HNHacker News
TopNewBestAskShowJobs

Lionsion

1,164 karma · joined March 12, 2018

submissionscomments
Lionsion··on Facebook is launching a dating feature
> Would people who avoid facebook because of privacy concerns use any dating sites at all?

Why would they? The privacy problem with Facebook is its size and the amount of personal data it integrates. If you're privacy conscious, using a stand-alone dating site is fine because the data is more siloed. It's also more practical to setup a burner identity on a special-purpose site than on a one that tries to be your online identity and social graph.

I never used tinder, but I thought about it. Part of that plan was to create a burner FB profile for it.

Lionsion··on U.S. Supreme Court to hear case about who gets paid in class action lawsuits
> The deal’s opponents were led by Ted Frank, director of litigation for the Competitive Enterprise Institute, a Washington-based conservative think tank. They said the deal violated procedural rules in U.S. law requiring settlements to be fair, reasonable and adequate.

What's the Competitive Enterprise Institute's goal in this lawsuit? I once read an editorial once by a CEI guy that was very pro-forced-arbitration, a view which often goes hand-in-hand with an opposition to class action lawsuits.

Is this lawsuit part of the legal campaign to to neuter class actions?

Lionsion··on Facebook announces Clear History feature
> If critics don't use this feature, they can put the blame solely on them.

Once this rolls out, I'm going to be posting instructions to my feed. One of the only reasons I still keep Facebook around is to publicize articles critical of social media and stuff like this.

Lionsion··on Against Facebook
> In principal, I completely agree with you. I have just found the effort futile. This could be the circle of friends I have are just drawn to this.

Yeah, I think it's more of a marathon than a sprint. Right now, I'm satisfied if someone's engagement is knocked down a level (e.g. heavy to moderate, moderate to light, light to none, none to deleted).

Lionsion··on Against Facebook
> Do you believe that we are manipulated to be addicts?

I believe the companies do their best to try (under the banner of metric-driven "engagement"), but people experience the addiction to varying degrees, with varying degrees of disruption. Some people are certainly more susceptible than others. You see the same thing with substance addiction, an addict can vary from a fully functional smoker to a homeless meth-addict whose lost their teeth.

I think this is true with social media as well. I don't think I'm too susceptible to addiction, but at times I've caught myself getting into habitual use of social media based on some of its reinforcement mechanisms.

Lionsion··on Against Facebook
>> Media Consumption Strike [list from OP]

> Seems kind of extreme to me.

Not really. Literally the next paragraph after that list is this:

> Don’t be a fundamentalist about the rules. Rules are meant to be broken. If it’s art, the rules are more loose; if its corporate media, more strict. Cinema, literature, sci-fi, comic books, indy games: as long as these types of works are not connected with our professional, interpersonal, or political responsibilities, use them in moderation. In general, make sure media consumption is done with more moderation than usual. The goal is to break your habits.

Lionsion··on Against Facebook
> They have to experience enough negative effects to reach out for help themselves.

I think, when it comes to social media, the harmful effects are much more subtle and harder to identify and articulate than those for addictive drugs. There's a benefit in pointing out and elucidating them, as well and the mechanisms by which they operate. For instance, until someone told me, I didn't realize the Facebook app works just like a slot machine, except it dispenses small amounts of social affirmation and novelty rather than small amounts of money. I just hadn't made the connection.

Lionsion··on Against Facebook
> This article makes it sound like people are forced to be social addicts.

I think "forced to be social addicts" is a misreading of the article. I think a more accurate rephrase is that "people are manipulated to be social addicts."

This essay is basically:

1. Statement of the problem, including exposure of some misleading narratives.

2. Advice to avoid being manipulated by technology and media, including but not limited to social media.

3. A heuristic for separating the media wheat from the media chaff (exploit survivorship)

Lionsion··on Hustle rallies $30M for grassroots texting tool Republicans can’t use
This is terrible. The country is already polarized enough as it is, we don't need businesses that cater to one tribe and exclude the other.

Also, I think it's creepy and a turn-off to get any kind of faux-informal mass-message "customized" with my name, mad-libs style. It's a particular uncanny-valley kind of impersonal.

Lionsion··on Use a Mikrotik as Your Home Router (2017)
What would you use then?

I don't think a manufacturer should be judged too harshly based on if they have vulnerabilities or not, since all software does, but rather on how they respond to and patch those vulnerabilities.

Lionsion··on Jan Koum to leave after broad clashes with Facebook
> WhatsApp and Facebook have many users in the developing world who could not afford a subscription unless the price was extremely low.

I would make sense to me to scale the price to the market. Make it $5 in the US and 5 rupees in India.

Lionsion··on Jan Koum to leave after broad clashes with Facebook
> The network effects would have not worked, because there are many people that can not afford $10 a year. These people would have used an alternative and at the end everyone would have used that alternative (because network effects).

There must be techniques to get around that. Maybe grant free or discounted accounts if you're connected with enough subscribers? Allow subscribers to gift free memberships to their friends? Maybe have a long "initial trial" (e.g. totally free for 1 year)?

Lionsion··on Twitter also sold data access to Cambridge Analytica researcher
> I know it’s out of fashion in 2018 to acknowledge that TOS exist and that users should have read them before agreeing to them (or at least before complaining after the fact), but this is the reality.

It's not "out of fashion," it's unrealistic and unreasonable.

If everyone fully read and understood every TOS and EULA they're affected by, along with all the unilateral changes they also usually "agree" to be bound by in the future, everyone would spend so much time reading them that they'd die because they'd have no time to eat, let alone actually use the services tied to the documents.

Lionsion··on Twitter also sold data access to Cambridge Analytica researcher
>> They didn’t realize quiz apps would harvest a huge amount of data about their profiles.

> They would've known, had they read the dialog they had to accept to access their much desired quiz.

You do remember Facebook would share your friends' data with the quiz along with yours? Your friends never got a vague click-thru warning when you accessed your "much desired quiz."

Lionsion··on IRS’ 60-Year-Old IT System Failed on Tax Day Due to New Hardware
> Fun (scary) fact – significant portions of the IRS tax system is still written in assembly. It's basically the original codebase plus 40 years of additions and patches as the tax code changed.

> They were working on projects to "elevate" it to Java, because it's pretty difficult to maintain it as-is.

Yeah, apparently an eight person IRS development team nearly developed a replacement, but the main developers were hired on a special program to pay them at above-GSA rates, and that program expired before they could put it into production:

https://federalnewsradio.com/tom-temin-commentary/2018/01/ir...

Lionsion··on IRS’ 60-Year-Old IT System Failed on Tax Day Due to New Hardware
> The IRS' IT "upgrade" is just a huge money grab. Nobody has the slightest interest or desire to do anything properly - they simply want in on that lucrative IRS money.

This is factually wrong (at least for the most current effort): https://federalnewsradio.com/tom-temin-commentary/2018/01/ir...

An eight person IRS development team nearly finished building a replacement, but the main developers were hired on a special program to pay them at above-GSA rates, and that program expired before they could put it into production.

Lionsion··on The IRS System Processing Your Taxes Is Almost 60 Years Old
The IRS already nearly developed a system to automatically translate their mainframe assembler logic into Java and check its correctness, but the main developer was hired on some special kind of program (to bypass the government salary structure) which could not be renewed before the project was completed.

Related: https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=16377329 (The IRS’s Effort to Convert Its Assembly Codebase to Java)

https://federalnewsradio.com/tom-temin-commentary/2018/01/ir...:

> Now, IRS is on the verge of solving this problem. The solution was engineered by a group of about eight people. And not under a multi-hundred-million-dollar systems integration contract. A leader of the group was Jian Wang, a Chinese emigre who is now a naturalized citizen. Wang told me his solution isn’t a silver bullet but rather a carefully worked-out methodology. It has three components so potentially powerful the IRS has filed patent applications for them.

> I say “was” because he’s left the agency, and the status of the project is dark.

> Wang was working under streamlined critical pay authority the agency has had since its landmark 1998 restructuring. It gave the IRS 40 slots under which it could pay temporary, full-time employees higher than GS rates. Former Commissioner John Koskinen pointed out Congress did not re-up this authority in 2013, despite his entreaties to former Congressman Jason Chaffetz’s Committee on Oversight and Government Reform.

> “The last one ran out this past summer,” Koskinen said. The departures included Wang. He says he applied to become a GS-15 or Senior Executive Service member so he could see through the assembler-to-Java project. But his approval didn’t come through until a week before his employment authority expired. By then he’d accepted another job. Wang says he had a house to pay for, kids to educate. Koskinen confirms the agency wanted to convert Wang. But the process of approval from Treasury headquarters and the Office of Personnel Management simply took too long.

Note: this is a repost of a comment I made previously at https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=16859012. This system has come up in the news a lot recently, but the articles are usually frustratingly vague the effort to replace it, which seems really interesting. There are so many critical mainframe programs running in business and government, and it's not an easy job to replace them. For instance, my employer has been working at it for 20 years.

Lionsion··on Artificial intelligence is being used to predict gambler behaviour
> Suggesting that people and companies are independently and collectively spending 1 trillion dollars for zero results without any form of verification is absurd.

> But, if you really want to go there. Plenty of companies only advertise online and 'magically' end up making money selling real products to real people.

Then quit the hand-waving and provide convincing proof. Also address the issue of bot-farms and other kinds of fraud that could cloud the metrics.

Lionsion··on Artificial intelligence is being used to predict gambler behaviour
> Google has about 1 trillion dollars per year in revenue that says otherwise. Online advertising became so huge because it works.

That's a non sequitur. Online advertising could be huge because of an irrational belief that it works. You conclusion needs much more support.

Lionsion··on Facebook Median Pay now $240k
> This way you are adding more complexity which in turn adds more loopholes.

I don't agree. Simple but dumb rules lead to easy to exploit loopholes. Saying they shouldn't be fixed in the name of "simplicity" is like saying a particular unhanded-case bug shouldn't be fixed because the extra case adds "complexity."

> A good tax framework should be as simple as possible to avoid this type of shenanigans.

The idea we're discussing is one where the tax framework is used as an instrument of regulation. If a behavior is found to be detrimental to society, I think society should rise to the task of regulating it rather than shirk that responsibility because of a fear of "complexity."

Lionsion··on Stack Overflow Isn’t Very Welcoming – It’s Time for That to Change
> Consider https://softwareengineering.stackexchange.com/questions/4417.... and consider is that useful?

Yes.

> curated?

It's not a worthless question. If you're talking about subjective questions, obsessive curation is not the answer.

> Should "Quit my last job." (entire answer) be there?

Sure, considering there were better answers that had far more votes. It might have been better if it wasn't, and moderation could have taken care of it.

Answers like that are certainly not an indictment of the format.

> Its not that those aren't interesting questions, its that they are the wrong fit for that format. There are better places to ask for the best programming joke than Stack Overflow and Exchange sites.

That's never the kind of think I asked or liked at programmers.se, but like I said before, they threw the baby out with the bathwater.

You haven't really convinced me that subjective questions are "wrong for the format." All you've really shown it that an unmoderated free for all produces some garbage that doesn't fir in a high quality tech Q&A site.

The real answer for why programmers.se failed is probably that the powers-that-be weren't willing to spend the time and resources to meet a new challenge, so they gave up and did something else.

Lionsion··on Facebook Median Pay now $240k
That's sloppy thinking. Here's and example why: what if a new regulation new banned targeted advertising? That would kneecap FB's business model and unique value proposition while making it easier for new entrants, since they won't have to compete with FB's now-legally-useless data trove.
Lionsion··on Facebook Median Pay now $240k
> It's easily gamed by contracting out for lower paid workers. What if Facebook came in at highest median pay because it relies more on contractors than other companies?

Easy gaming like that is easy to anticipate and account for. You just have to define "workers for the company" in a way that includes contractors and controlled entities, etc.

Lionsion··on Facebook Median Pay now $240k
> That sounds interesting but would probably be a paradise for tax lawyers. You just create a network of companies, one for each income band. That way, an employee never makes more than the average. Of course only large corperations can afford that so that smaller companies will have a harder time hiring talent.

You could probably define company, for the purposes of such a law, that excluded those kinds of structural shenanigans. Basically, define it in terms of its qualities rather than in terms of legal instruments.

I'd also guess that the IRS has already authored those definitions, or it at least a good distance of the way there.

Lionsion··on Alphabet's Median Pay Nears $200k
> Google has the lowest ceo/pay ratio since their CEO gets $1.

That's misleading, because their CEO gets paid in other ways. Garbage in garbage out.

Lionsion··on The Fall of Eclipse (2016)
> I believe Eclipse has it's own Java compiler, so it was probably a compiler feature.

It does, and it's much better than javac for IDE use cases. That's one of my biggest pain points with IntelliJ. They've tried to implement some kind of incremental compilation on top of javac, but it doesn't work reliably and often forced 5-minute from-scratch recompiles on the last project I worked on.

Lionsion··on The Fall of Eclipse (2016)
> I find complexity to Intellij a similar level.

Yeah. I recently had to use IntelliJ after a long period of using Eclipse. IntelliJ does some things better and some things worse, but IMHO, its strengths weren't compelling to override its weaknesses.

> I find those who think [Eclipse is] harder have never used it or bother learning it.

I find that very easy to believe. Some developers just don't seem to want to learn their tools, some want to be elitist about their tools, and the intersection between those sets is embarrassingly large.

Lionsion··on Stack Overflow Isn’t Very Welcoming – It’s Time for That to Change
> It was a the era of "what should I name my cat?"

A lot of those links 404 for me, but a lot of that stuff could have been taken care of by being better at defining what was on and off topic, e.g. it's a site for subjective questions about programming, rather than programmers answering subjective questions. SO has the moderation resources to handle that.

Lionsion··on Are you really Facebook’s product? The history of a dangerous idea
> “Television delivers people” was not about data privacy. It was about the medium’s impact on culture and politics. Serra and Schoolman’s critique was that TV placed the interests of advertisers over those of viewers in a subtle but deeply insidious way: by purveying content and ads that perpetuated the consumerist status quo, deadening free thinking and dampening activism. The big networks would never produce a show that threatened the interests of corporate America, they reckoned, because it was corporate America that they ultimately served.

That's true, but the "critique ... that TV placed the interests of advertisers over those of viewers" easily extends to questions about data privacy.

> What people seem to mean when they say that you’re Facebook’s product is that Facebook treats you like a product—that it fails to respect your individualism, your humanity, or your long-term interests. And the implication is that this disrespect flows inevitably from the fact that you aren’t paying for Facebook’s service.

When I use it, I also mean that Facebook's incentives aren't to cater to me, but rather to itself and to a lesser extent, its advertiser-customers from which it gets its revenue. I, as a non-paying user, have little leverage to demand consideration. It loses no revenue if I leave.

> That helps to explain why Google and Facebook really don’t think of their users as their products—at least, not their main products. Their leaders have always regarded advertising, and by extension users’ attention and data, as means to the end of building the products they really care about: Google search, Google Assistant, Facebook’s news feed.

I don't buy it. Google kills products that it has trouble monetizing. They aren't labors of love, begrudgingly subsidized by advertising.

Scandals like Facebook's are finally exposing this excessively optimistic line of thinking as the lie that it is. Tech companies aren't some special kind of company, they're companies just like Ford, Goldman Sachs, Philip Morris, Boeing, etc.

> But it’s 2018, and it’s time for Facebook’s critics to move past what has become a tired cliché. There’s something nihilistic about telling people they’re the product of a gigantic corporation and there’s nothing they can do about it. “You are the product” paints us as powerless pawns in Facebook’s game but gives us no leverage with which to improve our predicament.

This is BS. There's plenty they can do: they can disengage, they can find alternative services better suited to them, etc. It's only nihilistic if you think you have no choice except to use Facebook and play its game.

> There are at least two alternative ways of viewing our relationship to Facebook that hold more promise for making that relationship a healthier and less exploitive one. The first is to view ourselves as customers of Facebook, paying with our time, attention, and data instead of with money....The second is to view ourselves as part of Facebook’s labor force. Just as bees labor unwittingly on beekeepers’ behalf, our posts and status updates continually enrich Facebook. But we’re humans, not bees, and as such we have the capacity to collectively demand better treatment.

Aaaand it's confirmed: the author thinks we have no choice except to use Facebook and play its game, so we should try recontextualize our situation to motivate us to beg for better treatment.

Lionsion··on Stack Overflow Isn’t Very Welcoming – It’s Time for That to Change
> As the crud started piling up

You'll have to be more specific about what that "crud" is, as SO's culture seems to have a tendency to reclassify the baby as dirt and throw him out with the bathwater.

> the options were either abandon it completely (that was threatened) or clean it up along with the associated rules of what makes a good subjective question.

Seems like there should have been more options on the table than "abandon" or "remake in SO's image." SO has a better population to answer subjective questions than most of the alternatives it tries to push people towards. They really should have been more flexible.

← PreviousPage 5 of 9Next →