HNHacker News
TopNewBestAskShowJobs

LawTalkingGuy

194 karma · joined August 11, 2022

submissionscomments
LawTalkingGuy··on An Update on USDC and Silicon Valley Bank
100% of $0. Tether is entirely a scam by intentional criminals and not a single dollar is in a vault.

They say they're 1:1 backed but have committed obvious financial fraud around this. There's no benefit to them to be even 95% backed, it's 100% or jail, so why would they bother?

This is how they maintain the peg perfectly - it's all fake. They "redeem" their friend's Tether with their personal funds but they won't even try if there's a run.

LawTalkingGuy··on Microsoft is going to use Reflect to spot student with inadequate feelings
> Imagining Gen-E: A generation raised on emotional intelligence

> Image: A 'monster' saying "I feel valued today."

That's bad, not good. Feeling "valued" is teaching people to rely on others views of them, not their own internal views. If you're taught to take your value from others you're just being setup to be socially controlled. You can't have an unpopular opinion if you need to be valued by the group.

It's not, I think, that most of us think that emotions and the people having them are stupid, but that the things kids are being taught about emotion are counterproductive and will hurt them later.

Having a human check in is fine, but they shouldn't see their job as making everyone happy all the time. It should be in creating the most robust adults. We spend 99% of our lives away from teachers and babysitters so we need to know how to make our own happiness even in the presence of negativity and dislike or scorn of others.

You make a child stronger by letting them get hurt - but only a little, and suffer it alone - but only a little. In the end you have an adult who can be happy while they "fail" at tasks, or while receiving social pressure for unpopular ideas.

LawTalkingGuy··on Large language models are having their Stable Diffusion moment
The langchain project is an example of the iterative queries approach. It comes with constructs for working memory, factual lookup / calculation agents, etc.

https://github.com/hwchase17/langchain

The general (non-technical) guideline is that the LLMs can "answer" anything you just gave them the answer for. So you give it a problem, ask it how to solve it, tell it to use that method and explain the data it needs, give it that data, and then show it everything at once: "With this data you requested and summarized, use this technique to answer this question".

LawTalkingGuy··on Dutch police collecting demonstrators' personal data on a large scale
> the least useful is sticking to a hard definition, deciding noone qualifies, and therefore the term is "meaningless".

The point of the term is a political identifier. If it doesn't encompass anything you believe in but includes your mortal enemies it's not much good.

> large groups of people use the term that way and communicate just fine.

No, they don't. I don't know anyone "on the left" who would happily use it knowing the full scope of what others using it identified as - and validly under your definition. Surely they aren't communicating anything meaningful.

Worse, it encourages those people to label others using their own lax standards, such that everyone who isn't an anarchist, or a marxist, etc, is the polar opposite - "the right". The left is a grab bag, the right is simply everything else.

These terms signify a side a culture war but don't indicate any views or policies which may actually differ between them. They mark "us vs them" without being too specific to swap who is who when needed.

LawTalkingGuy··on Llama.cpp: Port of Facebook's LLaMA model in C/C++, with Apple Silicon support
> we would have to get rid of the tendency of these models [...] reply with something a bit more sexist/racist/

If you don't want it to be racist, don't say racist things to it. Also, it'll be fairly clear where the racism came from - like a parrot and their owner.

AIs that can tweet, like MS Tay, and that remote-work chatbot, get a lot of attention when they melt down. Private AIs on your phone don't seem like they'll caise any concern with the phone-using public.

I think we'll appreciate the benefits more than we'll mind that others can make it say dirty words.

LawTalkingGuy··on Dutch police collecting demonstrators' personal data on a large scale
> I don't think "like the left wing of the French legislature in the late 1700s" is a very good description of what leftism means to people in the modern day.

That's why 'left' and 'right' have little objective meaning. They're more tribal than explanatory.

> what leftism means to people changes over time with culture

Correct, I don't think there's a good idea what it means in the USA right now, let alone worldwide and across time.

> influences from many leftist writers and philosophers

That's a circular definition though. How do you know they were leftists? By the current or the old meaning? Do old works suddenly become leftist works as the term changes and their author would now qualify as a leftist?

> people's views could boil down to [mistaking a god for a theism] and yet all would easily be considered atheists by themselves and others

There's a difference between a god and a theism so they'd simply be mistaken.

LawTalkingGuy··on Dutch police collecting demonstrators' personal data on a large scale
> The large number of immigrants who drive trucks in Canada were also not represented.

There are famous videos of Sikh truck drivers on other drivers shoulders, as the crowd dances to Indian music - near the bouncy castle.

But would it be illegitimate if it appealed to one demographic more than another?

> Rank-and-file truckers don't have the time nor resources to go on multi-week vacations across the country.

They were out of a job so they had time.

> The icing on the cake was the hot tub. American protesters at January 6th brought a gallows. The Ottawa "truckers" brought a hot tub.

How is this good or bad? Lots of people enjoy hot-tubbing in cold weather.

> 1/3 of the country, the anti-Trudeau bit, could see no wrong in the trucker protests.

No chance any of their supporters are there because they agree with the issues? You feel that everyone who supported them was doing so because they disliked the PM?

Do you also feel that everyone who spoke out against them was a supporter of the PM? What opinions are legitimate opinions and which ones do people only have to support their party?

LawTalkingGuy··on Dutch police collecting demonstrators' personal data on a large scale
Highly doubtful. It's a "citizens commission" which means a bunch of people decide whose reports to republish. Nothing even attempting to be truthful or bipartisan.

The reports switch between describing attempted murder - trucks accelerating at pedestrians, etc - and crazy harassment like asking an asian man to do "a dragon dance" and then beating him with "blunt objects" when he refused, which didn't do any damage such that the police refused his report.

> "The pastor recalled convoy supporters, some of whom routinely urinated on his church, even taking issue with a sign indicating the church was broadcasting its masses online due to provincial public health restrictions: “One of them pointed a fist towards me shouting ‘you should obey God instead of F-ing Trudeau’.”"

Pointed a fist(?) and yelled a rude message about a politician. Oh, the harm! No photos of the urinators though - which supposedly kept happening.

The only likely crime (likely a crime and likely happened) I spotted in their report was someone pushing a photographer's camera away. Annoying, and criminal, but totally unpunished at all rallies and protests. The police literally don't react to anything less than theft of a camera or punching the photographer.

LawTalkingGuy··on Dutch police collecting demonstrators' personal data on a large scale
Leftism simply means "like the left wing of the French legislature in the late 1700s" which by tradition is where the socialists sat. Using it for other views would be like saying "I'm an atheist, my god is like ..."

In the USA people who have a live-and-let-live attitude tend to think they're leftists despite actual of-the-day leftists being as authoritarian as the rightists. Left and right, in their original sense, were both strongly authoritarian by today's standards.

How do you mean corporate liberalism, is this a flavor? What do corporations have to do with it other than espousing the beliefs of the day?

LawTalkingGuy··on Dutch police collecting demonstrators' personal data on a large scale
If I show up to your event carrying a weapon without your knowledge, is it your fault or mine? If we treat it as your fault, haven't we found a perfect way to keep you from ever holding events?
LawTalkingGuy··on How to start a rocket engine
He didn't. He tweeted that he's surprised the tiles don't need to be overlapped to avoid blowing off but didn't suggest that Elon change them.

https://mobile.twitter.com/Erdayastronaut/status/14426315302...

LawTalkingGuy··on We will not ‘walk out’ of UK, nor comply with any request to bypass encryption
People arguing for censorship can never show anything that needs to be censored but there are countless examples of things that shouldn't be censored being squashed under policy. There's literally not a single example through history of a truth that had to be squashed for justice and safety. There are no great stories of historical censorship not because they're secret, but because they don't do anything except protect the people in power.

A censorship policy is, by nature, impossible to check. If anything is being censored you have to assume that other things, including proper discussion of the censorship, are being censored. It's not some complex "not black and white" thing where you're partly right, it's a failed idea with absolutely zero support from historical precedent.

You can't censor away bad ideas because we can't even agree on the bad ideas - such as for instance your censorship push. Why shouldn't your push to censor people be censored itself? Why do you assume that your choices for societal control are the correct impulses, which need to be bolstered with thought control, rather than the harmful impulses which will destroy society though totalitarian means?

No, censorship is always wrong because it removes the ability of the people to make decisions on the facts. Any politician who pushes censorship has to be assumed to be trying to undermine democracy because censorship can't do anything other than weaken the electorate.

> The world is not black and white and claiming that it is is extremely naive and simplistic, and I am afraid that what I read here in response to my comment is exactly that.

That's fallacious because it assumes that censorship deserves a better rhetorical chance which it was denied when in fact it's simply a bad idea. If you suggested to punish people for their family's crimes you'd get similar pushback because it's a similarly corrosive policy.

You haven't properly argued for censorship at all, by showing thoughts which need to be censored and why, you've just argued that it's a super important tool without any examples or reasoning.

LawTalkingGuy··on Ask HN: Why is gain of function research allowed given possibility of lab leak?
What we need to do is make sure that the process is more transparent. If every approved lab had to log its research with a global watchdog we'd have a better idea where to start when things inevitable go wrong.

From discussion before the Wuhan lab was built: "worries surround the Chinese lab, too. The SARS virus has escaped from high-level containment facilities in Beijing multiple times, notes Richard Ebright, a molecular biologist at Rutgers University in Piscataway, New Jersey. Tim Trevan, founder of CHROME Biosafety and Biosecurity Consulting in Damascus, Maryland, says that an open culture is important to keeping BSL-4 labs safe, and he questions how easy this will be in China, where society emphasizes hierarchy. “Diversity of viewpoint, flat structures where everyone feels free to speak up and openness of information are important,” he says." - https://www.nature.com/articles/nature.2017.21487

LawTalkingGuy··on France's baby bust
> Who cares about you?

Me. That's why I want to find a simple set of rules that we can both agree to, where you care about me in trade for similar concern and protection.

> If a stroke reduces you to the same level of mental functioning as a newborn

Right, I don't consider that viable without some sort of prognosis of recovery but if we go too far down the line of 'burden to society' it starts to include people who drive too slowly in the passing lane and gets more subjective.

LawTalkingGuy··on France's baby bust
> from a purely utilitarian standpoint, there’s no compelling reason to draw the line at birth.

Except there is. You want the same protections applied to you, even if you're unconscious or otherwise unable to protest. Pretty much the only broadly supportable position is that killing a viable person is murder and no more or less supportable than them killing you.

LawTalkingGuy··on France's baby bust
Only the ones that integrate well with modern society. There are tv shows that point out the antiquated ways of the Amish such as how they teach their kids and dress their women and their older children's struggles to adjust in broader society, for example.
LawTalkingGuy··on France's baby bust
I'm an atheist and I think that murder is bad despite not believing in the religious sanctity of life. I'd have trouble with full-term abortions of healthy, viable babies.

It doesn't seem unreasonable that other people would have a lower comfort limit, again even without religion.

LawTalkingGuy··on ChatGPT get-rich-quick schemes are coming for magazines, Amazon, and YouTube
That doesn't make owning a book illegal, it recognizes that it's a crime to show some books to underage children and that includes when stocking a children's library.

> "We were instructed last week that we essentially had three choices as far as our personal libraries that are in our classrooms. 1) We could remove them and completely box them up. 2) We could cover them up with paper or some sort of something. 3) Or they could be entered into a database where the school district has all of the library books, and if the book was in the system, then it could remain on the shelf" - A Teacher

Read option #3. Having to report which books are in the library is not the same as banning books.

Sadly, bad reporting has distorted understanding of the issue. ex: this quote from a misinformed parent.

> "I would not suggest banning books. It’s a slippery slope. This is good literature with value. Please do not ban books!"

Nothing is being banned. That parent can read any books they want with their children. Schools also don't stock Marvel movies in their libraries and nobody claims those are banned - they're just not appropriate for school libraries.

LawTalkingGuy··on France's baby bust
Do you truly believe that hijabs and only hijabs (or maybe other Islamic symbols) are banned? Because if so I've got some good news for you - all overt religious symbols are treated equally.
LawTalkingGuy··on Dow said it was recycling our shoes. We found them at an Indonesian flea market
> You haven't proposed a viable alternative.

I was explaining the problem and now not solving it is my fault.

> Should developed countries voluntarily stop exporting used clothing? Would that actually make people in poor countries better off?

Yeah, that's what the developing country said in this instance. They passed their own laws to prevent import.

And the charity promised to use the shoes for an experiment in recycling which would have brought knowledge benefits at least even if not producing a superior product. They clearly defrauded their donors regardless of Indonesian trade policies.

LawTalkingGuy··on Mysterious object is being dragged into the black hole at the Milky Way’s center
> A telescope isn't a remote viewing device, it's photons hitting my eyes just the same as if I were standing directly in front of whatever I'm observing.

It is a remote viewing device because we're discussing using it to view remote events. And you're trying to say "just the same" despite that there are obviously some differences so it cannot be just the same. Try "somewhat analogously".

> If I, like the photons, travelled from the source 671 million miles away to Earth at the speed of light, time would not have advanced for me at all. I would be telling you that what you are seeing is happening right this instant. And I would be right!

No, because it took you 1 hour to get here, and if you went back you wouldn't be there at the time you left, so in no way are the events simultaneous.

You're only describing subjective experience - and someone who travelled much more slowly in stasis would have the same subjective experience despite their report of objective simultaneity being even more obviously incorrect.

LawTalkingGuy··on Mysterious object is being dragged into the black hole at the Milky Way’s center
You didn't watch them perform an act in front of you, you watched them on a remote viewing device (telescope, youtube video, etc) which was in front of you.

And no, you wouldn't deny it happened yesterday. If you were watching a live event in front of you you'd have the ability to interact with it, such as by asking your friend to stop. If you're viewing something that already happened, you don't have that ability to interact.

Quantum theory and relativity aren't tools to decrease our specificity and understanding of the universe so they shouldn't be used to justify "all interpretations are valid" type statements.

LawTalkingGuy··on Dow said it was recycling our shoes. We found them at an Indonesian flea market
They already had local clothing industries - people in poor countries weren't walking around naked until the mid 80s when container-shipping meant offshoring trash became cheap.

If this issue was isolated to shoes, and those were technically unavailable for local manufacture, then you'd probably be right. But these practices destroy all industry, leaving the people without any manufacturing base or value creation outside of cultural artifacts, and tends to keep the poor countries poor.

LawTalkingGuy··on ChatGPT get-rich-quick schemes are coming for magazines, Amazon, and YouTube
What books are illegal in Florida which are not also illegal in all of the USA?
LawTalkingGuy··on The Online Safety Bill: An attack on encryption
All representative systems are somewhat undemocratic but the point of them is to pick someone who's we can agree is legitimately the winner of the contest - not to deadlock trying to pick a winner to a better standard.

The primary goal isn't to represent, but to reduce misrepresentation to the point where we can literally live with it.

To me it's only illegitimate if this is coupled with unreasonable attempts to keep us from improving the system as technology and knowledge give us the means.

LawTalkingGuy··on Dow said it was recycling our shoes. We found them at an Indonesian flea market
Shipping western clothing to poor countries tends to destroy local industry.

I prefer to be able to make my own choices, not have people lie to be and then do whatever they feel is cheaper. They have to pay to properly recycle, but can just sell the old shoes. This is fraud, pure and simple. They asked for the donations of shoes under false pretenses. (There's a chance it was whatever firm they paid - but then they're just willfully incompetent.)

LawTalkingGuy··on Is A.I. Art Stealing from Artists?
> There are things which I'm not allowed to take photographs of ...

But photography isn't illegal per se. You don't need a license to have and legally use a camera.

Taking some pictures may constitute a crime, but it won't be simply having the camera and clicking the shutter button.

> There is data I'm not allowed to be given or store, like a random stranger's medical records.

Not really. If I give you my medical PII you've committed no crime. Even if you store it you only may be liable.

> There are communications I am not allowed to make, such as the sequence of bits in copyrighted material]

If you intend to interact with the media it encodes then yes, but if you're a dev and I send you a test vector you can't be expected to know what those bits encode.

> > You can't make any law you want, and keep a free society. You can't tell people they can't train neural nets on public data

You can't tell people they can't add public numbers. Training an AI is all math and in theory could be done on paper.

Having laws that would proactively make training an AI on public data illegal would make our society not free.

Public data wouldn't mean anything, because the public wouldn't be able to read it. Training an AI is so vague that making notes about a text could qualify. If the courts tried to enforce such a law non-selectively it would criminalize everyone.

> You're allowed to be an anarchist and say those things should be legal

Anarchists don't believe more things should be legal, they think there should be less or no laws. It's quite different.

Laws are supposed to recognize and punish damages, not to broadly prohibit new technologies that sound scary when they were invented.

LawTalkingGuy··on “Open source” seeds loosen Big Ag’s grip on farmers
It's a honest argument.

It seems perfectly reasonable to most people that even if you own a patent on a seed that if I obtain it and can grow it I should be able to, in the way that your rights are generally exhausted if you sell a patented part to retail.

Monsanto would lose nothing in case where it was accidental and where the farmer intended it Monsanto would benefit from selling roundup.

Because of this, no plausible damages to Monsanto and that doing nothing is a perfect solution, the lawsuits seem egregious.

LawTalkingGuy··on The Online Safety Bill: An attack on encryption
> This makes them a drain on taxpayers despite being able to support themselves if they were allowed

I hear this from people who seem to be promoting using the system as a back-door way into a permanent work visa. I'd rather avoid perverse incentives and just support people.

> I think it stays the way it is because of "taking the jobs" of natives

This sounds like something a privileged knowledge worker can sneer at the low-brows for. I think it's as valid a consideration as any other import/tariff type issue and should be examined honestly. Again though, we can avoid the issue by simply paying to help refugees and that's probably the kindest.

If we allow them to work then we're essentially requiring them to work and if they just escaped with their lives they probably have other priorities for a while. The economic benefit for us from more workers is minimal enough that we can forego it to make a better and less exploitative system.

> allows politicians to demonize them as a drain on the public purse

I think there are enough obviously false claims that people are upset about that they're not worried about the costs of the honest claimants.

LawTalkingGuy··on Ask HN: Can Browsers Have a Universal Hotkey for Website Login?
> In the event of a fire or other catastrophe, your credentials would be lost forever, correct?

If you intentionally did the hard path of owning all your keys then didn't back them up - yes.

But most users would be subscribing to some auth service (Google, their bank, etc) and that organization would have recovery issues.

> I would like to have a hotkey I can push that

This is already super simple with no new tech - just make your login button of class "LoginButton" or something we pick, and the plugin will just click it via code.

The UI really is slick. When the site requests auth the browser pops up a window with the help of the system's secret storage and shows you your identities. This could be automated to avoid even that single popup if desired.

← PreviousPage 8 of 19Next →