HNHacker News
TopNewBestAskShowJobs

MatthewWilkes

1,326 karma · joined October 26, 2012

submissionscomments
MatthewWilkes··on What is the ‘legitimate interests’ basis?
That's not gaming it, it's a feature. GDPR isn't designed to stop companies contacting you, it's designed to ensure companies have to think through what they're doing and have process for handling objections and problems. You have to do a "balancing check" to document your reasoning for why your legitimate interest is sufficient for what you're proposing to do.
MatthewWilkes··on What is the ‘legitimate interests’ basis?
Sure. I admit, I simplified things because hackernews can be a rather hostile environment on this topic. It's not that you can't use consent, it's (as you say) that legitimate interest is insufficient as most types of electronic marketing require consent and those where it is possible is made much harder to justify as a long-term strategy.

The PECR section on the ICO website is a good start: https://ico.org.uk/for-organisations/guide-to-pecr/electroni...

Also, the ICO has an FAQ on exactly this at https://ico.org.uk/for-organisations/guide-to-the-general-da... . It is the question "Can we use legitimate interests for our marketing activities?". The whole thing is useful, but the bit below the yellow call-out is specifically about electronic marketing, and says:

"If you intend to process personal data for the purposes of direct marketing by electronic means (by email, text, automated calls etc) legitimate interests may not always be an appropriate basis for processing. This is because the e-privacy laws on electronic marketing – currently the Privacy and Electronic Communications Regulations (PECR) – require that individuals give their consent to some forms of electronic marketing. It is the GDPR standard of consent that applies, because of the effect of Article 94 of the GDPR." There's also a helpful table of possibilities below.

There's still the so-called 'soft opt-in', which is for cases where you're emailing someone that you've recently sold something to (or given a quote to) about a similar product or service and that you've given the explicit choice to refuse communications both when you collected the data and every time you've subsequently used it.

It's certainly possible to use legitimate interest for some forms of electronic marketing, but only in very specific circumstances. To give you an idea of it in practice, one of my clients has a marketplace style site. If you try and book a service but the booking falls through, for example because the service provider is unavailable, they'll email you within a couple of days if you don't look for someone new, pushing some suggestions. Then they'll stop emailing. That's legitimate interest through soft opt-in. They also send emails periodically about new service providers in your area, that is not covered by the soft opt-in so requires consent. Same for their general service newsletters.

There is also a PDF guide at https://ico.org.uk/media/1555/direct-marketing-guidance.pdf which has some good info. The header for the electronic marketing section is "General rule: only with consent", which I think is good advice. As others have said, there are other obligations under GDPR, so even if you can stretch the soft opt-in beyond what was intended, you're likely to run up against hurdles when it comes to the balancing test, or your data minimisation obligations. The soft opt-in is specifically for cases where a member of the public would expect to get communications because of the recent sale or enquiry, as time passes that expectation goes away and it starts to become very hard to justify in a GDPR context.

MatthewWilkes··on What is the ‘legitimate interests’ basis?
The PECR regulations specifically state that consent is the only basis for electronic marketing. The ICO guidelines also state that legitimate interest is fine for marketing, but not electronic marketing.

Anyone who dropped explicit consent for emails, text messages or phone calls is a fool.

MatthewWilkes··on Do You Know Cobol? If So, There Might Be a Job for You
I can't tell if this is in the article as it's paywalled, but a company in York recently put up an advert for £20k/year for Cobol programmers with no programming experience required, doubling at the end of the training period.
MatthewWilkes··on UK Surveillance Regime Violated Human Rights
He has committed crimes in the UK that he is wanted for. The charges in Sweden were dropped for practical reasons, something the UK should also have done. It's a sunk cost fallacy, they've spent a huge amount of time and money trying to arrest him despite it not being practical.
MatthewWilkes··on Apple didn't delete that guy's movies – what really happened
While it is interesting to read more of the root cause, the tone of this article is surprisingly pro-Apple to my ears. No, they didn't delete his movies, but they did introduce a technical limitation to prevent him from accessing content that they told him he was buying because of details of media licencing.

This isn't something a reasonable member of the public would expect, and the UX and customer service paths he experienced did not help him understand or try to make him whole, they dismissed his concerns.

MatthewWilkes··on New Roomba Has Persistent Maps, Selective Room Cleaning, Automatic Dirt Disposal
Sounds great, but unless they offer a model with no internet connectivity it'll be a no from me. I've got an older Roomba that only has 802.15.4 and IR connectivity, with no cameras. That feels a lot safer.
MatthewWilkes··on Show HN: Unyt – Handle, manipulate, and convert data with units in Python
Is there a better link for this? The provided one seems to be some academic bureaucracy.

I'd be interested in knowing how this differs from pint.

MatthewWilkes··on Electric scooters are illegal in the UK because of 1835 law
I had no idea that electric scooters were a fad elsewhere, but the tone of this article makes me glad they aren't in the UK. The assumption seems to be that they'd be on the footpath, which just sounds crazy to me. As for the roads, I thought the pedelec compromise of not allowing throttle controls was quite sensible.
MatthewWilkes··on Six Months at Riot Games
9 clicks to opt out of tracking cookies. Why do these companies bother adding these banners if they're not going to comply with the law?
MatthewWilkes··on Wells Fargo says hundreds of customers lost homes after computer glitch
I know GDPR isn't very popular with some users of this site, but the rights related to automated decision making are a wonderful thing.
MatthewWilkes··on The Twilio API for WhatsApp
It's amazing how true that is. The last time I received an SMS from a person rather than a business was over a month ago.
MatthewWilkes··on Version Control Before Git with CVS
This is a really interesting perspective for people who haven't grown up with Git. I'd not grokked a distinction between three generations of VCS before and it's strange to me to hear git's bad UI described as something other people think.
MatthewWilkes··on Don't Provide Your References to a Recruiter Until After Your Last Interview
I had one background checking service (run by a credit reference agency) forge a document authorising them to get details of my finances and send it to my referees once. The whole process is infested with the least ethical people imaginable.
MatthewWilkes··on Why nobody ever wins the car at the mall
Amusingly, the website this article is hosted in pops up a modal asking you to sign up to a mailing list with a low contrast dismiss button and saying "you can always unsubscribe". People in glass houses.
MatthewWilkes··on UK’s Dixons Carphone admits huge data breach
Given they say this only affects cards without chip-and-pin, this is probably of interest to people from the US who have flown in to British airports, as Dixons operate electronics stores selling things like portable USB chargers, headphones, kindles, SD cards, etc in most large UK airports.
MatthewWilkes··on Gitlab does not comply with GDPR
They've most likely been mislead by very poor advice on marketing communications. Under GDPR a company can rely on "legitimate interest" as their lawful basis for processing for marketing purposes. However, this ignores the older PECR rules that say that electronic marketing requires consent.

Requiring users to agree to the a new privacy policy or updated terms and conditions is obviously still fine. GDPR does not restrict companies from requiring that their users agree to terms as part of their provision of services.

As far as I can tell from this post, the only problem is that GitLab have used the guidance for postal marketing when they're doing electronic marketing. Yes, it's not compliant, but references to the UDHR and the general tone of this suggest the user has a prior grievance and they're trying to over-inflate this issue.

MatthewWilkes··on German butcher's GDPR notice
See also, this italian version that did the rounds a couple of weeks ago: https://twitter.com/koenfucius/status/997783004155187200
MatthewWilkes··on Microsoft .Net Core telemetry is not opt-in
This has been covered here many times, but consent is not the only basis for lawful processing under GDPR.
MatthewWilkes··on Why You Can't Just Block EU Visitors, EU Customers, or Any EU Traffic Under GDPR
Fair point. Pretty much all of my data protection work recently has been with sites that can identify the person, sorry, I let thay context affect what I said.

That said, doesn't this assume the user has a dynamic IP address? You can't easily tell a dynamic from a static, so wouldn't you have to plan for the worst?

MatthewWilkes··on Why You Can't Just Block EU Visitors, EU Customers, or Any EU Traffic Under GDPR
Then why block the EU to begin with? The argument is clear, blocking users is not a panacea.
MatthewWilkes··on Why You Can't Just Block EU Visitors, EU Customers, or Any EU Traffic Under GDPR
IP address is PII, though. The fact that you're processing it into broader categories in order to make an automated decision is neither here nor there.

Logging HTTP requests is allowed not because it contains no sensitive data, but because you have a legitimate interest in logging usage of the web server in order to defend yourself against computer crimes, for example. What you aren't allowed to do is retain these logs indefinitely as if they weren't sensitive.

MatthewWilkes··on GDPR: Don't Panic
My (EU) clients fall into two camps. Those who haven't had to do a single thing to be GDPR compliant because they were already following the various data protection and privacy laws, and the ones panicking.

The latter group say things like "this is ridiculous, they're making us change so much" but never have an answer to the fact that they're already violating PECR or the Data Protection Act.

MatthewWilkes··on Medium tries to prevent people reading deleted articles on the Wayback Machine?
How will it work with copyright law, or defamation law?
MatthewWilkes··on VLC removed from Amazon Fire TV store by VLC developers
If post description is accurate and the old version has been remote-wiped from devices, does that mean the data migration issue is no longer relevant?
MatthewWilkes··on Credit Card Signatures Are About to Become Extinct in the U.S
I know some terminals here in the UK lie about their capabilities, for example they'll tell the card they're offline only even if they do support online transactions.
MatthewWilkes··on Credit Card Signatures Are About to Become Extinct in the U.S
I think it also depends on what buttons they press. I believe if they select credit card it forces it to be a signature.
MatthewWilkes··on Credit Card Signatures Are About to Become Extinct in the U.S
The UK was relatively late to the party, some large retailers here campaigned against it as they were afraid that going online for authorisations would increase the time it took to serve people. I believe that the offline mode was enough to appease them, even now you occasionally run up against offline-only EMV terminals.
MatthewWilkes··on ZFS 128 bit storage: Are you high? (2004)
The term does derive from Gullivers Travels, where the big endians and the little endians were both to be found on an island in the Indian ocean.

Of course, the real reason for the mistake is that phone spelling correction will convert endian to Indian.

MatthewWilkes··on Amazon will launch its own delivery service to compete with FedEx, UPS
It's interesting reading the comments in this thread as they seem to be very much from a US standpoint. Here in the UK it's rare for Amazon packages to be sent by anything other than Amazon Logistics. There are issues with misdelivery or leaving things in plain view, but the same is true of their competitors such as Yodel. The difference with Amazon is that even if they've taken a photo of a safe place as 'proof' of delivery for an item they don't argue if you report it as undelivered.

Prime gives you free next day delivery, including outside of business hours and weekends, and sometimes free same day depending on their logistics. Overall, buying from Amazon and having them deliver it is a better than average experience.

← PreviousPage 3 of 12Next →