HNHacker News
TopNewBestAskShowJobs

Keysh

508 karma · joined October 10, 2016

submissionscomments
Keysh··on Nakatomi Space
Ironically, the Greenglass-directed Bourne films that the quotes refer to are more like Bond than the very first Bourne film (The Bourne Identity, directed by Doug Liman). In that film, Bourne travels by boat to Marseilles, by train to Zurich, and then by impulsively-hired-car-driven-by-sketchy-woman to Paris. (And then by stolen car to someplace in rural France.)

In the second Bourne film (the first one directed by Greenglass), he starts off in Goa, then shows up in an airport in Italy, and later appears (with no indication of how he travels) in Munich, Berlin, Moscow, and New York City.

And, honestly, there wasn't a whole lot of visible "travel" in the "old" Bond, either. Bond is an agent of MI6, often with a cover as some kind of rich businessman or playboy. So of course he travels everywhere by passenger plane. (Unless he's doing some covert infiltration by parachute or surfboard or whatever.) The difference between Bond and (later) Bourne in terms of travel is that Bond has the resources of a wealthy government, while Bourne has... some kind of ninja superpower, I guess. In both cases, they mostly just translate invisibly from place to place.

Keysh··on Spanish astronomer discovers new active galaxy
Well, yeah. I was looking at the Veron-Cetty & Veron (2010; http://adsabs.harvard.edu/abs/2010A%26A...518A..10V) catalog recently, and it has more than 30,000 AGN galaxies (not counting the > 100,000 quasars/QSOs).

An AGN in a satellite galaxy of a nearby massive galaxy would be a bit interesting; but unfortunately this wasn't such a thing.

Keysh··on Spanish astronomer discovers new active galaxy
Not sure if this was addressed to me, but in case it was: I actually did my Ph.D. thesis on double-barred galaxies, and have continued to work on and off on barred galaxies over the years; here's a partial list of paper's I (Peter Erwin) have authored or co-authored on the subject: https://ui.adsabs.harvard.edu/search/fq=%7B!type%3Daqp%20v%3...
Keysh··on Spanish astronomer discovers new active galaxy
Sadly, this is a case of mistaken identity.

I downloaded a Hubble Legacy Atlas mosaic image of the Sombrero Galaxy, and found his galaxy ("Iris"), right where he said it was. From the appearance (and the color figures in his paper), it's a nice strongly barred spiral (something I study a lot). Given the very small angular size (roughly 4 arc seconds in diameter), it's probably hundreds of megaparsecs (well over a billion light years) or more away, and so not associated with the Sombrero Galaxy (which is at a distance of only 9 or 10 megaparsecs).

The object is not in the NASA Extragalactic Database (not surprising for something so mall and distant). If you search near its position in Simbad, you do indeed get "PSO J190.0301-11.6124" (listed as "globular cluster candidate"), just as he found -- but it's crucial to note that the latter object's position differs by about nine arc seconds from the position of the "Iris" galaxy. If you look at the Hubble image, you can see a compact, slightly elliptical object at the position of PSO J190.0301-11.6124; its appearance is consistent with being a "globular cluster candidate" associated with the halo of the Sombrero Galaxy. But all the deductions about possible distances, spectral energy distributions, etc., are vitiated by the misidentification.

So while this is a galaxy, it's way, way beyond the Sombrero Galaxy, and I doubt the claimed X-ray source association, so it's probably not an active galaxy. (Well, it could be, but we probably don't have any evidence for that.)

Keysh··on Modern Computer Architecture and Organization - Second Edition (2022)
Fractions = rational numbers, which are an infinitely small subset of the real numbers. The rest of the reals are irrational numbers, of which pi and e are examples.
Keysh··on A Fistful of Tropes
_when pacific islanders roll up trying to create indentured servitude on mars, we can expand & adjust the models and definition as needed. But for now there's no value in attempting to generalize, the narrow model fits the conditions we are presented with._

If you could travel to Mars in an open-air vehicle, and then land and survive on the surface wearing nothing more than ordinary clothing, and get your water from local streams and rivers, and grow crops on the surface with no special effort -- _and_ if Mars was already inhabited by human societies adapted to the land, whose food you could eat, with technology roughly equivalent or somewhat below yours, and political divisions you could exploit, and wealth and products you could extract -- well, then your European-colonialism analogies might have some relevance.

The reality is "the narrow model" (of European colonialism) doesn't remotely fit "the conditions we are presented with"... But we seem to be in the mode of "when all you have is a hammer, everything looks like a nail": when all you know is European history, European history is the only possible model.

(Really, something like the Maori colonization of New Zealand -- which had no pre-existing population, and required the settlers to bring their own crops and scout for resources for making tools -- is _marginally_ more relevant. Even more relevant are things like research stations in Antarctica, where -- again -- there's no pre-existing population, and where you simply _can't_ grow food locally or easily survive outdoors.)

Keysh··on A Fistful of Tropes
Would it make any sense to describe the Polynesian settlement of Pacific islands as "nazi bullshit"? (Granted, we have little or no access to proto-Maori ideologies of the 13th Century, say, but discussions of what "colonization" is or means tend to be really Eurocentric...)
Keysh··on A Fistful of Tropes
It's kind of interesting to read about contemporary reactions to Night of the Living Dead, which included "it's obviously a commentary on the Vietnam War" and "a critique of American capitalism". The closest anyone got to racial issues was the observation that at the end, the (black) main character is killed by a (white) posse led by a sheriff -- which seemed to some people to be an obvious commentary on the Civil Rights Movement and the recent assassinations of Martin Luther King, Jr., and Malcom X.

The modern (21st C) vogue for zombie apocalypse movies pretty clearly stems from two sources: Japanese video games in the 1990s; and a pair of British films in the early 2000s: Resident Evil (based on one of the aforementioned Japanese video games) and 28 Days Later. (It's a bit hard to argue that both the Japanese and the British were acting out some deep-seated fear of a black slave uprising.)

Keysh··on A Fistful of Tropes
Well, it's not as if people originally from Asia went and colonized islands all over the Pacific over the last few thousand years or anything.
Keysh··on JWST spots giant black holes all over the early universe
That means massive black holes have a much lower density that small black holes. So they are more likely to form than small black holes.

No, it doesn't, because you're ignoring all the physics required to get the mass into a small enough region so that it will collapse to form a black hole. The only way to make that happen that we know works is to form massive stars, where a fraction of the star's mass, in the center of the star, will eventually form a black hole. But the largest stars we know of have masses of ~ 200 times the Sun, and so can't form black holes more than a fraction of that.

If you imagine a more massive gas cloud collapsing under its own gravity, it will fragment into subclumps before getting very dense; these subclumps will themselves fragment or go on to form stars directly, but with an upper limit of, say, ~ 200 solar masses.

(It's possible that if you start with a cloud of pristine gas in the early universe -- nothing but hydrogen and helium -- that it might collapse to form a single supermassive star, or even a black hole directly. That might give you something like a 1000-solar-mass black hole. But that's still fairly speculative, and requires unusual conditions that don't exist generally.)

Keysh··on JWST spots giant black holes all over the early universe
... the only way we know that these super massive black holes can form is by smaller black merging.

The main way supermassive black holes in the centers of galaxies grow is by accreting gas, not by mergers with other black holes. (But you can still have potential problems with not being able to accrete enough gas in a short enough time to explain early SMBHs, unless the initial "seed" BHs are larger than those formed by conventional supernovae.)

Keysh··on JWST spots giant black holes all over the early universe
LISA is a scaled-up version of LIGO, and won't produce "photos" any more than LIGO does. Of course, LIGO has provided extremely good evidence that black holes exist (most of what it detects are the gravitational waves from two black holes merging), but if you don't buy that, then you won't buy LISA's observations, either.
Keysh··on A beetle that heads for the ‘back door’ when eaten by a frog (2020)
From the article

"He found that the beetles had similarly high success rates with four other frog species....

"When swallowed, other similar water beetles were killed and digested by the frog...."

Keysh··on Ancient Carthaginians did sacrifice their children (2014)
Quoting from the actual paper:

"As the relationships between scientific practice and social, archaeological and historical interpretations continue to be debated in the discipline at large (McGovern 1995; Jones 2001; Knapp 2002), it should perhaps not come as a surprise that we insist that it is critical that all types or ‘genres’ of evidence be taken into account in relation to the tophets as both a historical phenomenon and a series of archaeological contexts. We all have to work within the limits of our own expertise, whether as scientists, archaeologists, philologists or epigraphers, but we should also strive in the humanities as much as in the sciences to apply the highest standards of academic rigour, without preconceptions, in order to formulate falsifiable hypotheses and interpretations that take into account the full range of available sources—however strange we may find the results..."

I don't know, that sounds like a pretty good "understanding of the scientific process". (Admittedly, I'm just an astrophysicist, so maybe I don't understand "the scientific process".)

Keysh··on Ancient Carthaginians did sacrifice their children (2014)
No the article is about how child sacrifice by Carthaginians was widely accepted by ancient (Greek and Roman) authors, but has been doubted by (some) 20th Century historians and archeologists.
Keysh··on Ancient Carthaginians did sacrifice their children (2014)
Non-paywalled PDF of of the paper (actually both papers in the "Debate" section; the relevant paper is the second one): https://www.academia.edu/download/34987326/XellaEtAlDebate_A...
Keysh··on My Inventions – Nikola Tesla (1919)
Well, he alternated between not believing in the existence of (EM) radio waves at all and claiming that they were useless for transmitting messages, which isn't the same as the luminiferous ether idea.

Belief in a luminiferous ether (that fills all of space) is consistent with the idea that EM waves can travel through space (after all, we can see light coming from the Sun, etc.) and that radio waves could be used.

But Tesla seems to have argued that working "radio" technology was really electrical currents traveling through the ground (or through the ocean in the case of radio on ships), which then somehow induced "reception" in the radio equipment located above the currents.

Keysh··on What time is it on the moon?
GPS is affected by both general and special relativity, in opposite ways. The GR effect is larger, but if you don’t include the SR effect, you’ll get it wrong.

https://www.astronomy.ohio-state.edu/pogge.1/Ast162/Unit5/gp...

Keysh··on Economics Drives Ray-Gun Resurgence
Smoke screens are obviously not going to be useful as defenses for things like missiles, since the smoke immediately slows down when it collides with the air while the missile/projectile continues on at high speed.

(It might be useful in space, where you'd be creating something like a comet's halo, which separates from the body on a much longer timescale.)

Keysh··on Tocharian Languages
The Roman historian Walter Scheidel has a whole book (Escape from Rome) on this question -- basically, exploring the idea that Europe never really reformed a large-scale empire after the Roman Empire started to fall apart in the 5th C, whereas other parts of Eurasia (esp. China) did go through periods of reforming large-scale empires, sometimes larger than past empires in the same region.

Unfortunately, I'm only about halfway through it, so I haven't gotten to the part where he tries to explain why this happened. But so far, it's quite good.

Keysh··on The remarkable emptiness of existence
There were two problems with Einstein's original (1917) cosmological model. The first was what you mention: Einstein assumed the universe was static, but later observations showed this wasn't true. The second was that his static model turned out to be unstable to either expansion or contraction, something he had forgotten to check.
Keysh··on The remarkable emptiness of existence
From the article: > In December 2022, an international team of astronomers released the results of their latest survey of galaxies, and their work has confirmed that the vacuum of spacetime is wreaking havoc across the cosmos. They found that matter makes up only a minority contribution to the energy budget of the universe.

The linked paper -- https://arxiv.org/pdf/2212.11319.pdf -- isn't about measuring dark energy at all. (It's using data from a study meant to do that, but it's looking at something else.)

Also, > This phenomenon has various names: the quantum foam, the spacetime foam, vacuum fluctuations.

This confuses two different phenomena. The vacuum fluctuation of known quantum fields (electromagnetic, electron, Higgs, etc.) is what is thought to give rise to the cosmological constant/dark energy, and is what this article is about. (A limited version of it involving the electromagnetic field produces the Casimir effect, which has been measured.) "Spacetime/quantum foam" is the hypothetical fluctuation of spacetime itself, assuming a quantum theory of gravity. It has nothing to do with dark energy.

Keysh··on The remarkable emptiness of existence
> Dark energy is really the fudge for all this. The idea is that creating new space takes energy. That has to come from somewhere and dark energy is our fudge factor for that. No one really knows what dark energy is or looks like just like we don't know what creating new space looks like. It just solves a conservation problem.

That's simply not true. You don't need energy to create new space (and you wouldn't magically get energy from nowhere if the universe were contracting). General relativity gives you expanding (or contracting) space just fine if dark energy doesn't exist -- in fact, that was the most common cosmological model before the late 1990s discovery that the expansion was accelerating.

The fact that the simplest version of dark energy is the cosmological constant tells us your basic idea is wrong: if that energy was going into creating new space, then it would decrease over time, not remain constant.

In fact, it's worse than that, because the cosmological constant is a constant energy density. So if expansion doubles some volume of intergalactic space, then the total amount of dark energy also doubles (while the total energy in the form of ordinary or dark matter stays the same, and the energy in the form of photons decreases due to redshifting).

Conservation of energy in general relativity is messy and sometimes counter-intuitive; e.g. https://math.ucr.edu/home/baez/physics/Relativity/GR/energy_...

Keysh··on James Webb Telescope reveals Milky Way–like galaxies in young universe
I'm afraid that none of that is correct.
Keysh··on James Webb Telescope reveals Milky Way–like galaxies in young universe
When you have a (rotating) bar, the allowed orbits tend to intersect with each other. This has not effect on the stars, since they're so small relative to the space involved that they never collide; but gas clouds are quite large, and they will intersect with each other. The resulting collisions cause them to lose some of their (orbital) energy and sink onto smaller orbits.

If I remember correctly, a second effect is that the collisions tend to cause the gas to concentrate/pile up near the leading edge of the bar, which causes an offset between the mass of the stars (making up the bar) and bulk of the gas; the stars end up pulling on the gas in the direction opposite to the orbital motion, and so the gas loses energy and angular momentum, shifting onto smaller orbits.

It really has nothing to do with magnetic fields: you readily get this effect in hydrodynamical simulations without any magnetism, and most of the gas in the bar region isn't in the form of plasma anyway (it's primarily a mixture of neutral atomic hydrogen and molecular hydrogen).

Keysh··on Archaeology and genetics can’t yet agree on when humans arrived in the Americas
If you actually look at the link prpi provided, there are several examples. E.g., Atanarjuat: The Fast Runner (yes), Hiawatha, and Kings of the Sun; if you allow animated films, there's Pachamama and The Emperor's New Groove. More recent examples not in that list include the Canadian movies Maina (2013) and Edge of the Knife (2018).
Keysh··on Archaeology and genetics can’t yet agree on when humans arrived in the Americas
> Wikipedia doesn't quote the records associated with 1054

Wait, what? The Wikipedia article on SN 1054 has an extensive discussion of the Chinese records (https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/SN_1054#Chinese_astronomy), as well as Japanese records and the Arabic account of Ibn Butlan.

Keysh··on Archaeology and genetics can’t yet agree on when humans arrived in the Americas
"archaeologists believe that the mound's creation could have been influenced by two different astronomical events: the light from the supernova that created the Crab Nebula"

That's a pretty dubious assertion (and I notice that there aren't any references to which archaeologists supposedly believe this), since:

a) I'm pretty sure there aren't any examples of buildings or structures being "influenced" by this or any other historical supernova in any other cultures; and

b) No mention of the supernova of 1006, which was brighter and longer-lasting than the supernova of 1054?

Keysh··on Anti-War Speech Sent Eugene V. Debs to Prison, 1918
> The same thing happened with Libya and Syria, only now it was the other set of talking points - although again, Qaddafi was promoting pan-African unity, an alternative currency, independence from Europe and the USA on oil sales, closer ties to Russia and China, etc. Assad backed out of a Saudi-USA-Israeli pipeline deal in 2009 and went for the Russia-Iran pipeline instead (plus lots of electricity integration with Iran), so Obama signed off on the CIA overthrow/regime change directive.

Oh, bollocks. In what universe did the US go to war with Assad's regime? The US tepidly tried arming a few of the (non-fundamentalist) rebel groups once they appeared, but nothing more than that. (Presumably you think the Arab Spring uprisings in Tunisia and Egypt were caused by the CIA, too, for some unfathomable reason.) And how, exactly, has the US profited monetarily from what happened in Libya and Syria?

(Gaddafi was actually getting closer to the US and Europe; in 2004 he gave up his nuclear weapons program in return for better relations with the West. As for "pan-African unity" -- sure, from the guy who invaded Chad to steal land from it. No one took his bombast seriously.)

Keysh··on Alexander the Great in Firdawsi's Book of Kings
> it’s quite hard to know exactly what happened back then! For instance, the Greeks would never admit that Alexander was the son of the King of Persia and grandson of Philip. Yes, it’s unlikely but it’s not implausible…

Given that we know about Alexander's parentage from multiple contemporary sources, the idea that a pro-Persian epic poem written 1300 years later is plausible when it tells us something different is not very sensible.

What's probably going on is a bit of retconning to resolve two contrary ideas. On the one hand, by the time Ferdowsi was writing, several hundred years of Arab rule in Iran had made stories about Alexander (who the Arabs thought was pretty awesome) popular. On the other hand, Persians remembered that Alexander had conquered an ancient Persian empire. (We know the pre-Islamic Sassanid Persians hated Alexander.) How do you reconcile this in a patriotic Persian poem?

Solution: make it so Alexander was secretly Persian! (I have no idea whether this was Ferdowsi's innovation or something that had evolved over a few centuries of storytelling prior to Ferdowsi coming along.)

There's a nice discussion of the background to this (including why Ferdowsi did things like refer to Alexander as "Caesar of Rome") here https://www.reddit.com/r/badhistory/comments/20f0yh/historic...

← PreviousPage 3 of 7Next →