HNHacker News
TopNewBestAskShowJobs

Lionsion

1,164 karma · joined March 12, 2018

submissionscomments
Lionsion··on When banks abandoned American Samoa, the islands found a solution: public banks
> To understand why banks are scaling back and why it causes American Samoa such pain, imagine a basic small-town bank. It takes in paychecks and other deposits from locals and uses them as reserves when lending to their neighbors, who then invest in property and businesses.

> That model breaks down when banks span states or countries. The big banks with tiny branches in American Samoa are happy to take deposits from locals, but when it comes to lending that money back out, it makes cold, actuarial sense to focus on bigger, safer clients elsewhere.

This is another pretty good general argument against bank consolidation. In addition to increasing economic fragility during crises, large banks also neglect real communities that need their services during the good times.

Lionsion··on Facebook now denying access unless EU users opt-in to tracking
> GDPR doesn't cover enough of the population using Facebook to warrant such a change to their business model where you can use the service without them using your data.

The real question isn't population, it's revenue per user. An typical American or a European will draw a lot more revenue to Facebook than a typical person from a 3rd world country accessing Facebook through "Free Basics."

My educated guess is that Europe is Facebook's #2 market behind the US, and there's enough revenue there for them to change their business model.

Lionsion··on Facebook now denying access unless EU users opt-in to tracking
> "We require tracking to pay for the costs of providing this free service".

> No such thing as a free lunch.

Please square that with the fact (which I already pointed out) that they already provide their free service without targeting, based on user settings.

They can't using tracking to "pay the costs of providing this free service" without ad targeting (unless they're selling the tracking data, which they publicly deny).

I'm making an educated guess that mere declarations of necessity tracking are not sufficient legal justification for it in the EU.

Lionsion··on Facebook now denying access unless EU users opt-in to tracking
> what? seriously? Do EU citizens have some kind of legal right to Facebook access, now? It's illegal for Facebook to not serve people they can't sell to advertisers?

Facebook doesn't have a right to track people in the EU without gaining their consent to it in a way that complies with EU law.

EU citizens have a legal right to expect that Facebook will comply with European consumer protection laws.

If Facebook doesn't want to properly comply with EU regulations, they're free to totally withdraw from the EU market. Otherwise, it can expect penalties for its willful noncompliance.

Lionsion··on Facebook now denying access unless EU users opt-in to tracking
I can't see that argument going well: Since they let users opt-out of targeted advertising, which is probably the only thing "tracking" is useful for, they tacitly admit that "tracking" is not necessary for them to providing their service.
Lionsion··on Facebook now denying access unless EU users opt-in to tracking
IIRC, the GDPR is very explicit about what constitutes valid consent, so things like pre-checked check-boxes aren't valid.

Is "consent" gained by a screen with only an "I agree" button even kosher by it?

Lionsion··on List of screw drives
> Ugh, except Pozidriv will still cam and tear up their own screws, and same with Phillips.

That's true, but using a Phillips screwdriver with a Pozidriv screw is worse than either system by itself.

Robertson may be objectively better, but that's irrelevant to my point. I was I was addressing was one of confusion.

I think your comment more properly belongs at the root than as a response to mine.

Lionsion··on List of screw drives
> Here in the midwest US the hardware stores carry them and Phillips, in about 50:50 proportion -- At least for construction screws (decking screws for example) this is true.

I've seen them too, but only as construction screws. I've never seen a square drive sheet metal or machine screw in the US, for instance.

Lionsion··on List of screw drives
Important FYI for any Americans who don't know:

Ikea screws are not Phillips, they're actually Pozidriv, which is different enough to matter. Do not use a Phillips screwdriver to assemble Ikea furnature, as that combination will easily cam out and ruin the (typically soft metal) screw. It's easiest to buy the correct Pozidriv screwdriver bits from Ikea, but they're also available online.

My understanding is that Pozidriv is as popular in Europe as Phillips is in America. They look so similar that you probably won't know the difference unless you're told about it.

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/List_of_screw_drives#Pozidriv:

> Pozidriv and Phillips are not interchangeable. While Pozidriv screwdrivers fit Phillips screws, they may slip or tear out the Phillips screw head. Conversely, while Phillips screwdrivers will loosely fit and turn Pozidriv screws, they will cam out if enough torque is applied, potentially damaging the screw head or screwdriver.

Lionsion··on Volvo to Use Google Assistant, Play Store and Maps in Next-Gen Infotainment
>> Considering the lifecycle of a car vs an Android device, they better just build in a touch screen w/ a HDMI + USB connection, and let the compute brains get swapped out inexpensively ...

> This is literally what Android Auto and CarPlay are.

Except less open and less standards compliant?

Lionsion··on Uber vehicle reportedly saw but ignored woman it struck
> However, humans simply don't maintain focus for a long period of time without some sort of extreme, years-long training.

And anyone who's achieved this ability is unlikely to be willing to be hired as 1099 contractor for whatever low pay is being offered.

Lionsion··on Russian ALFA Class interceptor submarine
I think the opponent Russian sub was an Alfa, though. That's the one that's sunk at the end of the movie.
Lionsion··on China Plans $47B Fund to Boost Its Semiconductor Industry
> Let's just hope China will not take back Taiwan to get the state-of-the-art fabs there.

I wonder if the Taiwanese or the US has a plan for destroying those and similar advanced facilities to keep the technology out of the hands of the Chinese after an invasion? It might disincentivize the Chinese a bit, though I'm sure the nationalistic motivations would override any practical concerns.

Lionsion··on China Plans $47B Fund to Boost Its Semiconductor Industry
> I think the way this will play out as there will be another contest of Great Powers is that the United States will in turn decide soon to compete and pour billions more into technology. This will continue to be a great time to work in Silicon Valley.

My guess is that any such money will flow elsewhere. The government likes to spread its money around, and Silicon Valley is an expensive place and too hot on selling ads.

Lionsion··on Google embraces, extends, and extinguishes
> The complaint is that they're extending the email standard by sending single-URL bodies instead of the messages inline.

Someone needs to write a client to recognize the gmail, single-URL, bodies and archive the content with the messages.

Lionsion··on US accuses China of pointing lasers at its pilots from Djibouti base
This photo shows the situation much more clearly:

https://mashable.com/2013/07/01/egypt-protestors-laser-point...

Lionsion··on Swedish Academy Won’t Award Nobel Prize in Literature This Year
> E.g. why the Swedish academy instead of the Royal Society?

Because a rich Swede endowed it over a century ago, and its had that time to build up prestige.

It's sort of like why Harvard is so prestigious: it was the first American University, its existed continuously, and has always ran itself like it was elite.

> I think it is a bit strange how we fetisihize the Nobel above all others.

My guess it's one of the oldest extant awards of its kind, if not the oldest.

This scandal (and the hiatus) might allow a competitor to emerge as the most prestigious award in the field of literature, but I doubt such award will have the same popular awareness, because the Nobel's breadth helps a lot with it's fame.

Lionsion··on Searching for a Future Beyond Facebook
>> A lot would be solved by outlawing targeted advertising.

> Seems impossible without outlawing all advertising. Advertising in the nytimes over some other paper or advertising on fox over cnn are all examples of targeted advertising. You'd have to make people randomly choose advertising spots from all of media. Doesn't seem feasible.

Not the OP, but I think he has a good idea stated over-broadly. Let me fix it:

A lot would be solved by outlawing profile-based targeted advertising.

If Facebook can't use you profile to individually target you, the advertisers are left to target the mass of "Facebook users" like they target the mass of "NY Times readers."

Lionsion··on Searching for a Future Beyond Facebook
> I believe you are overestimating the intelligence and "woke-ness" of the Facebook user community, and of humanity in general.

That's an extremely cynical and pessimistic outlook that allows for little actual improvement.

If enough motivated people blast their feeds with news about how Facebook users are being used and exploited, I could see enough Facebook users becoming "sentient and aware" to cripple the network.

It won't die completely, at least no right away (MySpace is still around, after all), but I think a dent can be made.

Lionsion··on Searching for a Future Beyond Facebook
> ...and I don't see a company treating it's users as 'human beings' not 'commodities' being a front-runner to win a hypothethical future social media companies race; there are just no areas left that any rival company could simultaneously 1) exploit to stay profitable 2) make people use it.

There are a few billionaires who are having second thoughts about a lot of this, I wonder if one could fund a rival non-profit network and run it at a loss until it has enough momentum.

I know I'd shill for a non-profit, user-respecting social network and donate for its upkeep, but I just don't have the resources to keep one going.

Lionsion··on [dead]
> Centralization is kind of inherent to communism though.

Care to elucidate? My understanding it that only seems to be true if you exclusively argue from the examples of historical 20th-century regimes that labeled themselves "communist," but that's flawed perspective.

Lionsion··on [dead]
> What's the difference [between Marxism and Communism]?

You're unlikely to get a good answer to that here. HN is a site with heavy entrepreneurial/libertarian bent. Most of the people here (myself included) are chiefly going to be familiar with Marxism through the lens of mid-century libertarian polemics against central planning and histories of various brutal dictatorships that wrapped themselves in the "flag" of Marxism.

For my part, I think we're going to have to distinguish, at least, between Marx's ideas, Soviet Leninist ideas, and generic anti-market central planning. For instance, I think Marx envisioned Communism emerging from an advanced industrialized capitalist society, while all historical "Communist" countries emerged from feudal unindustrialized ones. I think some "communist" thinkers envisioned an end-state that was something like a market economy, except the workers would own the factories in which they worked rather than some remote "capitalist."

I would be extremely surprised (though grateful!) if many on HN had made a serious study of Marxism and could explain it, without succumbing to the biases I outlined above.

Lionsion··on [dead]
> Marx's comments on capitalism are still useful. His solutions didn't work out well.

> Russia ... China ...

IIRC, those "solutions" weren't his. They were dictatorships that took up central planning with a veneer of Marx.

> China now seems to have something that works, after a long painful period of Maoism.

Contemporary China has nothing to do with Marxism. It's basically an oligarchical state with its own business interests that rules over a capitalist economy.

Lionsion··on Amazon workers tell us their warehouse horror stories
> But each actor is merely doing the actions to their maximum satisfaction within the ruleset. "scuzzy" is not factored into the equation at all.

An ethical human being or organization is supposed to factor it in themselves, whether it's listed in the "ruleset" or not.

This is not a board game, real people's lives are affected.

Lionsion··on Fake it till you make it: the wolves of Instagram
> Haven't watched "Mad Men", but I think part of the appeal of Walter White was that his character, being the show's main character, was also the most well-written and nuanced which almost necessarily leads to him being the most sympathetic. The reality that he was unhappy is more than outweighed by the fact that he was living out carpé diem rather than surrendering to terminal illness.

One other thing is that he had great talent and competence as a chemist, which was often on full display. Many of the other characters in the show had no clear talents, or if they did, they it was more background or reputation than something clearly shown.

I think any character that shows extreme talent will attract fans, regardless how evil or unhappy they are, because people will divorce the talent from the other attributes and admire it on its own.

Lionsion··on Facebook Has Begun to Rank News Organizations by Trust, Zuckerberg Says
> If you want to solve the problem, I think you should try to promote critical thinking.

I don't think Facebook wants to encourage too much critical thinking, as it's business is to sell an audience to advertisers. If the audience thinks too critically, it's harder to manipulate into doing what's in the interests of FB its advertisers.

> Why not simply de-advantage the news and concentrate on social aspects? Simply put more emphasis on Original Content created by your "friends", not re-shares (no social added value, as the cost for creation was low) or simple link sharing (same thing, if you don't integrate a small comment or analysis, it has no social added value).

They've already done that.

Lionsion··on WhatsApp's CEO Is Suddenly Leaving Facebook. It Could Cost Him $1B
> The guy could have collected $336M, if he had just stayed for 2 more weeks. If it were me, I would have just grinded out those 2 weeks, and given the extra $300M to my favorite charity. I guess he must have really hated being at FB...

He he could've given an even larger donation to Signal than his co-founder did.

Lionsion··on Apple is a traditional business
Yeah. I love their commitment to privacy and security, but I only wish their platform wasn't so locked down. The only reason I went with Android in the first place was so I could side-load personally-built apps. IIRC (I could be wrong), if you want to write and side-load your own personal iOS apps, you have to pay a $99 fee and they deactivate after a week.
Lionsion··on Newton kills the ‘Sent’ folder to make email as easy as instant messaging
Did Apple let the Newton trademark lapse? I clicked on this totally expecting it to be some before-its-time innovation from 1993.
Lionsion··on U.S. Supreme Court to hear case about who gets paid in class action lawsuits
> There's a federal law from 1928 (I kid you not) that says no state can impair the ability of parties to agree to arbitration.

Do you have a citation for to the statute or the USC for that?

This is something that I'd like to write my reps about.

← PreviousPage 4 of 9Next →