It's a nice image but it looks like there are some FPN issues.
469 karma · joined May 3, 2023
It's a nice image but it looks like there are some FPN issues.
How generous. Psychopath was what came to my mind. No idea why he thinks that is funny. He is complicit in a scheme that is, according to the researcher estimate cited in the article, costing up to ~$60 billion a year; undoubtedly an enormous amount of harm and suffering has been caused (with more yet to come) and that is all he has to say for himself?
This is not an argument for it not being intelligent nor is it a coincidence. It has been shown mathematically that there is a deep, fundamental connection between compression and intelligence (an intelligent agent that behaves optimally effectively ends up computing the Kolmogorov complexity of the program that best fits and predicts the environment i.e. optimal compression). I do not know what you mean by "truly understand" since it obviously has an understanding of the various words it uses even if it's knowledge of the "meaning" of a word is simply a vector in a very high-dimensional space. I suppose you think this representation of meaning is profoundly different from meaning as it is represented in the human brain, that the former is a mere facsimile of the meaning while the latter must be the meaning itself, assuming such a thing exists. Even among humans I have conversations with people who use words or phrases for which they clearly have a poor sense of the meaning and make contradictory or nonsensical statements as a result.
All this "tells" is that it cannot (effectively?) bootstrap itself to higher performance levels with it's own output. This is not that surprising since humans have the same problem (for similar fundamental reasons). You do not teach children to write better by making them read their own literary output.
Finally, writing "ELO" instead of "Elo" is incorrect (this is just one of my pet peeves but indulge me nevertheless). This is some guy's name not an abbreviation, nor a prog rock band from the 70's! You would not write "ELO's" rating system for the same reason you wouldn't write "DIJKSTRA's" algorithm.
In my experience I have found the opposite to be the case. Most old maths libraries are written in FORTRAN (generally an order of magnitude or more slower than a comparable C/C++) and the implementations of standard algorithms are often sub-optimal and naive. I got the same impression when I compared arctangent (Taylor series) implementations in π programs and Minimax in chess (see Bernstein's program for the 704). I would guess that in the worst case they were 100x slower than what those machines could theoretically achieve. The C+inline asm libraries of today might be 2-10x slower at worst and some are even bottlenecked by memory. In this case I doubt the programs discussed in the 1989 paper, which were written in Prolog and FORTRAN, are exceptions to this.
TV engineers started working on HDTV in the 70s. Sony demoed a HDTV video camera in 1981. HDTV made it's broadcast debut in the late 80s in Japan, under the name "Hi-Vision". First version of Rec. 709 was published in 1993.
They are more tools of embellishment than tools of restoration. A good restoration actually "restores" information. If an old manuscript is missing a page or contains an error, we replace it with the same portion from another manuscript. Likewise if there is a scratch on this frame we should use the same frame from another print to patch it over. We should try to develop our tools to do more of that sort of work. A motion picture produced in the 1990s does not need to look like one produced in the 2020s, in the same way a Rembrandt does not need to look like it was painted in Photoshop.
We already know the answer to this and it is no, it is not a pre-requisite unless "sentience" is itself an emergent property of intelligence. Hutter's mathematical formulation of an optimally intelligent agent (AIXI) is not computable but approximations of it are, that is to say super-human intelligence IS just a computable function (as human intelligence is resource bound and suboptimal) with no extra "sentience" required. The only limiting factor at this point is the computational resources to compute this function, with the resources we have now it is still at the "toy" stage: playing noughts and crosses and Pac-Man etc.
People used to think that "creativity" was required for playing chess... clearly those people had not heard of Minimax.
I am almost certain they would of. The "fringe" and "pseudoscience" labels are used much more broadly on Wikipedia then one might expect.
I have seen a Palestinian scholar, whose research went against the prevailing Euro-centric Western view, labelled as "fringe" on Wikipedia even though it was being published by UNESCO and Cambridge University Press and he was by every metric a mainstream academic. The main editor's critique of his work was mainly ad-hominem and that it hadn't been acknowledged or "approved" by Western scholars. He didn't seem interested in verifying the texts that he cited and quoted; texts that the previous scholars were ignorant of. This was simply a case of a likely correct but minority view that was also difficult for an English speaking Westerner to verify, as the cited works were obscure and written in the 9th/10th century in Arabic. One of the few known manuscripts was located in a religious building in Turkey and not known to be available online in either scanned or transcribed form.
>if you actually measure time from keypress to event
Nobody measures keyboard latency this way because when you do the keyboards with less key-travel (Apple Magic) end up with lower "latency"; clearly an absurd result and not at all what you are actually trying to measure. It does not line up with anyone's definition of keyboard latency.
This article has been posted in response in the other threads: https://www.rtings.com/keyboard/tests/latency
So why would you expect it to be better if you shrunk them down to micro size? That is the whole point of my comment, that the observed latency is better explained as a function of hardware/software complexity and not "year of production". If you understand this, it should not surprise you at all that most contemporary desktops have the latency characteristics they do since we have seen it before in the old supers/workstations, their closest equivalents in terms of hw/sw complexity and capability. Of course it could be better and some are but you won't find them in that article.
>but these 'toy' computers are capable of running a word processor or spreadsheet, writing email, browsing the web (without js), compiling c, running an ide, etc. the zx spectrum even had a first-person 3-d shoot-em-up called elite. so i don't think it's pointless
Can it perform those tasks all at the same time like we expect now or like a mainframe/workstation user would have expected then? When you look at the entire landscape of computing hardware and software it is difficult not to see the early micros in that light. An extreme example would be the Altair 8800. I don't see how you could describe that computer as anything other than a plaything for enthusiasts. I made the analogy between modern desktops and old supers which you seem to agree with; could you even say that an early micro is the rough equivalent of a 50's mainframe with a straight face? It should be but the analogy is more difficult to justify: 36-bit vs 8-bit words, FORTRAN vs BASIC, FPU (some) vs no FPU, at every level of the analysis there are compromises. It should be clear that the micro represents an extremely compromised version of general computing that would be alien not only to us but to the serious computer user in the 70s/80s and yet their characteristics should be held as a benchmark for computing devices in general? Outside the context of "the home computing experience" they make for a poor comparison. Unfortunately there is great ignorance in this area due to the disproportionate focus on micros when discussing historical computing. Videos and articles on the Apple II series, awash with insufferable amounts of sentimentality, are a dime a dozen but you will be lucky to find anything on the IBM TYPE 704, a much more interesting and equally significant machine.