HNHacker News
TopNewBestAskShowJobs

Kudzu_Bob

160 karma · joined March 24, 2013

submissionscomments
Kudzu_Bob··on Logical Fallacies Are Usually Irrelevant or Cited Incorrectly
“Most fallacies are like that - they're heuristics which work most of the time. For example, if you see people running in terror in one direction, and you join them, you've committed the bandwagon fallacy, but you're probably right. If you refuse to invest in someone's business because they've been convicted of fraud, that's ad hominem, but you're probably right.”

http://chariotofreaction.blogspot.com/2012/11/slippery-slope...

Kudzu_Bob··on Should we let wunderkinds drop out of high school?
High schools are like prisons to smart kids.
Kudzu_Bob··on Warren Buffett: Success in investing doesn't correlate with IQ
Hsu's claim in this matter is much easier to swallow than your contention that an IQ of 120 is sufficient for eminence in any field. Next you'll be telling us that anybody over five and a half feet tall can play for the Knicks.
Kudzu_Bob··on David Karp Quit School to Get Serious About Tumblr
You seem to labor under the misapprehension that learning things and going to high school have something in common.
Kudzu_Bob··on David Karp Quit School to Get Serious About Tumblr
Karp lost nothing, and gained a great deal. I suspect that he can only shake his head at the notion that anybody with a three-digit IQ would step inside a high school under any circumstances.
Kudzu_Bob··on Warren Buffett: Success in investing doesn't correlate with IQ
Physicist Steve Hsu on Feynman's alleged 125 IQ score:

"Feynman was universally regarded as one of the fastest thinking and most creative theorists in his generation. Yet it has been reported-including by Feynman himself-that he only obtained a score of 125 on a school IQ test. I suspect that this test emphasized verbal, as opposed to mathematical, ability. Feynman received the highest score in the country by a large margin on the notoriously difficult Putnam mathematics competition exam, although he joined the MIT team on short notice and did not prepare for the test. He also reportedly had the highest scores on record on the math/physics graduate admission exams at Princeton. It seems quite possible to me that Feynman's cognitive abilities might have been a bit lopsided-his vocabulary and verbal ability were well above average, but perhaps not as great as his mathematical abilities. I recall looking at excerpts from a notebook Feynman kept while an undergraduate. While the notes covered very advanced topics for an undergraduate-including general relativity and the Dirac equation-it also contained a number of misspellings and grammatical errors. I doubt Feynman cared very much about such things."

http://www.psychologytoday.com/blog/finding-the-next-einstei...

Kudzu_Bob··on Philip Greenspun Reviews “Lean In”
That's because you don't know what bullying is.
Kudzu_Bob··on How Would You Save Journalism?
A much more interesting subject than how we can save journalism is whether journalism can save us.
Kudzu_Bob··on If People Could Immigrate Anywhere, Would Poverty Be Eliminated?
This New York Times article discusses not only why it is so hard for poor people to live New York but also why the cost of living for the affluent is lower there than elsewhere.

http://www.nytimes.com/2013/04/28/magazine/who-says-new-york...

Kudzu_Bob··on More Than 100 Million Worldwide Dream of a Life in the U.S.
America, flophouse to the world.
Kudzu_Bob··on If People Could Immigrate Anywhere, Would Poverty Be Eliminated?
In America, the ruling elites have ways of keeping out the rabble by means of making city life both costly and difficult.
Kudzu_Bob··on Being Really, Really, Ridiculously Good Looking
Gloria Steinem's career arc has been from B-girl to intellectual pickpocket.
Kudzu_Bob··on If People Could Immigrate Anywhere, Would Poverty Be Eliminated?
Open Borders can eliminate poverty only if evolution from the neck up doesn't happen.
Kudzu_Bob··on The Slow and Painful Death of Freedom in Canada
Rightly or wrongly, those who employ capitalized phrases such as "Our Sort" and "Not Our Sort" often fancy themselves ironists.
Kudzu_Bob··on The Slow and Painful Death of Freedom in Canada
The other restrictions aren't aimed at any particular group, and therefore harbor at least the potential to silence Our Sort. But by their very design, hate speech laws only target a bunch of misfit losers who most definitely are Not Our Sort.
Kudzu_Bob··on The Slow and Painful Death of Freedom in Canada
Adam Kingsmith makes no mention of Canada's far more threatening hate speech laws. This article should have been titled "The Slow and Selectively Outrageous Death of Journalism at the Huffington Post."
Kudzu_Bob··on Being Really, Really, Ridiculously Good Looking
Saying that it's tough being beautiful is one of those formulations along the lines of, "Oh, it's such a burden having all this wealth. How I envy the simple, carefree lives of the poor."
Kudzu_Bob··on Being Really, Really, Ridiculously Good Looking
Men's hormonal buttons are being pushed by images of hot women in order to empty their wallets, and you think it's the women who are being exploited. That's rich.
Kudzu_Bob··on Switzerland to restrict EU immigration
Your idea of putting the Swiss in Turkey is unworkable for the simple reason that nobody wants to go there. However, plenty of Turks move to Switzerland, where, I gather, their economic performance continues to be less than stellar. That crisp mountain air can only do so much, it seems.
Kudzu_Bob··on Switzerland to restrict EU immigration
Long after the EU has succumbed to gigantism the Swiss will still be around. To believe that the sick should shun the healthy is an inversion of reality.
Kudzu_Bob··on Being Really, Really, Ridiculously Good Looking
A reporter once asked the Italian giallo director Dario Argento why so many beautiful girls are murdered in his movies. He replied that the dictates of the giallo require that one or more persons die, and that the audience would rather watch beautiful girls being killed than ugly ones.
Kudzu_Bob··on Being Really, Really, Ridiculously Good Looking
Pascal: “Those who are accustomed to judge by feeling do not understand the process of reasoning, for they would understand at first sight, and are not used to seek for principles. And others, on the contrary, who are accustomed to reason from principles, do not at all understand matters of feeling, seeking principles, and being unable to see at a glance.”
Kudzu_Bob··on Switzerland to restrict EU immigration
If I don't know whether my laptop has been stolen or simply forgotten in some coffee house but I accuse you of taking it because I don't like your politics, that makes me a liar.
Kudzu_Bob··on Switzerland to restrict EU immigration
Gotta love that false consciousness.
Kudzu_Bob··on Switzerland to restrict EU immigration
I mean the economy for which we must all bend ourselves into pretzel shapes.
Kudzu_Bob··on Do Elite Colleges Discriminate Against Asians?
Then I guess brain surgery isn't exactly brain surgery, if you know what I mean.
Kudzu_Bob··on Do Elite Colleges Discriminate Against Asians?
Your question isn't really a question, just a clumsy attempt to use shame to stifle open discussion, a technique that goes WAY back. Priests in the Middle Ages used it to keep the peasants in their place, although I imagine that they employed it more effectively than you do.

But here is a real question, one that actually rises to the level of being thought-provoking, just for you:

You have a six-year-old girl who has recently begun to complain of headaches, dizziness, and double-vision. Tests show that she has a tumor in an especially difficult-to-reach part of the brain. If left untreated, she will die, but any attempt to remove the rapidly growing mass has a significant chance of leaving her a vegetable. You must choose between two neurosurgeons, both of whom seemingly have very similar resumes, but one of whom is non-white/non-Asian, the other of whom is white/Asian. Do you choose the former to operate on your little girl, knowing that affirmative action policies may well have greased the skids for him all the way from college to medical school to his residency, or do you pick the latter, for whom no such programs exist?

If you pick the former, then your commitment to egalitarianism is on a par with Abraham's to Yaweh when he bound Jacob to the sacrificial altar.

Kudzu_Bob··on Tech Companies That Only Hire Men
Gaslight much?
Kudzu_Bob··on Stop complaining about the lack of women in tech
That depends on the problem that is being solved. For instance, if your goal is to explain away what is obviously the case, then ignoring or hiding the truth is the ONLY solution. "Pay no attention to that man behind the curtain!"
Kudzu_Bob··on Tech Companies That Only Hire Men
It isn't right. What it is is humiliating. And humiliation is the entire point.
← PreviousPage 3 of 5Next →