2,161 karma · joined August 14, 2020
To my eye, this change does not appear to be driven by a change in corporate governance or profit motive.
They explain that the change and the timing is driven by two things.
1 - The burden and of processing public contributions has increased with the rise of AI
2 - They need to focus and stabliize the code base in preparation to introduce a public alpha
Those reasons ring true enough for me that I do not need to go looking for other motivations. I do not like this change but I can see why they would.
https://ladybird.org/#contribute
I hate this change and agree with your PR comment. This change makes me sad as well.
My hope is that public contributions can resume in the future. Part of their justification for this step is that they are trying to stabalize the project to produce a stable public alpha. Fair enough. And many Open Source projects have begun to voice concerns over the burden that the massive increase in contributions is causing, often from AI. Linus Torvalds has certainly been flagging this. The Open Source world in general is going to have to navigate this and come to a solution that works without the entire Open Source ecosystem becoming read only.
Once Ladybird ships a "stable" browser out to the world, I am hoping they can adopt whatever the "best practice" for Open Source has become to be able to accept public participation again.
Of course, Ladybird is not production ready yet. Feature-wise, it is getting close. I can use it to do most of the things I want to do with a browser. Speed and reliability are another matter. I has gotten dramatically faster but normal users would still find it slow. But the biggest problem is reliability. I would not use it in its current form for anything that matters.
But for a complicated application that was started from scratch, not being ready yet is not an indictment. They claim it will be ready for regular users to try sometime this year and, from where I type, this seems realistic.
Bringing up new software on old hardware is kind of like learning how assembly language works while the “why not use a Pi” approach is more like writing it in Python.
They both have their place but, to me, the “I will never understand” crowd is missing out.
I am not going to feel foolish enjoying excellent keyboards and screens instead of whatever I cobble together for a Raspberry Pi.
And it seems you just decided to ignore the whole native dev thing as well as the homelab. How many virtual machines and software defined networks do you run on Rasberry Pi?
I guess it also depends on what you mean by retro. I got a 2013 MacBook Air for $50 almost 2 years ago to take on a backpacking trip. It runs Chimera Linux now, with packages from an Arch Linux container. I used it at the park for a few hours this weekend. I took a video call on it this morning. My Rasberry Pi is not going to be better for any of that.
Anyway. I am glad you disagree. I would like my old hardware to be more affordable so the less demand the better.
I like retro computing but I never find myself using old software on old hardware. It is basically a museum piece sitting on a shelf at that point.
If I actually want to use my hardware, I want new software on it. If I am going to create software for it, I want to use modern languages and modern language versions. I want modern media codecs. I want to be able to read modern media and use modern filesystems. I want Linux on it if I can, including the conveniences of modern package management. I may want to use containers.
If it is going to connect to the Internet, I want it to be secure.
I do not want to deal with pointless compatibility problems, limited aofrware selection, or decades old bugs.
For me, part of the fun is seeing how much you can make old hardware do. And with new software, that can really surprise you sometimes. And in this age of the cloud, the hardware may not be the bottleneck you think it is.
I will give two examples. First, I have used OpenCode to write native software on old platforms. Toy compilers can be fun. The locally running software is not that demanding with the hard work being done in the cloud by a frontier AI but with the results tested locally and natively on the old hardware. This is a lot more fun, and makes more sense, than doing it in an emulator.
Second, the core of my homelab is Proxmox running on a 2013 Mac Pro. It runs dozens of VMs and containers. It cost me $200. Where else am I getting 64 GB and 12 cores for $200?
So, you may get filesystem access inside the VM. Breaking out of the VM may be a different matter.
So that is the mental model you should have for “how big is us-east-1”. But also, the data centers are not going to be, individually, anything like 244 acres. Best guess is that individual data centers are between 200,000 and 400,000 square feet. That is 5 to 10 acres.
Do the math above and us-east-1 may be 300 acres of floor space spread over a very large area.
Probably the only hardware they tested for this article was the K3 and the only recent test results they had that were slow enough were the Pi 500+, the P550, and Loongson. I agree though that comparing it to 10 different Ryzens is not super useful.
The Pi and the P550 are what people are comparing it against. And showing how much slower it still is compared to modern x86-86 is useful too. Something like the RK3588 would have been interesting.
This shows that RISC-V has improved a lot compared to itself, that it is becoming competitive with ARM, and that it has a long way to go to the high-end desktop. That is about the right story to tell.
There are not that many native applications. But there are a number of GTK and Qt apps that have been ported (like GIMP).
It depends what you need from your OS.
What does "SPEC2006 Compliant" even mean?
Already DeepSeek v4 is being hosted on Huawei Ascend 950. What do you think those cost relative to NVIDIA gear?
Not only that but other countries are very unlikely to follow suit, so it is just a straight-up productivity tax on the US.
Ladybird has taken sponsorship money from FUTO and claims publicly that sponsorship provides no influence.
Happy to see Ladybird using the best tools.
The RegEx and JavaScript interpreters are great places to use Rust for security reasons.
Ladybird has been pretty clear that they will accept money from pretty much anybody but that funding will not provide influence.
I mean, they mostly make sure sponsors websites look good in Ladybird but even that seems like a low priority if you watch them.