HNHacker News
TopNewBestAskShowJobs

MrSkelter

267 karma · joined December 8, 2023

submissionscomments
MrSkelter··on Field measurements of neighborhood-scale air temperature impacts of data centers
Why do you assume that building data centers is critical to begin with? You seem to start with an assumption you haven’t even questioned? Just 5 years ago very few Americans thought massive data center buildout was key to the economy.

Your comment about the size of the earth is confounding. How is that relevant? Raising temps 4 degrees locally is a serious issue. Yes it will be worse if it scales but it doesn’t have to in order for us to care.

The tech companies could be building green data centers. Using renewable energy they are paying to add to the grid ( ie building the solar plant along with the data centers) and then flowing half the power they make back to the grid to lower prices. They could similarly work with water, purifying non drinking sources and adding to supply overall.

Costs would balloon but the negative impacts would go and getting a data center would mean jobs, lower prices for energy, less carbon and clean water.

Doing it the way we are - based on subsidies and pollution - is a choice.

MrSkelter··on Israel creates fake think tank in likely attempt to dupe AI chatbots
You are implying conspiracy. It doesn’t track.

Israelis, and their supporters, love to boast of Israel’s technical prowess and world leading capability in many areas.

Most people do this and Israelis are no different. However in Israel’s case there is evidence of its ability to build, hack and exploit technology at a very high level. The attacks on centrifuges and pagers being prime examples.

Yet when reports of these capabilities being used for influence appear suddenly Israel is being unfairly picked on? It doesn’t make sense.

Israel is very open about its use of propaganda. From AIPAC to “hasbra” to funding film and tv projects pushing particular viewpoints.

Russia and China do not have anything like the power to work like this Israel does. There is no Russian or Chinese AIPAC equivalent.

MrSkelter··on Universal health coverage could save $1T and 114k lives a year: study
Healthcare reform isn’t actually hard. Every advanced country has done it bar the United States.

In every case costs have gone down and outcomes have improved.

You always build on what you have because you can’t pause healthcare for very obvious reasons.

Hence a lot of different systems all with the same aim. Controlled costs and universal coverage.

The idea the US is somehow different and cannot make the change is the result of propaganda and a mistaken belief that the current Us system is the worlds best despite its costs.

Healthcare reform is easy and there is an ocean of prior art.

MrSkelter··on Cursor is now a part of SpaceX
The idea that 2 or 3 founders means the next investor is a founder is total bunk.

It wasn’t a “paper” company because Musk himself valued it in order to get access to their IP and the assets which were the founders themselves.

Apple and Google had 2 founders. No one claims employee 3 or investor 1 is also a co-founder.

MrSkelter··on US vs. UK Baby Names 2025: The Biggest Top Differences Visualized
You seem to be implying that there is a huge demographic shift when the reality is that, just as was common in the UK 100 years ago, in the Muslim population men get one of 5 names and 4 of them are Mohammed.

The UK via colonialism has deep connections to India and Pakistan going back hundreds of years. We have a very significant population from the Indian subcontinent plus many other people from all over. London is more diverse than New York.

Meanwhile John isn’t in the top 100 male names. Not because of a lack of “white” people, but because people now prioritize “uniqueness” in names and in the UK fashions move much faster than they do in the US.

Lyra is popular because of the Phillip Pullman books which most people haven’t read and is a name they know because a pop star used it for their daughter. Noah is popular because of a pop song from the early 2000s. Alfie is tied to a classic Michael Caine movie, a couple of celebrities, and yet another pop song. 40 years ago these names were unheard of.

On top of that despite being a Christian country, people in the UK shun most Old Testament biblical names bar those which have been anglicized by time and royalty. No Ezekiel’s or Methuselahs here.

Etc.

MrSkelter··on The 19th-Century Family Fortunes Funding Degrowth
This is flatly wrong and why so many people still seem to think that 18th century economics cannot be improved upon.

Degrowth doesn’t mean making people less wealthy. It means consuming less overall and not mandating growth as an objective in itself.

There is usually no scarcity of housing. People are homeless because houses aren’t efficiently distributed. We don’t always need more buildings, we need better use of the homes we have.

Infinite growth in a finite system is absolutely the dumbest way to plan and the reason we are pushing the climate into unknown territory.

MrSkelter··on Why Are There Statues of Beavers on Top of This Oxford Street Shop?
I was offered a new silk topper when I bought my last Montecristo at Locke & Co. The right corded silk is in rare supply, not the skill.

They asked under £2,000 (not that much more than my Panama) and I was a fool for not taking them up on it.

Very few people are buying Toppers and most people inherit their’s. The British upper classes do not see spending money as proof of anything but foolishness. Extant hats can be repaired and reblocked. Signs of age are not shameful among people who are not nouveau riche.

The market for new hats is tiny. Most sold are plastic and those buying them are none the wiser and appreciate the robustness.

MrSkelter··on Worse on Purpose – How Corporate Greed Killed Product Quality
Your example is nonsense.

So someone cloned the market quality leader and you are suggesting that means the design, engineering and QA in the original isn’t valuable?

Show me those tools in 10 years.

The process of working out how to make them great is what you pay for.

MrSkelter··on US seeks cheaper hunter-killer drones after Iran destroys $1B worth of Reapers
You are making a good point but blaming the wrong thing.

Caution needn’t spiral cost. The reason US weapons cost so Much is because it’s profitable.

Building things that work 80% of the time makes sense in wartime. It doesn’t as a rule. Hence wartime production will always be cheaper.

Americas problem is that the military industrial complex is built to maximize cost and profit for private corporations, despite them being entirely dependent on government.

Until they are nationalized, and the profit margins are eliminated, you will always pay 20-50% more than you should and gains from efficient won’t be realized.

Look at the auto industry in the US. It’s protected by tariffs and still incapable of matching the Chinese and others on cost. It mainly survives because of incentives which subsidize vehicle types other countries don’t want (pickups) and Americans only buy because of incentives.

Iran is building drones for £3k. The US clones cost 30x that for “additional features” the spec didn’t ask for.

MrSkelter··on We charge $10k a week to delete AI-generated code
The industry is a joke.

Meta requires tens of thousands of engineers to maintain a social media site. Google even more for an ad platform.

Never have so many achieved so little and the joke is all those clowns think they are “10x engineers”. Meanwhile WhatsApp got to global scale with less than 30 people (before Meta bought it and piled on the inefficiency).

Vibe coding is many orders of magnitude more efficient than the industry standard and that’s why it’s so disruptive.

MrSkelter··on YC CEO says he ships 37K LoC AI code per day. A developer looked under the hood
You are completely right.

I have decades of experience building products working with everyone from remote teams I have never met to FAANG employees in Silicon Valley.

Pretty much every product and site is a combination of good work, hacks and hope. When people attack LLMs on the basis of quality I don’t know what they think the standard is?

Outside 8-bit games which shipped in cassette and the Apollo flight computer most modern code only works because it’s been consistently updated and fixed in flight. It’s sad but true.

LLMs write code the way they write English. It’s not pretty but is of much higher general quality than the human average.

MrSkelter··on 'There Is No Going Back': The Inside Story of Europe's Rupture with America
Europe is already competitive, or leading, in many areas.

The US only has leverage over ASML due to other ties. If those are broken the leverage disappears and without ASML Americas tech industry suffers greatly.

Similarly Rolls Royce engines and BAE manufacturing are critical to the US military. The F-35 cannot be built without critical parts made only in the UK and which have no second supplier.

Europe doesn’t need to math the US military and wouldn’t want to in 2026. Look at what Ukraine is doing to Moscow. The US military is a machine built for a war that never came and now which never will. No one wants 11 carrier groups anymore because fighting that way is the past.

Europe is in many ways a mess, and I say that as a native born European with American citizenship who’s spent my adult life in the California tech scene.

However America is totally dependent on Chinese manufacturing, global supply chains and European partners and bases. America can’t produce N95 masks, nitrile gloves, or a chip fab to compete with Taiwan despite billions in government funding to accelerate these projects as critical.

Americas situation is as messed up as Europes and the US has fewer people, less land and fewer resources as a whole.

MrSkelter··on Cannabis users face substantially higher risk of heart attack (2025)
You make some reasonable points but the implication, that cannabis is as benign as water, is farcical.

The popularity of cannabis doesn’t justify pretending it’s entirely harmless.

Consumed as an inhalant it’s impossible to claim that it won’t have similar negative impacts to putting anything in our lungs which isn’t clean air.

Consumed orally the harm will be in the dose. But there no evidence that the doses people consume for their pleasurable effect are within the safe range long term.

I am sure based on the available evidence cannabis is less harmful than alcohol, but it’s so unproductive that any research on its harms is immediately shouted down by fans who want to pretend it’s “water”.

MrSkelter··on 24-bit/192kHz music downloads and why they make no sense (2012)
Even more likely, high frequency ringing in the higher res file, caused by the converters, has the same effect analog distortion via tubes does creating the perception of clarity where there is none.

No one can hear the difference between properly mastered high res files. I will happily put money on it.

MrSkelter··on Sony erases digital content from libraries
The casualness with which you suggest AI can produce better films than the Disney archive makes the rest of your assertions irrelevant.
MrSkelter··on Digital identity management in Norway is a success but also a disaster
You misread your link.

That list is of the change in moving to cashless since Covid. Sweden is low in the list because it’s been cashless for such a long time already. Those places aren’t more cashless than Sweden. They are the ones that are moving towards cashlessness most dramatically in recent years.

MrSkelter··on Digital identity management in Norway is a success but also a disaster
As a sometime Swede the idea of dealing with daily life in cash is farcical. Possible, sure. Convenient. No.

When my coffee shop in Sodermalm’s card readers weren’t working they just gave me free coffee over taking cash. Cash in Sweden is a burden. Banks don’t want it and most won’t accept it.

I also think the days of cash being anonymous have passed. With cameras everywhere and the trivial ease with which numbers can be recorded and shared a government could probably trace the path of a bank note if it wanted to.

MrSkelter··on SpaceX launches Starship v3 rocket
The design is wrong in a fundamental level. The rocket equation says it all. By adding so much extra weight for “reusability” (which they don’t release numbers on in terms of cost and means nothing when the rockets end up in the Indian Ocean) they nerf the performance.

Hence tens of launches to make the moon and zero payload to orbit in a dozen flights.

This forum is full of fanboys but their arguments don’t hold up to reality. Saturn 5 had men on the mock. This much time and this many rockets in. Starship has launched a dozen times for $15B - over a billion per launch - and it hasn’t made orbit.

Say what you want about SLS, it works.

Musk is a conman and Starship is a failure. Like the F-35 supposed libertarians and conservatives will happily throw money at it until it achieves its targets, after multiple redesigns, and then claim success as if the neigh-sayers weren’t right all along.

MrSkelter··on Frontier AI has broken the open CTF format
It’s just bad writing. There is no such thing as a universally understood acronym. Even within fields. The cost of clarity is zero. Not elucidating means that over time the writing rots as meanings change and new “universal understandings” supersede old ones.
MrSkelter··on Power Tools Got Worse on Purpose. Who Owns DeWalt, Craftsman, and Milwaukee?
Bridge City Toolworks have been made in China for a long time now. China makes some fantastic stuff but Bridge City built a name on being American.

Woodpecker are a better choice. Expensive but high quality.

Mafell and Festool get a ton of hate from people angry at the prices but they are totally worth it if you know. Feel and precision matter. Balance matters. “Design is how it works” applies here. You can’t tell how a tool is to use off a spec sheet, and numbers for things like torque are very easy to manipulate (what’s the load!)

Good power tools are a joy. They change what you think is possible.

MrSkelter··on European Stagnation Is Real
The whole premise of this rebuttal is wrong in a self serving way.

Purchasing power and income are meaningless without accounting for what needs to be bought.

Americans can make high incomes for decades only to be bank d by medical debt. Having to own a car per household member can add thousands to monthly outgoings and is common in many places. Even schooling, which should be free, isn’t when sports cost thousands per year and parents are required to furnish their kids classrooms with books, pens and paper.

I am a US/European dual citizen. American wealth is an illusion. Average Northern Europeans are much better off in real terms.

MrSkelter··on Bitcoin miners are losing on every coin produced as difficulty drops
Bitcoin is arguably the worst designed technology product in history.

Burning $88k of carbon to run the world’s slowest payment network and produce a tiny corpus of data is stratospherically dumb.

The technological equivalent of raising a forest to produce a toothpick.

Just because “it works” (which is arguable in itself) doesn’t mean it isn’t stupid.

MrSkelter··on Artemis II is competency porn
Musk and his ilk have mesmerized a lot of people.

It’s easier for them to believe in the fantasy superiority of a rocket which hasn’t achieved orbit than the real achievements of NASA and other space agencies.

It’s supercharged by a desire to politicize science to defend their sexist and white supremacist worldview. It pains them to see people they dismiss achieving great things. There are no able minorities. Just unfairness. A fair world to them is white men on top, everyone else below.

What’s funny is how different they are from the people they idolize. Just as SS officers would be disgusted by your average ICE recruit, you average NASA engineer from Apollo would have seen through Musk in an instant.

A rocket that requires tens of fueling trips to make a single moon run would be an anathema to them and they would call it out of the bad engineering it is.

There is so much anger that reality is stronger than prejudice and whatever they say and do women, brown and disabled people will be increasingly prominent, powerful and influential whatever they wish the case was.

MrSkelter··on If you started a company two years ago, many assumptions are no longer true
Anyone who writes that VC investment in defense was zero five years ago is neither informed nor credible.
MrSkelter··on US plans to automatically register young men for military draft
It’s funny how mandatory registration and tracking is fine in the US when it’s in support of war or to track minority groups, but impossible when the aim is serving the public, increasing access or safety.
MrSkelter··on Many African families spend fortunes burying their dead
Africa contains a billion people over hundreds of cultures. Referring to “African” tradition is like referring to “Asian” or “European” tradition. Do better.
MrSkelter··on Am I German or Autistic?
It assumes you have an internal monologue which is a problem if like me you don’t.
MrSkelter··on Sam Altman may control our future – can he be trusted?
Here’s a reality check.

There are two types of vaccine be coders. Those who review the code generated and those who don’t.

Either because they don’t understand code at all, or because they don’t have time and don’t care.

Code quality is only one factor. Naive vibe coders, who don’t code otherwise, rate performance based on output alone.

MrSkelter··on The house is a work of art: Frank Lloyd Wright
I love architecture and falling water disappointed me.

It was in terrible shape firstly. The new round of fixes has just been completed so it would be good to see it again before it resumes crumbling (those cantilevers have been drooping from day 1 and were 4 inches off by 1955, when I saw it there were seismic sensors all over).

Secondly as a tall person, 6’4”, the ceiling heights are just uncomfortable. Wright sized things for himself and he was a little man. For me I had the feeling I needed to duck constantly and the sense of unease destroys the other positive aspects of the house. A real shame.

MrSkelter··on Marc Andreessen is wrong about introspection
You are just moving the goalposts to criticize a position without being required to provide a reason. You could pick any phrase and mark it as beneath intelligent discourse. You are choosing “problematic” because you don’t like the implication.

Musk is easy to laugh at and to criticize. Problematic encompasses his lying, pettiness, racism, sexual weirdness, ego and fraud as well as anything. Regardless of the proportions of specific traits, as a whole, he’s a problematic individual. That’s perfectly cromulent.

← PreviousPage 2 of 8Next →