HNHacker News
TopNewBestAskShowJobs

Kudzu_Bob

160 karma · joined March 24, 2013

submissionscomments
Kudzu_Bob··on Do Elite Colleges Discriminate Against Asians?
"I wonder what our 'racial' categories would look like if people treated these groupings as a statistical problem, rather than some sort of given natural phenomenon."

The outcome would no doubt have a lot in common with the ugly and ill-fitting suit made for Gulliver by the tailors of Laputa, who used quadrants, rules, and compasses rather than a simple tape measure.

Kudzu_Bob··on Do Elite Colleges Discriminate Against Asians?
That's a potentially life-saving bit of information. Thanks! I shall take steps to avoid letting any doctor who might possibly have been a beneficiary of affirmative action treat me or mine.
Kudzu_Bob··on Switzerland to restrict EU immigration
Switzerland is far more multicultural than the rest of Europe. Switzerland must embrace multiculturalism the way the rest of Europe has.

Switzerland is the most decentralized country in the world. Switzerland is inherently totalitarian.

Legislative policy that attempts to direct the composition of civil society is bad when citizens vote for it. Legislative policy that attempts to direct the composition of civil society is good when it is imposed on an unwilling citizenry by a foreign bureaucracy.

Got it. Everything is much clearer now.

Kudzu_Bob··on Switzerland to restrict EU immigration
Neither. Advocating that taxes be raised serves to increase their status, just as catapulting buckets of money in the generally direction of irredeemably corrupt African countries does. Biologists refer to such behavior as a "display of fitness," like a peacock's feathers or the way some tribal chieftains compete with each other to see who can give away the most stuff. We crave status more than we do money or even sex.

Besides, in this case their lawyers and lobbyists will see to it that they actually never will have to pay much extra to Uncle Sugar. In the end, the only people who will feel the bite of tax hikes will be ordinary people, and nobody cares about them.

Kudzu_Bob··on Switzerland to restrict EU immigration
You forgot to add, "and not being handcuffed to a dead man."
Kudzu_Bob··on Switzerland to restrict EU immigration
The image of the immigrant as invariably hard-working, noble, and law-abiding gets taught and passed along too, not by parents and peers but by business interests seeking cheap labor and political parties seeking permanent dominance by means of electing a new people.

When you label something as confirmation bias, make sure you're looking through the right end of the telescope.

Kudzu_Bob··on Switzerland to restrict EU immigration
Stereotypes don’t materialize out of thin air. If they did that you’d see a more random distribution of competing stereotypes.
Kudzu_Bob··on Switzerland to restrict EU immigration
You seem to think that participation is an end in itself. By that metric, Belgium is doing splendidly, whereas Switzerland is a failure.

Meanwhile, on Planet Earth, Switzerland is a marvelous country, while Belgium is on the verge of splitting up.

Kudzu_Bob··on Switzerland to restrict EU immigration
If you do not know what your birthright is, then it is unlikely that you will manage to keep it for very long.
Kudzu_Bob··on Switzerland to restrict EU immigration
If it is not clear whether it's a violation of the agreement, then it is dishonest to accuse them of being in violation of the agreement.
Kudzu_Bob··on Switzerland to restrict EU immigration
1) The words "life, liberty, and the pursuit of happiness" appear nowhere in the Constitution.

2) In any event, the above phrase has nothing to do with immigration.

3) Even though Bluto asks in "Animal House" if it was over when the Germans bombed Pearl Harbor, the Germans actually did not bomb Pearl Harbor.

Kudzu_Bob··on Switzerland to restrict EU immigration
What you call xenophobic, others call noticing what is right in front of their noses.
Kudzu_Bob··on Switzerland to restrict EU immigration
You sure are excited about this economy stuff. It's as though you think that people exist to serve the economy rather than the other way around. I hope nobody points out to you that per capita income would go up if we gassed all the old folks and cripples.
Kudzu_Bob··on Switzerland to restrict EU immigration
And they are making far better use of those benefits than Turkey ever could.

For instance (since so many people here are fond of economic arguments), tiny Switzerland (population under eight million) has a GDP a bit over six hundred and thirty-five billion dollars.

But even though Turkey has a population nine times greater, that country's GDP is only a hundred billion and change bigger than Switzerland's. If the Turks were as productive, their economy would be the equal of China's, with only a fraction of China's population.

The Swiss literally get more done before their morning coffee break than the Turks do all day, maybe because they somehow manage to spend their time at useful tasks rather than blowing up Kurds, staging military coups, listening to crazy preachers, banning political parties, and so on. I'm glad the EU is helping them out, because they deserve it.

Kudzu_Bob··on Switzerland to restrict EU immigration
By what metric are they unequal? Crime rates? Economic output? Level of corruption? Degree of political freedom? What?

You cannot name a single way in which Switzerland is not the equal, and often the superior, of the countries that comprise the European Union. It even has the highest per capita rate of Nobel Prize winners

On the other hand, Turkey is known for Islamic fundamentalism, ethnic wars, military coups, violence against women, and a level of intellectual accomplishment that ranks somewhere between D+ and C-.

Kudzu_Bob··on Switzerland to restrict EU immigration
Only an idiot or an ideologue promotes a particular policy even though he knows that it would harm him.
Kudzu_Bob··on Switzerland to restrict EU immigration
Aristotle contended that justice consists of treating equals equally, and unequals unequally. You, on the other hand, want to treat Switzerland just like Turkey, even though the two countries are strikingly unequal.
Kudzu_Bob··on Switzerland to restrict EU immigration
Some people seem to think that whatever is good for the stock market is good for the country, because the country IS the stock market.
Kudzu_Bob··on Switzerland to restrict EU immigration
Why? Because they're not as multicultural as the rest of Europe? Because they dare to live in a way that suits themselves?

The promoters of diversity ueber alles certainly are in touch with their inner totalitarian these days.

Kudzu_Bob··on Do Elite Colleges Discriminate Against Asians?
Sure, but you're pre-judging all pygmies as being short.

This is exactly the behavior that you condemn, unless I've missed something.

Kudzu_Bob··on Do Elite Colleges Discriminate Against Asians?
"Prejudicial discrimination is bad because its piss-poor discrimination."

Exactly. This is why basketball teams are missing out by their pig-headed refusal to send talent scouts to evaluate Rwanda's Pygmies.

Kudzu_Bob··on Stop complaining about the lack of women in tech
Increasingly, even silence is no protection.
Kudzu_Bob··on Stop complaining about the lack of women in tech
Whoa! Déjà vu!
Kudzu_Bob··on Stop complaining about the lack of women in tech
Sorry, but I can't help but remember encountering people who made comments much like yours, only to find on closer examination that they were incredibly, deeply in the wrong.

Since you don't go into any actual details about the basis of your comment, it makes it really hard for me to take your remembrances too seriously.

Kudzu_Bob··on Why it is important not to have children
"What about having families makes the world a better place?"

Families are vital. That everybody from Genghis Kahn to Jonas Salk was born into one ought to be the tip-off.

Kudzu_Bob··on Stop complaining about the lack of women in tech
The only practical, field-tested way to get more women into tech is to lower tech's prestige. Once that happens, men will flee to other careers, thereby creating vacancies that can be filled by women. Problem solved.
Kudzu_Bob··on Why it is important not to have children
Some people want to make the world a better place by having families. To me this makes at least as much sense most plans for world-improvement.
Kudzu_Bob··on Why it is important not to have children
If you want to do something revolutionary that potentially threatens the status quo, first you have to be born.
Kudzu_Bob··on Why it is important not to have children
They'll quit breeding (or at least slow down considerably) if we cease to subsidize their reproduction at the expense of our own.
Kudzu_Bob··on Why it is important not to have children
The Church tried its best to lower the population's average IQ by encouraging the smartest boys to become priests.

For ostensibly different reasons now we've got do-gooders doing exactly the same damned thing to us.

← PreviousPage 4 of 5Next →