HNHacker News
TopNewBestAskShowJobs

LurkingPenguin

542 karma · joined August 26, 2021

submissionscomments
LurkingPenguin··on 70% of Americans Support Solar Mandate on New Homes
Since this survey was conducted at the behest of an interested party (a "leading full-service residential solar provider"), it's worth looking at what was asked. Here's the question:

> How much do you oppose or support a nationwide solar mandate?

32% expressed "strong" support for the mandate, while 38% expressed that they "somewhat" support a mandate.

Notably absent in the question: how much such a mandate would cost and who would pay for it.

I'm sure if a group that opposed solar mandates asked "A nationwide solar mandate is estimated to increase the cost of a new home by $xx,xxx. How much do you oppose or support such a mandate?" they'd get different results.

LurkingPenguin··on Deadly infection linked to contaminated room spray sold at Walmart
Certainly, it was inevitable that the pandemic would hit the US. But after reading the articles I linked to, I think it's hard to argue reasonably that the CDC wasn't at a minimum incompetent if not negligent in its handling of the situation, especially early on.

The US literally imported the virus via evacuation flights, and then the CDC made the decision not to consider asymptomatic infection and spread. Not only would this have significantly reduced the risk of people from those evacuations potentially seeding the country with virus, it would have allowed the CDC to issue accurate preventative guidance to Americans.

Then the CDC pushed out test kits that it knew were faulty. I mean, come on! Is this the best America could have done?

Meanwhile, I was living in a country (Taiwan) that knew something was up in January. At the very beginning of the month, health officials started screening passengers with a travel history to Wuhan. There was a lot talk about what was happening, so people here started masking voluntarily and the government officially banned the export of surgical and N95 masks on January 24 to ensure adequate supply for the country. My family and friends in the US had medical masks and N95s because I told them to stock up in January.

Meanwhile in America, Fauci was telling Americans "there’s no reason to be walking around with a mask" and the Surgeon General was actually telling Americans masks might increase their risk of contracting the virus...in early March!

Yes, I'm aware that Taiwan is an outlier in its success against COVID due to a variety of factors, some intrinsic (like island geography). But the US response was an abject, embarrassing disaster and it wasn't just because of destiny or crazy politicians.

LurkingPenguin··on Deadly infection linked to contaminated room spray sold at Walmart
From the articles I posted:

> Yet Reuters has found new evidence that the CDC’s response to the pandemic also was marred by actions - or inaction - by the agency’s career scientists and frontline staff.

> In addition to learning of the early warning, reviewers determined the Respiratory Viruses Diagnostic Laboratory, run by a highly regarded scientist named Stephen Lindstrom, was beset with problems, including "process failures, a lack of appropriate recognized laboratory quality standards, and organizational problems related to the support and management of a laboratory supporting an outbreak response," the review said.

I know it's in vogue in America to blame everything on the current administration (this happens on both/all sides of the aisle) but in reality, institutional rot is responsible for a lot more of the shortcomings in institutional failures. There is an obvious decline that has been taking place in many agencies for decades, across both Democratic and Republican administrations.

LurkingPenguin··on Deadly infection linked to contaminated room spray sold at Walmart
> For the current pandemic, they did not initially recommend masking because they could not justify it for the general population over the medical community. They wanted to avoid a tragedy of the commons of PPE. The covid19 prevalence was low...

I posted links in this thread which discuss how the CDC was negligent in studying the possibility of asymptomatic spread early in the pandemic, and knowingly released test kits that were faulty.

What this means is that the CDC didn't actually know what the prevalence of SARS-CoV-2 was in the US in the early days of the pandemic. It was flying totally blind and as we eventually learned, the virus was silently spreading and establishing a foothold throughout parts of the country while the CDC was assuring Americans it had everything under control and the threat was low.

My family and friends in the US were able to stock up on medical masks and N95s in January before they were pulled from the shelves because I was living in Taiwan, where it was abundantly clear in January that there was a very serious respiratory pathogen on the loose.

LurkingPenguin··on Deadly infection linked to contaminated room spray sold at Walmart
> Relevant to this story, the CDC in particular is no longer trusted by roughly half the country.

See https://www.reuters.com/article/us-health-coronavirus-cdc-re...

> Yet Reuters has found new evidence that the CDC’s response to the pandemic also was marred by actions - or inaction - by the agency’s career scientists and frontline staff.

> At a crucial moment in the pandemic when Americans were quarantined after possible exposure to the virus abroad, the agency declined or resisted potentially valuable opportunities to study whether the disease could be spread by those without symptoms, according to previously undisclosed internal emails, other documents and interviews with key players.

Well worth a read, as is https://www.npr.org/2020/11/06/929078678/cdc-report-official...

The headline says it all: CDC Report: Officials Knew Coronavirus Test Was Flawed But Released It Anyway

> In addition to learning of the early warning, reviewers determined the Respiratory Viruses Diagnostic Laboratory, run by a highly regarded scientist named Stephen Lindstrom, was beset with problems, including "process failures, a lack of appropriate recognized laboratory quality standards, and organizational problems related to the support and management of a laboratory supporting an outbreak response," the review said.

> The CDC declined to make Lindstrom or anyone else available for an interview and declined to discuss the unreleased internal review. A spokesman would only say that the agency had "acknowledged and corrected mistakes along the way."

Is it unreasonable for people to have lost faith and trust in the CDC based on its many pandemic failures?

LurkingPenguin··on Ask HN: Are you a Digital Nomad? If yes, what are the pros/cons?
Don't really consider myself a "nomad" in the sense that pre-pandemic, I would establish a home base in a country and then do frequent regional travel. Personally, I find staying in places a little bit longer to provide a richer experience as you're less of a "tourist". It's also less tiring.

The biggest pro of "nomading"/living abroad is the only one you need: you get to see and experience the world in a way that you will never be able to do if you stay in your home country.

The biggest con is that living/traveling abroad isn't always glamorous. You will encounter situations that are uncomfortable, frustrating and perhaps at times even a bit scary. Not all of these are external. Some are internal, like finding yourself questioning beliefs and values that you developed after years of being in your home country and culture.

The good news is that if you stick with it, these all become positive things. For me, it has allowed me to grow in ways I don't think I would have otherwise, and to realize that I'm capable of things that I assumed I wasn't.

LurkingPenguin··on EU scientists reveal long-term brain damage caused by Covid
> I decided a while back that if I ever developed long covid, I'd off myself. This just confirms my priors.

I generally support the right for people to choose euthanasia under appropriate circumstances, but this is a really disappointing and frankly entitled comment.

Countless millions of people are born with or acquire from disease or injury chronic illnesses and conditions that can significantly impact their quality of life. Some of these are treatable but many in parts of the world these treatments are not accessible.

Most of those people don't off themselves. They move forward in life, as difficult as it might be. And some of them not only find ways to survive life, many make incredibly meaningful contributions to their families, communities and the world at large.

LurkingPenguin··on CDC Director: U.S. may change “fully vaccinated” definition as boosters roll out
I wasn't referring to transmission on the plane. I was referring to the fact that international travel for purposes of tourism, etc. is a privilege, not a right. No country is obligated to allow in foreign nationals who are at a higher risk of serious illness if they get infected. This especially makes sense for poorer countries that are already under pandemic strain.

Furthermore, border controls can be effective at limiting the introduction of variants.

When countries do choose to let foreign nationals in, at this stage of the pandemic, it's not unreasonable for them to limit arrivals to those with immunity, whether vaccine-based or natural, or apply different requirements (such as quarantine) for people with immunity versus without.

LurkingPenguin··on CDC Director: U.S. may change “fully vaccinated” definition as boosters roll out
Vaccinating large numbers of people every 6-12 months with a non-sterilizing vaccine when the initial vaccination series is said to remain highly effective at preventing serious illness against all major variants that are currently in wide circulation is not at all routine or "widely accepted".

Again, the flu vaccine is different each year because the influenza viruses it aims to protect against are different. You are getting a different vaccine, not a "booster".

The flu vaccine is not a sterilizing vaccine and neither are any of the COVID vaccines. It is widely accepted that the flu vaccine is usually 40-60% effective at preventing illness in years where we target the right influenza viruses, and that many vaccinated individuals will get (mostly) mild infections.

From the CDC:

> A 2021 study showed that among adults, flu vaccination was associated with a 26% lower risk of ICU admission and a 31% lower risk of death from flu compared to those who were unvaccinated.

> A 2018 study showed that among adults hospitalized with flu, vaccinated patients were 59 percent less likely to be admitted to the ICU than those who had not been vaccinated. Among adults in the ICU with flu, vaccinated patients on average spent 4 fewer days in the hospital than those who were not vaccinated.

By these metrics, against the endpoints of severe outcomes, the COVID vaccines currently look much more efficacious than the flu vaccine after the initial series, even without boosting.

While "long COVID" is of concern, many of the post-infection sequelae of COVID appear similar to known post-viral sequelae. Furthermore, the initial data suggests that the initial series of vaccination reduces the risk of long COVID sequelae in breakthrough infections. To my knowledge, there is not yet any data on long COVID and boosters, so it is highly premature to hint that repeated boosters are required to maintain protection against "long COVID".

Shutting down the world indefinitely because of COVID "infections" when the vast majority of people will have mild courses of illness makes no sense. We don't do this for the flu even though in bad flu seasons, people lose work and school days and the ERs and ICUs fill up. Furthermore, as time goes on, fewer and fewer people will be SARS-CoV-2 naive. They will either have some level of protection from exposure to the initial vaccine series or prior infection. The immune system is miraculous and there is a reason it doesn't indefinitely keep high levels of neutralizing antibodies in circulation for every pathogen (or vaccine) you're exposed to.

Finally, you should consider including repeated frequent booster vaccination in your "long-term effects that we can't yet understand" thinking. While I am not suggesting that the mRNA are "unsafe" or responsible for die-offs of baby dolphins, the reality is that we have no long-term data around giving people these jabs on a regular basis. The issue with myocarditis in some populations, questions about whether the vaccines affect the menstrual cycle[1], etc. are a reminder that there is still a lot we don't know and it is contrary to the principle of "first, do no harm" to strongly recommend (or try to force) people to receive regular pre-exposure prophylaxis when there is strong evidence that they already have substantial protection against serious outcomes from an initial vaccination series.

[1] https://covid19.nih.gov/news-and-stories/covid-19-vaccines-a...

LurkingPenguin··on Indexing the Creator Economy
I was curious about the creator in the screenshot who earned $1 million on Teachable in 1 hour[1].

Interestingly, it looks like this creator is involved in the credit repair "industry" and runs some sort of "academy" teaching people how to start a credit repair business.

Forget the creator economy. It speaks volumes about the state of the economy.

[1] https://ampmacademy.com/

LurkingPenguin··on No time to die: An indepth analysis of James Bonds exposure to infectious agents
> We uncovered above-average sexual activity, often without sufficient time for an exchange of sexual history, with a remarkably high mortality among Bond's sexual partners (27.1; 95% confidence interval 16.4–40.3).

"You clean? - Yeah. You? - Yeah" has always worked for me. Knock on my wood.

LurkingPenguin··on CDC Director: U.S. may change “fully vaccinated” definition as boosters roll out
The flu is a completely different virus. In fact, what we call "the flu" is actually several different influenza viruses, so your flu shot isn't targeting just one virus, it's targeting multiple influenza viruses. The rate of mutation of these viruses is very different than that of SARS-CoV-2.

The reason there's a different flu shot every year is that the efficacy of last year's vaccine against the current influenza viruses will likely be too low to provide adequate protection, not just against infection but against serious illness. This again is because of how much the influenza viruses mutate in a short period of time.

Currently, the data indicates that the SARS-CoV-2 vaccines are holding up very well in preventing severe illness, hospitalization and death for all SARS-CoV-2 variants. This is the reason why the boosters that were approved are the same vaccine, not a new variant-specific one.

SARS-CoV-2 vaccines do not provide sterilizing immunity, and it is clear that the neutralizing antibodies produced immediately after vaccination wane quickly, which allows vaccinated individuals to still become infected.

Unless and until you see a drop in the efficacy against severe illness, hospitalization and death, this idea that we will or should be taking COVID vaccines indefinitely every year is hard to justify with science.

LurkingPenguin··on CDC Director: U.S. may change “fully vaccinated” definition as boosters roll out
> One thing that I think is getting lost in all of these discussions

What's really being lost in all of these discussions is science. Looking at your case:

1. You decided to lie to get a booster even though it has apparently not been approved for your use.

2. The vaccines do not provide sterilizing immunity and it is possible to become infected even when vaccinated. While the data does suggest that vaccination reduces transmission, it also indicates that infected vaccinated individuals are still capable of spreading the virus.

3. Despite the fact that you have no idea how much additional protection your booster will give you, and for how long, or if and how much it might reduce your ability to transmit the virus to others, you're choosing to be "very bad about masking and social distancing right now" which will increase your potential exposure, especially if you live in an area with a higher positivity rate. More exposure, even while vaccinated, increases your risk of infection.

4. You say you're doing this to protect the children you are in close contact with, but according to the CDC, only 542 children under the age of 18 have died in the US during the entire pandemic.

> At the other end of the spectrum, I think it's totally okay for anyone who is vaccine-skeptical, for whatever reason, to take a wait and see approach. But there eventually comes a point when a majority of the public has actually gone ahead and been guinea pigs for you, and you're just needlessly endangering people.

How long before the definition of "vaccine skeptical" changes? Will someone eventually be labeled "vaccine skeptical" because they refuse to get their 10th booster?

LurkingPenguin··on CDC Director: U.S. may change “fully vaccinated” definition as boosters roll out
People with natural immunity should be considered to have immunity. The science clearly shows that their immunity is not inferior and is perhaps superior to those with vaccine-based immunity. It's crazy to me that we're even having a debate about whether natural immunity should count as immunity.
LurkingPenguin··on CDC Director: U.S. may change “fully vaccinated” definition as boosters roll out
While I personally have reservations about mandates/passports for being able to travel domestically, eat at restaurants, etc., in terms of things like international travel, which is a privilege, there is a valid argument for treating people with no immunity differently as they are at a higher risk of severe illness, hospitalization and death. Those can cause high costs that are borne by others.

But yes, statements like the one about protecting the vaccinated from the unvaccinated have been head-scratching, which goes back to my point about how the CDC and other authority figures continue to bungle the messaging and shoot themselves in the foot.

I'm fully vaccinated but am not sold on getting a booster because I'm not in a high-risk group and understand the current science to indicate that the initial series I received continues to significantly reduce my risk of illness, hospitalization and death. Of the friends and family I've discussed boosters with, most say they have similar thinking. I find it hard to believe that somebody who has not yet been vaccinated will see Walensky's comment about the "fully vaccinated" definition possibly changing and suddenly feel eager to get the initial series.

LurkingPenguin··on CDC Director: U.S. may change “fully vaccinated” definition as boosters roll out
The CDC once again continues to bungle its messaging, which is only going to fuel vaccination controversy and anti-vaxxer talking points.

According to the CDC, "The COVID-19 vaccines approved and authorized in the United States continue to be effective at reducing risk of severe disease, hospitalization, and death."[1]

Walensky has repeated this[2]:

> “The evidence shows that all three COVID-19 vaccines authorized in the United States are safe — as demonstrated by the over 400 million vaccine doses already given," Walensky said.

> "They are all highly effective in reducing the risk of severe disease, hospitalization, and death, even in the midst of the widely circulating Delta variant," she added.

If you have vaccines for which the initial series is "highly effective" at reducing the risk of severe disease, hospitalization and death, why would you tell people that you're considering changing the definition of "fully vaccinated" to exclude individuals who have received the initial series?

[1] https://www.cdc.gov/coronavirus/2019-ncov/vaccines/booster-s...

[2] https://www.axios.com/cdc-guidance-boosters-mix-and-match-90...

LurkingPenguin··on Multiple-property owners are now the largest slice of Toronto home buyers
> “Why wouldn’t we take that opportunity? It’s not up to the people to stop their growth as businessmen. It’s up to the policies to protect people, and to protect affordability.”

While it's true that real estate investors like this one aren't doing anything illegal, it's also evident that this "sucks for you but I got mine" mindset isn't going to lead anywhere good for society.

LurkingPenguin··on Chinese Developer Defaults Pile Up as Evergrande Contagion Spreads
> Some investors say they are now monitoring every pending interest and principal payment in the sector, and asking chief financial officers if their companies will pay back debt as planned. “We now need to track every single coupon and upcoming maturity,” said Jim Veneau, head of fixed income for Asia at AXA Investment Managers.

Funny. Normally that's what fixed income people are paid to do.

LurkingPenguin··on Ask HN: I'm making like 0 friends at college, how to fix it?
I'm surprised nobody has suggested "find a good supply of high-quality weed and start dealing on the side."
LurkingPenguin··on [dead]
> That is literally just text on a field from the same company making these claims

Huh? Are you suggesting that the company is illegally selling this spray in the US or other countries where it would be unlawful to do so? If so, please present your evidence.

> Where is there evidence of this treatment working or even a hint that it’s worth researching more?

You can reasonably raise questions about the efficacy of the treatment. Screaming "Where's the FDA?!?" when the company explicitly states that it is only selling the treatment in a country where it has authorization to do so is silly.

LurkingPenguin··on [dead]
> Apparently the laws are different in Estonia but this company has a San Francisco office.

I really hate "regulation!" comments like this.

Who cares if this company has an SF office? How is that relevant?

A quick Google search shows that the company has marketing authorization for the nasal spray in Estonia and is only selling it there.

https://www.icosagen.com/news/our-nasal-spray-with-antibodie...

> BioBlock® is currently restricted to sale in Estonia.

LurkingPenguin··on Paintmakers are running out of the color blue
I think you're vastly underestimating the volume of cargo that moves and the world of infrastructure that has been put in place to move it.

Also, to the extent that small vessels are used in the "transportation" business, it's for contraband, not Beanie Babies. Look up the street value of 100 kilos (~220 pounds) of cocaine in major US and European cities and compare it to the value of a 40 foot container full of nuts and bolts.

LurkingPenguin··on It's been nearly 20 years since inflation has been this high in Canada
I told my Canadian friends that legalizing marijuana would eventually have consequences. Nobody listened.
LurkingPenguin··on Paintmakers are running out of the color blue
No. Virtually all goods that move by sea (save for commodities like oil) move in containers, which require container ships and associated infrastructure (deep water ports, etc.).
LurkingPenguin··on Flexport CEO on how to fix the US supply chain crisis
Indeed. I live in Asia and one of the first things I learned when I moved is that Some American Brand's clothing in Asia is frequently not of the same quality as Some American Brand's clothing in the US, even when it's actually more expensive.
LurkingPenguin··on Paintmakers are running out of the color blue
> That's not a bad approach, but the problem is a lot of supply chain planning is top-down and dictates "we only want to keep $x tied up in inventory" and as you can imagine that number is driven by management as low as possible.

This actually isn't true to the extent you seem to think it is, though.

> Basically my view is that it's this over reactiveness and obsession with free cash flow has swung so far so as to create a too-painful jam.

But that's not the only cause of the supply chain situation. Transportation is also a big part of the issue. Even if you had 10 years' worth of widgets in a warehouse in China, if you can't get them on a ship, or the shipping costs are too high, you get supply shortages where the customers need those widgets.

LurkingPenguin··on Flexport CEO on how to fix the US supply chain crisis
I have had exposure to industrial equipment sales in Asia, Latin America and the Mideast. American-made equipment generally has an excellent reputation. Cost, however, is often an issue.

It would be helpful if you were more specific. Where do you come from? What types of products are you talking about?

LurkingPenguin··on Flexport CEO on how to fix the US supply chain crisis
Can you name Chinese products (made in China by and for Chinese companies -- not American or European companies) that you consider to be of high quality? Same for South America.

And what American products have "constantly" disappointed you?

LurkingPenguin··on Paintmakers are running out of the color blue
2 years' worth of Christmas ornaments? 10 years' worth?

The amount of crap that we consume is astounding. And in many cases, each specific type of crap requires a bunch of smaller crap (components).

There is literally no way for a consumption-driven society as broad and deep as ours to stockpile years' worth of everything.

LurkingPenguin··on Paintmakers are running out of the color blue
Toyota actually isn't as JIT as you make it out to be, but that notwithstanding, what's the alternative? Stockpile 30 years' worth of Christmas ornaments in warehouses in Oklahoma, right next to the oil storage?
← PreviousPage 6 of 16Next →