HNHacker News
TopNewBestAskShowJobs

OmicronCeti

235 karma · joined December 21, 2020

submissionscomments
OmicronCeti··on A Recap of the Mars Terraforming Debate
The person you're replying to stated elsewhere that they don't believe in the conservation of energy, so (ironically) save yourself the energy of arguing with them.
OmicronCeti··on A Recap of the Mars Terraforming Debate
What are you talking about? People have lived in Tibet for 20,000+ years?
OmicronCeti··on A Recap of the Mars Terraforming Debate
You mean add graffiti to my beloved red rocks? Blasphemy.
OmicronCeti··on A Recap of the Mars Terraforming Debate
None besides Earth.
OmicronCeti··on A Recap of the Mars Terraforming Debate
We use the rare Martian mineral handwavium
OmicronCeti··on A Recap of the Mars Terraforming Debate
Navigation is irrelevant to the space flight argument though, we know how to navigate between planets and stars (in theory). Speed is the limiting factor.
OmicronCeti··on A Recap of the Mars Terraforming Debate
> I don't think we would collapse all plant life.

I mean it's not really about what you think. See the top two links here about the devastating effects of small-scale conflicts

- https://doi.org/10.1038/d41586-020-00794-y

- https://doi.org/10.1073/pnas.1919049117

- https://doi.org/10.1126/science.222.4630.1283

- https://doi.org/10.1029/2019JD030509

- https://doi.org/10.1080/03036758.1986.10423349

- https://doi.org/10.1029/2006JD008235

OmicronCeti··on A Recap of the Mars Terraforming Debate
From the paper in the article:

>"MAVEN has observed the Martian upper atmosphere for a full Martian year, and has determined the rate of loss of gas to space and the driving processes; 1–2 kg/s of gas are being lost."

https://www.sciencedirect.com/science/article/pii/S001910351...

OmicronCeti··on A Recap of the Mars Terraforming Debate
From the paper in the article:

>"MAVEN has observed the Martian upper atmosphere for a full Martian year, and has determined the rate of loss of gas to space and the driving processes; 1–2 kg/s of gas are being lost."

https://www.sciencedirect.com/science/article/pii/S001910351...

OmicronCeti··on A Recap of the Mars Terraforming Debate
From the paper in the article:

>"MAVEN has observed the Martian upper atmosphere for a full Martian year, and has determined the rate of loss of gas to space and the driving processes; 1–2 kg/s of gas are being lost."

https://www.sciencedirect.com/science/article/pii/S001910351...

OmicronCeti··on A Recap of the Mars Terraforming Debate
Perhaps that's the end-game for lord Musk's Boring Company
OmicronCeti··on A Recap of the Mars Terraforming Debate
I can't believe I'm entertaining a reply, but how would a human-invented lifeform sent to the stars carry on human society if it is a) not human, and b) light years spatially distance and thousands of years temporally distant?

This reads like an ungrad astronomy major fever dream.

OmicronCeti··on A Recap of the Mars Terraforming Debate
I said this elsewhere in this thread, but I study surface processes on Mars, so to me the planet is still alive and active. Things change, mysteries unfold, new environmental conditions come and go.

I'm sure you wouldn't object to national parks or wilderness areas, it's just that in the case of Mars there is no (known) life. How much each of us values the presence of life will differ, but in my view it's worth preserving Mars.

OmicronCeti··on A Recap of the Mars Terraforming Debate
What were the order of magnitude speed developments in seafaring before 1800? I'm not familiar with the topic.
OmicronCeti··on A Recap of the Mars Terraforming Debate
The collapse of all plant life would mean the death of humans. Nuclear winter is a well-studied and modeled phenomenon.
OmicronCeti··on A Recap of the Mars Terraforming Debate
I totally accept extinction. It's natural. Homo sapiens will burn bright and briefly, and the planets will continue to spin. I would argue that it would be much more worthwhile to spend money improving Earth for humans while we can, than dumping trillions of dollars into spaceflight (which I say unironically as someone who is currently paid by NASA).

>Space development shows how to thrive WITHOUT fossil fuels.

Not sure how that's the case given the staggering emissions of Falcon 9 for example.

OmicronCeti··on A Recap of the Mars Terraforming Debate
'we' did not go to Mars, 'we' did not go to pluto. We sent cameras with walky-talkies. That is so vastly different than sending people to the moon, that it's not really something we can disagree on in good faith.

If you truly do not believe in the conservation of energy, I think we're done here since none of my arguments will be good enough for such wild speculation.

OmicronCeti··on A Recap of the Mars Terraforming Debate
I see it as littering, we'll all be dead in 100 years so what does it matter if I toss my trash into the bushes?
OmicronCeti··on A Recap of the Mars Terraforming Debate
Seems a little grandiose considering its just a comment on HN.
OmicronCeti··on A Recap of the Mars Terraforming Debate
I think the disconnect here is between potential and probable. Humanity likely has the potential for interstellar travel, but our nature will prevent it in my opinion. Homo sapiens have twice come to the edge of nuclear oblivion already (being saved only by luck essentially), and I would wager we are are speeding much faster towards nuking each other than reaching the stars.
OmicronCeti··on A Recap of the Mars Terraforming Debate
The distance to the moon and Mars is absolutely trivial compared to even the closest star: to Mars is 0.0007% of the way to Alpha Centauri.

>We got to the moon, Mars, and several other solar system bodies

You're conflating humans and probes, which are vastly different.

OmicronCeti··on A Recap of the Mars Terraforming Debate
We simply exploited fossil fuels.

You are extremely optimistic about having several hundred million years left on Earth, when the longest living hominid existed for only ~2 million years.

I firmly believe that homo sapiens will self-destruct long before that point, as we have greatly overstressed the planet in only 200,000 years, mostly in the last 200.

OmicronCeti··on A Recap of the Mars Terraforming Debate
There is model for flight on Earth: birds. Humans achieved a similar feat through mimicry and the use of fossil fuels. There is no model for instellar transit. I am not optimistic that we can develop a technology that can speed transport between stars to such a degree before we destroy ourselves like every other hominid that has ever existed.
OmicronCeti··on A Recap of the Mars Terraforming Debate
As the commentor below stated, I do not believe humans will colonize anything but our own solar system. Things are simply too far away, even assuming there is some breakthrough that speeds up travel by two or three orders of magnitude.
OmicronCeti··on A Recap of the Mars Terraforming Debate
I see no point to it. As another commentor mentioned below, humanity is unlikely to travel to another star system. To me, terraforming Mars is like going camping in your backyard. It's different, it's harder, fun, but ultimately has no real purpose. Mars is more likely to be colonized for exploitation of its resources than as some utopian egalitarian human endeavor. To me that would be a shame. I would like to see it preserved more or less as-is as a record of its own history.
OmicronCeti··on A Recap of the Mars Terraforming Debate
Are you referring to the sun going supernova? I'm not familiar with the luminosity increase.
OmicronCeti··on A Recap of the Mars Terraforming Debate
Guess pristine is subjective. I study surface processes on Mars so to me the planet is still alive and active. Things change, mysteries unfold, new environmental conditions come and go.
OmicronCeti··on A Recap of the Mars Terraforming Debate
This piece from the NYT suggests that Siberia may be the new frontier: https://www.nytimes.com/interactive/2020/12/16/magazine/russ...
OmicronCeti··on A Recap of the Mars Terraforming Debate
Are you arguing that the surface area is too small or too inhospitable? What does the development of those areas have to do with Mars?
OmicronCeti··on A Recap of the Mars Terraforming Debate
I would conclude the opposite. If in fact Earth requires terraforming, that would be the strongest possible argument against any human influence on other planets. Our current irresponsibility should be proof in and of itself that we should not try. To me it feels deeply wrong to use Mars as some sort of testing ground when it is currently pristine.

Also, with a rich and privileged life raft available on Mars, there is no incentive to preserve the world we have now. Elysium comes to mind.

← PreviousPage 2 of 3Next →