HNHacker News
TopNewBestAskShowJobs

Niksko

945 karma · joined February 12, 2011

https://www.skouf.com

[ my public key: https://keybase.io/niksko; my proof: https://keybase.io/niksko/sigs/4_K48wgjxKBXyJFpmjrvHFlKOAJVWwd3S-VbG3-S6Ng ]

submissionscomments
Niksko··on Ask HN: What are some of the best Reddit alternatives?
This is not a good take for the things that Reddit really excelled at: niche hobbies. Mechanical keyboards, mushroom cultivation, home brewing, just to name a few of my interests. None of that gets much traction on HN, nor outside unless your friends happen to have the same interests. Discord has a bit of that content, but I find Discord harder to engage with because it feels a bit more synchronous and time sensitive.
Niksko··on Addressing the community about changes to our API
The dev recorded things. You can hear it for yourself. To me it's pretty clear that he's saying 'my API is loud in terms of API calls, it would be quiet if it went away' not 'I will go away quietly if you pay me hush money'
Niksko··on We reported a security issue in AWS CDK’s eks.Cluster component
This special creation role has always puzzled me a bit. Why does there need to be a special role with unrevokeable root privileges? I understand that it's useful, but why can't I at some point revoke its privileges when I'm done bootstrapping the cluster? If I do that in such a way that I need AWS support to help me get into a cluster I've locked myself out of, so be it.
Niksko··on Why do ships use “port” and “starboard” instead of “left” and “right?”
And further, "port" wine is red, and the red beacon light is on the port side of an aeroplane (with the starboard side having green, and white on the tail)
Niksko··on Dishwasher Salmon
Not really. Farmed salmon and tuna are basically safe, because there are FDA controls around how they have to be frozen before they can be sold, which ensures that parasites die. Other fish are basically down to your risk tolerance.

There's just so much misinformation out there about food safety it's insane. If you understand basic hygiene and aren't immunocompromised, there's really not much need to be so terrified of food.

https://www.seriouseats.com/how-to-prepare-raw-fish-at-home-...

Niksko··on GM plans to phase out Apple CarPlay in EVs, with Google's help
I own a pretty old car, so haven't got the bells and whistles. But I've just rented a new model Camry for the last 3 weeks, and here's my takeaways:

Android Auto is much better than Apple Carplay. Carplay was janky and the navigation stuttered. Also the layout of the on-screen UI was weird, and poorly thought out. As usual I think, Android Auto is probably designed to work ok on any size screen and gracefully degrade. Carplay is probably impeccable on a few cars and crap on the rest (like this Camry).

But my pain point is that it would be easy not to notice that this exists. My mum for example has a very new car, I'm sure it supports Android Auto, I'd be shocked if she knew it exists. GM could make plenty of money from people who don't know Android Auto/Carplay exists (or from those that prefer to not need a phone), while still supporting Auto/Carplay for those that want it.

Niksko··on The Missing Semester of Your CS Education
A CS course isn't programmer occupational training in name only. Practically, there aren't many CS research jobs and working as a programmer is more often than not the career path for someone with a CS degree.

Universities can choose to be puritans about what CS is as you seem to be advocating for, or they can be realists and fill a very real gap in skills and knowledge.

Your point about "the topics needed for the degree to be granted" is also a very purist view of the role of university. Is the role of university solely to teach a curriculum that aligns with some abstract ideal of what a particular degree title means? Partly it is. But again, that doesn't match the expectation and the practical reasons why students choose a course. There are very few students studying CS for the beauty of it. Those that do probably do end up in academia and don't need this course. The rest are there for jobs, and they certainly could benefit from this.

Niksko··on I use C when I believe in memory safety
I couldn't quickly figure out what sort of applications this person writes for a living. But for 95% of applications I can think of: whatever, you do you.

Lots of people have pointed out flaws in his arguments here. There are always at least two collaborators on a codebase: you and you in two years time. You can enforce your own documentation best practice, but it's always possible to make mistakes unless you have a probably correct way of enforcing those best practices. I'm sure there are other very valid criticisms.

But in the end, there's a good chance that 100% guaranteed memory safety actually doesn't matter for the software that write. If you told me this person writes software for pacemakers or ABS systems or something similarly safety critical I'd take issue. But beyond that it's a sliding scale from merely irresponsible to an inconvenience.

Niksko··on Whipper: Accurate Audio CD Ripping
I mean, that's literally what RAW files from cameras are, and there are uses for them. I don't know if a multi pass CD rip is quite as useful as a RAW image, but your analogy is not as strong as you think it is.
Niksko··on Distributor cancelled an order and we need to move 30k bags of coffee [updated]
There's high end and then there's high end. I don't know this roaster well, but I can take a stab at how this works, based on roasters local to me.

The absolute biggest and best roasters have relationships and locked-in supply or exclusivity with farmers. They're also likely re-investing profits in those farmers. There are a very small number of roasters of this scale and sophistication, and they're probably already the ones in national retailers.

Everyone else is buying high quality but still commodity green coffee and roasting it.

The first group is able to get higher quality and guaranteed supply because of the deep relationships. They're excellent roasters, but they also are able to attain a higher level of quality because of the garbage in garbage out principle. Everyone else is competing on who can do the best job of roasting the same product. Important, but not quite the same.

I can't say that this company falls into the second category for sure. But if they do, that explains how they can get lots more supply very quickly. Their coffee is high end, they're doing a good job of roasting it, but it's not so high end that there isn't a bunch more green supply that they can get.

Niksko··on MIT faculty adopts “Statement on Freedom of Expression and Academic Freedom”
> Would suggesting they be legal be legal?

Have you encountered situations where ethicists and absolutist free speech advocates have encountered any legal problems for exploring concepts such as this?

You can make slippery slope arguments if you like, but they're somewhat analogous to the very idea you're defending. You're allowed to make meta arguments about curtailing absolute free speech being dangerous, why would someone else not be able to make a meta argument about allowing death threats? They're both equally removed from reality.

Niksko··on Twitter's tweets and blog post banning other social media platforms deleted
Boy do I hope this is not true
Niksko··on I Asked ChatGPT to Explain Some Jokes to Me
I've been a little underwhelmed by some of the creative writing that ChatGPT generates. I think the safety features are a little too strong, and I found it hard to get it to generate stories that didn't have incredibly saccharine endings. Maybe I didn't utter the correct incantations? By default though, every story is a happy story with a happy and uplifting ending.
Niksko··on Paul Le Roux is Satoshi?
This just feels like another entry in a long list of supposed proofs of who Satoshi is, which is missing detail (almost certainly by design) and which could have many other plausible explanations. The most obvious of which is that a private key leaked.
Niksko··on GPT based tool that writes the commit message for you
Please add functionality so that you can show some sort of badge on your GitHub profile based on your use of this. It would be a great tool to sort out who actually understands the purpose of a commit message.
Niksko··on Show HN: I fine-tuned Flan-T5. Can it cook?
Sorry, but 'searching google' for recipes is a surefire way to cook mediocre food. Most recipes on Google are optimized for convenience over quality. Even if that's what you want, it's a lot more useful to build a stable of recipe websites that you like and have had good results with and go from there.

Whenever I want to cook a new dish, I usually search Serious Eats, Chefsteps, Smitten Kitchen, and maybe then I'll look at Bon Appetit or a few cookbooks if I'm really struggling. Life is too short to bother cooking crap recipes, but that's basically what you'll get if you just do a Google search.

Niksko··on Smartphones wiped out 97% of the compact camera market
Yes, kinda. Other comments about camera makers being pathologically incapable of making good software are mostly true, Fuji just seems like the best of a bad bunch.

My X100V is awesome. But there are definitely rough edges, particularly around the functions that interface with my phone. This should be bread and butter for cameras these days, but sadly it's still a fairly slow and sometimes buggy process to get photos from my camera to my phone, or to use my phone as a remote control.

As for the camera interface and features itself, they're fine, but there are seemingly weird limitations. Only 7 custom simulations? No option to apply a custom sim after I've taken a photo? And the locked down nature is pretty annoying. I know that there are Android based cameras which opens up a whole can of worms, but there's money to be made with a camera that can leverage the wisdom and ingenuity of the internet to provide upgradeable features. Especially when camera lifecycles are pretty long, you're not cannabilizing your own market if you let people provide custom paid film sims that I can directly load into my camera

Niksko··on Consider working on genomics
Sounds like the only way you could ensure a healthy environment in this field would be to follow the Matlab or the Wolfram model. In other words, create a software company whose customers are bioinformaticians. Maybe find a bioinformatics academic to help guide product development enough to get some contracts with research institutions, and take it from there.

It sounds like academia is simply too toxic, entitled, full of itself and hierarchical to provide an environment with good software practices can thrive.

Niksko··on Scaling Mastodon is impossible
Two things stuck out to me as not very good arguments in this article.

One seemed to be that different moderation standards make a coherent experience impossible. I think this is a fundamental difference of the fediverse. There is no one experience, and that's a feature not a bug.

I think it also makes out that by banning other instances outright, instances will be largely disconnected. I think this ignores that, more or less, people agree with what is acceptable and what is not. And if they don't largely agree, maybe those groups of instances should be disconnected.

I think it also assumes that this disconnected experience is somehow opaque to users, when I think it's pretty easy to figure out that you're only seeing Toots from your own server. I think that's also not a bad thing. Again, if you set aside the idea that everyone has to be on the same experience, viewing the same content, the decision calculus becomes easy. Are you happy with the depth and breadth of the content you're seeing? No? Then move instances (which is easy).

My other criticism is about legality. The US has section 230 of the telecoms act, which basically allows internet companies to moderate their websites, without having to be responsible for what is posted there by users. Basically, the argument that the law will somehow sink the fediverse ignores that we made it this far. The web was allowed to flourish, in part because what you say online is largely your responsibility, not the responsibility of the sites that host the content (with a few exceptions). I'm not sure how Mastodon meaningfully changes that.

Niksko··on Twitter’s mass layoffs have begun
Time and time again, Musk has shown that he does not understand the nuances of free speech and moderation, and has presented nothing to indicate that he has any new solutions to the problems he is claiming to want to solve.

You're applying good faith reasoning to someone with a proven track record of acting in bad faith. That's noble of you, but you shouldn't be surprised if others don't follow suit.

Niksko··on The Restaurant Industry’s Worst Idea: QR Code Menus
Huh, maybe that explains why living in Australia, I don't understand the hate for QR code menus. Basically everywhere that has a QR code menu over here these days also lets you order and pay via the same QR code.
Niksko··on Puzzles to convince you you don't understand dependence
Every supposed puzzle in here boils down to the same answer: the dependency can be rephrased as a dependency on an interface. Sometimes the interface is just hidden or a bit abstract.
Niksko··on The Secretary Problem
Set some timeframe you'd like to buy a house in, x months. For small enough x, you can choose some constant rate of houses coming on to the market per month y. xy is your finite number of options.

The question then becomes: how much do the simplifications made affect the outcome of applying what we know about the secretaries problem to the real world situation? Someone could probably write a neat article about it.

Niksko··on Kubernetes for Developers Who Know How to Develop
At a small org, what is the advantage of Kubernetes over the vendor provided application runners i.e. AWS AppRunner or Google's App Engine?
Niksko··on The case for bad coffee (2015)
Fast, good, cheap. Pick two. Applies to everything.

Let's break down this specific context (food and drink), because I think it's interesting.

Good generally refers to quality (quality of the beans, quality of the machine, skill of the maker, etc), but what this article touches on is that good can also mean 'nostalgic' or 'evocative'. They're different kinds of good, perhaps more psychological kinds, but our perceptions of taste are functions of our brain anyway. Good can also mean 'what I grew up with' or 'what I'm used to'. Similar to nostalgia, but worth breaking out because temporally it's what you used to like, and you still like it, instead of merely harkening back to simpler times occasionally.

In terms of fast, usually we think of the coffee at the corner store that's always ready, or instant. But there's also an element of great food where you need to spend time understanding what you enjoy, and this is something that rarely comes quickly. In this thread there are many people saying they don't enjoy acidic coffee, and equating this with not enjoying specialty coffee. Spending lots of time understanding roast levels and finding a specialty roaster with less acidic coffee is something that would take lots of time and understanding. Wine and beer are similar, people who claim to hate either can generally be convinced that there is some style of wine or beer that they like if you take some time to understand what other foods and drinks they like and pick something that matches. But this takes time and expertise, and it would take even longer for the person to discover on their own.

Cost is similar to speed. Developing your palate, trying lots of different coffees, buying all of the equipment, it's all expensive.

"bad coffee" magically hits all three: good, fast and cheap. But the good is the nostalgia/evocation/what you're used to, and well since you didn't pick quality you can have good, fast and cheap.

It is perfect, to some people. But for me, who has no strong nostalgic association with "bad coffee", and who enjoys food and drink and deep-diving and learning, picking good and fast (in the case of espresso) is a better choice for me.

If I can end my post on a slightly inflammatory note: my goal in writing this is to make sure that people realise that loving low quality things when they can afford and have the time for higher quality things is on some level blissful ignorance. There's nothing inherently great about the low quality product, there are just other choices and tradeoffs you're making, which low the appeal of higher quality products (time and cost investment in exploring them) and raise the appeal of the bad quality product (nostalgia).

If you're fine with this (and there's no reason not to be), then enjoy!

Niksko··on Code replay attack on the myGovID Scheme
Sure, the mitigation isn't perfect. But I think the wider point is that as usual, the Australian government have implemented a shit scheme, full of obvious and rookie mistakes, when they should have just used a well known open standard.

Spelling out the very simple flaw is a means of underlining how poor this system is.

Niksko··on Internet Filtering in Canada: Rogers' NHL Blocking Order
The irony for me is that the NHL is an excellent example of why piracy happens. Last hockey season, I could pay the NHL directly to get access to all hockey games from Australia. They have a Google TV app that was flawed, but worked well enough, and I was happy.

This year, because the NHL have done a deal with ESPN, I have to do a convoluted deal with a third party to get access to ESPN, and my experience is terrible. ESPN's Android app is terrible, the Google TV app flat out doesn't work, and casting from my phone to my TV craps out during period breaks and long ad breaks.

Piracy would be easier, better and cheaper than paying for things. It's the same reason Netflix reduced piracy, and now it's tanking. They created something that was easier, cheaper and better than piracy. Now with their increasing prices, declining quality, and fragmentation of their library, piracy is going to increase again.

Niksko··on Mygov is a ‘huge disappointment,’ key architect despairs
Can you provide any notable examples?
Niksko··on The Gitlab Team Handbook
Thanks for sharing. I'd seen snippets of things out of GitLab, but in particular their section on remote work is a treasure trove of great ideas and practices.
Niksko··on Ask HN: Am I going insane or is there genuinely no value in blockchain tech?
Don't you need to also trust all of the other nodes on the network to come to consensus?
← PreviousPage 3 of 10Next →