HNHacker News
TopNewBestAskShowJobs

Noseshine

1,519 karma · joined May 18, 2016

submissionscomments
Noseshine··on Boeing to lay off hundreds more engineers
> because after a 200 year trend that is a reasonable thing to say

I don't think you understand how history works. Don't know if this is merely risible or sad.

Noseshine··on Boeing to lay off hundreds more engineers
I don't really mind what you say (don't care about the issue), but I do care when someone very confidently extends a trend into the future, here even into eternity, based on nothing but "it never worked before". That's just extreme intellectual laziness, which is fine, until you start commenting and pretend you know more than you do. There is way too little argument in your argument.
Noseshine··on Deep Patient Predicts Patients Future from Health Records
Grapes are high sugar fruit. There are others you might want to eat more of, but limit the sweet stuff.
Noseshine··on Monsanto Weed Killer Roundup Faces New Doubts on Safety in Unsealed Documents
There is nothing special about charities. You describe most human organizations. Whose nature also depends on their environment - I posit that in a less cut-throat world humans and their organizations would be less cut-throat too. I also don't believe that the way it is is "inevitable" and/or "human nature" (http://nautil.us/issue/46/balance/survival-of-the-friendlies...).

Think about this: At least in the western world we have achieved wealth and productivity where the word "unimaginable" from a point of view of even 500 years ago would be a gross understatement. And yet, to many people daily life still feels full of threats, while many work what they themselves recognize are meaningless jobs (see the popular Dilbert cartoons). It doesn't make sense, it is artificial. It doesn't need to be this way. We force people - and organizations - to live in a "stress and survival mode" that is completely unnecessary.

Noseshine··on Monsanto Weed Killer Roundup Faces New Doubts on Safety in Unsealed Documents
The point is not that someone knew something was/is dangerous - in retrospect you always find them (see financial crisis too). The point is what/who actually impacted the real large-scale actions.
Noseshine··on PhantomJS: Stepping down as maintainer
I'm not sure that the results should be expected to be the same in GUI and in headless mode. I don't know - I'm just saying this is not clear without a test or clarification from someone who knows how it all works.
Noseshine··on Apple Loses Top Laptop Rating
Then why did you click to come to this discussion thread instead of ignoring it like you doubtlessly do for 90%+ of all topics that come up on HN?

How about this: You don't upvote stories you don't like, and every person has (only) one vote to upvote what they do like to be seen and/or discussed. Incidentally, that's exactly how it already works... If you want to be the one with veto power there also is a way: You can create your own subreddit on reddit.

Noseshine··on How to Study (2016)
After a CS degree (2 decades ago) and many hundreds of hours and courses on medical topics over the last few years, I think studying medicine and fields like engineering or math are very different though, and what works in one may not be the best idea for the other. A lot of memorizing in medicine, like neural pathways, (bio)chemical pathways, location of nuclei in the brain, anatomy (of course), regulatory circuits. You learn everything to "debug" one concrete instance of a biological being, and although variations exist in comparison to all that could be (or even what there is, looking at all animals) it's very little, and it doesn't change (beyond the inherent variation, which only seems great because you are looking at only humans so any deviations appear greater than they are without the perspective of "all possible biological systems" for comparison).

Engineers learn existing systems - and many kinds of them - to be able to create new ones. Medical doctors instead work on only one already existing systems. Engineers can experiment and fail, many times. Medical doctors should "do no harm" first of all. So that limits the creativity and determines how you learn from the outset. Therefore which methods work will also be different.

Noseshine··on How to Study (2016)
Also gives you bonus points with the professor, simply because they can't help notice that you did that and even subconsciously getting closer signals interest. My very first exam grade when I started studying CS (25 years ago) was an "A" with a very strict professor who rarely gave anything better than a "B" on a theory-heavy (algorithms) subject - who could have known nothing at all about me, only that I seemed to actually be interested in what he had to say because I always sat in the front. I don't think the oral exam itself was responsible, because there were few hard questions, it was more a back and forth talk about things not even the core subject of the lectures. I think he would have asked more actual questions to people he thought he knew less about. So I think I already entered the exam with a significant bonus.
Noseshine··on How to Study (2016)
I can very well imagine note-taking helps with memorization, but I can't imagine that it helps with concepts, with connection the dots. Your mind has to be able to wander freely for that, when you are busy writing you have to concentrate on that particular task, which is the opposite of a freely roaming mind ready to explore ideas and connections. Just my theory, and I'm certainly biased, since I'm someone who very rarely wrote anything down at university At school we had to, and looking back the results I got from that education support my theory. I never had any trouble at school, but getting good grades and actually caring about the knowledge and connecting it all in my head didn't happen - only now, decades later, when I discovered online learning and took over 70 courses by now am I able to connect it all in a meaningful way. No, I certainly don't have a good opinion about note-taking as a basis for gaining knowledge. The results are too narrow, I think.

What I found that helps - which unfortunately doesn't scale very well given how much students have to learn in a given time - is to teach others. Become a TA. Answer other people's questions, explain stuff. It may be an individual thing, I always work better that way in all parts of life - doing things other people need, I don't have a lot of questions myself and I do much better under this system.

Noseshine··on We’re dropping Google Ads
> the "enlargement penis" spam works because the average person is not that selective on the ads they chose nor the websites they visit

I don't think you understand "average". It's the extreme tail of the distribution that is targeted by such ads.

Example:

> Nigerian scam emails 'deliberately implausible'

> New research from Microsoft suggests that email scammers maximise profits by entrapping only the most gullible.

http://www.telegraph.co.uk/technology/microsoft/9346371/Nige...

Noseshine··on Leaked email from United Airlines CEO blames passenger for violent removal
> A person was legally required to do something he didn't want to do

That is your claim but it does not appear to be true.

Read this comment on reddit from a lawyer (unless someone shows that to be wrong I'll assume it to be true):

https://www.reddit.com/r/news/comments/64nluh/united_ceo_dou...

(EDIT: The comment is actually just a quote of another comment here: https://thepointsguy.com/2017/04/your-rights-on-involuntary-...)

According to that guy's reasoning they violated the law and that's all.

> and escalated the situation

I don't understand the mental gymnastics unfortunately performed numerously by people like you which can be found all over the comments to somehow let United be in the right here. Apparently in your eyes customers have no rights, and anything the corporation demands must be done, period. Especially when I look at how you phrase it: It seems more than obvious that if anyone escalated the situation is was United. The other people on board apparently saw it that way too! Nor did they do what they were required by law to do, to the end the compensation they offered was below what they were legally required to offer. Who escalated, tell me again?

Noseshine··on We Need a New Deal to Address the Economic Risks of Automation
I would replace "own" with "control". They don't hoard production facilities and buildings in their locked cellar. The things they own are still being used to produce stuff consumed by other people than the owner.

No, but they control the economy. They decide what projects to start, and since they are so rich they only think in hundreds of millions at least. So we get less local control - which are all small projects - and more mega-projects/corporations. Which are better at producing at scale, but are (much) worse at providing a satisfying work environment. So we end up producing more than enough stuff, but much of it not actually needed - here you need clever marketing to convince people to consume stuff they don't need, from drugs to insurance to a new shiny car.

I think much of the discussion and the picture a lot of people have in their heads about "the 0.1%" is Scrooge McDuck, with all the money right there only for himself to even see. But in reality capitalist ownership is more a matter of control of what, where, how.

Apart from the means of production, the "body" of the economy, they also control a large share of the "blood" of the economy, the money. Wherever that flow is directed things grow, where it doesn't go lights go out.

While the rest of the population still has quite a bit of money taken together, there is another problem of psychology: Money is no problem for a rich capitalist. They can easily finance billions. But for the people who don't have such easy access to the streams of finance money is much more static, money is much more valuable for the majority of people. Also, "credit" has different meanings for someone investing in a small venture and a billionaire: The latter has financial instruments so that he ends up carrying little to none of the risk.

Noseshine··on Hull teacher held in Chinese jail for 'not being a friend of the country'
https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Whataboutism
Noseshine··on Iosevka – A Typeface for Code, from Code
Coding font ligatures mostly are meant for symbols though. Examples (linked for the example images there):

- The submitted font - scroll down to "Ligation sets" https://be5invis.github.io/Iosevka/ (note that they only show symbols)

- https://github.com/tonsky/FiraCode

- https://github.com/i-tu/Hasklig

I think people using a programming language with a more math-like notation probably benefit much more than those using "normal" languages.

Noseshine··on Australia hasn't had a recession for over 25 years
> Yes, despite it being the poster child, the mining sector only comprises 16-18% of the economy.

Uhmm.... I just pointed out that the use of the word "only" is not justified... :-)

> I can't remember exactly but the Banking sector in Australia may be the bigger than mining.

What do you mean by "larger"? Employ more people, pay more wages? Just "having" money (and large numbers in their balance sheets) is kind of a given for that sector.

Besides, the point never was finding the "biggest". Somebody can be a tall person even if they are not the "tallest". So large changes to that sector will have large effects to the overall economy, many of them indirect.

Noseshine··on We’re losing the information war
Sure - but you are talking about those spreading stories, he was talking about those - far more numerous - who are consuming stories, from all sides. You shifted the frame. There's nothing we can do about some people coming up with... "theories", they will always exist unless you have a dictatorship and total control. However, they are harmless just like a virus meeting a well-vaccinated group of people is harmless.
Noseshine··on Australia hasn't had a recession for over 25 years
"Only" 16-18%?

How much of that from exports? Which pumps more money into the economy where it has a lot of follow-up effects. Given that a rise or fall in GDP of a low single-digit percentage point can already mean a big boom or bust the above number is huge.

Noseshine··on Night Shift compared to f.lux
How "orange" it gets depends on the color temperature you set. f.lux allows a very wide range of final-spectrum settings, from almost-no-effect to small-medieval-candle-light.
Noseshine··on Syringe injectable electronics (2015)
It's been a while since my various neuroscience lectures/courses, but as far as I remember LTP only refers to the process of strengthening existing synaptic connections, not the forming of new ones. The process of forming new connections is called synaptogenesis.

That's just nit-picking about terms though, it is clear enough what you mean - except that growing the exact same network still doesn't give you the exact same synaptic strengths of each connection. And I don't know what you mean by replicating the existing network - do you mean a technique to recreate the exact same neural network? But even if you manage to do that, where are the boundaries, how do you know which connections matter and where do you stop? I probably don't understand your plan though.

Noseshine··on Canada seeks to end Uber's tax advantage over taxi companies
Aren't Uber fares subsidized by its investors?

https://news.fastcompany.com/investors-are-paying-2-billion-...

Noseshine··on Elon Musk seeks “specific amendments” to recommend to Trump on immigration order
Well, you show you are unable even to read and comprehend a few simple sentences. As I said:

> I would argue the other logic of hammering Trump blindly is the logic that doesn't care about the issues it claims to care about nearly as much as about "feeling good" on a childish level

Another example for your stupidity:

> Presidents can be removed.

So, DO IT! Oh, you can't? What I said.

It is what YOU can do, not what somebody else and/or the universe can do (but doesn't!!).

Amazing that people with such a lack of thinking-skills complain so much about Trump. I have the feeling what really irks you about that guy is that you are looking in a mirror, he's just like yourself!

Noseshine··on CIA Declassified Coldwar Russian Jokes [pdf]
Unless you refer to old(er) working class women with a hard life I don't see how any reasonable person can think that's even remotely a basis for a joke, given how much more beautiful Russian women look on average. Just walk around Russian cities. Having lived in the US for a decade and having been to Russia and Ukraine several times, sometimes for months living in a rented apartment, I know which country I'd choose if "women" were the decision-driving factor.
Noseshine··on Tripling Down Against USA Conference Hosting

  "do they offer worthwhile value"
You merely rephrased "need", so I refer to my reply above, same response.
Noseshine··on Elon Musk seeks “specific amendments” to recommend to Trump on immigration order
I would argue the other logic of hammering Trump blindly is the logic that doesn't care about the issues it claims to care about nearly as much as about "feeling good" on a childish level: The main goal seems to be to make Trump angry and not to solve any of those issues. For another example, it's not exactly news that calling Trump supporters (and Trump himself) names does not help, yet that still is what a lot of anti-Trump comments seem to concentrate on. It doesn't help, it doesn't change anything, but it's a main feature of the discussion. Most people on the side of "logic" don't follow logic, they go by emotions. If you cannot remove that president or the people who elected him, and you can't (you don't even have the means to get rid of them, so there's no need to even look at the morals of such a move) you would think that proponents of logical thinking actually use stone-cold logic to find a way, instead they use the biggest hammer they can find and try to use it on the opponents, deriving pleasure not from solutions but from eliciting angry reactions. "I made them angry - my job is done."

For example, the downvotes I got immediately for this comment. The anti-Trump camp disappoints me A LOT more than the Trump camp. You guys claim to be better, yet you act exactly the same. Irrational and emotional and out to hurt your perceived "opponents". Maybe the reason some of you dislike Trump so much is because you are looking in a mirror, deep inside yourself you find mostly raw emotions and rage rather than logic and reasoning.

As I said, you guys don't care about progress on any issues, only about hurting people you perceive as even slightly different and only superficially so (since I'm not even remotely in the Trump camp).

Noseshine··on Tripling Down Against USA Conference Hosting
Define "need". Do you need to breathe? Only if you think you need to live, and the only reason you want to live is that you are wired that way (selection bias, all those who didn't care enough have been removed). Life isn't something objective, you can just decide on what's important to you, as long as it doesn't interfere with your ability to go on living it does not matter. Some people like cats, some people like ice cream. Some people like to talk to other people in their field in person and go to conferences or far-away meetings. Some people go far away for no reason at all (vacation)!
Noseshine··on Tripling Down Against USA Conference Hosting
I know that the UK situation for tuition is comparable to the one in the US. My points is about universities in countries that don't have that financial incentive and pressure. The UK is just one small somewhat "special" country in Europe.

The difference between European countries can be quite high (http://www.mastersportal.eu/articles/405/tuition-fees-at-uni...), so my comment wasn't about any one in particular. When I look at just Germany even within the same country there is a lot of variation depending on the university and the particular program. But in general universities in many European countries don't rely on income from foreign students to the extend that US universities seem to do.

Noseshine··on Tripling Down Against USA Conference Hosting
Do universities that don't have to rely on the money they get form international students have the same incentives as US universities?

From what I read that's a major consideration for US universities why they want to attract foreign students. For German universities that would only be of marginal concern, even if/when they take some money from foreign students it's just pocket change and not nearly enough to finance the institution to a substantial extend. Sure they still have an incentive, but it's much less and not monetary.

I think, that's what I get from what I've been reading in comments over the years.

Noseshine··on How to Avoid a Post-Antibiotic World
Uhm.. it won't be MADE. It won't be RESEARCHED. It won't be MARKETED. It won't go through CLINICAL TRIALS.

I wonder how low the average HN reader IQ has gotten lately that my insightful comment got downvoted and that I have to deal with crap like yours. Way too many total little teenagers and idiots on this site now.

Noseshine··on How to Avoid a Post-Antibiotic World
I think you are both right, both forces (and more) are at work. Market effects are not about what individuals plan or want, it's about system outcomes.

If, just as a thought experiment, it was possible to treat a disease quickly with a cheap drug or intervention, for example a cheap herbal drug that is available patent-free and for mere cents per liter, there would be no business in it, so no company could viably pursue this. The market selects for treatments that give a lot of profit. That always or even merely "usually" automatically somehow translates into the best option from a public health point of view only if you close your eyes and make lots of assumptions about how great the market magic works - in a market with extremely unequal information and very high pressure on customers (when you are sick).

On the other hand you are right that symptom treatment usually is the best we can do. The body is built during the early years and from then on it's maintenance, also what the body itself does and not just the doctors (it does not regenerate most structures, only repair). Just more and more ever more horrible hacks, workarounds and kludges and patches delaying the long decline more or less well. Or as most drugs do, don't even repair anything, just push levers and buttons in the body, but it doesn't do anything structural unless the body does it on its own. So if the structures don't regenerate the button-pushing drug has to be take lifelong.

That is so fundamental to complex life forms that current medicine simply cannot work against it. Maybe never, because replacing a structure in the grown body is much more difficult than growing it with everything else. For example, the difficulty of finding the path for new axons after a spinal injury is much greater than building everything together during very early development. Medicine would not just have to achieve what nature already does (when the body is assembled) - it would have to become far better! Repairing something often is much more difficult than starting from scratch.

← PreviousPage 2 of 22Next →