HNHacker News
TopNewBestAskShowJobs

Mc91

549 karma · joined August 17, 2017

(defun mc91 (n) (cond ((<= n 100) (mc91 (mc91 (+ n 11)))) (t (- n 10))))
submissionscomments
Mc91··on Why did Usenet fail?
This is (part of) the correct answer, yet it is way down the list of upvoted answers.

The story is:

1) There were a number of independent ISPs, but oligarchic forces, in addition to the Verizon/AT&T last mile monopoly consolidated things so that Verizon/AT&T became the ISP for most people, with limited competition.

2) Once consolidated, Verizon and AT&T killed their news servers. This mostly happened in 2008. The old Internet which was more open and peer-to-peer became a platform with end users limited mostly to web clients, consuming from big corporate upstream web servers.

3) This was helped along by various places in the US government, which blessed or even applied pressure to kill off the old peer-to-peer nature of the Internet, particularly Usenet, for the current model of big corporate web servers to end user customers.

Of course the public relations announcements were all of this was done for the litany of reasons companies and the government do anything - to protect customers/children/whatever, fight against the forces of evil etc.

Mc91··on Ask HN: Who got hired from HN?
I got a consulting gig a few years ago, which is what I wanted.
Mc91··on Where have all the hackers gone?
> Like, the people who say that they can’t work for a manager unless the manager could do their job!

I've worked in IT for over 25 years. Other than a CTO or senior tech executive reporting to CEO, I have seen problems with technical people reporting to non-technical people that I never see with technical people reporting to, if not technical people, at least formerly technical people. A technical manager can have problems of their own, but why enter a new class of problems that don't exist otherwise.

Why would I work somewhere where my boss is effectively a PM?

Mc91··on Ask HN: Was tech always so scammy?
> Ask HN: Was tech always so scammy?

Yes

Mc91··on More students are turning away from college and toward apprenticeships
I have been programming for a Fortune 500 company for four years. Not long ago, I applied for a job at another Fortune 500 company. HR really had only question for me, they saw on my resume I did not have a college degree listed, and did I have one? I said I went through most of college towards a Bachelors in Computer Science but dropped out before graduation. I did not get the job, although I don't know if that's why. Same thing has happened in the past with other HR departments. It's not completely fatal, but it's not helpful either, rather the opposite.

I went to a good state school and didn't rack up any debt while going to college.

In recent headier times, a BSCS was a preferred requirement. In the current environment, I can easily see job listings on Linkedin that say a BSCS is a minimum requirement.

It's just another stumbling block that can be in your path. Some people don't have a problem with it in their career, and in headier times it doesn't matter, but when layoffs are happening as they are now, and companies are flooded with dozens or hundreds of resumes, an easy thing to do is just look who has a BSCS and who doesn't and put the latter in the wastebasket.

Mc91··on Load 'em up and throw 'em under the bus
> One theory of mine is that we assign senior-sounding roles in this industry too readily.

Some large companies, particularly non-technical companies have to pay a certain amount of money to get people of a certain skill level, say a level below senior. However the company management does not want to pay market rates for that level, that salary only goes to "senior" people. So people with a skill level below senior are put on work that fits for a level below senior, but are given the senior title, because within the company, that is the title that matches up with the market rate for those people.

Mc91··on TikTok-owner ByteDance planning to layoff thousands in coming months
I always see them hiring Android programmers on Linkedin, including right now

https://careers.tiktok.com/position?keywords=android&categor...

Wonder if Android people will be laid off.

Mc91··on Walmart to close three tech hubs, tells tech staff to return to offices
It is not team dependent in our division. I know it is happening in another division too, since late January they've been required to be back in the office for some days during the week.
Mc91··on Walmart to close three tech hubs, tells tech staff to return to offices
I am a SWE at another Fortune 100 retailer...we have been told to start reporting to the office this month, after about three years of WFH. Two days a week to start with.
Mc91··on Vim is touch-typing on steroids
I think this is the answer. I started using vi 33 years ago and initially learned just what I needed to know. As time went on I learned more commands.

If I wanted to erase a word in a sentence, which had seven letters, initially I might type x eight times (erase the word and a space). Then as I learned more vi I might type 7x. As I learned more vi I might type dw.

You can get a lot of navigation and editing done just knowing a few commands in vi. If you use it a lot, you can learn more commands and have an easier time.

About 7-8 years ago the standard IDE for my programming niche changed, and I had to learn a new IDE and what I knew of the old IDE I have almost never used since. The vi stuff I learned 30 years ago I am still using.

Mc91··on Ask HN: Do anyone get anxiety from following Hacker News?
>> Crypto, ML, Data, Quantum Computing

> I think the key is to focus and prioritize

I think prioritizing is the key. Part of that is figuring out

What is past its prime (Cobol on punch cards), or never really had its day in the sun at all.

What is dull but you can make money with, which will probably be around in some form five years from now too (backend programming of micro-services with a popular JVM language)

What exciting things are coming into being now which might have some jobs or interesting applications now, or perhaps a lot more in a few years (training and using deep learning models).

Crypto nowadays is mostly a scam which began unwinding over a year ago. Probably best to ignore it, its day is past.

Quantum computing is interesting but it's such early days that you can put off reading about it this year if you're overwhelmed.

ML and big data have had a lot of interesting applications this year. GPT, Stable Diffusion, DALL-E. I can do some pretty cool things on my workstation with Stable Diffusion that was not able to do five months ago. If you have time to look into something new this would be it.

As I said, there's modern but dull and not much new innovation things, which there is steady work and money in like React front end programming, or JVM Microservice backend programming, or whatever. There are also things like deep learning which are going from innovation to innovation, which is exciting and may open up a whole new field (Stability AI just got $100 million in funding, although things are so new, they only started putting their hiring team together last month - they're mainly recruiting recruiters right now).

Mc91··on Debunking Statistical AI – Noam Chomsky, Gary Marcus, Jeremy Kahn [video]
Chomsky is saying what he has basically been saying for a while - deep learning neural networks are "strong" (as he called it) in engineering, but "weak" in being scientific.
Mc91··on Ask HN: How do you focus on work for long periods of time?
I might know I have to look at some code or something for a few hours, but looking at my day I know it will be interrupted by meetings and lunch, and that I will probably get Teams messages during the day as well. Even if I have a block of time free, if I know there's a 50% chance I will be interrupted with an issue I don't get started.

So in this scenario what I do working from home is spend a lot of the work day that day doing my laundry or whatnot. Then after 5 PM no one will be interrupting me so I then look at the code. I probably do this at least one day every week. Maybe I shift the schedule around - I work Tuesday night and do my laundry Wednesday afternoon. This is a scenario where the interruption is fully external.

If I am not being interrupted...some things I sometimes have to kick myself to do at first, but then I can go for an hour or more. This would include going to the gym, or, I don't know, studying what a monad is. I just have to determine I'll start doing, but once I am doing it I am not distracted.

The last thing that I have to kick myself doing even while doing it. I sometimes had to do this in college - I had to do a lot of studying for something which was not my major, which I did not care much about etc., and it was purely to pass the class and get a grade. Actually these things used to get a lot of other things on my things to do list done - I'd say, I will clean the living room tonight, not study Lewis structures or whatever. There's not much solution to this other than just kicking yourself back to the task.

While things being as they currently are we always have to kick ourselves a little to do some things the whole way through. At some level it becomes psychologically untenable and you just have to face the fact that you don't enjoy doing whatever. For example - at college I enjoyed most of my Computer Science classes, reading the material, doing the homework etc. I even enjoyed some of the books we'd be assigned in English classes and that sort of thing. Some classes I did not care about, and had to kick myself to study. But that is normal. However, if I was not interested in computer science and had to kick myself to study everything, it becomes more untenable. It's not going to work psychologically or in general. Although in retrospect, some things I didn't realize the use of until later. Like my graph theory class I generally found boring, but then my next class was a data structure class where I made use of nodes and trees and graphs, and the graph theory came in handy.

Also - as some other people here said - wake up after a good sleep, shower, have a clean environment around you, eat decent foods, get a good deal of cardiovascular exercise etc. Take at least one day a week to just relax.

Mc91··on Some thoughts on social networking and Usenet (2018)
> My hope for Usenet back in the day was a fully decentralized implementation that would allow each Usenet client to act as a client as well as a mini-server to cut the middleman out.

Gnutella started as this, but for a lot of reasons it didn't work for what it did, with every node sending broadcast to every other mode. The network became a number of federated super-nodes, or ultra-peers, or whatever you'd call them. These would be nodes that had a decent uptime, had a steady network connection, could handle a number of connections etc.

Mc91··on More U.S. companies charging employees for job training if they quit
I work at a Fortune 100 company. More than one contract programmer who came in were under these agreements. Most of them were placed by an agency. Furthermore, most of them were billed by the agency as "senior programmers", even though some of them had little to no IT experience. None of them were renewed on their 3 month contracts or extended a job offer.

Some of them had multiple layers of management - they were placed at our company by an agency, who was getting them from a subcontracting agency. Sometimes the management layers were even a level more - the subcontracting agency had a subcontracting agency.

Also for one guy I talked to, the agreement was not just if they quit, but if they were not re-upped for the contract, which they were not. The agency was unable to place them again, and laid them off. The agency did not go after him for the "training" money, although according to the agreement they could have. He had gone to a six month bootcamp, but that was at his own expense and before he connected with the agency. He said the "training" the agency gave him was worthless.

Mc91··on You will ask many, many questions
Actually I've told some people "don't struggle on something all day and then at 4:45PM tell me you haven't made any progress and ask for help" many times, and I still get the 4:45PM messages from them. It's not like the idea of telling them these things did not occur to me.
Mc91··on You will ask many, many questions
> Is there anything you would like me to do differently when asking questions?

Don't jump on me at 9 AM with a list of questions you have from the night before - I am going through e-mails and instant messages at that time. Wait half an hour, unless it is an emergency.

Like most people, I eat lunch at some point between noon and 1 PM. That's why my calendar is open, yours is as well, as are most people's. This is a bad time to start peppering me with questions.

Also, don't struggle on something all day and then at 4:45PM tell me you haven't made any progress and ask for help. Have this realization at 4 PM, or better yet 3:30PM or even 3:00PM. Sometimes a quick look by me at 3 PM can get you on the right path again.

Mc91··on More US Employers Are Trapping Workers in a New Form of Indentured Servitude
I work for a Fortune 50 company, more than one software programmer consultant who worked for us had one of these agreements. Of course, they never got any real training. All the ones I knew didn't have their contracts with us re-upped as they were eager but didn't know anything and had been presented as senior programmers when they weren't even associate/junior level programmers.
Mc91··on Ask HN: What are examples of companies dying due to many people quitting?
> I'm pretty confident that there are very few engineers at FAANG that can't be replaced. I'd also expect there are very few engineers at Epic, Activision, Blizzard, Naughty Dog, Sony, Rockstar, Ubisoft, Valve, etc... that can't be replaced. Sure, if 30%-70% of the team left on any particular project it would probably die

The thing is these two things are linked - one engineer leaving and 30-70% of a team leaving. The quantity of who leaves does not matter as much - a project may be able to handle 70% of consultants, interns, junior and regular programmers leaving, but might die if the 30% (or 25%, or 20%) leaving is entirely senior/staff/principal.

One of the lead programmers who has been at the company for many years leaves. He is friendly with some of the other senior programmers and says he thinks the company is slowly going downhill, and he got a new job with better money, and with a saner schedule, work environment and work-life balance. Maybe one of the other senior people leaves for the company he left for. Then other senior people start leaving.

It's like Steve Blank's essay about how a company deciding to start charging fifty cents for soda led to an exodus of its best senior programmers. One lead leaving can be a catalyst for others leaving. So they are in a sense irreplaceable.

If a company is an oligopoly like Verizon/AT&T or the like, then they are privy to revenue and profits they don't have to compete for, and for companies in that situation people are more replaceable. Not for companies that have to be competitive though.

Mc91··on Ask HN: How do you decide which language/tech stack to learn?
> a market dominated by web dev and java enterprise

Which also means there are a ton of web devs and java enterprise programmers. If a technology is ubiquitous, the number of people doing it is also ubiquitous. A technology being too niche can be a problem, but a technology being too commoditized can cause other types of problems.

Mc91··on Ask HN: Is no one hiring junior devs?
It may be useful to think of companies as categories - Fortune 1000 companies, startups, and consulting companies, although categories these can overlap.

From what I've seen a lot of startups seem to need "full stack" programmers, who can program ReactJS. Especially before a series A these companies usually can't afford to hire senior programmers, or even regular programmers, so it is a good place to get your foot in the door and get some experience, although probably at the worst pay.

Then there are consulting companies. As you are going in on a team, and the companies you are being placed at often do a mini-interview before you go in, and your placement contract can be for just a few months, companies you are placed at are less worried about taking a risk bringing you in. The trick is the level - the consulting company might not care much what level you're at, but the company you are being placed at generally wants someone who can bang out features cleanly and with little to no help. I have seen 22 year olds just out of coding boot camp being placed as "senior" programmer for a three month stint, which they are generally not reupped for - and I have heard this happens in other places too. It gets you in the door but it's hard to stay there. If you're not reupped and on the bench, the consulting company might show you the door fairly quickly too.

Some Fortune 1000 companies have internships, generally for college students, and the ones who managers and mentors are happy with can get offers as a junior/associate when graduating. It's probably good to try to intern at a different company each summer and to keep in contact with managers and mentors. It also depends on the job market - people who graduated in 2000-2001 or 2008-2009 or maybe now probably have worse luck than graduates at other times.

Mc91··on HN Leaders — What are the most upvoted users of Hacker News commenting on?
> One peculiarity about HN culture I found is that commenters will often comment something tangental to the subject of the post, so I often find myself reading really insightful comments on threads I otherwise have zero interest in.

Four days ago I was reading a thread I did have interest in about hiring freezes at Google and Facebook, and there was a tangential thread, which was even more insightful, between the Linux maintainer for ext4 (the Linux filesystem probably 99% of Android devices use, and a high percentage of Linux servers too), and another Googler/Xoogler about whether the Google storage engineering team could make non-incremental contributions, and which contributions were worthwhile and which weren't ( https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=32323734 ).

Mc91··on Ask HN: Why do companies not list your weaknesses in rejection emails?
Sometimes your interview was the same as the past three interviews. You did as well as them so I can't point to what your weakness was where you were rejected. Maybe you did good compared to a dud four interviews back. Then after you I interview someone who answered every question I asked correctly and in great depth. They are also pleasant. They get the offer.

You are not taking a pass/fail test, you are in a marathon and the first person who crosses the finish line gets an offer. Your weakness is they got to the finish line before you did.

Mc91··on Ask HN: If you’ve considered homeschooling, what’s stopping you?
> As your kids get older, it is harder and harder to give them a proper education. By the time your kids are in middle-school, subjects get harder for a parent (or pairs of parents) to cover in a way that does each subject justice.

I agree. My cousin's daughter was not home-schooled, but she was having trouble with high school math so I tutored her. At the time I was going to college for computer science. We did algebra for a year and that went fine. I still remembered it from high school. Then we got to trigonometry. The year I was supposed to learn trigonometry in high school was disruptive so I never learned it properly. So I studied the lesson and learn it myself before I would go see her. I'm supposed to be the math/CS guy too. It worked out and she passed trigonometry too - I did have to spend much more time preparing to teach trigonometry than algebra as I had never learned trigonometry. I can imagine one parent having to teach trigonometry, biology, physics, chemistry, the themes of the Scarlet Letter, French, Medieval history etc.

Mc91··on What startup snakery have you experienced as a developer / employee?
More than once I've been asked to demo features that are not completed.

Once was by someone who told me to do this verbally. He was not formally my manager but some nepotism was happening at the company. I wasn't able to push back on most things with him, this is one of the few things I pushed back on some directly, and then just didn't do it. Also, this was all told to me verbally - I didn't really trust this person, and am sure if someone had noticed I hadn't really completed any of these things I was claiming to have finished, he would have disavowed that he had told me to do this.

On the other hand, I was under a good lead once where we were getting a lot done but had two weeks where were just doing prep work. The lead said to do a UI mockup and to mention during the demo that the UI was a mockup because "they won't understand any how" but it was the only method of some to understand we were making progress. In this case I did demo the mockups, saying they were mockups, since I did trust this lead, and we were making steady progress, he just wanted demos to show something UI displayable every sprint.

Mc91··on The business impact of code quality (2017)
< using any number of 3rd party libraries (vs the developers desire to build from scratch)

HN is strewn with stories of people with dependencies on log4j, left-pad, and who knows what else. A programmer wanting to move off log4j and build logging from scratch might seem like a personal preference for some time, until the entire tech staff suddenly has to go into lockdown to remove dependencies on a dependency like log4j.

It can vary one way or the other, but if I advocate for not using a 3rd party library there is usually a good reason.

Mc91··on Ask HN: What do technical co-founders look for and avoid when joining a startup?
The first thing I'd look for is someone who was themselves a technical co-founder.

For someone who is not that technical, that would be a big drawback. I would say in that case that they be an adult. Even if they're in their mid-20s - they are an adult. They are confident and decisive. They're optimistic about the business. I don't know how to put it into a word, but it's all one thing.

Insofar as avoiding - nepotism for one thing. Relatives, wives etc. working for the company is not a good sign for a company on the rise. I can think of companies we all know of who have been harmed by co-founder nepotism, which has all kinds of pitfalls.

Also petulance, inability to handle stress, the desire to point fingers and blame in an unproductive way. Not wanting to deal with things - passive-aggressiveness.

Also, flightiness. Bad CEOs seem to have many projects in flight, and seem to start and cancel products with no rhyme or reason. Good CEOs are usually focused on one product (or maybe product suite). Good pivots or new products are usually due to customers throwing boatloads money at the company because they want us to do something they don't offer, we don't pivot because the CEO thinks up a new idea and wants to chase a new shiny. Lack of focus.

Mc91··on Patreon cuts deep inside creators’ pockets
The same with me. I gave a little money each month to four different organizations on Patreon, about six months ago I saw LineageOS was on Patreon and started giving a little to them each month too. It makes it easier to get recurring donations, I already send to Patreon once a month, now I just send a few dollars more a month.
Mc91··on Remaining Ambitious
> Even if it was “you were great, but we are going with someone else at this time”

This is how it is with two out of three people. By the time they pass the filter of their resume and whatnot, two or three people are OK. They can answer basic questions, they act normally, they seem to have been doing the job as they said for a few years. They are also somewhat interchangeable with the person we interviewed before. Then we interview someone else, and maybe they were referred by an internal team member with a recommendation, maybe they are just a standard deviation above who we interviewed in terms of what they know. There's nothing really wrong with the people rejected, it's "you seem to know how to program basic features like two out of three people we interviewed, but we interviewed someone else who has a deep understanding of the language we use".

Mc91··on High tuition costs mostly stem from the Omnibus Budget Reconciliation Act 1993
Western Europeans seem to have figured out how to get a good, affordable college education without this sort of thing. Some Europeans I talked to said the government even gives them a per diem for spending money or what have you while they go to college. They don't seem to have onerous debt.

Just like high medical costs, or school shootings (nineteen children were just killed by a gunman at a school in the US, for the Europeans unaware) and so forth, this seems to be a mostly US specific problem.

← PreviousPage 3 of 7Next →