440 karma · joined June 9, 2019
A classic example of this is nasal steroids for seasonal allergies versus histamine blockers. Steroids will actually cause the genes that code for histamine/inflammatory proteins that are released by the cells to be downregulated. Whereas antihistamines bind to the histamine receptor at the penultimate step in the process. Steroids have a much stronger effect and are the current first line treatment for allergic rhinitis.
My undergrad degree is in biology and it was depressing to learn how humans have eviscerated nature. I remember joking with a classmate during my evolution class saying "what way are we going to learn about how humans destroyed nature today?"
My hypothesis is that it's not going to be hydroxychloroquine that will be the miracle drug. There are better "hypothetical" alternatives that aren't getting as much mainstream attention but have a more realistic potential for working.
Giving someone who has had essentially a heart attack (by definition COVID patients have elevated troponin which is the marker we use to assess if one has had a heart attack) is probably a bad idea so my question is: why would we celebrate a drug that has massive cardiac adverse effects as a side effect? Don't get me wrong I understand that there are drugs that are even worse. Cyclosporine is the first line immunosuppresant for kidney transplant. Do you know what one of the most common adverse effects of cyclosporine is? Kidney failure. But we don't know what is causing the kidney failure in a kidney transplant (rejection vs adverse effect) so we have to biopsy. Kidney biopsy is a very invasive procedure, FYI. My point is, maybe waiting for double blind placebo research here is the best case. Also, I made this exact same point on here a month ago and people told that they would take my dose if it came to that and at this point I will say go ahead.
[1] https://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pubmed/32169400
[2] https://www.nejm.org/doi/full/10.1056/NEJMoa2004500 [3] https://www.ahajournals.org/doi/10.1161/CIRCULATIONAHA.120.0... [4] https://jamanetwork.com/journals/jamacardiology/fullarticle/...
How often does this happen because someone was doing research on Coronavirus and it accidently got released from a biosafety level 4 lab? Not often. How often do novel Coronaviruses spread from bats to something to humans? All the damn time.
I'm saying that the response to COVID-19 is easy. You know why? Because all it would have taken is surveillance and proper quarantine. I'm going to say it again: if you give me a normal amount of resources and a normal team I would be able to manage anyone with COVID with reasonable success. Now it starts getting tricky with any serious comorbidities and luckily we have nephrology to manage electrolytes. Shutting this thing down is not challenging. What's challenging is when you have incompetent leadership that ignores expert advice.
Not even close, not even a little close. With proper containment COVID-19 is easily contained. This isn't that great, especially when you look at countries who are handling this well: Taiwan. Bioweapons are notorious for being quick and lethal. As per the CDC on bioterrorism:
>When the potential agents are reviewed for these characteristics, anthrax and smallpox are the two with greatest potential for mass casualties and civil disruption
https://wwwnc.cdc.gov/eid/article/5/4/99-0411_article#r6
If you give me a normal amount of resources and competent public health professionals COVID-19 does not scare me. It's CFR is below 1% with adequate protocols (Standard, honestly).
China is so interconnected to the rest of the world, especially the US, the worst thing for them is to shut down both their and the US economy. Why would they test a weapon that disrupts the entire globe when you could have a weapon that has a narrow focus of a small region?
Here's the list of agents that are better than SARS:
https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Bioterrorism#Types_of_agents
Edit:
So far I'm dissapointed with the comments to my post. I can't tell if some of these are trolls or not, but generally they don't add much to the discussion.
These hypotheticals are specious, sure they sound like lucid idea but with even a slight amount of criticism they'd fall apart. I'm going to posit some ideas here. Why didn't China weaponize H5N1? It has a higher Ro and CFR. It is commonly found throughout Southeast Asia and is what most pandemic experts thought was going to be the next pandemic. How would a virus get through a biosafety level 4 lab? If anyone else here has experience in biosafety labs I'm all ears, but I'd be shocked that a virus would be able to escape from something like that; not that mistakes don't happen but this isn't exactly a durable pathogen. Then we have the issue of every single advanced military in the world wouldn't even touch The Coronavirus family. I'm going to go ahead and assume that the people who are making bioweapons are good at their jobs and can recognize what makes a good bioweapon and what doesn't. Finally, there are just so many better options for bioweapons. The US invests massive amounts in making precision weapons because when you're a military power hitting a precise location is what's key. COVID is like a cluster bomb that has 90% duds.
But after all of this, instead of random people on the internet, we have experts who have time and time again said that COVID is not a bioweapon:
https://www.washingtonpost.com/world/2020/01/29/experts-debu...
https://www.nature.com/articles/s41591-020-0820-9?fbclid=IwA...
https://www.livescience.com/coronavirus-not-human-made-in-la...
https://edition.cnn.com/2020/02/18/politics/coronavirus-cott...
https://www.ft.com/content/a6392ee6-4ec6-11ea-95a0-43d18ec71...
Anyway, I agree with your last sentence; at what point is something "good enough". Lately I feel like the "good enough" in a significant amount of corporations isn't acceptable. I'm in healthcare and the absolute lack of security in my day to day is absolutely amazing.
Edit: I was being sarcastic here. China messed up the initial response but their draconian tactics worked well.