HNHacker News
TopNewBestAskShowJobs

OmarShehata

1,448 karma · joined March 23, 2012

Graphics programmer. I like telling stories.

https://omarshehata.me/

submissionscomments
OmarShehata··on Does “building in public” work?
> Let's admit it, the main purpose of build in public is to attract attention and build a community

It's more like open sourcing your code. On one hand: yes, it's good marketing. On the other hand: you're creating positive externality, so random people show up, thank you for your contribution, and help you, monetarily, or by giving you valuable leads & feedback.

it's the same benefit of going to a conference & networking, just doing it continually. It's still useful even if everyone is doing it, because when someone stumbles on your work, they have an entry point/signal on whether there's mutual benefit in collaborating.

OmarShehata··on Washington Post collecting TikTok user data from its followers for public good
Direct link to the WaPo page: https://thewashingtonpost.formstack.com/forms/help_investiga...

Post from 2 days ago about users collecting their own Twitter user data: https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=41581923

(A WaPo data journalist on twitter is soliciting ideas/feedback for what questions users have to explore with this dataset. They have 800 users/watch history on 55 million videos so far..I think it's awesome, involving the public in efforts to study the public)

OmarShehata··on What Happened To: "In Search of Excellence"?
This is a good article that answers this question: https://www.furia.com/page.cgi?type=log&id=473

> This is problematic, clearly. A company needs to be able to treat its employees as interchangeable and expendable, both individually and collectively. It needs to be able to periodically layoff 17% of its workforce to cut its margin overhead by 1% and temporarily boost its stock price by 5%, without having to endure existential upheaval to its ongoing business processes.

as for the solution: basically I think the people who CAN be better managers keep saying, "oh I hate working with people, I'd rather code" and hence you're left with a very specific subset of managers.

> everybody is better off if companies ignore this caution with the same exuberant disregard as people doing their jobs with inadvisable devotion. The most transformational human ideas begin in individual hearts, whatever gantlets of brainstorming and strategic opportunity-analysis they subsequently have to run. Spotify was more right, I think, to tolerate my curiosities and experiments for 10 years than they were to finally give up on them out of exasperation or ignorance.

OmarShehata··on Twitter shut off API access; users volunteering their own data for an open API
Here is the washington post doing this with TikTok users to reverse engineer the algorithm!! https://thewashingtonpost.formstack.com/forms/help_investiga...

they've got data from 800 users so far, with watch data on 55 million videos

OmarShehata··on Twitter shut off API access; users volunteering their own data for an open API
Alternatively, build a private invite only dataset of specific communities. Scale horizontally instead of having one single central dataset! That's still a huge win for user ownership.

It doesn't have to be one company controlling who gets access, the users can decide this

OmarShehata··on Twitter shut off API access; users volunteering their own data for an open API
A lot of users/communities are stuck because of network effects & the long history of posts (they still reference them, like living wikis)

These pipeline tools can help people migrate if they want without losing that history & network (my prediction is once people see what's possible with an open API, that'll further motivate user migration, or for twitter to open up again)

OmarShehata··on Twitter shut off API access; users volunteering their own data for an open API
feedback is very much needed
OmarShehata··on The expected value of the game is positive regardless of Ballmer’s strategy
is it? If I was forced to ask this question as an interviewer, and the candidate said, "actually, you're wrong, here's why" that's a very good signal. Do most people not do this?

(typically there's discussion with all the interviewers and it isn't just "did the candidate get the question right or not). I personally think a lot of big tech interview questions are dumb but I think the process isn't as broken as I thought, seeing it from both sides.

OmarShehata··on Is My Blue Your Blue?
Is the data collected by this open? Would absolutely love to take a peek/contribute to analyzing it

(I'm trying to do similar experiments like this myself and I think it would be great if the data is published and we can like, reproduce each other's work/explore variants etc)

OmarShehata··on Best ad I've ever seen (half fiction / half true)
This is a narrative about our world, written from the perspective of a future historian. Everything falls into one of 3 categories:

predictions (what author thinks will happen) history (has already happened) retro-predictions (wrote as prediction but readers pointed out has happened)

the article contains "an answer key" at the end

OmarShehata··on Fixing a bug in Google Chrome as a first-time contributor
yes if the standard practice on the codebase is to include tests, the maintainers will ask for tests

if the author doesn't want to do it, the PR will likely remain abandoned unless an external contributor comes along to finish it, or a maintainer takes over.

OmarShehata··on I am starting an AI+Education company
> Most learners, the world over, are not self-motivated

this seems like a bizarre conclusion. In my experience, most people, the world over, are in fact self motivated. You won't see that if you have a very narrow definition of what is it that they're supposed to be learning

kids aren't motivated to do boring math drills, because they don't see why it matters to their life (the real answer is: it does not, they are not wrong).

I appreciated hearing this echoed by Conrad Wolfram in a recent PIMA episode: https://freakonomics.com/podcast/why-do-we-still-teach-peopl...

OmarShehata··on Let's stop counting centuries
> Citation heavily needed

I'm not going to give you any proof of this, because I know you've seen it, but I think I just wasn't very clear on what I meant here.

I'm talking about PRs that fix a typo in the docs, or tweak confusing wording. You know the ones I'm talking about, the ones that get merged immediately because it's clearly just better

OmarShehata··on Let's stop counting centuries
"the current practice may not be perfect but has obviously stood the test of time"

has it stood the test of time? or is just an arbitrary choice that no one has bothered to change?

I'm sorry, it just seems like we're looking at spilled milk in the middle of the room saying, "well, it's been here since I walked into the room, obviously it's supposed to be here?" no we can just clean it up, no one's going to stop you

it's actually super, super easy to change this: you just starting using the new term. You don't even need to get anyone else on board, everyone understands what the new term means (this isn't even like inventing a new word, it's just a rephrasing that's just easier for the speaker & listener).

The goal isn't to get everyone to switch overnight. That's not how conventions are created nor how they spread. You just start doing the thing if it's useful to you. Whether it spreads beyond that is not up to you.

My takeaway from the post is simply: hey, if you find this confusing, here's a much simpler way you can talk about it! I am personally going to start using this, and I am going to get immediate benefits from this, and so are my readers. That's it, that's all it takes.

OmarShehata··on Let's stop counting centuries
small issues are easy to solve!

I think it isn't as sexy/interesting as what I thought the article was going to be about (about a different way of talking about our history, in eras maybe vs centuries or something).

this strikes me as kind of like a small PR to our language that makes an incremental improvement to a clearly confusing thing. Should be easy to merge :)

OmarShehata··on Show HN: I made a puzzle game that gently introduces my favorite math mysteries
I love this! I'd for this to be a more typical experience in math class

(I bought Paul Lockhart's "measurements" but gave up because I felt like I needed a sandbox to play with and little hints. Like, I don't want to be told the answer but I want to know feedback exactly like this demo. Very simple: "this is not right" or "this is right, but can be done with fewer")

(My dream is to have a little game jam where we make interactive versions of these concepts as puzzle)

OmarShehata··on Bouba/kiki effect
this implies that humans have an intuitive sense of the shape of the waveform, which I think would be surprising!! And also empirically testable

(not saying you're wrong, but it's not necessarily obvious to me as true. The sound is a vibration/signal, how our brains interpret it may have no correlation to its "shape". Do we have an intuition for "spiky" electromagnetic signals? maybe we do, that's why looking at nature, smooth curves and such, is empirically more relaxing for people than artificial environments..?)

OmarShehata··on Do not try to be the smartest in the room; try to be the kindest
fun experiment: let's try to have the most charitable interpretation of this comment ^

My best is: they are saying it is worth taking a step back and making a prioritized list of our values. If we do this, we may place "being kind" over "being productive"

I think their warning here is about: what happens in a situation where being kind is NOT productive? Will you just drop it?

I think I agree with the broad strokes of this. My rebuttal is: the comment above this was just pointing out, for people who do not value kindness over productivity, that they are not in opposition. That you don't have to pick one or the other. You can have both.

We can get mad and turn away from people who do not share our values/priorities. Or we can show them ways that our value systems do not clash and it can be win win

OmarShehata··on Data-fueled neurotargeting could kill democracy
> they understand, from centuries of experience, that provoking strong emotional responses is one of the most reliable ways to get people to change their behavior

this is easily defeated by teaching everyone a sprinkle of meditation (it has been quite shocking to me the extent to which I'd have an emotional reaction -> rationalized argument -> action, even over things like, slack messages from coworkers/my manager. I used to think it was always rational thought -> action. But noticing this makes it very easy to alter the pattern)

now I want to see a response article: "Meditation will save democracy"

OmarShehata··on Feynman’s Razor
Quanta is a great example! They don't dumb things down. It passes feymans razor because the professor can read it and know what it's talking about

I think it'd be a fun follow-up and talk a quanta article, and some PhD in the topic, and walk through why it does (or does not) pass this razor.

I think one very simple but important thing they do is they don't shy away from mentioning the technical terms. I just opened a random one and in the first paragraph they say the word "Hamiltonian cycle", and explain it. The explanation is probably super simplified, but that's fine, it's (1) an anchor for the curious layperson to read more/Google it (2) it's a marker for the expert, he immediately knows what they're talking about, and doesn't have to try to reconstruct it/guess

OmarShehata··on Extracting concepts from GPT-4
This is super cool, it feels like going in the direction of the "deep"/high level type of semantic searching I've been waiting for. I like their examples of basically filtering documents for the "concept" of price increases, or even something as high level as a rhetorical question

I wonder how this compares to training/fine tuning a model on examples of rhetorical questions and asking it to find it in a given document. This is maybe faster/more accurate? Since it involves just looking at neural network activation, vs running it with input and having it generate an answer...?

OmarShehata··on This Message Does Not Exist
> And then cease being a non-technical user

I'm glad you said this because Feynman has a beautiful response to it: basically, there is no such thing as a "non-technical user". Almost everyone is adept at navigating _some_ complex system in their life. I agree with you that they probably don't want to learn.

but the reason they don't want to learn is because they don't think there is any value on it, they believe it is a waste of time. For the same reason I (used to) believe it's a waste of time for me to play puzzle games (I'm bad at it, I don't enjoy it, what's the point). Or learn to manage people, or learn to understand politics, etc.

I'm asking you (and everyone reading this) to suspend disbelief and pretend that these users DO have capacity to learn, and they just don't see any value in it, and it's on us to clearly (and concisely) communicate the value without gatekeeping and without dumbing it down. I have been surprised at how people's capacity to learn was much greater than I expected, and I hope the same will be true for you.

I see this attitude a lot of, "well, if you want to understand how this system works, we have to start from scratch" (and they start to lecture for hours about some fundamental things). I think this is a failure mode: an inability to figure out _what_ fundamental pieces actually matter to understanding the current system.

Apologies for the rant, I feel strongly about this because I think there's a lot of low hanging fruit here that everyone can benefit from, but I'm still trying to refine my thoughts.

i tried to write about this here: https://omarshehata.substack.com/p/my-favorite-1980s-canadia...

OmarShehata··on This Message Does Not Exist
this is the only correct answer. "a non-technical user has no idea what a server or cache is" sure, but they can learn. The average person is much smarter than you think they are (when it comes to matters that actually affect their day to day life). If they don't get your explanation, it's almost always because (1) they don't care, they don't see why it matters to them (it often doesn't) (2) you're not explaining it well enough

feynman has a nice philosophy on this that I think is true & useful: (that there's great variety in capability of the average person, we should explain things faithfully & without dumbing it down):

https://mastodon.gamedev.place/@omarshehata/1123783593602927...

OmarShehata··on Examplar: A better way to teach programming (make students make the examples)
They talk about how the difficulty in teaching is in knowing what the students know. But just asking them doesn't give us enough information:

> So we have the kernel of a good idea—asking students to read back their understanding—but words are a poor medium for it.

Their solution, of making students come up with examples, basically serves to map out their understanding and whether they are falling into common misconceptions

> we think of Examplar as performing what we call conceptual mutation testing: we only want to make sure they have the right conception of the problem, and avoid misconceptions about it.

This seems really powerful to me. In some ways it's like test driven development. In another way, it's like going into reading a complex article with a list of guiding questions, mapping out what you think the article is saying, and having a system (either automated or a human teacher) correct you/guide you in the right direction

OmarShehata··on OpenAI No Longer Takes Safety Seriously
You might enjoy this article (https://aisafety.dance/)

the section: "No, AI Safety isn't a fringe concern by sci-fi weebs"

> AI Safety / AI Risk used to be less mainstream, but now in 2024, the US & UK governments now have AI Safety-specific departments![10]10 This resulted from many of the top AI researchers raising alarm bells about it. These folks include: > Geoffrey Hinton and Yoshua Bengio > Stuart Russell and Peter Norvig > Paul Christiano

> I'm aware "look at these experts" is an appeal to authority, but this is only to counter the idea of, "eh, only sci-fi weebs fear AI Risk". But in the end, appeal to authority/weebs isn't enough; you have to actually understand the dang thing. (Which you are doing, by reading this! So thank you.)

OmarShehata··on Ambitious but at peace
> your network will not have a jump start on everyone else

I think this is not the most useful frame. You don't necessarily need to outcompete people for limited spots (I think a lot of people's definition of success or greatness is very narrow, and mostly informed by what others are vying for)

I think the bar for doing something great is shockingly low, most people aren't even trying. That's the impression I get every time I read a patio11 article (most recently the super long but worth it "story of vaccinate CA" [1]. This is not patio but same vibe, "Lies, Damned Lies, and Manometer Readings" [2]). My takeaway from these is that there are big problems in society that nobody is working on.

This is kind of a good thing for ambitious folks: everywhere you look there are problems everywhere, the bar for making something better than what is there is low. I think the network & support is critical but it isn't always given. I think great things happen when we start to move towards what we are capable of fixing, what is within our control, finding others who have that attitude and supporting each other.

I think for me now, the point isn't to outcompete everyone/make it to the top 1% or whatnot, it's to make it as far as is possible with what I have. Those two approaches are identical if you have the support to reach the 1%. But if not, why worry about what is outside of my control? I have plenty within my control in the menatime.

[1] https://worksinprogress.co/issue/the-story-of-vaccinateca/ [2] https://asteriskmag.com/issues/05/lies-damned-lies-and-manom...

OmarShehata··on Ambitious but at peace
Can you add more detail here? What is your prediction? That they will (1) change their mind and not be at peace, because this feeling doesn't last or (2) they will not accomplish much because ambition is not compatible with being satisfied?

(this is my wild guess based on the tone of your post, just trying to understand it)

OmarShehata··on Embeddings are a good starting point for the AI curious app developer
Are you saying it's pure chance that operations like "man - woman" = "king - queen" (and many, many other similar relationships and analogies) work?

If not please explain this comment to those of us ignorant in these matters :)

OmarShehata··on This is a teenager
It's not clear but I think what it's signaling is a progressive ideal of taking ownership over the collective good / a rehabilitation mindset towards crime vs a punishment, based on the following that's meant to get the viewer to empathize with "failure" as an adult is due to factors beyond just personal responsibility.

> When we're young, we have so little control over their lives [...] Then we turn 18 and we're expected to be "adults" and figure things out. > > If we fail, we are punished. > > We are blamed for not going to college [...]

OmarShehata··on Show HN: Building a GPS receiver
absolutely, and most people do! I encourage you to go around asking your friends and family this question (without judgement, and see if you can prod them along to the right answer on their own!) i think the world is better when the average person has a more accurate understanding of the tools they use

(and contrary to popular belief, I think the average person is interested in understanding this, they're more motivated to understand things that actually matter to them, that are in their hands every day. A lot just have an emotional aversion to math due to bad school experiences, but they are genuinely curious)

← PreviousPage 2 of 7Next →