HNHacker News
TopNewBestAskShowJobs

Merrill

2,260 karma · joined August 28, 2018

submissionscomments
Merrill··on IBM to cut about 3,900 workers while still hiring in ‘higher growth’ areas
In the early 1980s, DoD pushed back vigorously against the breakup of the Bell System, but the breakup happened anyway. Once the anti-trust suit is in progress, they have little influence over the legal outcome.
Merrill··on What Do We Do When Compute and Memory Stop Getting Cheaper?
Move functionality into custom ICs blocks.

Write software that runs on bare metal, rather than on top of inefficient stacks.

Merrill··on A flurry of new studies identifies causes of the Industrial Revolution
Slaves/serfs make economic sense primarily on a plantation/manor where they can be given use of a small plot where they construct a shelter and raise their own food. They receive little or no subsidies from the planter/lord.

The difference is that serfs are attached to the manor instead of being owned by the planter. Thus, serfs are not sold, but change lords by inheritance, marriage, or other changes in land rights. Europe was so densely populated that serfs probably had little or no cash value. If you had a manor, you already had serfs.

Merrill··on A flurry of new studies identifies causes of the Industrial Revolution
The industrial revolution was enabled by the rapidly declining price of first iron and later steel.

Making iron requires bringing together iron ore, coal, and limestone in a furnace. These are heavy, and transporting them by horse drawn wagons any distance is expensive.

England was fortunate in having coal mines, iron mines, and limestone quarries either co-located or on the same river so barges could be used. So once charcoal was exhausted and coking developed as the reducing agent, England had a distinct advantage in producing cheap iron.

Once cheap iron was available, it could be used for rails, wheels for mining carts, mining tools, pumps, and eventually steam engines, one thing feeding another in a virtuous cost cycle.

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Ferrous_metallurgy#Transition_... https://www.nmrs.org.uk/mines-map/coal-mining-in-the-british... https://www.nmrs.org.uk/mines-map/iron-mining-in-the-british...

Merrill··on Why is Amazon selling fake 16TB portable SSD drives?
If it is not "Ships from amazon.com" and "Sold by amazon.com", I don't usually buy it.

Sometimes I'll buy a "Ships from amazon.com" and "Sold by XYZ Corp", but only if I recognize "XYZ Corp" as a reputable firm.

Customer ratings and reviews as a crowdsourced reputation mechanism is pretty unreliable. The Q&As are sometimes more informative.

Merrill··on On-demand learning comes at the cost of conceptual understanding
This is only a problem for the incurious who stop when they solve the immediate problem.

The curious will often descend into conceptual rabbit holes and acquire conceptual knowledge as well. It's sort of anticipatory yak shaving for future projects.

Merrill··on CA high-speed rail is Exhibit A for how America can’t build big things anymore
High-speed rail requires a new railway that has no grade crossings of highways, has wider-radius curves than freight lines, can have higher grades than freight lines, and has better rails and sleepers.

There is no chance of getting new high-speed railways built through the outskirts of major metro areas, so there will always be long end sections operating at less than 90 mph.

Smaller cities along the lines will also want service, so trains will have to decelerate, loiter, and accelerate multiple times between major metro areas.

The end result is that in the US high-speed rail is impossible to build, and it would operate on average at far less than the maximum speed.

Acela on the Northeast Corridor is about as fast as it will get. Even there, Boston to NY times could be improved by realigning some tracks in eastern CT and RI to remove tight curves, but even that has not been done.

Merrill··on The Origins of Python
Ease of use and ease of learning are often at odds with performance.

A go-kart is easier to learn and to drive than a Formula 1 car.

Merrill··on Systems Engineering, or "why james gets paid"
System engineering is the art of specifying the general, overall characteristics and design of the thing to be produced without overlooking any detail which may later turn out to have been important.
Merrill··on Hoardiculture
Older people have the advantage that if they do discard something, they later won't remember that they had it.
Merrill··on Under anesthesia, where do our minds go?
The mind application is terminated, and the autonomic OS continues until the mind is restarted from memory. It's like a good night's sleep.

Why is this so complicated?

Merrill··on The rise of air conditioning (2018)
Before air conditioning, there was the rise of central heating.

Is the total energy used for the combination of heating and cooling greater in a warm climate or a cold climate, given the same floor space and appropriate insulation and construction?

I was under the impression that less energy would be needed in Dallas than in Chicago, but I don't have actual data.

Merrill··on Eero Saarinen’s secret wartime role in the White House (2010)
https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Bell_Labs_Holmdel_Complex

But the roof leaked.

I also worked here. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/IBM_Rochester

Merrill··on To Keep Students in Stem Fields, Let’s Weed Out the Weed-Out Math Classes
I took vector calculus from professors in the institute of technology and in the school of liberal arts. You got a BS or a BA in Math depending on which was your home. The professors from the institute of technology used diagrams and related concepts to mechanics and electromagnetics. The professor from liberal arts taught a purely abstract course without such aids, and it was far more difficult to understand. It was also far less useful for an electrical engineer.

That said, I realize that if one is headed for an advanced degree in theoretical physics, communications theory, solid state physics, etc., then the more abstract course may be the better choice.

Merrill··on To Keep Students in Stem Fields, Let’s Weed Out the Weed-Out Math Classes
Reimagining calculus has changed several schools’ success rates. Here’s how.
Merrill··on Bell Labs Org Chart (1980)
A "Center" was managed by a third level manager titled "Director" with "Department Heads" and group "Supervisors" reporting to them. An alternative organizational name was the "Laboratory", also managed by a "Director".

Above that were "Divisions" managed by "Executive Directors". Divisions were in "Areas" managed by Vice Presidents, and Vice Presidents reported to Executive Vice Presidents and then to Presidents.

This appears to be a Center which prepared the official design documentation that was sent to the engineer for manufacture at Western Electric who would then work out the manufacturing processes need to produce the equipment for the telephone companies. It appears to have supported the Transmission area and the Customer Premises equipment area.

Merrill··on The Zen of Drinking Alone
Drinking alone may be bad for your health and lead to alcoholism, but you are less likely to kill yourself in traffic, break some law, or damage your reputation and prospects. So it's much better than drinking with the wrong people.

That said, I think the piece overestimates the benefits of alcohol and underestimates the benefits of solitude.

Merrill··on New York City bans natural gas in new buildings
In the US, 220 Volts is standard for applications requiring high power, such as heat pumps, whole house air conditioners, cook stoves, hot water heaters, clothes dryers, electric car chargers, etc.

110 Volts is standard for lighting, ordinary outlets, and appliances drawing less than about 30 amps at 110 Volts such as clothes washing machines, dishwashers, furnaces, window air conditioners, etc.

Merrill··on Everyone on Earth is your cousin (2015)
A child inherits half of the mother's DNA and half of the father's DNA. This is because in somatic cells chromosomes come in pairs, but when sperm and eggs are produced, the pairs divide and each sperm or egg contains only one chromosome from each of the 23 pairs.

Therefore, given that you have received one of each pair, the probability is 1/2 that your sibling received the same one of the pair. Thus, siblings share 1/2 of their DNA on average.

When you get to first cousins, each line of descent from the common grandparents is diluted by 1/2 from the grandparents that they do not have in common.

Thus Nth cousins share on average 1 / 2 ^(2N+1) of their DNA in the sense that the shared DNA is inherited from their common ancestor. This is the only part of their genome that would cause their phenotypes to be similar. Any other similarities between cousins is by chance or because their relatives may have married into similar ethnic groups with shared deeper ancestry.

Merrill··on Everyone on Earth is your cousin (2015)
First cousins share 1/8 of their DNA, which is sort of meaningful. Second cousins share 1/32 of their DNA or about 3%, which is really marginal in terms of their being any resemblance or affinity due to DNA. By the time you get to third cousins the shared DNA is down to 1/128 or less than 1%.

So I've lost interest in tracking down any relatives beyond second cousins.

Merrill··on This is Marshall McLuhan: The Medium is the Message (1967) [video]
"Retina" LCDs and high quality earbuds have turned the internet into a "hot" medium, which causes recipients to believe the messages they are receiving. This puts society in a different position than previously when broadcast analog video was the prime media, and its noise and low definition made messages less believable and encouraged skepticism. TV was a "cold" medium. The hot internet is more like the hot broadcast radio and wired audio of the '20s and '30s during the rise of the great totalitarian regimes.
Merrill··on The $150M Machine Keeping Moore’s Law Alive
But suppose some nation decided that they could devote more software development resources to designing efficient software, and that they could limit processing intensive applications (like online gaming?).

Conceivably they could run the economically important IT functions of the country using less powerful, easier to manufacture, less power hungry greener, and readily available semiconductors.

Merrill··on Empty storefronts are killing neighbourhoods
Maybe the US and Canada have too much retail space per person. The US has 23.5 square feet per person, Canada had 16.8, Australia has 11.2 and the rest of the world has less than 5 square feet per person. https://www.statista.com/statistics/1058852/retail-space-per...
Merrill··on The Global Chessboard
Were it not for an explicitly European political event, the British colonies might have been walled off from the Mississippi Valley by the Appalachians, and separate countries might have occupied the territory.

The Seven Years War (1756–1763) resulted in the British taking control of Canada and French possessions east of the Mississippi. The British colonies on the coast, many of which had no defined western boundary, then wished to extend westward. This was resisted by the British Crown, which asserted control from London over the new territories.

The colonists then fought the War of Independence by which then won control of the Ohio Valley and south from Britain. This enabled the colonies to expand via upstate New York and across the mountain passes.

The French Revolution and Napoleonic Wars further weakened France and Spain resulting in our acquisition of Florida and Louisiana on very favorable terms.

Merrill··on Cryptanalysis of GPRS Encryption Algorithms GEA-1 suggest intentional weakness
At the time when digital cellular was first designed, the main objective was to design sufficiently strong authentication to stem the rampant theft of service then occurring on the analog cellular systems. In the US this was estimated at roughly $2 billion/annum.

Encrypting traffic for privacy purposes was less important. Prior analog cellular telephony systems were unencrypted, as were analog and digital wireline services. Thus, the privacy cryptography was intended to be strong enough to make it a little more inconvenient/expensive to eavesdrop on digital cellular than it was on analog cellular or wireline services without significantly impeding law enforcement.

Merrill··on U.S.'s Biggest Gasoline Pipeline Halted After Cyberattack
‘Arm Waving’ Response to Hackers Makes Oil Industry Easy Prey

Everyone from the facility managers to the private equity owners assumed that the plant’s computer network was “air-gapped” -- a term referring to computers that aren’t connected to the internet or another unsecured network. But when Mission Secure installed monitoring devices to check, they discovered that a worker on the night shift was connecting his Roku device to the internet to watch episodes of “CSI: Miami.”

https://www.bloomberg.com/news/articles/2021-05-12/colonial-...

So stuff like this wouldn't happen.

Merrill··on New technology has enabled cyber-crime on an industrial scale
The problem is that politicians, being lawyers, believe that cybercrime can be controlled by after the fact detection, apprehension, and punishment.

This does not work for cybercrime. Cyber systems must be designed so that crime cannot happen.

But a large part of the government does not want that level of security built into systems.

Merrill··on U.S.'s Biggest Gasoline Pipeline Halted After Cyberattack
Any IP packet that is valid on the Internet would be invalid and dropped on the critical infrastructure network. The only packets that could pass between the Internet and the critical infrastructure network would be those that are intentionally bridged by rewriting the CRC-32. This should not be done at the IP level, but only by application level bridges.

It would prevent inadvertent connections between the Internet and the critical infrastructure network.

Merrill··on U.S.'s Biggest Gasoline Pipeline Halted After Cyberattack
Why don't critical infrastructure networks use a different CRC-32 polynomial for their IP packets?
Merrill··on 1 in 5 electric vehicle owners in California switched back to gas
Driverless cars? They should test them in Boston in the Spring, after all the lane markings are gone, at night in the rain.

Testing in cities with grid street systems and visible lane markings during fair weather in the daytime is not informative.

← PreviousPage 4 of 28Next →