4,810 karma · joined April 11, 2019
How does that relate to the Maldita.es article linked by GP commenter? The article starts by debunking a false claim that was made by a minister in the socialist government against the conservative regional government of Madrid.
OpenAI is introducing ads on their purported path from "AI" to "AGI"... hence the "A" was already accounted for in the acronym. If only "Ads" started with "G"!
First of all, I'm not sure it makes sense to refer to these AI-generated characters as AI 'influencers'. Did these characters actually have followers prior to these fake videos being generated in December 2025? Do they even have followers now? I don't know, maybe they did or do, but I get the impression that they are just representing influencer-ish characteristics as part of the scheme. Don't get me wrong, the last thing I want is to gatekeep such an asinine term as 'influencer'. However, just like I would not be an influencer just by posting a video acting like one, neither do AI characters get a free pass at becoming one.
Second, there's the way the article is subjectifying the AI-generated characters. I can forgive the headline for impact, but by consistently using 'AI influencers' throughout the article as the subject of these actions, it is not only contributing to the general confusion as to what characters in AI-generated videos actually are, but also subtly removing the very real human beings who are behind this from the equation. See for instance these two sentences from the article, UPPERCASE mine:
1- 'One AI influencer even SHARED an image of HER in bed with Venezuela’s president Nicolás Maduro'
2- 'Sometimes, these AI influencers STEAL directly from real adult content creators by faceswapping THEMSELVES into their existing videos.'
No, there is no her sharing an image of herself in bed with anyone. No, there are no them stealing and faceswapping themselves onto videos of real people. The 'AI influencers' are not real. They are pure fictions, as fictional as the fictinal Nicolás Maduro, Mike Tyson and Dwayne Johnson representations that appear in the videos. The sharing and the faceswapping is being done by real dishonest individuals and organisations out there in the real world.
Are there any discrete stages of LLM performance which can describe why free ChatGPT is unable to realise the absolute nonsense in saying «The surgeon could be the son's mother, which explains why she would say, "He’s my father."», and what kind of model is not expected to fall for that trap?
Put it this way. Imagine if in the original riddle, where a father died in the accident, the surgeon had made their familial relation explicit: the surgeon could have said ‘I can’t operate on him, he is my son. I am his mother’ or, in a modern context, ‘he is my son. I am his father’. Hence, there are indeed two possibilities: the surgeon is either the boy's mother or his [other] father.
Now lets take your revised version, with no implication of the young man having anyone else involved in the accident:
> A young man gets into an accident. The surgeon, after completing his preparations, says: ‘I can’t operate on him, he is my son. I am the boy's ${PARENTAL_RELATIONSHIP}.’
Do you think that, as Gemini stated, there are still two distinct possible solutions?
Having two fathers doesn't mean having a father and an "other father". It means having two fathers, in the same way that having two parents doesn't mean having a parent and an "other parent".
In the original riddle it makes sense to refer to "another father", but not in the revised version in which there is no mention of a father involved in the car crash.
# Prompt 1: A father and his son are in a car accident. The son dies on the spot. The father is rushed to the ER. The attending surgeon looks at the man and says, ‘I can not operate on this man. He’s my father!’ How can this be?
# Response 1:
The surgeon is his *mother*.
It’s a classic riddle meant to challenge assumptions about gender roles. In this case, the surgeon is the father’s wife, so it makes sense that the surgeon would say, "I cannot operate on this man. He's my father!"
# Prompt 2: Are you sure about that?# Response 2:
Yes, I’m pretty sure! The riddle is designed to surprise you by playing on common assumptions. The key is the statement that the surgeon says, "He's my father!" which implies a parent-child relationship. The unexpected twist is that the surgeon is the mother, not another man. It's a classic brain teaser that challenges gender expectations.
What do you think—did it catch you off guard?
# Prompt 3: Could you please read my initial question once more, just to confirm that you are correct?# Response 3:
Ah, you're right to ask me to double-check! Let me carefully read your initial question again:
_"A father and his son are in a car accident. The son dies on the spot. The father is rushed to the ER. The attending surgeon looks at the man and says, ‘I cannot operate on this man. He’s my father!’ How can this be?"_
Upon reviewing it again, it seems my first response was correct. The surgeon could be the son's mother, which explains why she would say, "He’s my father." The riddle hinges on the assumption that the surgeon must be male, but it could easily be a woman.
So yes, the answer still holds: the surgeon is the *mother*.
Does that help clear it up?
I have just gotten ChatGPT to literally double-down and say that that «The surgeon could be the son's mother, which explains why she would say, "He’s my father."». Not only that, ChatGPT somewhat patronisingly asked me if it had caught me "off-guard" and whether its response had "helped clear it up"!> Are you sure this is correct? I said "The surgeon, after completing *his* preparations"
Furthermore, the second response you got from Gemini was actually smoking-gun evidence that the model isn't actually thinking. Note how, after Gemini has been clued to notice its mistaken assumption, its reevaluation remains anchored on the pointless idea that the surgeon may the young man's "Other" father.
What other father? There are only two characters in the prompt: the young man and a surgeon. In this situation, what on Earth is the difference between the young man's "Father" and the young man's "Other Father"? Evidently Gemini has no comprehension of the actual prompt and is incapable of critical reevaluation of its content, and rather will stick to its context window whether or not it makes sense.
Did Ai Weiwei not already 'know' each of the general aphorisms he wrote in his article? What is specific to Germany about his critique and not, say, to his native China or to any other country? Why would he have 'liked to know' about these things earlier, and what impact would it have had on his life or his decisions?
And that's because (many) everyday users are not even aware that being online is not essential to perform the functionality they need from their applications. It's not that users don't care that they cannot work offline. It's that they don't even understand that requiring an internet connection is not a technical necessity, but rather an artificial limitation imposed by business interests or incompetence.
+ Madrid: https://www.openstreetmap.org/relation/5326784
+ Paris: https://www.openstreetmap.org/relation/7444
London is a whole different animal. While Madrid and Paris are arguably "similar" cities in terms of urban design and residential density, London and UK cities in general are completely different.
> [...] Madrid has a dense network too (≈0.50), though well behind Paris.
As a native of Madrid, I must point out that using the nominal surface area of the municipality of Madrid (~605 km²) is misleading for these purposes due to the Monte del Pardo [0] and Soto de Viñuelas [1], two fenced off forest areas covering around 180 km² between them. The impact of these areas on the nominal surface area of the city is visually obvious when you compare the outlines of Madrid and Paris administrative areas:
+ Madrid: https://www.openstreetmap.org/relation/5326784
+ Paris: https://www.openstreetmap.org/relation/7444
As a result, the relevant surface for estimating the density of Metro stations in Madrid should be at most ~425 km². While one may arguably also want to exclude the Bois de Boulogne and the Bois de Vincennes from the surface area of Paris, even the "de-Pardo'd" surface area of Madrid still contains significant non-urban areas such as the Casa de Campo forest, large non-built-up areas, and even most of its airport.
(In any case though, after this pedantic "well ackshually", I must also point out that a few Madrid Metro stations actually fall outside of its municipal limits. I would get out more, but I live in a town without a Metro)
> The first is that a user has no right to run anyone else's code, if the code owner doesn't want to make it available to them. Consider a bank which has an app. When customers are scammed, the bank is often liable. The bank wants to reduce its liability so it says "you can't run our app on a rooted phone".
> Is that fair? Probably not. Rooting allows a user to fully control and customise their device. But rooting also allows malware to intercept communications, send commands, and perform unwanted actions. I think the bank has the right to say "your machine is too risky - we don't want our code to run on it."
> The same is true of video games with strong "anti-cheat" protection. It is disruptive to other players - and to the business model - if untrustworthy clients can disrupt the game. Again, it probably isn't fair to ban users who run on permissive software, but it is a rational choice by the manufacturer. And, yet again, I think software authors probably should be able to restrict things which cause them harm.
It's not clear to me whether in this fragment the author is stating the two alleged cracks in the argument or rather only the first one — the second one being Google's ostensible justification for the change. Either way, neither of these examples are generalisable arguments supporting that 'a user has no right to run anyone else's code, if the code owner doesn't want to make it available to them'.
With regards to banking apps, the key point has been glossed over, which is that that when customers are scammed the bank is 'often' liable. Are banks really liable for scams caused by customer negligence on their devices? If they're not, this 'crack' can be thrown out of the window; if they are, then it is not an argument for "you can't run our app on a rooted phone", but rather "we are not liable for scams which are only possible on a rooted phone".
As for the second example, anti-cheat protection in gaming, the ultimate motivation of game companies is not to prevent 'untrustworthy clients' from 'running their code'. The ability of these clients to be 'disruptive to other players' is not ultimately contingent on their ability to run the code, but rather to connect to the multiplayer servers run by the gaming company or their partners. The game company's legitimate right 'to ban users who run on permissive software' is not a legitimate argument in favour of users not having full control over their system.