HNHacker News
TopNewBestAskShowJobs

Olreich

711 karma · joined July 9, 2012

submissionscomments
Olreich··on Trump wins presidency for second time
We could make it not opinion with ease. Make the test:

“Can the fetus survive without the host body?”

That’s a medical question that will slowly move toward not aborting ever. And it solves the medical issues as well. “This fetus is killing the host” always allows for removal, because we can either keep them alive, or it can’t survive.

Then the folks who want more babies to reach term can focus on improving medical technology instead of getting involved with the mess that is people’s love lives.

Olreich··on Trump wins presidency for second time
Do you want your children to have a better life than you? They won’t unless we start putting in the work to fix climate change.

As a species we took on some climate debt to improve our standard of living, and we’ve been talking bigger loans every year. Those loans are coming due in the form of larger and more frequent weather-based disasters as well as health problems for millions. If we start paying off the loan more aggressively now, we can help prevent harsher payment plans for the next 50 years.

You don’t pay off a house all at once, but you’ll thank your future self for paying it off earlier rather than later.

Olreich··on Trump wins presidency for second time
I can’t find any statistical reporting to back there being millions more undocumented immigrants coming into the country in the last 4 years. Data-backed reporting indicates that we’ve had ~11 million undocumented workers since the 2005 with little change until 2020. https://www.pewresearch.org/short-reads/2024/07/22/what-we-k...

Any chance you know where to find some more?

Olreich··on How Discord stores trillions of messages (2023)
This was a “double-pump” migration to a faster database and building a caching service. There’s nothing particularly fancy or creative about their solutions. The migration efforts and working out issues with the reverse table scan were probably way more creative, but they didn’t get into that unfortunately.
Olreich··on The war on remote work has nothing to do with productivity
You don’t have time to work two real full time jobs. If you have time to keep 2 bosses happy where both are expecting 40 hours a week from you and you are giving 20, then those bosses suck at gauging performance and making good hires.

If you are actually twice as productive as your co-workers and can manage a 40-hour a week job in 20, then the companies are getting what they paid for. Good for you that you found two jobs you’re uniquely qualified for. I’m happy you’re getting paid to do both jobs instead of having to waste the other 20 hours of your week on labor you don’t get paid for.

Olreich··on The war on remote work has nothing to do with productivity
Why not all three? Helping their feelings of power, Helping their bottom line with attrition, and Helping their real-estate buddies with big dumb investments in tall buildings.

There’s no reason it has to just be one thing

Olreich··on Amazon tells employees to return to office five days a week
Amazon has yet to share any of that internal data with its internal employees or the outside world. The only reasoning shared has been vague talk about energy being higher and culture being easier to spread. There is a lot of money to be saved and a lot of initiatives that would benefit from broad embracing of WFH by Amazon.

They claim to support improving DEI for neuro-divergent and mobility-impaired folks, where WFH would be a massive improvement in their ability to contribute without being required to commute into the office which might present challenges for them.

They claim to support sustainability and achieving carbon neutrality, but forcing employees into the office burns significant fossil fuels and puts wear on vehicles and increases pollution since the majority of the workforce winds up driving a car to work. They will increase this measurable impact by 60%+ by mandating another 2 days of office-work per week.

Much more likely, there are motives to doing this change that are not aligned with data and stated goals. That could either mean nefarious goals or lacking data. But it's more likely nefarious goals, since WFH didn't seem to be hurting anything according to all the data anyone has been able to tell. I'd expect someone to be able to come up with plausible ways that WFO is better than WFH in a data-oriented manner, but it really does seem to be down to personal preference for individuals on how they like to work. Who knows, maybe Andy Jassy really likes to work in-office and thinks that anyone saying they don't is lying and lazy. We have as much evidence for that as everything else that's been conjectured.

Olreich··on Amazon tells employees to return to office five days a week
Once organizations get to a sufficient size, increasing your "scope" is the only metric left to compare. You could compare revenue, but the easiest way to get more revenue is to increase the amount of work that falls under your purview. You could compare profitability, but then you encourage everyone to make the most expensive products they can get away with and your company fails. You could compare productivity, but there is no scientific way to do that, and funding the research required would bankrupt you and your company fails. You could do it by vibes, but the snake oil salesman will sell you garbage and your company fails. You could do it by seniority, but then you stagnate and your company fails. You could do it at random, but then none of your managers would bother trying and your company fails.

Do feel free to suggest a better way to compare two managers that doesn't fall into worse situations than "scope".

Olreich··on Amazon tells employees to return to office five days a week
Strategic of them to include the 5-day a week to hide the 15% managerial layoffs. 1 in 8 managers need to be converted into ICs. The average manager has around 8 ICs with the "two-pizza team" ideal, so that means 2% overall layoffs. Not huge, but managers generally cost more than ICs, so there's likely outsized salary impact. Organizational changes will surely reduce productivity as everyone gets shuffled too.
Olreich··on Amazon tells employees to return to office five days a week
Considering many shops are just "implement whatever the business people want" and have things silo'd out across many teams, the autonomy to make a thing you work on and support better is hugely valuable. You can get that lots of other places, but it's very hit and miss on the level of ownership you can actually achieve. Amazon does tend toward a very startup-like sense of technical ownership, even if there's little financial tie to the product.

I'd argue that most startups have little financial tie to the product too for all but the first couple of contributors due to all the complications that wind up going into startup funding. If you can only realize any value from your equity with 1:10000 odds, your expected ownership is 1/10000 of whatever you actually got in equity.

Olreich··on Amazon tells employees to return to office five days a week
Usually the tax incentives are relatively minor and are long term as well. The more important thing with the real-estate strategy is that there's a lot of capital and personal clout wrapped up in these massive building projects and investments. Amazon recently had 2 shiny new buildings built in Arlington, VA. They have a bunch of buildings that were built in Seattle. There's definitely tax incentives involved, but those tax incentives are tiny compared to the billions of capital poured into the buildings.
Olreich··on Amazon tells employees to return to office five days a week
I'm sure that the numbers indicate that, but it's quite a leap to pin WFH as the driving reason that the juniors not moving up and the seniors not moving into management. It's a good story, and I'm sure that's the sort of thing that top leaders in big tech are using. Except for the reporting that 60-80 CEOs got together and just decided to move, and that they aren't willing to share those concerns of low IC improvement in the communications.

If the story were true, then that'd be a reasonable thing to share in broad terms and would reduce the impact to morale as there's at least some shared, reasonable argument. Instead we get vague reasoning about energy of the workforce and spreading the corporate culture.

Everything I've seen aligns on three pillars:

* Real-estate strategy (lots of contracts and promises to commercial real-estate as well as local governments)

* Quiet layoffs (if they leave on their own, then we aren't firing!)

* Disconnection with reality (upper-management's job is harder remotely or they're bad at it, and having face-to-face conversations is really important for politics, their primary job)

Olreich··on Steve Ballmer: facts on the US federal budget [video]
Or you can apply taxes to corporations and the ultra-wealthy and drop the debt easily while expanding medicare, social security benefits, college, etc. The counter-point of "then all the companies will leave" seems unlikely considering the wealth of natural resources and high quality of living that the US offers.

We haven't really tried fixing the wealth gap since the Great Depression, so maybe it's time to give it another go.

Olreich··on Buy, Borrow, Die – Explained
Theft is illegally taking something. Taxes are part of the legal system. Literally not theft.

Ethically is it right to increase the risk to accumulate wealth? That depends on what you buy with that risk. It’s well-established that people will take risks for fun, and they’ll take significantly more risk when security for themselves and their family is on the line.

Folks with hundreds of millions or billions in assets or millions in income have vastly higher levels of security compared to folks with $100 in the bank and a $15/hr job with no benefits.

So, how much is it ethical to take from the rich to ensure that the poor have decent odds to improve their situation and have a basic level of security? In America, it’s been as much as 60% in income taxes for the highly-paid. A wealth tax of 40% upon death still exists, even if the rich have found a way around that. It sounds like America has already established that 40% taxed to the benefit of all is ethically okay.

So we should probably be killing the buy, borrow, die strategy of tax avoidance, especially on transfer taxes should be collected. But could we take more from the wealthiest and have that be ethically okay?

Let’s say we have someone with $300M in assets and those appreciate 8% annually on average. Those assets will be worth $600M in 10 years. Assuming a spend of $10M per year, they’d still be worth $400M by the end of 10 years. So we’ve had at least $100M generated compared to where we started just for existing and living a lavish life. But we could have taxed that $100M at 40% and put 40M into public services, infrastructure, or entrepreneurial grants to provide tens of thousands of people with more security without materially affecting our asset-owning individual. Even just distributing $40M to supplement incomes for low-security folks would translate to 2500+ people getting a chance to improve their situations.

So, is it ethical to tax the excess asset appreciation that the individual didn’t use for anything? It’s not that it didn’t grow, it’s that it grew a little less fast. And we were able to impact thousands based on that. I’d argue yes, and I struggle to understand how “make life no different for the individual vs make life better for thousands of people” comes down on the side of the individual. It’s not until taxes grow higher than appreciation that I start to think it might be unethical.

But as you approach taxes equaling appreciation, I can see how it could be counterproductive. I think that’s not the argument though. It wouldn’t be terribly difficult to tax assets based on appreciation above their highest appraisal, with appraisal triggering taxes being owed. Certainly no more complicated than our current taxes assets and the loopholes that lead to buy, borrow, die.

Olreich··on No "Hello", No "Quick Call", and No Meetings Without an Agenda
And replacing all slack threads with meetings is similarly non-productive. Making everything a slack thread and refusing to ever go to meetings is bad. But refusing to write anything down and forcing everyone to exclusively go to meetings is bad. So find the most effective through line. Most often that’s: 1. Slack message with enough context that someone can answer 2. Discuss on slack until it’s clear the topic is going to need 3+ people to decide on or is in need of higher bandwidth, such as a screen share or just is urgent enough that talking while moving would be faster 3. Hop on that quick call 4. When you realize you’re missing folks you need or whatever and it’s not urgent enough to drag them into the call, set up a full meeting

Nothing in the article contradicts the above flow, and the above flow is what works best in my experience

Olreich··on No "Hello", No "Quick Call", and No Meetings Without an Agenda
Innovation is about attention, not ideas. If you want to encourage that, you need to give folks a forum to share their ideas that they feel safe and supported. If your team is good at that in person at lunch, then having an “ideas” meeting with the folks who would be at lunch would work for that. If your team is bad at that, there’s likely some folks who don’t embrace the new ideas at your ideas forum and until you get them fixed, the folks with ideas aren’t going to bring them up for fear of looking dumb or whatever.

I’ve worked remotely and had a great time innovating, and I’ve been in person and had a terrible time innovating. It has always come back to giving folks a comfortable forum to share ideas and not rejecting them.

Olreich··on CEOs are running companies from afar even as workers return to office
Sounds like you need a group chat that people are willing to talk in. If that isn’t happening, then there’s a barrier to doing it that you need to resolve. Could be they’re fine with you listening in, but not the manager. Could be something else. Fix that, and get back to productive remotely.
Olreich··on Show HN: Voice bots with 500ms response times
Almost any gap in audio is detectable and sounds really bad. 40ms is a lot, but sending 40ms of silence is probably worse
Olreich··on How to test without mocking
At some point, you need to interact with something that looks like I/O or an external service. Not handling failures from them is a source of a lot of bugs.

Even if pushed to the periphery, how do you test the wrapper you built to hide these failures from the rest of your code base? If you don’t hide these failures in some wrapper, how do you test that your system handles them properly?

Olreich··on The Swift compiler is slow due to how types are inferred
Type checking is horribly slow in Swift if 59k things to check causes 30 seconds of slowdown. That would mean that on a 4ghz processor it requites more than 2 billion operations per check. That’s insane no matter how you slice it.
Olreich··on PEP 701 – Syntactic formalization of f-strings
Semantically, these say the same thing, so all of those concerns exist for “concat(a, b)” too. Avoiding having to parse the concat every time the line is invoked, avoiding having to apply runtime introspection to find out mapping between the variables and their locations, etc.
Olreich··on Being Healthy Enough to Retire
I want to be able to stably enjoy many years of working on whatever is of interest to me without needing to exchange money for it. So accumulating enough wealth for that is super reasonable. It looks like you don’t mind spending most of your time working for survival and pursuing your interests as fully as possible right now. That’s also a reasonable way to live.

These are just choices different people making different choices

Olreich··on Fewer people are buying electric cars in the US
Charging infrastructure and speed would mitigate that as well. Driving 3+ hours is going to cut it close on many combustion cars’ ranges too, but gas stations are ubiquitous and almost always have gas. When they don’t, you get the gas crises we’ve seen around the world when supply or delivery runs low.
Olreich··on A group of scientists set out to study quick learners. Then saw they don't exist
Math is the canonical one. You need arithmetic to get to algebra. You need algebra to get to geometry. You need geometry to get to calculus. Everything builds on each other, so you can’t skip to calculus when you barely know how to add.

There is a component of most domains where you figure out the fundamental building blocks and you can learn a bunch of different branches in any order without much overlap, but that’s usually after the initial mastery equivalent to math’s calculus.

Olreich··on Push ifs up and fors down
I’m close to giving up on dogmatic junior devs. They don’t ever seem to give up their dogma, even in the face of direct damage caused by their dogma. The closest I’ve seen is a dogmatic junior dev saying they understand and will relax on the dogma, but turning around and enforcing it when they think you aren’t looking.

I’ve seen dogmatic junior devs turn into dogmatic senior devs, but I’ve never seen a dogmatic junior dev turn into a pragmatic senior dev.

Olreich··on YouTube crackdown leads to ‘hundreds of thousands’ of ad blocker uninstalls
Ad marketplace is a hell of a thing. Advertisers want your specific demographic and they’ll pay to dollar compared to others. So you see 4 companies ads 1000 times
Olreich··on M3 Macs: there's more to performance than counting cores
Scaling based on node size has been limited for a long time. It feels like it started at 13nm that every shrink was getting less and less performance uplift, but it's likely it's been going on for longer and we just had much more room for improvement on chip design.
Olreich··on Why programming languages matter [video]
STM is about hardware, not programming languages, but is decently recent so maybe someone will actually try it in hardware and see if it provides a good benefit for the increased complexity of the chip.

Region based memory management was first conceived in 1967 and is achievable by any programming language that lets you manage memory yourself.

Mutable value semantics in native code have been available since at least 1980 with Ada.

Lifetimes in Cyclone seem the best example of PL research in the last 50 years you have there, as it’s only 20 years old.

Overall, I’m still unsure if this list proves the point that there is active useful research in the PL space or if it proves that there’s very little in the PL space to research. More research is probably required.

Olreich··on A small warning about UDP based protocols
I don't think skipping the handshake is much of a benefit to QUIC. TCP was designed to have long-lived connections. Mobile networks are moving toward keeping your external IP consistent between handoffs, handling the routing internally. Fixed networks will connect to servers once every couple of minutes at most. QUIC mostly affects time-to-first-paint, which is mostly of interest for the slowest connections, which is nice, but becoming less and less relevant over time. It's not like speeding up the connectivity time is going to matter when all gains in connectivity time will be used for additional advertising and tracking against the end-user.

The main value propositions of QUIC for me are in the encryption earlier in the connection and in the reduced infrastructure usage on the server side.

Olreich··on Cities Skylines 2 runs with 20fps on an Nvidia RTX4090
The speed of your simulation in a game like this should have minimal impact on the framerate of the game. You can paint the screen 144 times a second, but only tick the simulation 10 times a second and get a much better experience than painting the screen and updating the simulation 20 times a second. Maybe your city runs slowly, but you can still look around at the various bits moving slowly.
← PreviousPage 2 of 9Next →