HNHacker News
TopNewBestAskShowJobs

Medicalidiot

440 karma · joined June 9, 2019

submissionscomments
Medicalidiot··on Why does all life use the same 20 amino acids?
I thought it was sulfur, but it may have been silicon that the researchers had used.
Medicalidiot··on The Browser Monopoly
Spotify and some video sites do not work on Safari, which is mind blowing to me.
Medicalidiot··on Why does all life use the same 20 amino acids?
We are carbon based life forms, but researchers have hypothesized that there are probably sulfur based lifeforms out in the universe.

If I remember correctly, there's over a hundred various amino acids. For humans, we have only 20.

Medicalidiot··on Time to Get Serious about Tick-Borne Diseases
Doxy is the firstling treatment for Lyme disease
Medicalidiot··on CEO compensation has grown 940% since 1978
Physicians are grossly underpaid for the level of education they have to go through, the amount of work that is done weekly, and the high stakes nature of their job. I'm biased as a medical student though.

Fun fact: ~5% of health care costs come from physician salaries, 8% is from nurses.

Medicalidiot··on Ebola Is Now Curable
There's a significant amount of fake news around the Ebola outbreak epicenters, such as aid workers trying to take people's blood and other conspiracy theories. We have to keep in mind some of these places recently had a genocide and/or are generally unstable.
Medicalidiot··on Proteins That May Restore Damaged Sound-Detecting Cells in the Ear
There are some conditions, like cranial nerve VII (facial nerve) palsy, where hyperacousis is a symptom. You have a couple muscles in your ear that attenuate sound, so it's not out of the realm of possibility that something happened to your father and his hearing improved.
Medicalidiot··on Ebola Is Now Curable
As someone who works in a hospital, we can bleach every single patient room, wear all the PPE we want, but pathogens will always spread; the only question is when, not if. Even in an isolation chamber a resistance to penicillin would develop independently of each other as penicillin resistance is usually predicated on a mutation in the penicillin binding protein.
Medicalidiot··on Ebola Is Now Curable
In practical terms, there will be a resistance that develops eventually. Even though the reservoir is hypothesized to be bats, that doesn't have much significance because of its ability spread from person to person without a vector.

What is notable about Ebola is that its virulence keeps dropping while its ability to spread has significantly increased. The larger issue is that Ebola is in areas that don't have the resources to handle any serious outbreak. It's becoming more likely that Ebola is going to be self sustaining soon.

I'm kind of amazed that a comment expressing interest in when this therapy will be obsolete, see that 96% of bacteria are resistant to Penicillin G now, gets a negative response. Drugs are only effective when the pathogen is still sensitive to them.

Medicalidiot··on Ebola Is Now Curable
I want to know how long it will take for Ebola to evolve a resistance to this therapy.
Medicalidiot··on Don't donate canned goods to food banks (2017)
Keep donating canned vegetables, you can eat that stuff raw, it lasts for years, and it's incredibly healthy even when you consider the high sodium levels.
Medicalidiot··on Google admits listening to some smart speaker recordings
Finding out how the sausage is made is uncomfortable.
Medicalidiot··on Google employees are listening to Google Home conversations
Brave New World by far is the most accurate book to date of what the modern world looks like. That's my strongest recommendation.

Fahrenheit 451 is also a solid read.

Medicalidiot··on Kuo: Apple to include new scissor switch keyboard in MacBook
I recently bought a MBP, my first ever Mac, and it is absolutely amazing. Smooth, fast, secure, and the trackpad is an incredible experience. My only significant complaint I have of it is the keyboard.

If Apple replaces only the keyboard, the MBP is the undisputed best laptop available today.

Medicalidiot··on $499 AMD Ryzen 9 3900X Almost as Fast as $2000 Intel Core I9-9980XE
Ryzen is an incredible processor. I'm still happily running my 1700 like the champ it is.
Medicalidiot··on Slack – Degraded service affecting multiple features
I respect your opinion, because even if an application could handle 200k users at once was able to be run on a MBP without serious issue, it's still gauche to forcibly invite 200k people in your company to a chat.
Medicalidiot··on Lyme Disease Cases Are Exploding
Why do you say cefdinir as the second antibiotic? It's not recommended in uptodate.
Medicalidiot··on 16-Inch MacBook Pro Said to Launch in September
Better keyboard and no touch bar would cause the MBP to be the undisputed champion of laptops. I have a 2019 MBP and love absolutely everything about it minus the keyboard, thank god the 13" has an option without the touch bar.
Medicalidiot··on Google Maps is filled with false business addresses pretending to be nearby
The permanently closed point is the most salient in my mind. There was a business that was closed for, what I was told, over 6 months in my area; Google said it was still open. Later I checked out the business on Google maps, but this time the hours were updated to say closed every day.
Medicalidiot··on Why are we so pessimistic?
In the Developed world, we don't have to hunt our food. We don't freeze outside. We have comfortable lives in that we have are physiological needs taken care of. Yet, happiness is at an all time low and our psychological needs are neglected. I believe that OP is onto something in that humans are programmed to struggle with something, and if we don't, we start having issues. In my mind this is similar to an autoimmune disease: when our bodies don't have to fight outside pathogens, out white cells start attacking ourselves; this is one theory out there among many of why we develop autoimmune diseases.
Medicalidiot··on Blood sugar patterns to master as a type 2 diabetic
One of the most important parts of diet we fail to educate the public on is glycemic index vs glycemic load. Index is essentially the raw score for how drastically a particular food will raise blood sugar. Glycemic load looks at the totality of what one eats then predicts what the effect of one's blood sugar will be. For example eating sugar with fat will spike blood sugar less than simply eating sugar.

Further reading: https://www.health.harvard.edu/diseases-and-conditions/the-l...

Medicalidiot··on Gut microbes eat medication
IV will always be king for drug administration, but I'm not too surprised that it's oral absorption is poor considering amino acid absorption is fairly specialized within the GI tract.
Medicalidiot··on Gut bacteria may change the way many drugs work in the body
If DNA doesn't code for everything then you deserve the Nobel prize because there isn't any other mechanism for how cells derive structure and function from that is known outside of this conversation. What else codes for PTM, ubiquitination, and basal level expression.

>DNA dictates whether a protein can be expressed or not, but not whether it is expressed in any particular cell, how much is expressed, or whether and how much is activated or otherwise modified over time.

It does determine whether it is expressed and how much is expressed. The difference between being a heterzygote and homozygote for certain proteins literally determines whether one will have fully protein expression or half. When a gene is doubled in the genome its expression is usually doubled as well.

>Because there are cases (probably the majority) where drug-gene interaction is insufficient.

80-90% of drugs are metabolized by CYP2D6, CYP2C19, CYP2C9, CYP3A4 and CYP3A5 to which we are starting to isolate polymorphisms in the general public. This isn't that difficult to do the genotyping, but what's limited right now is correlating polymorphism to what the side effect of drug is; this is going to be purely a time and data collection issue. I'm curious what your examples would be, because the majority of cases I've been apart of it's a simple base pair substitution that cause deleterious effects.

Medicalidiot··on Gut bacteria may change the way many drugs work in the body
DNA not only contains the most basic information, but all the information. It houses more information than what we get purely from protein expression. Where your point falls short is that we don't need to know every nuance behind protein expression, ubiquitination, posttranslational modifications, etc. to know that if patient A has polymorphism X and polymorphism X means that they cannot have succinylcholine, because they are susceptible to malignant hyperthermia or hyperkalemia we will not give them succinylcholine. My next point is that you will have variable expression of proteins based on drug concentration (the lay meaning: whether we have administered a drug or not). The classic example of this is the Lac operon, which is taught even in medical school. It demonstrates that when lactose is present the enzyme lactase will be made to metabolize it, but only when lactose is present. If a drug is not present its enzyme could not be as well skewing results in a way that could lead the physician to not try first line medications. Why would I want a snapshot of something when I need to predict drug-gene interaction before I give someone a drug?

Yes, pharmacogenomics is a home run on straight forward cases, but the amazing thing is that straight forward cases are the most important for medicine. Drug-gene interactions are so unbelievably basic and require next to zero know how to correlate side effects to genes. My previous example of genomics not being lucid is in intelligence because we have zero idea what makes someone intelligent on a molecular level, which physicians could not care less about.

My final point is purely on practicality. Last I had heard, there are some hospital systems that have genome sequencing are down to tens of dollars and are done in under an hour or two. Isolating a single protein, looking at its expression, and assaying activity is not only the bane of every biochemists existence, it takes a significant amount of time and would have to be done for every single enzyme that we want to look at. We have to be practical in medicine and the most practical option for the foreseeable future, unless a CRISPR like breakthrough comes along, is going to be genome sequencing.

Now, what is going to be absolutely insane in the field of proteomics is when we can accurately predict a protein's structure and then make novel drugs to enhance or inhibit said protein. I can't remember how many amino acids it is before we're unable to predict the structure of a protein, but it's low and the current method to look at protein structure is stupid hard. Obnoxiously hard; I don't even want to talk about it but it's hard and you have to send your samples to a handful of locations. We use super computers at the moment to elucidate small proteins and usually they suck bad at doing it. If we were able to accurately predict structure and function of a novel protein with computer models, use CRISPR to insert the gene into a genome for said protein we are talking about increasing human life span in a logarithmic fashion.

Medicalidiot··on Gut bacteria may change the way many drugs work in the body
Definitely for certain things like intelligence, but many disease processes will be one gene coding one deleterious enzyme. For example Hyper-IgE syndrome will be a STAT3 mutation, Cystic Fibrosis is going to be a change typically at 508 to F(amino acid phenylalanine) on the CFTR gene, and Menkes disease, with its kinky hair, is going to have a mutation with ATP7A. These phenotypes are easy to recognize because the symptoms precipitate so significantly that most individuals die prematurely and because we've isolated them time and time again in the same diseased individuals. My point here is that isolating a phenotype from a genotype is pretty easy for a significant amount of polymorphisms.

Now what makes drug metabolism easy to understand is that it will typically be one gene that codes for one enzyme (I'm overly simplifying this here, it's way more complicated and we don't fully understand gene expression). It will also usually be one enzyme that is going to break down a certain drug (I'm also oversimplifying this). Let's look at ethanol; it's broken down by alcohol dehydrogenase to acetaldehyde, the thing that gives you the hang over. Certain populations, Asian and Native Americans namely, have a different alcohol dehydrogenase enzyme than other populations and thus have a common effect; colloquially termed Asian flush. This variability in how an enzyme breaks down a drug is part of the reason why some people will have certain effects whereas other people won't (overly simplified, again). Pharmacogenomics is actually one of the more easy phenotypes to delineate versus other, more nebulous, things.

Medicalidiot··on Gut bacteria may change the way many drugs work in the body
These are all salient points and I would like to comment as someone who has experience in medicine. We are truly on the precipice of so many breakthroughs in the medical field. Cancer is going to be a chronic condition soon. HIV will likely be gone in our lifetime. Congenital diseases will be eradicated very soon.

What's going to also happen that mainstream media has failed to grasp the gravity of is pharmacogenomics/pharmacogenetics. Essentially what we are going to do the second you enter the ED/PCP/PreOP is sequence your DNA. Then we will tailor your drug regime based on your phenotype (What traits/characteristics you have expressed). This kind of thing was just imaginary, but last year I listened to one of the world's leading pediatric pharmacogenomicists that had a half dozens cases he shared; one of them was having a 16 y/o female that presented with depression that was not ameliorated with first line SSRI. Upon sequencing her genome they realized that her phenotype was incompatible with this SSRI, switched her and upon 4 week followup her symptoms were significantly reduced.

The 20th century was the century of physics, the 21st will be the century of biology.

← PreviousPage 6 of 6