HNHacker News
TopNewBestAskShowJobs

LawTalkingGuy

194 karma · joined August 11, 2022

submissionscomments
LawTalkingGuy··on Tell HN: We should start to add “ai.txt” as we do for “robots.txt”
> specific copyright terms of use

There's no such thing. Without a license you can't enforce any restrictions.

AI training is basically just building a very complex Markov chain, that's obviously not copyright violation because the output product doesn't contain the input - only data about it. If your text has been copied then please point to it in these weights here.

LawTalkingGuy··on Tell HN: We should start to add “ai.txt” as we do for “robots.txt”
This is how it is a failed system. It doesn't really do what most people who have one think it does and yet it gets rolled into law and everyone now has to deal with it constantly while still not fixing the original issue.

It's like the EU doesn't understand that bad law has a negative value.

LawTalkingGuy··on Transcending My Father's Abuse
>> bias against cishet identities.

> I always hear this, but I never see it. Could you share a few examples?

Jobs. There are too many white, asian, and Indian males in my company, we're told. So we have to hire others preferentially now to balance out our numbers. Yet if a white male identifies as a woman there's a space for them.

That sounds like an anti-"cishet" and racial bias.

"It is no news that women are underrepresented in the tech industry and even more so in open source. That’s why we are proud to announce the news of the first-ever all-women Open Source Program Office (OSPO). The Comcast OSPO is a geographically, culturally, and technically diverse team of members who identify as women, and who are accelerating in open source leadership, community, compliance, and security. This presentation will discuss the challenges women face in open source and the dynamics of an inclusive team."

Also like really shitty women's lib.

> the banning of gender-affirming care [...] constitutes child abuse and medical malpractice in some instances.

This is where the problem is; what's being banned, the stuff we're told never happens?

Nobody is trying to stop appropriate surgery for children with developmental sexual disorders. Generally the DSD (Intersex) community knows what's appropriate treatment (or appropriate lack of treatment in many cases) for their specific conditions.

The problem is happiness/depression issues being turned into surgical modifications.

> irreversible puberties [...]. The question is: which happens more often?

Puberty isn't child abuse. Pretending that there's an option to puberty is.

Dr Marci Bowers - a leading pediatric gender doctor and surgeon says that - “every single child who was truly blocked at Tanner stage 2 has never experienced orgasm. I mean, it’s really about zero.”

> I have yet to see any data suggesting that [the eager diagnosis of gender identity] is applicable in more than a handful of cases.

Would you consider it proven if doctors routinely ignored pre-existing mental health issues such as autism, major trauma such as child sexual abuse and loss of a parent, and signs of existing issues such as "cutting", and anorexia.

How about if the child's initial gender-identity contact admits to homophobia being their reason to seek transition? Susie Green CEO of Mermaids, "Jack’s favorite outfits were the tutu and the snow-white costume [...] that was fine but not for Dad [...] the conclusion of the sort of years up until she was about two was that I had a very sensitive quite a feminine little boy who was probably gay but Jack’s dad did not approve of our child’s effeminate behavior [...] at six she asked when she could have the operation to make her really a girl".

We forget that children often asked to go to gay-conversion therapy, because they'd been brainwashed into thinking they were failed people with a horrible sinful condition that needed fixing. Jack Green was bullied into thinking that he had to make himself a girl if he wanted to choose his own interests. He "freely chose" to have cosmetic genital surgery to be allowed to be himself.

LawTalkingGuy··on Intel OEM Private Key Leak: A Blow to UEFI Secure Boot Security
> There is no part of the official process where anyone is required to listen to or respect the opinion of a protest. That's kind of obvious.

Actually, I think there is one - government media. CBC/BBC/etc should cover these instead of covering them up. If they represented the citizens voices honestly, they might not feel they have to blockade parliament to get their point across.

> Democratic politics means there's official channels for exercising this by voting instead of having to do this.

That breaks down a bit when your media only presents one side of certain issues.

There's no requirement for corporate media to be honest, but for state media paid for by the citizens that's basically its only purpose.

> If you want a rep to know your opinion on something you can call them.

You can contact them, but if you can't do it in public others won't know and they can basically kill issues by just ignoring them.

LawTalkingGuy··on Prediction and Entropy of Printed English (1950) [pdf]
Just for kicks, are you?

And why does it matter? I'm part of a multi-racial group of parents. What does it matter if I'm the asian one or the white one or the black one?

LawTalkingGuy··on Prediction and Entropy of Printed English (1950) [pdf]
> Please read the first paragraph of the wikipedia article, it'll clarify the issue.

No. It doesn't. Because we have the school boards saying this in this in their own words and publishing them in their policy updates. All the "limited in value" stuff in the Wiki article is about ad-hoc and poorly collected evidence and that doesn't apply here. We're pointing to their own words.

> chat with your representative with all this wonderful evidence

It's perfect evidence. It's their own policy statements with their own justification.

A lot of people are like you initially but when they actually read the policies they come around - race-based rules are something most people feel icky about.

I've seen people rudely dismiss a pamphlet about this from a white parent only to happily read and engage when approached by an asian parent only moments later. That's racist, but I understand because all the news pumps out is a constant stream of partisan race-baiting and it takes many people a while to turn off that defensiveness.

> or they will gladly answer all your questions

No, usually they refuse to let us even get on the agenda for meetings.

> I'm sure you'll change their mind

Thankfully we don't have to talk to our representatives when they're this dismissive, we can simply vote them out and we have been.

But usually we find that at least half of them felt railroaded into these blatantly racist policies by a bunch of small frog-boiling policies and they're grateful for an opportunity to put things back in order.

LawTalkingGuy··on Prediction and Entropy of Printed English (1950) [pdf]
> wiki: Anecdotal Evidence

Yes, but you haven't explained why this is a problem though.

Let's say a black man gets beaten by the police. It's just "anecdotal" in that he hasn't performed a study showing that it's a global issue, but it is irrefutable proof that police do beat up at least some black men.

In this case, let's say that only our school was enacting these policies and that we the parents discovered it only by our personal observation of policy updates, why would that matter? We'd still want to change it.

But in this case it actually is a widespread issue: https://archive.is/bZcXu

"The high school, [the parents] argued, should reinstate honors English classes that were eliminated because they didn’t enroll enough Black and Latino students. The district earlier this school year replaced the honors classes at Culver City High School with uniform courses that officials say will ensure students of all races receive an equal, rigorous education."

> "no ideological battles"

You're the one having a battle, and over an ideology. Walk away or engage with the issue, either is fine, but you're attacking me directly, using labels (radical, reactionary, etc) and saying that I "know what I'm doing".

You don't say what you'd do instead. You don't say why you support the policies, or would/wouldn't if they existed.

LawTalkingGuy··on Prediction and Entropy of Printed English (1950) [pdf]
> when you don't have factual evidence.

You don't understand evidence. When our school boards are getting rid of advanced classes they're referencing race based reasoning like that example. Also, these specific recommendations are adopted in many schools - Stride Equitable Math - it's one of the more common.

> "cause (someone) to adopt radical positions on political or social issues".

That's circular reasoning though. What about the positions I would encourage someone to adopt is "radical"?

So far you're just using it as an insult.

> What do you think reactionary mean? You have no further point other than reaction to what some activists do. You don't work for schools to have actual policy, you just flail your arms.

That's probably the dumbest standard because by nobody has a plan when they first discover a problem. As you're using it, it's just an insult, and an empty one at that.

> "You don't work for schools to have actual policy"

Also, um, yeah. We do. A policy which bans using racial identifiers in all policy and policy discussions. Mandates that the same curriculum be available to any student gated only by skill.

> Vetting media outlet by general editorial quality is a good idea to not read nonsense.

I said I don't check for ideology. The quality is just fine - a mom had a complaint and they published her opinion piece as an editorial.

You pointed to a headline you didn't understand about lesbians but that's on you, not the paper. The headline was fine and references real events.

> Good job not using HN for ideological battles

Ironically, here you are flailing with insults and wildly reacting to my comments about a radical new movement to shove racism into schools.

Only one of us is having a battle.

You got freaked out because you saw something you didn't understand, refused to read deeply and engage, and now you've accused me of all this crypto-racism because I'm trying to remove racist policies from schools. Slow down. Not everyone uses your dog whistles, and not everyone on the other side is a bad guy.

Do you actually have any problem with my stance on this, that "what should be done to support minorities is the same thing that should be done to support the majority - full and proper academic standards."

LawTalkingGuy··on Prediction and Entropy of Printed English (1950) [pdf]
> Why are we talking about this?

Why here? Because, as I said below, I posted that in response to this specific thread somewhat by mistake. I was discussing racially motivated changes in university acceptance criteria on a parenting forum and pretty much the same example was being used as an example of the thinking of those calling for the changes.

> And great example of anecdotal evidence.

Is anecdotal the new dismissal word of 2023 or something? "Oh, sure that happens and you see it near you, but that's just an anecdote - if you can't show it happening worldwide it doesn't count!"

Racialized teaching is in schools, rarely with justification this blatant though. They're using this rhetoric to justify getting rid of advanced classes and push groups of people entirely out of academics sometimes. If you don't follow schools and local politics I can imagine why you don't hear about it though.

> The only effect your long comment has is to further radicalize people into believing

Oh, I thought you were using the actual meaning of radicalize - you know. Violence instead of speech, etc.

> that nothing should be done to support minorities

No... That what should be done to support minorities is the same thing that should be done to support the majority - full and proper academic standards.

You should never need to talk about a student's race, or even take it into account. If a specific group of students really need extra help, use class analysis (ie, poverty) instead of racial analysis.

> Think twice before writing reactionary nonsense

Is this like calling me fascist, or do you actually mean something by this label?

> btw, the source you quote here, Unherd, has this article at the top of their website "Why lesbian women should sleep with men". Laughable.

I don't pick and choose source sites by their overall ideology so I didn't check the rest of their site before sharing the opinion piece.

But, yeah .... That is laughable. Can you believe that homophobes are literally attacking lesbian at pride parades and dyke marches for saying things such as "Lesbianism is female."

Note the Benford question mark in the headline though, it's sarcastic - the content says lesbians should not sleep with men. Sadly though, the article is in response to very real calls for violence against lesbians.

LawTalkingGuy··on Prediction and Entropy of Printed English (1950) [pdf]
> Are we on a submission about language? Why are you guys talking about race-based admissions

My mistake. I'm also discussing the anti SAT/ACT and anti-MCAT movement on parenting forums and I open posts in new tabs to respond to them and forgot which thread was which.

The reasons being given for dropping the standardized tests are to help minorities despite that tests generally end up being a positive for disadvantaged people, not a burden. That's exactly where I was going with that "anti"-racist racist teaching guidance - rules that are claimed to help minorities which are in fact the worst things you could do.

> You know what you're doing

You read that post and you think I want minorities to fail? That I want racist school policies?

I was railing against the assumption that minority (it's always racial minorities they mean) students are failing to begin with, and then that they were failing because white courses and white standards are too hard for them.

That sort of racial framing goes against decades of psych research into things like stereotype threat and is known to be harmful to students' success.

LawTalkingGuy··on The UK’s tortured attempt to remake the internet
So did I, but those forums were different. As someone else pointed out, no selfies, no actual names, no real identities.

There's no hard and fast rule the government can apply which would serve the people, for sure.

But from a parent's point of view it's not that hard to evaluate. If a forum is about things, and people rarely enquire about each other's personal life, it's probably safe. If it's about feelings and dividing communities along personal lines, it's probably not. If adults and children commonly come into contact and the community isn't on guard for creeps, it's not okay. If your kid really wants to participate in an unsafe seeming community, do it with them.

What government could do is mandate that social media sites of a certain scale run only from known domains, with clearly separated subdomains by activity, and have other tools to express parental control - and then leave the application of those to parents. Right now it's technically hard or impossible to enforce parenting rules, often by design.

LawTalkingGuy··on So this guy is now S3. All of S3
It's not as much that it's trivial (but it seems like it always is because social engineering never stops working) but that once the attacker has authed they can generally delete whatever extra file or record they made and stay authed, potentially hiding the attack.

Whereas, if that required a signature from a private key, with a counter or other log of use in the TPM, it'd be caught by an audit without having to notice the symptoms.

I know that in security design that I've been involved with there's a lot more scrutiny given to each use of a privileged key than there is to making sure that all website logging lists each file in the directory at each request, or logging the full public state of your DNS every minute. Requiring a signed request makes the attacker come in through the front door.

LawTalkingGuy··on Prediction and Entropy of Printed English (1950) [pdf]
There's so much condescension in that sentence alone.

They say 'LatinX', where the correct term is Latin. They specifically list black students because the constant message in the liberal USA is that black people aren't capable and need to be called out by skin color in all contexts so they can be helped across the line by virtuous white people who recognize their weakness.

But keep reading the lesson plans and it goes on and on.

Chapter 1 is "Dismantling Racism in Mathematics Instruction", and it claims that "White supremacy culture infiltrates math classrooms [...] perpetuate educational harm on Black, Latinx, [...]"

- "greater focus on getting the 'right' answer ..."

- "required to 'show their work' in standardized, prescribed ways."

- "Independent practice is valued over teamwork or collaboration."

God forbid individual minority students are given the ability to personally succeed without being forced into a group identity, or that they be taught how to use math to communicate with others.

- "It also presupposes that “good” math teaching is about a Eurocentric type of mathematics, devoid of cultural ways of being."

Yes, of course, because math is about the numbers! You can apply it to your personal cultural way of being after learning how to get correct answers.

It's actual racism is to assume that all black people need to have a social-justice framework put in front of their academics to "help" them. Not help them to success, but to a white-constructed pseudo-success of wrong but "culturally correct" answers that is somehow the best they can be expected to achieve.

- "study ethnomathematics and incorporate into all classrooms."

In other words, don't try to help everyone achieve a common goal, create race-based targets and replace all education with them.

"the practice of school mathematics in the US regulates the child by privileging:"

- "algebra/calculus over geometry/topology/spatial reasoning;"

- "rule following over rule breaking;"

- "Western mathematics (culture free) over ethnomathematics"

- "logic over intuition"

Calculus encompasses geometry and spatial reasoning, so that's just wrong.

They attack "Rule following" - like the rules that get you correct answers. Western mathematics (which they've just identified as the type of math focused on correct answers). And logic, damned logic, getting in the way of the "lessers" just doing what they culturally know is right rather than applying critical thought like white people.

There's nothing in that course, or any of the rest, or in the critical theory that it came from, which is capable of helping, or even intended to help, any minority student.

It only prioritizes raising students uneducated and with a bunch of misplaced racial baggage.

If you don't believe me, or want to write it off as "what a white supremacist would say", read this:

https://unherd.com/2022/02/anti-racism-betrays-asian-student...

"After the tragic killing of George Floyd in 2020, much of the virtue-signalling that followed focused on an unexpected target: admissions processes. Activists claimed children “of colour” weren’t getting their fair share of places at good schools — or, to be precise, black and Hispanic children weren’t. The same couldn’t be said of Asian children. And so Asian students became a convenient scapegoat for “anti-racists”. [...] in the months when America was rocked by race riots, self-described “equity warriors” described the Asian, mostly immigrant families of TJ as “white-adjacent” and “resource hoarders”. The white principal, Ann Bonitatibus, told us to check our “privileges”, [...] the local school board — all 12 members endorsed by the Democratic Party — voted to remove the school’s merit-based, race-blind admissions process, and replace it with one that was race-based. Along with other parents I was horrified by the school’s readiness to use identity, rather than achievement, as the basis of admissions. But when we objected, the Virginia education secretary, a Democrat, told our families that preparing for tests was like using illegal “performance enhancement drugs”. A black father, Harry Jackson, who spoke up for our cause was called a “motherfucker” selling “segregationist bullshit” — by a white activist who uses the Twitter handle @Antiracist14"

LawTalkingGuy··on faulTPM: Exposing AMD fTPMs' Deepest Secrets
And if they aren't using such a password library, what other errors are likely?

Timing attack on the character of the pw which failed?

LawTalkingGuy··on Avoiding hallucinations in LLM-powered applications
Because the model doesn't contain facts at any point - only words.

The size of the LLMs is an easy way to currently demonstrate this - even if you took only the factual statements from all its training material and compressed them, they'd be larger than the model. The model isn't magic thus it can't contain all those facts.

The only way it can write a fact is if those words are simply the most likely completions and happen to be right.

This means you'd be essentially training it randomly by selecting factual answers. You wouldn't be reinforcing that it gave you a correct fact, just whatever the sentence structure was that you judged to be factual.

I think what would happen is that it would start to write very careful statements which would be more likely to be technically correct merely by not being wrong.

For example, if you trained by asking questions like what year president George Washington was born it would quickly learn to stop guessing a year because that's got a low probability of being right and those statements would get trained out. It'd probably write something like "Before 1760" because that statement has a much higher likelihood of being right even if it's a less useful answer.

LawTalkingGuy··on Fox News, Dominion Voting Systems reach $787,500,000 settlement
What problem are you trying to solve with e-voting? To make the vote more accurate by cutting down on UI-type errors? Get results sooner?

> > Not only should the voter be marking their ballot by hand not doing so through a machine whose UI may have bugs

> I don't think I agree with the first part. Marking by hand is probably more error-prone. People are notoriously not great at correctly filling in a bubble, leading to scanning errors.

Perhaps, but risk of systemic failure allowing a vote to be stolen is the paramount concern. UI errors (esp on randomized ballots) tend to balance out.

The UI concerns are real, but they can both be addressed physically and through ballot design.

> the QR code to something other than the human-readable

You wouldn't want to have a QR code though, if you simply read the human-readable marks. The QR code is some sort of premature optimization based, I think, on the assumption that scanning is difficult. If you have only one mark then you know it's the canonical mark.

> Any UI bug should be caught thanks to the human-readable printout. If I select Biden and my printout says Trump, I'll notice.

Real ballots often have twenty or more choices so this is harder in practice.

And you're trusting a machine's UI at each step. It's telling you which marks mean what rather than you marking the paper according to instructions on the paper. A paper ballot can't be altered after the fact to change your vote, any machine-generated paper can simply be reprinted.

The correct answer, if anything is needed at all, is an under-vote detector. It doesn't tell you how you voted, it just says "no selection is readable for Mayor" or "You only made four marks for City Councillor but are allowed to place up to five votes", and so on.

LawTalkingGuy··on AI Generated Propaganda
The railroads did not enable the Nazi genocides, they merely shaped them.

Rwanda killed a higher percentage of people, more quickly, without any advanced infrastructure. Without railroads the Nazis would have put the camps closer to the population centers or killed people where they lived. During that period the same technology and eventually even the same rails enabled the Allies to break the Nazis and free the remaining prisoners.

Verdict: Neutral.

LawTalkingGuy··on AI Generated Propaganda
That's like licensing all photocopiers to make sure the state knows who can produce propaganda. Not only is it an obvious rights violation, but it will never work.

If watermarking is the solution it needs to be applied to the legitimate content.

LawTalkingGuy··on IBM to pause hiring in plan to replace 7,800 jobs with AI
You can't hire their research arm.

> regardless of how you feel about consulting

It's a matter of how well they do it. They're not known for creating customer value.

> Are the only companies that make sense the ones

... who don't lay off entire arenas full of people and discuss stupid platitudes like replacing them with AI.

Pretty much. Management's messaging around this was so delusional - "replace with AI" - that it's obviously a stock play from a company desperate to cut losses, not a positive statement from a going concern.

LawTalkingGuy··on Fox News, Dominion Voting Systems reach $787,500,000 settlement
I don't think that it's always a lib/con issue, even if it gets played that way on the news, and I think the actual conservative side is often a lot more focused on kindness and safety than they are played. Even where I disagree with them (and libs too) I can often find happy middle-ground that both sides, divorced from their TV-applied baggage, can appreciate. It helps that I'm usually not in the USA and speaking about things outside of their rep/dem news-based framing.

> I’ve watch gun ownership rise to hundreds of millions sold including weapons that liquify human life and a party that can watch the outcome of child massacres and just look the other way.

I think this is a good example.

In Canada there was a mass shooting and the government responded with a huge list of firearms restrictions. Ammo, magazines, models of guns, etc. Like 1400+ restrictions.

But none of that would have impacted the guns the shooter had, which were all obtained illegally across the border. What it would have done is left even more country families without defense and made it easier for the shooter to go house to house. But it played well in the cities and was used to create an artificial lib/con divide in what is fundamentally a city/country issue.

None of the "don't ban guns" people I spoke to wanted anyone to get shot, but they didn't want laws that won't help. We know that the vast majority of guns used in crime are illegal and that they come from the USA, not via stolen legal guns, so no amount of legal firearms crackdown would impact their numbers.

If those restrictions were separately proposed when there wasn't a shooting some of them might have gotten some support, but when presented as a knee-jerk solution where they obviously wouldn't work there was a lot of pushback. Nobody wanted more shootings, especially the conservative side who had suffered in them, but they weren't willing to have their tragedy turned into a political defeat as well when it wouldn't even help.

> the misogyny

I'm pretty sure you mean abortion. I'm pro-choice and the bans scare me, but I see women getting shit on from both sides of the aisle.

Men are being put in women's prisons:

https://fairplayforwomen.com/campaigns/prisons/

Even if they're baby rapers:

https://torontosun.com/news/national/hunter-trans-killers-ba...

And when they abuse women, the female inmates face extended punishment for describing them as male:

https://insidetime.org/women-face-punishment-for-using-wrong...

Also sports:

https://rileygaines.com/

https://shewon.org/

And violent terrorism against peaceful protest:

https://archive.is/SrILu

https://www.cnn.com/2023/04/07/us/former-ncaa-swimmer-riley-...

Both sides of the Dem/Rep fight are absolutely abusing women and women's rights, and while they're fighting against the other's excesses it's generally not to help women but to score points.

LawTalkingGuy··on AI Generated Propaganda
If only a few people at an event publish photos and video there's a lot of dead space/time to insert stories, but if nearly everyone publishes their video feed the majority of the event will be locked down.

And not just multiple angles of something, but distributed images through the entire crowd while it's happening. Let's say they show a fight, does the rest of the crowd move appropriately to make room for it? If they show a politicians speaking does the crowd surrounding the closer videos cheer in time with the distant crowd, or are they perhaps spliced together?

Forensics will get harder and only more data will give us a chance. Ultimately, analyzing the data is easier than faking it consistently and scale is our advantage.

LawTalkingGuy··on Fox News, Dominion Voting Systems reach $787,500,000 settlement
Tell you what, I'll examine any of those studies with you if you wish. If you're serious, tell me which claims resonate with you and we can examine them.

My post (parent to yours) outlined enough problems with "studies" in general that I can't think you're seriously suggesting any of them except by inertia at this point. Trying to pick an accurate journal, by reputation, in a time of extreme cancelling doesn't work. Even if SciAm had any standards they couldn't have published a negative article about transition because they would literally receive death threats.

If you've got sources that say sex is a spectrum, they're simply wrong. Developmental sex disorders don't make a new sex. Males produce sperm, and females produce eggs. There's no third sex that produces spegg, or what have you.

All of these articles contradict basic, and observable, biology. If they were true we'd have discovered it long ago when people and animals couldn't breed in expected ways. It's one of those things that only academics, who've never set foot on a farm, could believe.

Further, most of those articles are literally attempted child murder to justify the fetishes of their adult authors. They say things like "puberty blockers are reversible" despite all evidence (and basic logic) showing that they are not. It's impossible to have performed a study on giving children puberty blockers (at regular puberty age, not earlier like in the cases of precocious puberty) because we weren't performing a standard procedure until recently which could be studied. Those authors are saying "things we've never tested, which have huge and systemic impacts on your body, have zero long-term consequences".

John Stewart tells us that children are not being given puberty blockers, but doctors are telling us they are - and in sufficient quantity to have studied their impact. Obviously one, or both, of these is a lie. The more you look into trans "science" the more you'll see none of it is even intellectually plausible, let alone the pinnacle of science as you implied.

LawTalkingGuy··on U.S. Rep. Angie Craig drops college requirement for staffers
https://www.clearchoiceprep.com/sat-act-prep-blog/the-most-i...

Basically though, anything that relies on something not printed on the test runs this risk.

LawTalkingGuy··on Whistleblowers are the conscience of society, yet suffer gravely
> there is significant value at the world level, of keeping secrets.

There can be. But secrets can also be unimportant, or easily learnable through other public means. We need to analyze what we're keeping secret and optimize.

The democracy answer is omni-present. People can't really be said to support something they don't know about and if secrets encompass too much of their government it becomes, for practical purposes, illegitimate.

The cost of keeping the secret has to be weighed along with the cost of it leaking and the chance of that happening. It's not practical to keep everything a secret for reasons of censorship limiting other valid activity or just the increased bookkeeping in tracking secrets without revealing them.

And ultimately, not everything is all or nothing. You can have an undisclosed number of weapons for instance, but have a process where civilians can band together and form a special body, get some people vetted, and be granted access to otherwise secret information that they, because of their unique skills or interests, may have input on. This exists today in the form of aerospace companies, etc, who have access to many secrets to aid in the planning and construction of further tools.

LawTalkingGuy··on Whistleblowers are the conscience of society, yet suffer gravely
Russia is literally claiming that the Ukraine is run by Nazis. Not that there are people there who see the Nazis as a lesser threat than the Reds, but run by Nazis today.

That's a lie so big it's visible from space.

LawTalkingGuy··on U.S. Rep. Angie Craig drops college requirement for staffers
> "IQ" tests (which are completely fraudulent)

No, not really. Up for debate is pretty much only the overloading of the word 'intelligence'. But whatever it is, it correlates well with job performance and maximum level of education attainable.

But they are culturally sensitive, and thus racially sensitive, and you need to apply the right test to people, for the right goals, to get meaningful results.

If you want to hire only people n-sigma above the norm, in an area of rich and well-educated locals, and you apply the same test to them as to foreign applicants, you'll likely never hire a foreigner - they won't test as well as they would on a test in their native tongue/tasks/etc.

But if you try to estimate the level of abilities needed and you use the correct test to establish an applicant's ability against that metric and hire from anyone qualified, then the tests are useful. They're even a way for skilled foreigners to test into qualification without having to jump through expensive credentialing hoops.

LawTalkingGuy··on I cloned myself with AI, and she fooled my bank and my family
Embeddings are great for this, capture all posts by all people in the sub and embed them, then cluster users by their overall position and the distances between their posts, etc, to profile them ideologically and single-issue wise, and then graph the links between similarly located users. Do they post in a web, or a tag-team way that differentiates them from other users?

And then also color these by the average response time, etc. But don't rely on these types metrics because they're the easiest to avoid by simply delaying responses based on their length and complexity, plus a random discovery time, plus a time-of-day dependent offset.

And then, potentially just issue warnings. "You've been detected participating in a brigading fashion, and bot or not, may be banned if this continues" and see what changes.

LawTalkingGuy··on AI Is a Waste of Time
> NFTs are still happening, but the insane multi-million dollar monkey jpegs are not really happening anymore

I think all the high valuations are money laundering. You create a pre-order system and get your friends on it, then buy their monkey pics for your near-stolen (FTX, etc) crypto and they give some back under the table.

> web3 had a big presence

The NFT tech is pretty cool. It lets (by packaging a friendly UI around it) people be their own identity providers.

LawTalkingGuy··on A small number of companies are colluding to cheat H1B visa lottery, US says
Remove the potential for abuse by still requiring the application to be approved.
LawTalkingGuy··on Upward Farms throws in towel ten years after founding vertical-farming business
Only the marketers are saying it's a panacea.

Vertical farming (defined as the inefficient use of indoor farming, versus greenhouses which are an efficient use of indoor farming) is not a good replacement for most sorts of food production. It's a potentially competitive way of producing the most delicate and high-value items as close to the customer as possible.

It could make it possible to sell some foods, like apricots, in the city which are otherwise impossible to ship because they have to be picked soft.

Often though, there is roof space available where high-value crops could currently be grown efficiently in greenhouses and it's not being looked at because of the VC focus on tech and growth.

← PreviousPage 3 of 19Next →