Kerb_··on Researchers use AI to find new magnetic materials
And are pretty cheap to produce relative to mine at this point
Kerb_··on California's plastic bag ban is failing
How much do you suppose you need to be paid for picking up the spoon and putting it in your mouth? Taking out the trash should be basic self maintenance
Kerb_··on AI-generated child sex imagery has every US Attorney General calling for action
The feds would probably be able to use metadata and facial recognition comparison against existing CSAM databases to verify many such cases. And investigators would likely use hints such as the image resolution or comparison to other images on the drive to verify if a collection is a photoshoot or a crafted prompt for example.
Kerb_··on AI-generated child sex imagery has every US Attorney General calling for action
An AI that puts child faces on young adult bodies would still likely be considered AICSAM, and wouldn't need to be trained on any real CSAM
Kerb_··on Get a cable modem, go to jail (1999)
I agree with almost all of this, but a lot of the people who point loaded guns at their crotches act like normal people at the range or shoot at unsupervised DNR land
Kerb_··on Therapy isn't fixing America's mental health crisis
Tbh that sounds like a lack of initiative on your part. Hearing out people's basic experiences is a good way to socially engage with people
Kerb_··on Portal 64 – A demake of Portal for the Nintendo 64
Our free time is likely dwarfed by the labor spent on inefficient means towards inefficient ends if we're going to this level of analysis though
Kerb_··on AI model weight providers should not police uses, no matter how awful they are
Lotta old redditors swapping over to other social media sites around then
Kerb_··on Armed with traffic cones, protesters are immobilizing driverless cars
According to the International Energy Agency, cars emit between 57 and 322 gCO2-eq/pkm—compared to buses at just 22-92 gCO2-eq/pkm, and trains at 6-118 gCO2-eq/pkm. That metric meaning “grams of carbon dioxide-equivalent per passenger-kilometer”. They are also just massively safer to ride.

https://climate.mit.edu/explainers/public-transportation#:~:....

So driverless busses would probably be a better outcome than driverless taxis. Does a driverless electric bus fall under "any bus"? This group targets individual transport systems like robotaxis, and similar developments in the field of public transit would probably not be targeted by this group as such.

Kerb_··on Armed with traffic cones, protesters are immobilizing driverless cars
They argue for "public transit, walking and bikes" according to their website. Bikes are mainly how they choose to protest, but they want accessible public transit. Your last sentence is phrased like a "gotcha" but seems like a disingenuous way to say that young members of the community are organizing over this cause.
Kerb_··on So Long, Twitter and Reddit
This isn't Reddit.
Kerb_··on People in a genetic database have segments of DNA in common unexpectedly often
Why not take DNA from randomly selected trashcans, since discarded waste can be used to steal DNA

https://www.usatoday.com/story/news/nation/2023/07/20/police....

Kerb_··on ChatGPT turned generative AI into an “anything tool”
To have the social and physical capabilities to create and pass on the concepts of "fishing rod" and "car" as well as how to use them. We did start from scratch, after all. But I think the learning of simple, complex, abstract, and nuanced concepts throughout a person's development as their brain grows is more than enough to compare to an artificial general intelligence without taking into account development of a species, considering we're the ones building the chips the AI is running on.
Kerb_··on ChatGPT turned generative AI into an “anything tool”
Remember that people have decades of generalized training before becoming able to perform tasks with very simple instructions. I would consider years of pre-training to be acceptable if the model is usable and trainable quickly in practice as well
Kerb_··on Coffee grounds make concrete 30% stronger
It would still probably be a better carbon capture plan than capturing it for temporary use in the fuel supply as ethanol. But worse of a measure than just burying the trees
Kerb_··on We are witnessing the first stages of civilization’s collapse
"Get organized in your community" seems just as vague as "we need to change" when the response requires global action, in my opinion. Reading and commenting on articles is how many people process and understand the contents of the articles and fit it in to their framework when deciding what actions are "constructive" and which are "destructive". Coming to terms with the idea that our quality of life might need to lower in order to continue at all is something we all need to consider. It's not unfair to vocalize that.
Kerb_··on How Hinge's algorithm decides who you date
Maybe the part you're missing from my comment is that you have proven just as little yourself, and there is precedent for both.

Because you want to ignore that and nitpick that I mentioned other apps doing the same thing, as if that prevents Tinder from doing it, I went out of my way to get a screenshot of my own Tinder settings. What do you know? It's right here. "Only show people in this range" https://imgur.com/a/yt34L2b

Upon further reflection, I'm just going with "they were actually correct".

Kerb_··on South Korea's biggest telco says 5G has failed to deliver
After the Bambu malfunction, I'm imagining a thousand self driving cars backing through the garage door in the middle of the night and driving to a location creating massive traffic jams for everyone to wake up to
← PreviousPage 5 of 7Next →