HNHacker News
TopNewBestAskShowJobs

OmarShehata

1,448 karma · joined March 23, 2012

Graphics programmer. I like telling stories.

https://omarshehata.me/

submissionscomments
OmarShehata··on A journey into the shaken baby syndrome/abusive head trauma controversy
> A system that does not incarcerate anyone for any reason would be much preferable

surely you don't actually believe that? I don't think the result of this is just 0 false positives. The result of that is a lot more crime, and a lot more injustice.

OmarShehata··on My solopreneur story
One the flipside here, you can argue that, every time you get another "1", this is great for the economy. You now have someone who's making their own money, leaving a salaried job spot open for another person.

A lot of these indie hacking ventures probably wouldn't exist at all if the person making them decided not to. If that is, or for the subset of indie hacking companies for which it is true, it means this is growing the economy.

OmarShehata··on My solopreneur story
There are two ways of approach entrepreneurship, and the conflict between each is why there's some dissonance here:

1) Do it to escape the grind, as one commenter here mentioned. In this way, it doesn't matter what product you make, or how you make it. The goal is self sufficiency, to find a niche that you can fill, etc.

2) Do it because you're trying to effect some specific change in the world. Something doesn't exist yet, so you will go out and make it happen.

"2" is much harder, and more rare. And, if you believe 2 is the way, then it makes sense to NOT start a company & instead join an existing effort, if there are already people working on pressing problems & you have the skills to help them out.

For "1", it almost always makes sense to start a company if you can. Because that life & amenities is itself the goal.

OmarShehata··on Breakfast cereal is in long-term decline
This is really interesting because I can see intense pushback against suggesting the government do this in the US (unless "nutriscore" is a private 3rd party score, not the gov?)

I think no one would _really_ object to labelling like oatmeal healthier than chips. The issue would be along the thresholds, when a product gets a B and its competitor gets an A. I can see wanting to dispute that decision, or claims of corruption to skew the ratings in favor of certain companies etc.

OmarShehata··on FindMyCat – Open-Source Pet Tracker
> Obviously that trick does not work if you want to know where the animal is live, it can only tell you where it has been once you have processed the data.

why can't you just forward those radio samples back, and process that on the receiver end (your phone), vs processing on device and sending back the location?

It should be a tradeoff of less battery consumption on device, and no need for large storage, at the expense of a lot more bandwidth? Would having to send all the raw samples consume more or less battery than just processing it and sending the result?

OmarShehata··on Interactive Map of Linux Kernel
One UX feedback: it's very hard to navigate the map when links open if you happen to pan over one. Instead, if JS is supported, links should open on click vs on release. (maybe there's a way to do it without JS too?)
OmarShehata··on LÖVE: a framework to make 2D games in Lua
I made one of the first big commercially successful games with with LÖVE (Move or Die - https://moveordiegame.com/). Highly enjoyed it.

We had a devblog, doesn't exist anymore unfortunately. The thing I enjoyed the most was the flexibility of Lua, and the whole framework seemed to adopt that mindset. It gave you all the core pieces you need it (audio, input, physics, rendering), and then got out of your way.

The drawback to the full flexibility is having to spend time thinking about what design & workflow your wanted (but, really, wasn't a drawback, that's what I wanted, just took more time). We ended up designing a really flexible engine that allowed us to pivot from a 2D puzzle platformer with a story (Concerned Joe) to the action packed fast multiplayer game that Move or Die became.

OmarShehata··on Apple vs. Meta: The Illusion of Privacy
The industry is still struggling to track who's clicking on ads properly in all cases...we're very far from this idea of tracking cash purchases & building a profile with facial recognition. This sounds like science fiction. Are there any companies actually doing anything like this?

Closest thing I know is companies who sell "foot traffic" data, of who walks in front of your store. But that's done with phones pinging wifi networks passively as you walk, not anything as fancy as facial recognition.

Example: https://grapeseedmedia.com/blog/foot-traffic-data/

OmarShehata··on X/Twitter has updated its terms of service to let it use posts for AI training
I'd like someone to address this. Surely there's a limit. The statement "your account balance belongs to Twitter" is not against the law (like they can say the service is worth whatever amount of money and that you owe them this money), but you're not allowed to do that, because you're not allowed to retroactively change a contract's terms.

So, surely, you can't change ToS retroactively and expect that any of it applies?

OmarShehata··on When your coworker does great work, tell their manager (2020)
It's manipulative only if there really is no redeeming quality to their approach, which, in any realistic scenario there probably is.

I interpret this as, not that you should lie, you should just NOT focus 100% on the negative aspect. At the very least you can thank them for taking the time & effort to implement this solution & test it or w/e (I assume they did "some" work & put in some amount of well meaning effort).

If I can't genuinely find anything to praise about something I want to criticism, it's a sign that it's pretty bad (or I have a bad working relationship with this person) and that is a bigger, separate problem

OmarShehata··on I raced a homing pigeon against the Internet [video]
This isn't very uncommon in geospatial companies, where data is often hundreds of terabytes. I remember there was open government data you could request from USGS (high res satellite imagery of all of the US), it was technically free, but you couldn't download it. You requested it, filled out a form, and they shipped you 4-5 drives with bubblewrap.
OmarShehata··on The WordPress 100 Year Plan
Now that you mention it, it seems quite clever. This seems to be targeted at people who run businesses, who already spend a lot of time & money thinking about their estate & leaving it in a good state for their children to inherit. I wonder if the price point was figured out based on that (like as long as it's ballpark similar to paying attorney or whatever to provide this service for your house & business, then it makes sense to pay something similar for your digital wordpress assets)
OmarShehata··on How to Solve It (1945)
What do you mean by "hacked"? It's just an old domain that's expired and now redirects to the hosting website. Nothing nefarious going on.

Here's the original, which does indeed have a translation as one would expect: https://web.archive.org/web/20111005170154/http://webhosting...

OmarShehata··on Is this a good book for me, now?
I relate to a lot of this! I have had a similar transformation. I think it's really important and changes practically how you read books. It frees you from this "I need to read these books that X said transformed their life".

But also, the small things like, you can just skip a section, or drop a book. If it's not working for you, then powering through it isn't necessarily going to make it better. But also this mindset has allowed me to re-read books, knowing that the "me" is different and I might get something new out of it.

I once read an HN comment a long time ago saying "why would you ever re-read books? You already have this knowledge. Seems like a complete waste of time" and I couldn't disagree more, but had trouble articulating why. Next time I will link to this post!

OmarShehata··on A brief glimpse at recent events in Egypt
Not a typo! This was my source: https://www.timedoctor.com/blog/average-salary-in-egypt/

Also, that's not even like necessarily poor. A software engineer in Alexandria (2nd biggest city after Cairo) makes $5k annually (according to this https://www.levels.fyi/t/software-engineer/locations/alexand...) and that matches my experience (from people I knew who worked in egypt ~5 years ago, adjusting a bit for inflation).

Rent in a good apartment in a good part of town would be $160-ish a month.

OmarShehata··on Pixar, Adobe, Apple, Autodesk, and Nvidia form alliance for OpenUSD
What about glTF?
OmarShehata··on Flash Museum
Newgrounds just hosted a "Flash Forward Jam" recently where people did just that!

https://www.newgrounds.com/bbs/topic/1517301

Results are here: https://www.newgrounds.com/collection/flashforward2023

OmarShehata··on I Am Leaving
I think this sentiment underplays how useful casual acquaintances are, on their own but more importantly as a step towards forming those strong bonds in the first place.

As an adult, how do you make the strong bonds that lead to people going out of their way to remember to invite you to things? Maybe you meet someone and click immediately, more likely it's someone you know from work, and commonly it's acquaintances from seemingly superficial activities that become close friends after you're mingled and mixed with enough folks to find your tribe.

"everyone complains about group chats being noisy" but there's a good reason they're still in there (obviously a big part of it is fomo but it's not obvious to me that everyone's lives would be better rejecting them. Human social dynamics are messy and not efficient).

OmarShehata··on Bret Victor update
I've echoed this sentiment from time to time and someone recently asked me "Why don't you just disconnect and apologize later?"

Might not work for you, but I found this surprisingly liberating: allowing myself to just drop the ball, not respond, or just say "Sorry I can't" with no justification, so I can focus my energy where I need it

OmarShehata··on Orca rams into yacht near Scotland, suggesting the behavior may be spreading
There are videos of it, and lots of people have seen it, not sure how much more proof you need:

> An optical spectrum of what appears to have been a ball lightning event was published in January 2014 and included a video at high frame rate

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=1bBNeyrMOJE

I think what that sentence is saying is that we don't know how to reproduce it in a lab. We don't know what exactly is happening in the real world that is causing us to perceive this. It could be an illusion I guess, but I think it's undisputed it's a real phenomenon.

OmarShehata··on Making Games
I think the hard part is the initial phase, before you know how to make things move, how to draw to the screen, how to handle multiple states of multiple objects without the code getting incredibly messy and unmaintainable etc. If I had to guess I'd say your brother spent a lot of time building many little things before getting to a point where he can quickly build a basic prototype of any game he saw.
OmarShehata··on Mistakes to avoid to build a better 1-person business
> The problem with this advice is that it's not any advice

It sounds like very good advice, or rather, information. If I believe this, a few decisions I might make are: (1) spend more time networking, and following up with people I've met, whether at conferences or local events, even if they are outside (2) recognize I have a handicap if I am not a social butterfly and think about ways to counteract it (or realize this as another factor working against me and decide not to start a business)

I don't think you need to be a social butterfly to have a large network. I think you just have to show up to a lot of things. Which might feel like wasted time if you don't frame it this way.

OmarShehata··on Most tech content is bullshit (2020)
I am completely baffled by this comment. You're saying the _juniors_ are creating overly complicated modern frameworks, or are the ones pushing it?? It's clearly the opposite in my opinion. Big companies/teams are releasing tools that may work well for their scale but are overkill for most, and they're championing them as good solutions for everybody, and juniors are the force working in the opposite direction (trying to simplify/untangle all this complexity, they don't have the experience to recognize if it's overkill. They also want to get hired at all the companies that use these tools so they have to learn it).
OmarShehata··on Most tech content is bullshit (2020)
> Spam from junior devs who started a blog so to build a name for themselves.

I often find this is the most useful category out of the 5 you listed. Junior devs writing something like "How to setup webpack" often explain things in plain words and just spell out how to get the thing working. There's humility to the post like "I don't know what all these options do, but this is what worked for me".

I find that a lot more honest/useful than say category 5 there where I have no idea if what they're talking about will actually work for me or how much effort it's going to take to integrate because the assumption there is you have big teams who can spend all their time maintaining these tools.

OmarShehata··on The “smolnet”, build for friends and friends of friends
Yes, this is just a wiki about small communities. I guess one of the problems of small communities is that you probably can't just one that's advertised since it'll likely be full, so you have to make your own or get invited to one.
OmarShehata··on Lawyer who used ChatGPT faces penalty for made up citations
This is not an unreasonable mental model. You can ask ChatGPT to give you a program, ask it "is this correct?" and it'll find and fix bugs. To a layperson it looks like it is capable of double checking its work and finding an error. Why would it be any different here?

(the answer of course that the LLM doesn't actually search the internet and/or doesn't have access to a law database it can query)

OmarShehata··on Child Labor Is on the Rise
> Having a job is a moral obligation and making kids work is good for them.

The second part of this sentence is not obviously false to me. Kids working exploitative & dangerous jobs, yes that's bad. Kids being allowed to work in general, I think is good.

I like Simon Sarris's take on this, from:

https://simonsarris.substack.com/p/the-most-precious-resourc...

> I find it striking just how early, and how varied, the avenues were that allowed one to pivot off-script, to do something differently than everyone else. For a 13 year old today, what is the equivalent of being a telegraph office boy, where he can learn technology while contributing? What about for a 16 year old? 21 year old? What is today’s equivalent to being a studio apprentice of Verrocchio?

OmarShehata··on Ask HN: Did Anyone Else Here Simply Not Do Well at School?
I appreciate you bringing this up. I myself suffered from this type of thinking: "if I am struggling with something, that must mean I am not good at it, and shouldn't waste time on it". The idea that you need to struggle a bit, get better at things little by little, look at how much progress you've making over time and then decide whether it's for you or not I think is much healthier thinking
OmarShehata··on Intelligent Brains Take Longer to Solve Difficult Problems
Not the OP but I would say: yes exactly. A culture where you only see team members presenting ideas in their done state leads to overall worse solutions because people aren't collaborating & giving each other feedback on ideas-in-progress.
OmarShehata··on Writing summaries is more important than reading more books
I had a similar reaction to a lot of the language in this post, but I think there's something to it here that is still valuable even for just the joy of reading.

For me it's important that I am paying attention as I read. I used to rarely re-read books, and have started re-reading my favorite ones, and it's often surprising to me how many interesting ideas I missed, or maybe just forgot about. I enjoy talking to friends about books too and I find that helps me explore the ideas more deeply. I've recently started trying writing up my takeaways for books I've enjoyed, partially as something to send friends to talk about with or try convince them to read the book too so we can talk about it.

I think the caveat here is that it's totally valid to not do any of these things if you are enjoying whatever process you have. I just appreciate being exposed to this idea because it's increased my enjoyment of my own reading.

← PreviousPage 4 of 7Next →