HNHacker News
TopNewBestAskShowJobs

Kialo

52 karma · joined August 23, 2016

https://www.kialo.com https://www.kialo-edu.com
submissionscomments
Kialo··on Kialo – a platform for rational debate
If you want to see the full functionality, create a private debate (you'll then have admin rights) and play around in it, incl voting, moving, linking, extracting, copy branching, intermap linking, perspectives, suggesting claims and 5 permission levels. https://www.kialo.com/tour
Kialo··on Kialo – a platform for rational debate
Sure, just click on it and then click on the red + and add your con.
Kialo··on Kialo – a platform for rational debate
Firefox?
Kialo··on Kialo – a platform for rational debate
You can't and we aren't. What is considered rational, is often cultural and builds on very different epistemological systems.

Thus all you can do in a collaborative reasoning platform like ours, is give everybody the tools to portray their reasoning as well as they can.

E.g. an underlying reason for somebody's arguments might be the existence of God. An atheist would consider this irrational, but the logic, given the underlying thesis, might be sound. So in the end, we are going to debate epistemology. Something, I feel, we don't do enough.

Nor are we taught in school enough how (utility vs happiness) to evaluate the different epistemological systems.

Kialo··on Kialo – a platform for rational debate
Could you give some examples of the hidden biases introduced by the theses? I presume you don't mean the way the theses are written, as in for or against the motion, instead of as a question?
Kialo··on Kialo – a platform for rational debate
How would you apply it in our context?
Kialo··on Kialo – a platform for rational debate
Agreed. It seems that the single biggest divider are epistemological systems and the ways people choose which to adhere to. That's a debate which I couldn't convince anyone to start yet.
Kialo··on Kialo – a platform for rational debate
Thanks!
Kialo··on Kialo – a platform for rational debate
Good news everyone...we found a way to monetize :) (Agreed, though you'd probably want demographic data with that, which we deliberately don't have. The best we do have are our follower audience analytics on T / FB. We are happy about every user who signs up with an anonymous email address.)
Kialo··on Kialo – a platform for rational debate
In a multi thesis discussion (https://www.kialo.com/2027) you can propose different theses.

The problem with evolving theses is that they invalidate a huge amount of claims and require many claims to be edited.

Threads, where you are not fixed on a particular thesis are of course often more fun, but bring their own set of problems. When a thread goes on for long enough, the different strands are discussing entirely different bits and pieces and newcomers are completely lost, plus the mixing of claims and commentary...HN is truly exceptional with regards to the quality of contributions and I agree, reading comments here is often a wonderful learning experience, one of the very few sites, where I first open the comments, then the linked article.

And yes, we are a bit dry. It's a bit like Wikipedia article editing, less like an enthusiastic commenting thread (https://twitter.com/KialoHQ/status/954461988960251904). But given the nature of our topics, we are happy about things being a bit drier. :)

Imagine the outcry if we forbade users to create their own discussions. We wouldn't have that tabs vs spaces debate (https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=17486949) :)

Kialo··on Kialo – a platform for rational debate
We had filters already, but removed them about 2y ago...

The hordes would have been an issue, just coming in and downvoting claims that they disagree with.

When we switch from the all votes average, we might introduce them again. For individual perspectives, it would already make sense, you would then only see claims that a particular user voted of at least impact 2 or so.

I would not rely on the "impact votes" today, plus, the average is not really interesting. What is more interesting is how people that agree or disagree with the main thesis voted. (hint: what we'll be building)

Kialo··on Kialo – a platform for rational debate
Agreed. It's one of our main issues, we are effectively three startups:

1 public discussions / repository of the why / community 2 free edtech solution 3 SAAS for decision-making, -preparation, ideation...

We have for now focussed on 1, as we consider it the hardest and most pertinent problem.

2 We are deploying a dedicated edu cluster in 2 weeks. Already quite popular for classroom debates (some Harvard profs being the first to use it), introducing students to controversial issues, etc

3 We provide teams for free right now and are building another cluster for them. (they too do not want to be inundated with gun / atheist debates)

In the end, our core, is something like a wiki technology. When we launched, we didn't know what would stick and now we have all three kind of sticking. 3 being the one that has received the least amount of love till now, as companies seem to be doing ok, regarding decision-making, even though everybody hates emails, chat and meetings...

Kialo··on Kialo – a platform for rational debate
...fortunately, we have got a tool for that ;)
Kialo··on Kialo – a platform for rational debate
We might add another color scheme, exactly for those cases. But the colors, other than for the sunburst in the beginning, aren't really essential (that's at least what our color blind team members tell us) as pros and cons are always on a particular side.

We finished read and navigation accessibility (screenreaders) last month, if anyone knows a great company for testing this, please let us know.

Kialo··on Kialo – a platform for rational debate
I fear that's too easy to game at our scale, given the horde out there.
Kialo··on Kialo – a platform for rational debate
Agreed.

We have a "reputation system" it's the thank count next to usernames. We have not handed out any privileges based on those yet, but will probably soon take all with a certain thank count, look at their contributions and grant them some poweruser rights, e.g. commenting into all public debates and see how that goes.

Kialo··on Kialo – a platform for rational debate
What was it called? We are building this since 2011.
Kialo··on Kialo – a platform for rational debate
If it shows you linking, then link it. (that means you should have permissions to do so)

In discussions where you do not have editor rights, click "view in new tab" copy the url and suggest a claim with text "suggest linking this(link) as a pro (or con)"

We are building suggest linking in a couple of weeks for discussions that you haven't been invited to yet.

Kialo··on Kialo – a platform for rational debate
We don't do anything with the data. We'll probably provide the public discussion corpus anonymized to researchers. It's all too sensitive and some users cannot be dissuaded from using real names. :(
Kialo··on Kialo – a platform for rational debate
You couldn't just let it go...next up emacs vs vi? :)

At least we have a >1k claims Star Wars The Last Jedi (https://www.kialo.com/7055) and Rebel alliance would defeat the United Federation (https://www.kialo.com/9394) debate already. :)

Thank you for your kind words!

Kialo··on Kialo – a platform for rational debate
Regarding democratizing, the problem are the troll hordes out there. One person with many followers tweets out a particular claim and then you'll have the strangest things suddenly appearing at the top. It's the same reason Internet polls don't really work. And the reason we consider the default perspective ALL votes, problematic (we are building something here soon). This is especially a problem due to our topics, primarily very controversal issues. These are the type of topics that very often get edit-locked on Wikipedia because of edit wars and we deal exlusively with them. That's why we built the suggestion system (https://support.kialo.com/hc/en-us/articles/115003791445-Sug...) and 5 permission levels (https://support.kialo.com/hc/en-us/articles/115003877705-Par...).

Suggested claims that were not accepted, aren't deleted. users often argue back and forth with admins on those claims, often edit them and then get them accepted. Very often it's really just a clarification or "could you please add sources" or "do you mind moving this claim over there".

Duplicates are thornier. What we have considered, is linking them to the ones that they supposedly are duplicates of, so you could see them there.

That's possible and we might do it, but we really don't get that many complaints about them. It's really just a problem in the debates with >1k claims. but as more debates grow, this might become more of an issue and then we'll build that.

Thanks for your input.

Kialo··on Kialo – a platform for rational debate
Argh. And support all of them on all platforms, the dev team will shoot me. :)
Kialo··on Kialo – a platform for rational debate
If anyone wants to try out teams (private portal for team discussions etc), please drop us a mail to support@ and we'll enable your account, reference HN.

It's been used in organizational contexts for decision-making, -preparation, -logging, ideation and funnily enough job interviews, where you let people reason a business decision in a given time and then compare their reasoning to others'.

We are right now building dedicated sites for edu (free) and teams, which won't be cluttered up with the public debates.

Yes, SAAS is how we will want to make money at some point in the future. :)

Kialo··on Kialo – a platform for rational debate
We thought that green = pro and red = con, is kind of universally agreed upon, no?

The most common misunderstanding is the one mentioned before, a con to a con, indirectly supports the thesis, but is red.

But changing that around is even more confusing. Especially when the parent to that con is then used as a pro somewhere else (and the con now having to be labeled red again).

We consider pros and cons always to be relating to the parent directly above them. This allows them to be linked or copied between debates, irrespective of what debate they originally were a part of.

Kialo··on Kialo – a platform for rational debate
Well unfortunately, in the large debates, really many duplicates are being submitted. Take the UBI one with close to 3k unique claims. It's really hard to suggest claims that aren't already in there.

If you have specific examples, please point us to them, but we are not aware of any really large (>500 claims) biased debates.

The idea is for claims to be canonical for each debate, otherwise you have to rewrite them a gazillion times, including their children. That's what we have linking for.

Generally speaking, if you think your claim was unfairly rejected, just hit report and we'll look into it.

Having claims rejected as duplicates, happens to us too. :)

If you have any suggestions, other than reporting, and roaming powerusers (which we will introduce soon), please let us know!

Kialo··on Kialo – a platform for rational debate
Ni afable konsentas :)
Kialo··on Kialo – a platform for rational debate
Not sure, what would you want to see in Kialo for that?

We and others have tried that.

We gave experts a multi theses debate and let them discuss the various options (that's also what we do internally when having to decide things) and then looked at the outcome and switched through the perspectives to see what the individual experts thought.

Some use it in that way for board meetings. Instead of receiving memos that don't touch upon each other's points, you receive a Kialo in which all departments added their reasoning for why their favorite solution is good and the others' not.

Kialo··on Kialo – a platform for rational debate
We are waiting for IBM to unleash their Debate AI on us :)
Kialo··on Kialo – a platform for rational debate
That was a tongue-in-cheek example that many (https://developers.google.com/search/docs/data-types/factche...) considered to be lighthearted, uncontroversial and settled. In case you wonder, we agree with this user's debate on the matter :) https://www.kialo.com/7216
Kialo··on Kialo – a platform for rational debate
Well, at least we tell people to vote the claims "impacts" not likability. We haven't yet researched how well this works, but anecdotal evidence suggests that it does have some impact.

The heart, is just a thanks to the original author and doesn't impact the sorting.

We are going to do something drastic to the default impact shown, because we agree that the average is not really an interesting measure. 1-2 months.

I hope we are not overselling ourselves. We are no panacea, what we do, is facilitate and capture the reasoning of all viewpoints. This won't automatically lead to consensus. But at the very least you can now truly understand where others are coming from and write your opposing claims to whatever they consider being their strongest points.

← PreviousPage 2 of 3Next →