HNHacker News
TopNewBestAskShowJobs

Medicalidiot

440 karma · joined June 9, 2019

submissionscomments
Medicalidiot··on Covid-19: the harms of exaggerated information and non‐evidence‐based measures
There's a tonne of speculation about CFR still at this time. Maybe I'm hyperbolic, but there are still ~1,500 serious/critical cases in China which is 1/3rd of all active cases. I have a feeling like the 4% CFR is high here because many of the COVID cases became clinical diagnoses instead of rtPCR; in other words, the Chinese physicians started using CT scans and clinical presentation to diagnose COVID instead of testing. Normal viral pneumonia diagnostic criteria is a chest radiograph and clinically compatible features (e.g. fever, cough, dyspnea, etc.). My take away is that they probably ran out of test kits and therefore many asymptomatic patients are out there.

As time progresses I have a feeling that the official CFR in China is going to spike soon when they start deciding to take people of ventilators, unless the CCP decides to pour massive resources into keeping these patients alive. Regardless, I have a feeling like the number of deaths/resolved is significantly lower than what it actually is and I wanted to nerd out here for a second because I love talking about medicine.

Edit: I want to say that I still think that we should be taking this entire pandemic seriously and am in no way commenting on this article's suggestion that we are in anyway over/underreacting. I'm making a comment on CFR.

Medicalidiot··on 'Pandemic ventilator' could offer solution in potential 'worst case' scenario
>You realize most science isn’t double blind, right?

That's nice, but most science isn't reproducible at scale. We need to do a drug trial for SARS-CoV-2 because we need to 1)establish efficacy and 2) establish safety for this drug in this disease. There are a significant amount of adverse drug effects in individual infectious diseases. Jarisch–Herxheimer reaction when treating syphilis, epstein-Barr mononucleosis and penicillin; Reye syndrome with Aspirin and influenza. The list is long here. We want the most vetted research possible because even if the chance of death is less than half a percent, half a percent of what seems like is going to be over a million is going to be in the tens of thousands here.

Medicalidiot··on Why is Japan still a coronavirus outlier?
Age is the best correlating factor right now. They are prime for an outbreak demographic wise.

>http://weekly.chinacdc.cn/en/article/id/e53946e2-c6c4-41e9-9...

Medicalidiot··on Twice as High Diet-Induced Thermogenesis After Breakfast vs. Dinner
To add to your comment, they measure calorie expenditure throughout the day but seemingly stop collecting data throughout the night (23:00 to 7:00). Their conclusion that breakfast is better isn't because they compared the data from the day to night, but because they didn't have any data throughout the night.

Maybe I'm stretching this, but I want more calorie expenditure while I'm sleeping and having the highest amount of somatotropin in my body so it can mobilize proteins and facilitate healing.

Your compliance point is salient. I can recommend every single therapy in the book, but getting a patient to take a drug let alone at the correct time and correct dosage to maintain therapeutic index, is an art.

Medicalidiot··on Twice as High Diet-Induced Thermogenesis After Breakfast vs. Dinner
The sample has serious flaws and is quite unrepresentative of the population:

>We examined a group of 16 healthy young men (age 23.6 ± 2.3 years) with a normal body mass index (22.5 ± 1.1 kg/m2)

Size, demographic, gender, and BMI are all seemingly within the same cohort. I have seen neurological studies with an n=8 be the predicates of clinical practice because that's what the patient population on the East coast is, but this could have been expanded.

When looking at the results section, it looks like the data lines up almost inversely. Where if you have a high calorie meal in the morning you'll burn more calories throughout the day whereas eating at night you'll burn more calories at night. But they didn't measure calorie consumption from 23:00 to 7:00 so we have no idea what the measured consumption is.

Maybe I'm naive, but every time I talk to one of my colleagues with a PhD in nutrition they constantly say the same recommendations: eat a diverse diet free of sugar, try to avoid salt and red meat, and get your fiber. Meal timing has been shown to be more for the mind that for your health, in that it doesn't matter when you eat, how much you eat, but you eat correctly. I'll get off my soap box now.

Medicalidiot··on Locked-down lawyers warned Alexa is hearing confidential calls
I got rid of smart speakers a few months ago after being enriched with everyone's perspective on this forum; tech is my hobby, not my career. I have zero regrets. It's a little inconvenient now to not be able to say "play [music]" or "play [show]", instead having to use a remote. But the peace of mind that I'm not being recorded is paid for en masse.
Medicalidiot··on Coronavirus is not a good argument for quitting cash
SARS-CoV-2 has been demonstrated to live on surfaces for multiple days. I don't know if your phone touching the card reader or handling cash is going to change much.
Medicalidiot··on Netflix to cut streaming quality in Europe for 30 days
I agree with you that maybe we should wait to see how this plays out before we judge their actions. I've never had a situation yet where waiting for a more lucid picture was a bad move.
Medicalidiot··on Twitter broadly bans any Covid-19 tweets that could help the virus spread
This is an interesting paradigm, but I'd assume that anything going against CDC/WHO guidelines will be removed.

I had a physics professor in undergrad that still wasn't sold on the entire dark matter/dark energy phenomena and was proudly in the <1% of physicists who shared his beliefs.

Medicalidiot··on Man who stockpiled hand sanitizer donates it all ahead of investigation
I'm shocked at how this forum has changed its mind on COVID-19 in the past week. This makes me happy that y'all are taking this more seriously.
Medicalidiot··on Lesspass – open-source stateless password manager
Bitwarden is one of the best pieces of software I use regularly. Anecdotally, I've had awesome success with it and love the dev behind it.
Medicalidiot··on Open letter from Italy to the international scientific community
My attending went on the news to say that flattening the curve is our best bet at the moment. He's also considered to be one of the top physicians in the region. Y'all can sit here in a bubble, but the medical community has no hallucination that containment should have been done months ago and now it's past that.
Medicalidiot··on NY hospitals pitch tents, nix surgeries to prepare for influx
I came here two weeks ago to downvotes and nonmedical people telling me how I was inciting a panic. Welcome to the show, folks. A lot of my colleagues are going to die soon and I'm beyond sad because of it.
Medicalidiot··on Open letter from Italy to the international scientific community
This is one of those times where it gets bad so quickly by the time you're starting to respond it's too late.
Medicalidiot··on Open letter from Italy to the international scientific community
Flattening the curve is the only scenario a lot of countries can realistically do outside of a Wuhan style quarantine.
Medicalidiot··on Open letter from Italy to the international scientific community
I was downvoted here recently for sounding the alarm bells on how bad this is going to be and accused of trying to incite panic. Folks, COVID-19 is something that should be taken seriously. President Obama had great advice: "stay calm and listen to the experts". All the experts are saying this is going to be bad and we should be getting ready now for what will happen in the future.
Medicalidiot··on Italy is extending its coronavirus quarantine measures to the entire country
All my medical colleagues kept saying this was bad. In the first cohorts of patients, 10-20% needed ICU level care. I have privy to the latest peer reviewed guidelines for medicine and had a double take when I read the initial complications: 19.6% Acute Respiratory Distress Syndrome (ARDS). ARDS has a supportive type of treatment, which means that we give you all the basics for life and hope that you pull through. It's the last resort of care. It's only ~150 people, that statistics might be off. Then the cohort study came out that was looking at 44k patients. It lined up with the first cohort so close you could consider it a rounding error.

Folks, get mentally ready to know someone that will die because of this. Luckily, almost everyone in this thread will be alive, but those that have diabetes, cancer, coronary artery disease, and the elderly are the ones who will have poor outcomes because of it.

>http://weekly.chinacdc.cn/en/article/id/e53946e2-c6c4-41e9-9... >https://pubmed.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/32031570-clinical-characteri... >https://pubmed.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/31986264-clinical-features-o... >https://pubmed.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/32007143-epidemiological-and...

Medicalidiot··on Seattle-Area Patient With Coronavirus Dies
I understand, I appreciate your feedback :)
Medicalidiot··on Seattle-Area Patient With Coronavirus Dies
Oh so we don't care about anyone over the age of 50 now? Almost no one reading this thread is going to be in the patient populations that are going to die. I'm here to say this is going to kill the people you love, who are elderly. Also, smoking looks like it exacerbates the problems but the worst factor is age and immunosuppression; 1-2% of the US is immunosuppressed at any time.

I'm advocating that you take precautions by not touching your face, washing your hands, and avoiding public places. Stocking up on food so you can avoid the grocery store later is a great idea. Avoiding people when you don't feel well and self quarantining are also great ideas.

Medicalidiot··on Seattle-Area Patient With Coronavirus Dies
I'm not going to stop saying this. This looks very dangerous and we should take very precaution possible to slow transmission. All nonessential travel should be avoided, don't touch your face, wash your hands. Slowing this virus down makes everything so much better.

[1] Estimate that the case to fatality ratio is between 5-8%. The transmission rate is between 2 and 3. Both of these numbers are similar to the earlier SARS outbreak in the early 2000s.

[2] The death rate in Wuhan is significantly higher than that outside. We want to buy time so our healthcare facilities can handle the volume of patients.

Take precautions everyone! This may not seriously affect you but you can help prevent the spread to people you love.

[1] https://www.mdpi.com/2077-0383/9/2/523

[2] https://www.medrxiv.org/content/10.1101/2020.02.17.20023630v...

Medicalidiot··on My Covid-19 Story in Brooklyn
I keep hearing rumblings about test kits not being where they need to be, but nothing in the news. It would be so hard to make a clinical diagnosis of COVID-19 when the chief complaints are "Fever, cough, shortness of breath". Is that the common cold or is this SARS-CoV-2? Giving a massive diagnosis like and being wrong is bad.
Medicalidiot··on I have the coronavirus. So far, it isn't that bad
I was in the wrong here and could have worded this more tactfully. I do appreciate your insight.
Medicalidiot··on I have the coronavirus. So far, it isn't that bad
As stated elsewhere, I lacked tact towards the person who I was condescending towards and it was not my intention. But my behavior towards someone else does not mean it's ok for you to now treat me poorly.

I'm not going to argue with you any more because this doesn't seem worth it, and justifying bad behavior is just not something I'm into. This looks like SARS 2002-2004's cousin. The virus is actually called SARS-CoV-2, the disease is COVID-19. The transmission rate is astounding, the fatality rate is also looking like SARS 2002-2004 [1]; this is something you should take very seriously. And no, I don't need a medical degree to recognize a pattern. But I'm guessing you're not immunosuppressed or elderly so it's not a big deal for you. Do whatever you want, bud, because your actions will only get the people around you killed.

I just want to say it's making me laugh to myself how ignorant people are as to what my education actually entails and the nuances between every step of the medical education hierarchy. Like how in a few months I'm going to magically know what I'm doing because I have a piece of paper.

[1]https://www.medrxiv.org/content/10.1101/2020.02.17.20023630v...

Medicalidiot··on I have the coronavirus. So far, it isn't that bad
I didn't even think of how many people are asymptomatic carriers when I said that number. More data, like all science, is the answer here.

Honestly, someone I highly respect who is high up on the medicine food chain is very concerned that a lot of people are going to die and that's been making me very concerned.

Medicalidiot··on I have the coronavirus. So far, it isn't that bad
I think if I had said this in person it would have sounded a lot less dismissive, but the way I typed it up came off as mean which was not my intention.
Medicalidiot··on I have the coronavirus. So far, it isn't that bad
Let me ask you a question: what is the intention of responding to me in a condescending way? What do you get out of it? My intention right now is for people not to down play how serious this will become and that this isn't just the flu.

This is the only data we have right now and it's saying this is really bad. You can talk selection bias here, faulty statistics, etc. but right now the death rate is 8% (deaths/(deaths+resolved) not deaths/total infections) and the list of complications is the check list for an intense ICU (no pun intended) visit.

Medicalidiot··on I have the coronavirus. So far, it isn't that bad
Let me try to rephrase what you're saying just to understand where you're coming from. "these are cool numbers, but what's the chance that the average person is going to actually have any of these complications?". I don't have any cogent numbers on that, but the current deaths/(deaths+resolved) percentage is 8%.
Medicalidiot··on I have the coronavirus. So far, it isn't that bad
"Hey it's not as bad as people making it out" will make people complacent. People need to self quarantine if we want this to be well contained. We need people to understand that if they don't take this seriously people will die, people they care about.
Medicalidiot··on I have the coronavirus. So far, it isn't that bad
^This is exactly why we should take this seriously. Even if this "isn't a big deal" that attitude will get people you love and care about sick potentially leading to their death. I'm advocating that people be mindful and try to take this very seriously.
Medicalidiot··on I have the coronavirus. So far, it isn't that bad
Right now the Deaths/(Deaths+resolved) is 8%, which is on par with SARS in 2002-2004. This affects most demographics, but mostly the elderly. I'm not here to advocate for panic, but we need to take this very seriously now while the outbreak is still young. The more we can slow this the less dangerous the virus will become.
← PreviousPage 3 of 6Next →