HNHacker News
TopNewBestAskShowJobs

LionessLover

479 karma · joined May 13, 2016

submissionscomments
LionessLover··on Simple Rules for Healthy Eating (2015)
Corporations - especially publicly traded ones - are not exactly known for their long-term planning. Quarterly reports on the other hand...
LionessLover··on Is ‘grit’ overrated in explaining student success?
Doubt is good! As an extreme example, remember how at the end of the war Nazis committed suicide, and it happened on all levels, not just the very prominent examples like Göbbels that everybody knows about? It wasn't because they were afraid of being judged (there were plenty of them who managed to escape justice), it often was because they were so convinced of their cause that when it failed they saw no future, nit just for themselves - they actually thought it was the end for the German people's future.

So please keep your doubt. The more I learn - and I've taken courses like crazy over the last couple of years - the more I doubt. It#s just that now my doubt is more specific.

So what you may want to do is replace "unspecific doubt" like the one exhibited in conspiracy theories by much more specific doubt. Donn't try to abandon doubt itself!

Also, life inherently only has exactly the meaning you decide it has, so looking outside yourself is prone to failure. Also see https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=X4CvFWCULuI :-) Seriously, as soon as you look for something on the outside to tell you what you should do you limit yourself and start on a path to failure - because now, instead of taking responsibility for your choices you will say "but I had no choice!".

LionessLover··on Is ‘grit’ overrated in explaining student success?
Add "environment" and we may have something here. After all, ones own determination and attitudes are significantly influenced by environment.

A long article was very recently posted either here or on reddit - was it the Washington Post? Don't remember unfortunately - about mass murderers. It looked at the actual research and tried to dispel myths like "they are all mentally ill, so if we just fix health care for mental illness to discover such people early we can solve much of the problem". The actual statistics showed that less than 10% of mass murderers (I think that was "more than two") had a treatable mental illness. Turned out that the major determining factor instead was "environment". Of course, individual factors such as certain personality traits play a role - but they are the same ones that can be found in successful people (it helps to be "full of yourself" and not dwell too much on what other people think, unless it's important for your own success). Whether such traits make you a murderer depends on your environment much more so than anything else.

And here we get to "luck": Environment is a lot of luck, the initial settings matter most of all (the womb you crawled out of). Environment can greatly enhance - or dampen - whatever you inherited genetically. Who will do better, an Einstein born in a favela of Rio de Janeiro surrounded by gangs, or an average guy born to wealthy parents? Example: G.W Bush... Those are extreme examples, but even if you only look at relatively equal American middle class examples, but one ends up in a group of peers mostly interested in girls and booze, the other one in a group of kids with more academic parents and more interest in learning than party will be influenced by the group.

LionessLover··on Is ‘grit’ overrated in explaining student success?
It seems to me that a one-time positive experience with one person hardly influences attitudes formed over a far longer period - and I don't even need to take into account yet that for evolutionary reasons negative signals have a much stronger influence than positive ones. So to me all this shows is that they were aware of the problem - I don't see that this shows that they did anything significant to address it.
LionessLover··on Scaling to 100M: MySQL Is a Better NoSQL
Are graph databases key/value? Are document databases key/value?

Try this:

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/NoSQL#Types_and_examples_of_No...

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=qI_g07C_Q5I

LionessLover··on 83% of browser features are used by under 1% of top websites
In addition to the reply with the pointer to the standards, sure NaN !== NaN.

NaN means "no idea what we've got here". When you get to say that phrase, would you expect it to be used for exactly one thing and one thing only? To me "I have no idea" means the possibilities are endless (infinite). We can only compare for equality when we know what we are looking at, otherwise it's just "status unknown". Yes, it might be equality - the chances are infinitely small though.

If you take the argument a step further and say "but I got the two NaNs that I compare doing the exact same operation, so even if I don't know what I've got from a mathematical point of view whatever it is it should be equal". In that case you are not actually comparing the NaNs but the path(s) that got you there.

I must say I find the whole NaN, null, 0 vs. undefined interesting on so many levels. There is a world of a difference between knowing you've got nothing (null or 0) and not knowing what've you've got at all.

"null": I have no bank account. "0": my balance is 0. "undefined" or "NaN": I lost my memory after yesterdays binge drinking and don't know who I am and if I got a bank account or not. Knowledge vs. no knowledge.

LionessLover··on 45 years since its creation. The C language still very popular
"Availability" doesn't mean much. There are plenty of all kinds of libs available on all platforms (who wants to program WiFi access for the embedded sensor from scratch, for example?). Doesn't mean it makes sense to put any of them into the current project. The stdlib is one of many and not that often the one that is put in. The libs I use on my embedded system are much more likely to be for some specific piece of sensor or I/O device (like the mentioned WiFi module), I rarely have need for what's in the stdlib. Of course, embedded systems vary far more than the PC and server stuff so you can easily find people who will say the exact opposite.
LionessLover··on Microsoft criticized for changing the pop-up box encouraging users to upgrade
I just re-activated that dialog (I had disabled it with registry setting changes) because I don't want to miss the free upgrade option but use it at the last moment.

Anyway - I found that when I simply say "No" to the inevitable "Terms and conditions" license dialog question the upgrade stops even if you said "go ahead" in the previous step.

LionessLover··on 45 years since its creation. The C language still very popular
Happens every day when writing code for small embedded systems. :-)
LionessLover··on Japan adding mandatory programming education to all elementary schools
That has nothing to do with you guys being very cheap, right?

No argument that STEM education was good in the East - I even have proof. Immediately after reunification German magazine "Wirtschaftswoche" (Businessweek equivalent) sponsored a very big test of students who had just finished high school "Abitur" in Germany) in East and in West Germany. It was tens of thousands of students. The result was that East German students wre significantly better in everything STEM, and worse in "language" (not just English, also in the use of their own language - so they were good engineers and bad at marketing and PR, to translate it to job profiles).

However, that is not nearly enough for success, the main reason Western firms outsource to the East is price. Competence is necessary but not sufficient. Most of the software boom in the East is fueled by demand from the West.

LionessLover··on Japan adding mandatory programming education to all elementary schools
Politicians will start being competent as soon as the populace giving them jobs values that trait enough.

That also includes keeping the loudly howling minorities for any given topic in check that raises hell whenever a person in public view seems to disagree with them, thereby teaching such people that lying and pretending is the best option.

LionessLover··on Japan adding mandatory programming education to all elementary schools
When you are a "TA" - which you basically were, according to your description - then of course you learn a lot. I've been a TA myself, and that alone gives one a very big boost because you spend a lot of time researching and solving problems - and it's fun because you are motivated like hell.

However, that says nothing - nothing at all - about the experience of everybody else in the course.

LionessLover··on Peter Thiel on the Global Economy, Technology, Artificial Intelligence [video]
The average IQ will always be 100. It will also always be perfectly normally distributed. Because it's designed that way.

http://www.michna.com/iq.htm

> In truth the IQ is a purely statistical measure. It has no direct relation to brain performance, is not proportional to it, and doesn't even have any linear or otherwise straightforward relation to it. The only thing you can say is that somebody with a higher IQ will show higher scores on most other brain performance tests as well, but the IQ doesn't say how much higher.

LionessLover··on Grandparents raising children is in line with human biology
> it was likely much shorter on average

The average includes a huge number of deaths of children and of mothers though - not counting those risks (childhood, especially the very early one, and giving birth) it's higher than most people think. In a lecture on microbes (http://www.gresham.ac.uk/lectures-and-events/return-of-the-m...) the professor mentions as an aside that a late Victorian British citizen after excluding those risks actually had a slightly longer life-expectancy than a modern British citizen! While that is fairly recent it still is long before modern medicine and antibiotics.

Quote:

> And what is interesting, if you take out the childhood mortality, the Victorian person between 1850 and 1880 lived slightly longer, if he was a male, than you do today.

("if he was male": giving birth was very risky)

So it seems that good food (variety plus enough of it) and hygiene did most of the job of extending life-expectancy outside the above two risks - and modern medicine very significantly lowered childhood and birth (mother) deaths. In the light of such evidence modern medicine does not seem to have had a great effect on life expectancy once you made it past childhood. We can't do anything against "aging".

LionessLover··on A 54-year-old custodian just graduated from the college he cleaned at night
> nothing beyond a few calculus and physics classes

With this quote of your own comment I rest my case :-)

LionessLover··on A 54-year-old custodian just graduated from the college he cleaned at night
I read this when it was first published and while it's impressive for sure this is easily overlooked:

> Decades earlier, in 1982, Vaudreuil received an associate’s degree in aeronautical engineering, but didn’t pursue his chosen career in the struggling airline industry.

So he had significant prior training in a related field.

Also, maybe that's my European bias, but I'm not so thrilled about this story because to my mind it shouldn't have been so hard for him in the first place to get that education, and some more aid after a normal failure in life.

I mean, are we making lives hard so that we can then celebrate the few(!) successes as if they prove anything? Like, that making lives in one of the richest countries in the entire million year history of mankind hard is a good thing?

This is like a Roman circus, we throw people into the arena and then celebrate the few who make it out again as "heroes".

"Are You Not Entertained?" (https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=FsqJFIJ5lLs)

LionessLover··on Why do we have allergies?
That would depend on the kind of toxins, not just "toxins". Also, nothing works in isolation: Maybe living in the East (I'm from the East too) had other - mitigating - advantages. Whet we are looking at is what to an account would be just the final "net income" number - but behind 10 cents there can be a multibillion dollar business or a teenager who spent most of his/her pocket money. So I don't think it can be decided so easily. Do you think the people thinking about this are not aware of global statistics and did not consider simple explanations?
LionessLover··on Why do we have allergies?
Well... time for anecdotal sample-of-1 "science":

About two decades ago I got a huge case of almost-asthma pollen allergy out of nowhere, almost overnight. I got the usual treatment (desensitization + meds) and it got somewhat better over the years. Simultaneously I developed other allergies though, for example, suddenly I was very allergic to cats (I had had cats earlier, so that was new).

A few years ago I was diagnosed with a case of chronic heavy-metal poisoning.

Now, many treatments with DMPS (the main chelator for mercury) and DMSA later, I have completely lost all allergies (and a long list of other "strange" problems, including a real medical miracle that left the endocrinologist repeating "I'm amazed" over and over after checking his ultrasound results twice, after asking me to lie down again because he did not trust his results).

End of anecdote.

------------------------------

EDIT: As someone who has taken hundreds of hours of anatomy, physiology, org. chem, statistics (focus on public health and use in medicine), neuroscience, I am aware that there is not "one path that explains all". There are soooooo many pathways, and different things can affect different parts leading to similar results. So I am NOT saying "this is the one and only way to get an allergy". In fact it is highly unlikely that there is only one possible cause. So if you have found an anecdote that seems to show that something else helped and/or caused it than "heavy metals" that's just fine and normal - and has nothing to do with my anecdote. You can get a flesh wound not just by cutting yourself with a kitchen knife, there are endless possibilities.

LionessLover··on How Windows Everywhere finally happened
I know the feeling. My mother's approach to computing is infuriating: If she would just READ the often perfectly simple message on the screen she could solve 90% of her problems. For the same reason as your parents ending up with Windows 10 my mother managed to install the pay-version of the free anti-virus software I had installed - when it asked here if she wanted to upgrade to the non-free version she clicked on "Yes" and then didn't dare to cancel the process...

It seems that in some people anything unexpected happening on the screen causes some of their inhibitory neurons to fire action potentials (only 10% of neurons in the brain, but an inhibitory signal has a much stronger effect than an excitatory one) - blocking entire brain circuits from contributing their output. It's probably an ancient fear response.

So the best solution isn't to educate them - that's mostly unnecessary, since their intellectual capacity is not really the problem. One would have to get them to relax, so that unexpected things happening on their computer screen don't trigger the blocking of all reason.

LionessLover··on How Windows Everywhere finally happened
I'm just curious because I really don't know more than my own sample-of-1 experience:

Don't you have to agree to "Terms and conditions" before the Windows 10 installation actually starts?

I actually re-enabled the Windows 10 upgrade warnings on my Windows 7 desktop, because I intend to upgrade in the last week of the upgrade being free. My desktop (Dell XPS 8500 from 2012) is not supported with Windows 10 (the first time I have to say "Dell, you suck!" - I've had 5 systems from them, desktops and laptops, and a few monitors up to 32 inches), and with my XPS (9333) 13 laptop (which Dell supports with Windows 10) I had pretty much unsolvable (Realtek) sound crash issues.

So anyway, just two days ago after reenabling the Windows 10 upgrade warning it started installing it on its own, as you say - but it first asked me if I agree to the "terms and conditions". I clicked "disagree" and the upgrade was canceled.

So from my own experience I can't see that Microsoft installs Windows 10 without an option to stop the process? I also have not been bothered with another attempt of auto-installation in the days since, but that's probably going to happen after an actual reboot - thus far I've only used "suspend to disk" to switch the PC off.

LionessLover··on One Chart, Twelve Charting Libraries
> is a prerequisite to learning R

Which is not what I said, so I have no idea what exactly you "very strongly" disagree with - it's all in your head. You disagree with your own vivid imagination.

> I also dislike the claim that R is not a real programming language

The only one saying that is YOU!

This is you - "Dick from the Internet": http://dilbert.com/strip/2015-06-07

Making up stuff to (strongly, of course!) disagree with!

LionessLover··on Lessons I wish I had been taught (1996)
So you think people comment and don't care if nobody ever responds to them? That they don't like getting reactions (not counting the negative ones - which of course according to you nobody cares about either, unless you are "famous" - because for some inexplicable reason(ing) only famous people like positive and fear negative responses)?
LionessLover··on Lessons I wish I had been taught (1996)
Do you like it when I reply to your comment, thereby indicating that I read it, and by replying I further show that it was more important to me than many other comments I didn't reply to?

That's what you were hoping for when you wrote your reply, didn't you?

:-)

LionessLover··on AI will create 'useless class' of humans
> If you get to pick your definitions, you get to say what you want.

The term "useless" is inherently relative. The universe does not have a natural position on "usefulness". So yes, you do get to make it to mean whatever you want it to be. That is not a basis to criticize anyone - any framework you choose to set a basis is itself arbitrary. Unless you believe in some "higher purpose", where all discussion ceases to be meaningful because nothing can be proven and you can claim whatever you want, and the loudest and/or strongest "wins".

LionessLover··on Visual Group Theory
I found the book on scribd:

https://www.scribd.com/doc/116393104/Visual-Group-Theory

I don't really know that website, I just googled, and I checked that I can access all pages and without having to login or subscribe. "Download" asks for a login, but I only wanted to check the book out.

LionessLover··on One Chart, Twelve Charting Libraries
I can only speak for R but I guess it's the same for all of them: With just very few options the output can be vastly different.

Have a look at some basic ggplot2 examples (all examples were made from the same data): http://tutorials.iq.harvard.edu/R/Rgraphics/Rgraphics.html

I hate to be negative, but this overview is useful only for people who don't really need it - who want to have a look but not actually do anything with it. It's not useful to select a library (especially since it compares completely different languages), and if you already know which system and language to go with it's not useful either.

If you think about learning R: If you don't also learn (a significant amount of) statistics it's a waste of time IMHO. There are (free, if you ignore the "verified certificate" options) courses available on Coursera and edX - even Microsoft has one (on edX). It's worth it - and I mean learning the statistics, not just R. Even if you don't think you need it professionally. Don't try using R as a "graphics" (plotting) or even a programming package - quite frankly, it's not very good at the latter (all modern "real" programming languages are better and more consistent and less "hacky"), but to work your way through lots of DATA quickly R is beautiful.

LionessLover··on Anguish: Invisible Programming Language and Invisible Data Theft
Jetbrains: "Zero Width Characters locator" plugin (https://plugins.jetbrains.com/plugin/7448)
LionessLover··on The pressure to publish pushes down quality
Your criticism of Gladwell is oddly unspecific given the nature of your criticism. You fail to state what exactly you criticize in his 10,000 hour statement.

When I read the kind of criticism you seem to be referring to, like this one:

http://www.businessinsider.com/new-study-destroys-malcolm-gl...

I notice that the examples are silly: They equate "success" with "mastery". For example, they write

> Then there's a band like the Sex Pistols, who took the world by storm even though Sid Vicious could barely play his bass.

So they themselves say he "could barely play his bass"! How does that refute the mastery theory? The Richard Branson example is about "success" and not "mastery" too - I bet Richard DID have "10,000 hours" of business practice.

Not that Gladwell made any specific predictions either AFAIR. I wish the people criticizing his work would made an example of how to be better - but it seems the criticism itself sets new low points in quality.

"What Malcolm Gladwell REALLY Said About The 10,000 Hour Rule":

http://problogservice.com/2012/03/15/what-malcolm-gladwell-r...

> “Malcolm Gladwell said you have to have 10000 hours in a subject to be an expert,” they will often state. The problem is, they’re repeating a misquote from someone else who has never read the book.

Also note how Gladwell quotes scientists - so any criticism should be directed at those:

> “The emerging picture from such studies is that ten thousand hours of practice is required to achieve the level of mastery associated with being a world-class expert—in anything,” writes the neurologist Daniel Levitin. — p. 40

LionessLover··on Museum of Soviet arcade machines
https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/U880

> The U880 is an almost identical copy of Zilog's 8-bit Z80 microprocessor.

I wrote my first machine-level programs on that chip (I didn't have an assembler, only a dis-assembler, so I hand-translated the code and then used the dis-assembler to check if I had made typos).

LionessLover··on Standard deviation is ready for retirement: Nassim Taleb (2014)
You didn't read it? Or you overlooked the part where he said WHO should "retire" it - and who should keep it!

This is about how people interpret statistical results. Which is not a mathematical process - it is what comes after the math.

← PreviousPage 5 of 6Next →