HNHacker News
TopNewBestAskShowJobs

LawTalkingGuy

194 karma · joined August 11, 2022

submissionscomments
LawTalkingGuy··on After days of destruction, Macron blames a familiar bogeyman: video games
> Were these men speeding through civilians or fleeing dangerously when they were shot?

No, the men in your stories were sleeping in their cars. One was shot 55 times.

The driver in France had just been witnessed fleeing through civilian traffic and crosswalks. They saw him commit a crime and try to flee to continue risking others' lives. He was shot once, only when he tried to escape.

What do you think these stories have in common?

> Do you want others to make the same excuse as you if you were shot by the cops?

If I was risking other people's lives by fleeing from police and used deadly force to try to escape, then yeah. It's not "an excuse", it's their literal job. They tried to detain him peacefully.

LawTalkingGuy··on After days of destruction, Macron blames a familiar bogeyman: video games
Joyriding and fleeing police at high speed through a city is a violent crime. He doesn't have to be convicted - they witnessed it. They told him he'd be stopped and yet he chose to endanger more people trying to escape lawful custody.

> never [...] been convicted of a crime

That's the injustice. He'd been arrested for resisting arrest just the weekend before and if they treated him properly he'd have still been locked up - unable to get himself killed.

> Whatever you say, man. It’s pretty clear what you’re doing here.

You're race baiting. You're taking something an entirely understandable reaction to violent crime that happened between two people of the same race and are distorting the facts to play it up as some systemic white supremacy despite that a whole country has been thrown into violence and people have already died for that lie.

You're trying to get people killed and stoke tensions to support your politics at home because the lives of these people (French people, sit down) are worth so little to you that it's a game.

But please, do go on about what I'm doing.

LawTalkingGuy··on After days of destruction, Macron blames a familiar bogeyman: video games
> I claim a society where the cops can shoot an unarmed young man in the face with no repercussions is an unsafe society

Then you aren't talking about this case. This man was driving his weapon and had already risked the lives of pedestrians and other drivers before he was stopped.

> Society's checks and balances breaking down so far

The breakdown of society is that the driver, a known criminal, was out on the street. If he'd been arrested, charged, and jailed as he should have been he wouldn't have been able to risk his and other lives.

He was literally a danger to himself and others.

LawTalkingGuy··on After days of destruction, Macron blames a familiar bogeyman: video games
What does "people like him" mean, is that some racist dog whistle?

> you’d already decided that it’s okay

Before I heard his race, yes. Based on the fact that he'd risked people's lives before they stopped him and he was trying to flee to do it again. The police gave him a warning and a chance to surrender.

> to murder [him]

Shooting a violent criminal to prevent imminent further violence is the epitome of justification.

> I just want you to know that no one is actually fooled.

I assure you, no fooling, that I'd support shooting whatever color of criminal was driving the car.

My thoughts are with the pedestrians they nearly hit and those people's families, and the police officers who risked their safety to stop him.

LawTalkingGuy··on After days of destruction, Macron blames a familiar bogeyman: video games
You're trying too hard to force a racial context onto France and deny one in the USA.

In California a Christian is less likely to be white, and a progressive more likely to be white than not. And many of those Christians come from countries that the USA has been involved in and not always left in good shape so most of the same dynamics even exist.

Regardless, criticizing religion is fair game and a Euro has a right to criticize Islam the same as to criticize Christianity, even if there's a racial disparity between the membership of the two.

LawTalkingGuy··on After days of destruction, Macron blames a familiar bogeyman: video games
Every driver who was fleeing at high speed through civilians, and who attempts to do it again, yes. Absolutely.

It's literally the time they're supposed to shoot.

I'll quote US law here because it's in English, but it's pretty much the same worldwide.

> "1-16.200 - DEADLY FORCE - Law enforcement officers and correctional officers of the Department of Justice may use deadly force only when necessary, that is, when the officer has a reasonable belief that the subject of such force poses an imminent danger of death or serious physical injury to the officer or to another person."

Fleeing wouldn't be enough, but fleeing in a car after reckless driving that already endangered civilians is.

LawTalkingGuy··on After days of destruction, Macron blames a familiar bogeyman: video games
> why cops are shooting unarmed kids.

Which unarmed kid? A car is a deadly weapon if you've been driving it through crosswalks at high speed.

If your family had been in that crosswalk you'd be complaining about the lack of policing.

LawTalkingGuy··on After days of destruction, Macron blames a familiar bogeyman: video games
That's surely what happened, even though it obviously isn't correct. Islam is a religion, not a race.

It's just as reasonable for the French to complain about Islam as for a progressive Californian to complain about Christianity.

Sadly, HN doesn't seem to take away the right to flag posts when people abuse it.

LawTalkingGuy··on After days of destruction, Macron blames a familiar bogeyman: video games
> the birth of a child doesn't obligate either parent to accommodate the newcomer.

The newcomers were accommodated, just not feted. They have rights, but those don't override the rights of other French citizens and residents.

> When you let immigrants in you acknowledge that you're letting change in.

Sure, if the immigrant has new food, or music, or religion, etc, then they'll provide new choices to their society. Society is under no obligation to take those new choices, and not doing so isn't harming the newcomer.

And this is in the context of maintaining a functioning society. Driving through crosswalks at high speed isn't one of the available choices for anyone.

LawTalkingGuy··on Lawsuit claims OpenAI stole 'massive amounts of personal data'
I think that generally if the customer hires you for something that is legal in general in their country, like price comparison, that they're fine if you employ means that wouldn't be legal for them, such as automated scraping, as long as it's legal for you.
LawTalkingGuy··on TSMC faces $70M ransom demand following lockbit cyberattack
You wouldn't hire some ex US special forces person hiding in Russia in deep cover, like a movie. You'd hire local thugs who works as enforcers for a gang to simply grab these guys and shove them in a van and deliver them to a warehouse.

These are cash-motivated criminals not ideological or patriotic fanatics. I imagine the interrogation would be like "You know why we captured you, right? Yes. Login and disable your entire network and live or we brutalize you until you do and then kill you. Ok."

Especially if this was at a government level (ie, not private "loss prevention") you'd be able to tap the intel network for local criminals and things to hold over their heads to motivate them.

LawTalkingGuy··on Harvard dishonesty expert accused of dishonesty
> There have even been multiple instances of myself and other rank-and-file coworkers trying to have discussions about bigotry at large (not even in the workplace itself), only to be shut down by those very same DEI coordinators under the guise of "let's use kind words instead of unkind words

How do you have these conversations such that you're using unkind words? Are you racially stereotyping people as bigots?

> I'm speaking as someone who falls into several ""diverse"" hiring categories.

Yeah, that makes sense. If your intersectionality was switched those conversation probably would have gotten people fired.

> I have literally never once heard language like that from DEI professionals

Like the "whiteness" thing from the other post. Rules for thee and not for me.

> not good HR-speak to call a spade a spade.

"Although the term has its origins in Greek literature, the subsequent negative connotations with the word 'spade' means that the phrase should be used with caution or not at all." -- Elimination of Harmful Language Initiative, Stanford

You might not be held to the same standard as other employees, if you can freely speak in this fashion...

LawTalkingGuy··on Harvard dishonesty expert accused of dishonesty
> I also find it suspect that equity or inclusion are "political,"

The way you say "suspect" seems like an attempt to sway opinion, which seems like a tacit admission that that the terms are political.

For instance, inclusion of who? What groups do you divide the world's people into such that you need one of every group for proper representation?

> Logistically speaking, it makes zero sense to hire an anti-diversity advocate for a DEI role.

I think most people can do jobs they don't agree with. An engineer can design a bridge that they didn't vote for, an administrator can follow rules they wouldn't have chosen, etc.

> Companies only have DEI teams because they want to promote diversity, equity, and inclusion;

How should you do that though? Is any diversity of thought allowed? For instance, is anyone allowed to think that affirmative action is ultimately harmful and focus on the diversity and inclusion over "equity", and/or argue for what they feel are more helpful methods?

Is DEI defined as a specific set of practices or a general goal of bettering society?

LawTalkingGuy··on Open source licenses need to leave the 1980s and evolve to deal with AI
> I find the "precedence" approach taken by English / Common Law incredibly silly — and actively harmful, [...] Judges' interpretative rulings should not have (almost) the same effect as the legislative passing a law.

Precedents are visible. They're the outcome of prior cases. If the people or the legislature doesn't like the rulings they can look at the judges' reasoning and fix the law, invalidating the old precedents at the same time.

> Anyway the original argument was that you could apply some license-like terms onto spam mails, and for that — no, you very much can't.

By the act of giving you the email they're implicitly giving you permission to do email things with it - read it, forward it, store it, etc. But you don't own the copyright and can't create and publish derivative works, etc.

We never questioned the anti-spam use because it's obvious. You aren't storing data for the purpose of recreating the spam, you're storing details about what spam looks like for the purposes of recognizing more of it.

> The situation for AI is, to my knowledge, still very muddy at this point.

The question is if the NN weights in an AGI are materially different than the NN weights in a spam filter.

LawTalkingGuy··on Harvard dishonesty expert accused of dishonesty
> Should DEI teams be hiring people who are against [...]

Yes, otherwise you're saying hiring is just a political test.

LawTalkingGuy··on Killing Community
> CP and gore for shock value

No, that stuff is gross and you block/avoid it. The integral part is that the forum uncensored - even if a large quantity of that uncensored content is unwanted.

And fwiw, 4chan is only one example of a (nearly) uncensored board, it's far from the best or nicest.

> I don't understand why it's important to be flamed at all

That's not the important part, but that you can have the conversation at all. The idiots running around screaming are like ghosts in Harry Potter, distractions if you let them be but almost invisible if you ignore them.

> racial slurs ... are an integral part of the culture?

Well sometimes yes, actually. Like the now banned subreddit, 2balkan4u, sometimes "hate subs" actually aren't. I'm familiar only via gaming friends, but it's basically people who've come together around "hating" each other for ethnic reasons. It doesn't look friendly but is, with people bonding over their shared history - often dark - and collectively watching the world go by from a cynical pov. It's like therapy and the hanging out with the only people who understand you, something many veterans feel even when meeting ex-"enemy" combatants. A sanitized version of this wouldn't work.

LawTalkingGuy··on “But the SEC let us go public” and other flawed arguments in Coinbase's defense
> It’s pro bono legal advice.

No, it's asking an agency to clarify its own rules.

If I, as a ham radio enthusiast, find an unclear section of the FCC rules I expect to be able to contact someone and ask what the agency's understanding of it is. They wrote it after all.

For example, if they wrote 5-15Mhz, I might wonder if they mean inclusively. Does that cover 15Mhz, or just 14.9999?

I'm not expecting them to preemptively rule on all legal cases which depend on this, just on their interpretation of their own words.

LawTalkingGuy··on Killing Community
> I'm so sorry, I'll try to be better.

Thanks.

> That shouldn't even remotely be a debate on why I left.

Sure, you're the definitive source for why you left.

> there's a forum that I saw tons of child porn on.

It wasn't a forum for that though (I hope), it was a forum where people trolled others by posting it. Do you know someone put CP in the bitcoin blockchain?

And yeah, I use a no-images no-JS browser for a lot of things and 4chan would be one. I expect to be blocking 99% gore, but that last 1% is many things I'm also happy not seeing.

> I guess I shouldn't be upset

Upset at who, though? Upset at the people who enjoy an uncensored forum and have accepted that it'll be full of crap, or at the people who feel the need to poison it simply because someone else was enjoying themselves?

> trans-hating homophobes

Anonymous forums are actually one of the first places trans people were free to discuss themselves. You might (will) be flamed and trolled for it, but also engaged with. Reddit seems more free to be trans, except if you look at the forums there's always someone being banned for non-hateful things, such as being the wrong type of trans, or detrans. (Truscum vs Tucutes vs old-school Transexuals ...)

LawTalkingGuy··on Ted Kaczynski has died
> It's a weakening of Kaczynski's argument to say it's about activists not caring about collateral.

Maybe, but what you say here isn't supported by the bit you quoted.

That bit actually seemed completely level headed and well written. He defined his terms (leftist) and admitted it's a sloppy term, and then he wrote something I feel is true about most political ideologues - that they care more about their arguments and winning than the correctness of the arguments or value of their opinions.

> He absolutely mixes in there insinuations that this is all by some secret design.

Again, maybe in the overall manifesto, but not there. In the quote provided he just says "Xs works for the goals of X, even if their message is 'Save the Ys'"

That's not hard to believe, it's something we all need to try to avoid in our own thinking.

> ungodly amounts of paper writing about the motives of the leftist.

:D Have you ever read what leftists themselves write? You could fill libraries just with analyses of Marx.

I think the scary thing is that Ted is very well read and could be writing for the New Yorker ... and he justifies violence.

But not because he's the only one doing so, he's just the one who decided to take it into his own hands instead of the acceptable ways to call for violence - to advocate using our military to do it, or hoping that someone 'punches' them for 'being a nazi'.

He's scary because he disproves the narrative of a barely literate, ignorant, conservative-adjacent, god-fearing, terrorist who hates us because of our freedoms, or whatever. He is us, one of the best of us at one time, and we can be vicious.

LawTalkingGuy··on Killing Community
> Americans ingrained need to be racist against everyone

Have you ever been anywhere in the world which you found less racist than the USA? (Bonus points if it actually has a substantial population and racial/ethnic mix to test that, and it's not just theoretical.)

A lot of places have hidden hatred of groups which acts like racial hate, but doesn't appear that way to people from the USA where the divide (black/white) was so stark and visible. Turks/Armenians, Shia/Sunni, etc.

The USA isn't perfect, but I can't think of anywhere else that I could so unreservedly recommend to anyone around the world. Not Canada, not Germany, maybe the UK, sorta Singapore if you're not certain races, etc, etc.

LawTalkingGuy··on Killing Community
> you ... defending CP

Yikes. On 4chan you'd have just blindly implied that the poster fathered himself in a freak accident with his mother, who is a bovine. Here, on the nice polite internet, you merely implied that a real person, whose name is attached, is defending ch1ld s3xual abuse.

You're so upset about there being a forum you don't like that you've decided to use one of the most powerful accusations you can make about him - one that imho could justifiably get him killed if true - so casually. So much hatred.

LawTalkingGuy··on Ted Kaczynski has died
> To paraphrase 'ole ted "You see, affirmative action makes white people feel bad and mad at black people which is the real secret goal of leftists".

No. It's more like "Leftist activists push AA and other policies with no concern for the impact on the communities they're purportedly intended to help."

> Do you, or have you ever, felt mad a black person because of affirmative action?

I'm pretty sure you could find a ton of people who do if you searched for it. But even if the harm wasn't real I think the point is that activists don't care about collateral damage.

LawTalkingGuy··on Google uses in-person office attendance as part of employee performance reviews
fwiw, I get this just as much with remote, but it's a chat message.

To fix this, use "the process". Create a ticket for the job for this person and if they want the job done right now, get them to up to priority themselves (presumably with their and your managers' approval).

LawTalkingGuy··on Severance payments at Wikimedia Foundation
>> supply and demand in the labor market has nothing whatsoever to do with the profitability of a firm

> [supermarkets]

All supermarkets have to pay the same price to buy strawberries, regardless of their individual profitability.

LawTalkingGuy··on UK’s GDPR replacement could wipe out oversight of live facial recognition
> Do they genuinely have a mindset that nothing is worth trying if it failed the first time?

No. But the way you first picked to do the thing is very likely impossible to make work. Don't decide on a mechanism, like cookies, and fixate on it without regard for practicality or effectiveness.

Preventing invisible tracking is probably a good goal that's worth iterating on but making sites pop up a list of good and bad tracking and being allowed to track the people who accidentally don't click "No!" seems like an entirely failed way to go about this.

If tracking is bad then stop it for everyone, not just people who clicked the correct thing. If some tracking is generally bad but allowable for certain functionality then mandate that tracking is only applied once the user had opted in, etc. Don't make users mark "Don't steal my organs while I sleep" on the hotel paperwork.

LawTalkingGuy··on UK’s GDPR replacement could wipe out oversight of live facial recognition
It's a joke because it demonizes a specific technology which is only tangentially related to the goal. Imagine if we wanted to make drive-by shootings illegal and rather than passing a murder law your politicians criminalized having windows in cars.

Cookies are the least offensive tracking technology. They're visible to users and the interactions with them can be seen. The EU should have mandated that all tracking has to be implemented as a cookie so that users could see it and block it themselves. Instead they added a lot of cruft and legal risk to every website and it doesn't make anyone "safer".

> you quickly see who works in bad faith

No, and that's the ultimate fail. You click the button and feel safe but you can't see the server-side logs so it's entirely a false sense of security.

If you want to stop tracking, make the law about tracking not about the current methods.

LawTalkingGuy··on Transcending My Father's Abuse
> Could the bias you see have other reasons, given it's not purely predicated on sexual identity?

It's cis-phobic and het-phobic. Cishet. That's partly sexuality and partly identity.

They were cishet men, they became lesbian transwomen, it's unclear what of that got them hired.

LawTalkingGuy··on Intel OEM Private Key Leak: A Blow to UEFI Secure Boot Security
This is exactly what the media does, point to the craziest and imply that the group shares all their views. Even if everyone in the group was a conspiracy theorist they can still be right that workers are feeling the strain more than others.

We need to steelman the views of our countrymen, not mock them.

Think of what they'd say about your side if the tables were turned.

LawTalkingGuy··on Tell HN: We should start to add “ai.txt” as we do for “robots.txt”
> You don't get to use [a copyrighted work] unless you have a license.

Not when you give it to me. "Hey, can I see your pamphlet? Sure, here's a copy."

> an implicit license to consume this content

No, copyright prevents copying, not use. There's no implicit license needed to use a work so there's no place to attach those usage restrictions. If you want me to agree to a license you need to not give me the work until I do.

You could have a ToS click-through agreement ("no training an AI on this!"), and then only serve content to logged-in users who have agreed to your conditions.

> but not to reproduce it.

I agree - those "pamphlets" were given to me and I can't copy them for someone else. They'd have to view my collection.

> The exact legal status of AI models trained on other people's unlicensed works and their output is still largely unknown.

Sure, predicting all courts in the world is a futile exercise. Surely someone will try to over reach from copyright to preventing what they feel is a bad use but it's unlikely to become law because there are already analogous uses, scanning someone's text and pulling data from it - data like which words follow which other words.

> I do have a problem with these multi billion dollar companies scouring the internet for their money maker, giving nothing in return.

Well, FB released Llama... It's not a closed technology, it's being led by for-profit businesses but the community (which consists of many of the corporate engineers as well) is trying to keep up.

Even if you can and do attach usage regulations to your site I feel it'll hurt the little guy more than the corporations. There are probably not any unique linguistic constructions on your site that will render a corporate AI less valuable, but for hackers and tinkerers and eventual historians, who knows what it'll interfere with.

LawTalkingGuy··on Tell HN: We should start to add “ai.txt” as we do for “robots.txt”
> focus on improving its context recognition rather than trying to fix that by inserting even more training data.

That's how you improve its context recognition. You show it many contexts.

> most AI projects don't exactly care about things like the wishes of authors, copyright, or ethical considerations

Why is it 'ethical' that you get to add a bunch of restrictions to a pre-negotiated situation? You get copyright protections in trade for letting people use your work. There's a way to add restrictions - licensing - and you're looking to get the benefits of licensing, and to take away fair use right from other people, without paying the costs of doing so.

fwiw, I copy most pages I visit and store them. The website has given me the equivalent of a pamphlet and I store it instead of discarding it when I'm finished. This way I can go back and read it again later without having to track down the author and ask for another copy. It's not AI which has me doing this, I've been doing it for decades - it's censorship that has shown me the need.

← PreviousPage 2 of 19Next →