HNHacker News
TopNewBestAskShowJobs

MrSkelter

267 karma · joined December 8, 2023

submissionscomments
MrSkelter··on Market design can feed the poor
This reads like straight propaganda.

An inefficient system is always going to be ineffective. The author tries to posit that anything that isn’t market based is inherently inefficient and that their Chicago School solution is a success because it’s market based.

None of this is supported with evidence outside the new system working better than the old one.

Militaries efficiently allocate nutrition without markets (it’s the most important work they do) as do grocers.

There are a lot of ways you could improve on this, many not requiring the complexity and overhead of market based solutions.

MrSkelter··on Loss of moist broadleaf forest in Africa has turned a carbon sink into source
This is a common misconception. Commons are well maintained in healthy societies. Over extraction being punished by the group.

Moreover private owners optimize for wealth under capitalism, not preservation. Look at why oil companies want to do to the sea and arctic. Or the replacement of Amazonian forest with pasture for beef grazing.

African countries suffer under the poverty created by colonial extraction of both resources and people, followed by being charged for the privilege of having their resources taken, and saddled with unpayable loans. Those loans also placing them in a position where they are forced to allow western countries to continue to extract, and are prevented from protecting their national interests.

If Africa was allowed to own its wealth and develop without negative interference (assassinations, extraction, the world bank, foreign militaries) it would be the richest region on the planet.

MrSkelter··on Claude Code creator says Claude wrote all his code for the last month
As someone who knows how to code and who employs a number of coders I am not sure choosing to do it yourself means the underlying code is unworkable.

In two decades I have never met an engineer who joined a project and didn’t at some point suggest starting over.

The world runs on buggy, hack filled, good enough code. The idea LLMs are failing when that’s what they produce is wrong in my opinion.

MrSkelter··on Fish-Inspired Filter That Removes over 99% of Microplastics
This is the way.

I have been selling my extremely high quality plastic clothing (Veillance made in Canada items and Canada Goose) and been replacing them with wool and cotton.

Ventille cotton can keep you dry without plastic. Developed in WW2 by the UK for hoses and buckets when rubber was in short supply. Wanted cotton is another option but doesn’t breathe.

Mover - a Swiss brand - have an entire range of plastic free clothes of high quality.

Tons of other options but the above are easy substitutes at the high end.

Bonus, unlike even the best plastics these age beautifully and there are no taped seams to degrade.

MrSkelter··on I doubt that anything resembling genuine AGI is within reach of current AI tools
Not at all.

LLMS can appear intelligent until they, often, say things no intelligent being would. Then they appear profoundly stupid.

Washing machines wash reliably. LLMs do not.

A machine will be intelligent when instead of producing false output it responds with “I don’t know” and can be trusted.

MrSkelter··on Show HN: 100 Million splats, a whole town, rendered in M2 MacBook Air
I work in Hollywood and this is or true. We do not have to pay to have buildings in the background. Nor does TV. How would anything be filmed outside if news crews had to pay fees for filming like that? I have made films in NY, London, Paris, Sydney. We can shoot someone walking through a city as long as we have permits for the space. The skyline is free. As is anything else we capture from space we have rights to.
MrSkelter··on I'm Kenyan. I don't write like ChatGPT, ChatGPT writes like me
This is a uniquely American obsession.

I am English and from a well educated upper middle class family. When I moved to the US I was staggered to find my language being corrected by people taught that specific words were overly complicated and that any sentence over a handful of words was excess. It seemed that Hemingway was credited as Shakespeare and Americans all now lived in his very limited world.

(Don’t even get me started on the nonsense promoted by Strunk and White).

Like the poster I am also accused of writing like an LLM because I use constructions that aren’t simple and more than the first page of punctuation symbols.

The irony is that the machines have been trained on the world of English language writing and the complaints come from people who find the breadth of it intimidating.

LLMs were trained on all English text. Much of it from my home, the home of the language. Much more from the children of empire educated to write like Englishmen. Chat GPT is thus biased toward native English and upsetting people who want it to adopt the American dialect/patois.

America, a country with a majority of non English speaking immigrants over time, has developed a dialect that’s been simplified for ease of learning; undergirded with local rules which aren’t part of native English, and aren’t reflected in English writing.

It’s as if Canadians insisted that Quebecois French was the standard. Or Mexicans stated that Spanish is written only as they speak.

I often see, my now fellow, Americans struggle not to split an infinitive—pointlessly as it’s perfectly cromulent and correct. Or waste words describing something for which a word already exists. The illusion of efficiency in Hemingway’s style is just that. It works for him because he isn’t being required to convey anything he doesn’t want to.

Look it (as my relatives confounding say)

LLMs often write poorly but they should not be criticized for writing like an educated, global, English speaker.

MrSkelter··on Modern Walkmans
They did no such thing. Sales numbers were tiny outside Japan. People only tolerate lossy compression when that’s all they are offered. Hence the streamers introducing lossless options years after launch due to demand.
MrSkelter··on Modern Walkmans
Nothing has managed to capture the mixtape model. A tangible object made with care you could give as a gift and was unique and valuable. CDs got close but people didn’t have the gear to make them until mp3s had arrived and overshadowed them. Plus CDs with handwritten tracklists didn’t feel as nice as tapes and blank CDs were invariably ugly.

Music as an object is a thing and playlists are in no way the same. You can’t even control the music on a playlist as it’s in the gift of the streamer.

MrSkelter··on Modern Walkmans
It’s a funny comment because those formats only existed to be proprietary. Sony learnt the wrong lessons from CD, which they co developed with Phillips. They saw the success of that format and wished they were getting royalties on the underlying tech.

They then wasted billions and decades in formats other companies wouldn’t touch because they had fees attached. Minidisc being a prime example. Sounded worse than CDs, cost the same. Had a recording feature people already had with cassette.

MrSkelter··on Tested: 1981 Datsun 280ZX Turbo (1981)
True but remember the American obsession with acceleration is very different from actual speed. Driving involves moving the car round corners and bends. Many less accelerative cars will beat their betters point to point on handling.

Then there’s stoping. The less time you spend slowing down the faster you go and lighter better handling vehicles win there too.

That F-150 will get its ass handed to it by an older sports car through a city.

Drag racing is a tiny niche, it’s not the true measure of automotive performance any more than horsepower is.

MrSkelter··on We're learning more about what Vitamin D does
Two points.

You can’t say somone is being over cautious without k owing their location. It’s easier to supplement vitamin D than cure skin cancer. If the local population looks different to you there is reason to pause.

Secondly Asian people, East and South, are sun adapted. East Asians may not be dark but they, like Northern Europeans, selects for their current appearance based on environment. Just because they are not brown does not mean they aren’t sun adapted for their locale in ways visitors are not.

MrSkelter··on The writing is on the wall for handwriting recognition
I have a personal corpus of letters between my grandparents in WW2. My grandfather fighting in Europe and my grandmother in England. The ability of Claude and ChatGPT to transcribe them is extremely impressive. Though I haven’t worked on them in months and this uses older models. At that time neither system could properly organize pages though and chatGPT would sometimes skip a paragraph.
MrSkelter··on Earth was born dry until a cosmic collision made it a blue planet
That’s newer than Star Wars and isn’t a huge piece of IP. To the estate a few book sales makes a difference.
MrSkelter··on Buyers of Radio Shack, Pier 1 brands accused of running $112M Ponzi scheme
As someone who has been involved in dating sites you have no idea how standard this is.

Until Match bought the industry it was pretty much impossible to launch a dating site with profiles. The industry standard was to post fakes. Real users would then receive stock responses to keep them around until real people showed up. No AI needed. Just a bag of standard emails. Guys are incredibly dumb and ego driven. It’s very easy to get them to think a beautiful stranger is into them.

MrSkelter··on UK Millionaire exodus did not occur, study reveals
You are morally liable to pay taxes where you use services and rely on infrastructure.
MrSkelter··on The World War Two bomber that cost more than the atomic bomb
This is also the result of the failure of the third most expensive technical project of the war. The Norden sight. At the outset of the war it was believed that precision bombing from the air was possible. A vast sum was spent making a sight to allow accurate targeting to that end.

It simply didn’t work and the result was a return to area bombing and the massive civilian casualties that resulted in.

Even worse the bombing did almost nothing to lessen enemy output. In fact over the war Germany and Japan managed to constantly increase their output of weapons for various reasons. One being that having a large industrial base pre war meant they could always sift production. Ie at the start you are making bullets in a bullet factory. At the end you are making bullets in what was a sewing machine factory.

We still like to believe accurate weapons make for “clean” conflicts but we never seem able to resist area bombing.

MrSkelter··on Rotring 600 Ballpoint Pen
This is correct. I have NOS Rotrings made in Germany. They sell for a pretty penny online. People who love the pens know the modern production isn’t the same.
MrSkelter··on How big can I print my image?
Good luck printing anything at 870dpi.

This whole article is a bit confused. Image quality isn’t about the ability to discern detail. Many people cannot see the detail in their 4k TVs or a photo, it’s about not seeing visible pixelation.

Those aren’t the same thing. Visible pixelation is connected to contrast and color depth. That’s why a perfectly smooth gradient appears as bands of color in poorly encoded images and video. There’s no detail in gradients at all. The pixelation is due to a lack of color information.

On top of that printers use different numbers of colors (from 3 to 11 or more) and different ways of sizing and layering dots (if you aren’t using continuous tone printers which are very rare nowadays).

Then you have to add in the ability to up res images plausibly using modern algorithms. Whereas before we were always stretching the data we had, now by adding false detail using ML we can scale a significant amount without a visible reduction in quality. That can be very effective at removing pixelation while preserving the original image content.

So in reality there aren’t hard and fast rules. It’s totally image and output dependent.

MrSkelter··on The Israeli "art student" mystery (2002)
This was all widely reported. The problem here is that people don’t read and they routinely dismiss stories based on source, not content.

The 9/11 attacks were incredibly bizarre from day one. Everyone with any knowledge of the world immediately started asking questions.

Also remember that the attacks were the largest terrorist incidents by death for non-American countries. NY is a world city. More British people died that day than in any other single terrorist event - and that’s a country dealing with the IRA. That meant immediate global press and government investigation.

MrSkelter··on The average chess players of Bletchley Park and AI research in Britain
The entire premise is wrong. Humanity isn’t defined by expertise. Most average people will reach the “I don’t know” or making-it-up stage on most subjects pretty fast.

Perfect responses are more Likely indicative of a machine than a person.

MrSkelter··on IDF officers ordered to fire at unarmed crowds near Gaza food distribution sites
The lack of journalism in this conflict is a direct result of Israel forbidding press access and their targeting of Palestinian and other journalists. This deliberate effort enables them to then criticize the reporting which is done and cast doubt over sources.

Since October 7th sources from within Palestine have been accurate regarding deaths and actions. Often being attacked first and then quietly acknowledged later.

There is no reason to doubt the reporting of Israel’s paper of record, which though considered left wing writhing Israel, supports Netanyahu’s attacks on Gaza and applies rigorous journalistic standards.

MrSkelter··on New IQ research shows why smarter people make better decisions
IQ doesn’t measure intelligence. If anything it measures how well a person integrates the educational methodology they have been exposed to.

At best - and it’s a stretch - IQ correlates with intelligence sometimes. It’s far from a reliable measure though.

The problems in testing are obvious. You can depress someone’s results simply by changing the language used in the questions. I.e. you can make Americans score worse by using British English. That’s nothing to do with innate intelligence.

MrSkelter··on UK to buy F-35As that can't be refueled from RAF tankers
The F-35 cannot be made without the UK. There are key components which are only produced in the UK and for which there is no secondary supplier.

Even countries happy to spend huge proportions of GDP on weapons, like Israel, cannot build a modern fighter in house.

The solution for the UK is European integration which potentially brings the money, skills and manpower to build a better plane than exists anywhere including the US.

MrSkelter··on U.S. bombs Iranian nuclear sites
FYI every credible expert agrees that Iran aren’t making bombs yet. They are enriching to 60%. Far from what’s needed for a weapon. They have been capable of making bombs for decades and have chosen not to. They even adhered to the JCPOA when Trump tire it up.

It’s odd to have a country that illegally proliferated treating a neighbor who isn’t doing that yet as the greatest threat to world piece. Backed by the only country that’s used nuclear weapons in anger.

It’s very possible that in a decade the Us will be at war in Iran. Trump and Netanyahu will be off the world stage. The cost to the US will be thousands of lives and several trillion and China will have taken Taiwan while we aren’t capable of stopping them.

These wars always seem to start well because destroying things is the easy but.

We don’t know if we’ve done much damage to the buried facilities. Bunker busters don’t dive very deep, they can be deflected via engineering, and concrete is cheap.

Conflict like this are what will definitively end “The American Century” and we are currently witnessing that.

You cannot bomb your way to peaceful coexistence.

MrSkelter··on SpaceX Starship 36 Anomaly
This is an inane comparison.

Starship is “the program to build a permanent base in the moon”. It’s not even the only vehicle involved in the moon program. It’s a rocket designed to take astronauts from moon orbit to the moon’s surface. The astronauts will actually fly to the moon in SLS.

So far it’s proved incapable of being launched, attaining orbit, and returning to earth as designed. That’s without a payload.

It has no life support system built and is literally years behind schedule.

Rather than making progress it is being redesigned on the fly to mitigate fundamental problems with its capability which Musk laughs off as “moving fast and breaking things”.

The problem is we aren’t moving fast at all.

The rocket is a disaster. Saturn V was better by an order of magnitude and likely cheaper if you consider how much fundamental work went into creating it which is now easy to buy off the shelf.

Comparing the programs while ignoring the fact that hobbiest regularly reach the Karman line is deceitful.

Starship is doing this on easy mode and it’s failing.

MrSkelter··on Honda conducts successful launch and landing of experimental reusable rocket
It’s harder to land shorter vehicles. If you can land a short one the taller ones are easier.
MrSkelter··on Self-reported race, ethnicity don't match genetic ancestry in the U.S.: study
You have missed the point.

“Race” is only reliably visible based on skin color for a single generation. You can be a green eyed redhead with a black West African grandparent.

Americans obsession with “race” and racial superiority means that families both lie about their ancestry (turning African ancestors whose features are passed on into “Native American Princesses”) and misidentify themselves by using skin tone as a proxy for nationality.

Even the idea that people can trust unscientific racial indicators is wrong. Ask a Guyanese person where people think they hail from? And before people say that their have distant African ancestors why does that matter? How many generations count and why must we look further when skin colors are dark than when they are fair?

I.e. King Charles is considered English although his recent forebears were German and Churchill had an American mother and is likewise considered fully British. Yet someone of West African descent whose family has lived in the USA since the founding of Jamestown will still be considered “African” in a way more recent pale skinned immigrants are not.

Any discussion built on an unscientific foundation like “race” will lead to ridiculous and contradictory conclusions based solely on skin tone.

MrSkelter··on Deepseek R1-0528
This is a fundamental misunderstanding of copyright.

Copyright isn’t violated when someone consumes a copyrighted work.

Copyright is violated when a copyrighted work is used by someone who isn’t the author to generate profit without prior permission.

You can read a copyrighted book and remember it. You cannot copy it and sell copies. If you want to excerpt it you must give credit and there are limits to what’s considered “fair use”.

MrSkelter··on How can traditional British TV survive the US streaming giants
90% of the BBC wasn’t crud. Even if you didn’t like it. Until the early 90s it was making programming commercial companies couldn’t justify or take a risk on. This programs were fantastic and impacted the entire world.

This was a corporation (the BBC) who made their own cameras and microphones.

Go and watch “Ways of seeing” on YouTube. It’s 50 years old and still as exciting and relevant as it was then.

It was most when conservatives decided that the truth felt a little too left wing and they became vocal about not wanting to fund things they didn’t find entertaining.

Hence quality was traded for populism.

← PreviousPage 4 of 8Next →