HNHacker News
TopNewBestAskShowJobs

Oxitendwe

291 karma · joined August 14, 2016

submissionscomments
Oxitendwe··on The End of the DreamHost vs. DOJ privacy case
It makes no sense to talk about means without ends.
Oxitendwe··on Using Binary Diffing to Discover Windows Kernel Memory Disclosure Bugs
It is one of the greatest failings of our industry that we are apparently incapable of constructing programs that are in any sense "complete" due to requiring vast amounts of upkeep just to ensure their most basic possible property: that their semantics are defined completely by their source code and not inputs (as is not the case with programs containing remote code execution or escaping bugs like SQL injections, XSS, etc). This constant upkeep not only has an enormous cost in terms of time spent modifying these programs to move them asymptotically closer to a version with clearly defined semantics, but (unlike other classes of bugs which involve incorrect behavior that do not have implications for security) produce an air of mistrust and a general malaise and lack of confidence in all software.

One direct implication of this fact, for programs which must be constantly updated to fix their security flaws, is that because the only semblance of trust and security you can obtain in using this software comes from its popularity and reputation (because these things generally mean a large amount of resources can be spent auditing and testing ("many eyes make all bugs shallow"), and because a large userbase means that any bugs found will be more valuable and more difficult to find, and thus less likely to be used against people who are not profitable to be hacked, which is most people), viably forking large projects becomes impossible without a similar or proportional amount of resources to the original project. Without that, having confidence in the new project becomes much more difficult, because you cannot receive an assurance that bugs found in the original project will be fixed in the fork, and because bugs found in the fork might be easier to find (because of less thorough testing, because of fewer resources) and so of less value, and so have a higher chance of ending up in the hands of low-level skiddies who might use them even less responsibly than e.g. the NSA (who has never directly installed ransomware on anyone's computer, that I know of). None of this of course is mentioning the effect this culture of fear and mistrust (and its basis in reality) has on computer users who truly are valuable targets, and must use computers to do their job knowing full well that they are a mire of both intentional and unintentional security vulnerabilities and that somewhere out there exists a string of exploits that can be used to exfiltrate their IP address and send them straight to the gulags.

Another cost of this unfortunate facet of computer programming is that for programs which cannot be directly updated (for example, their source code is not available), modifying them so that they are closer to a version with clearly-defined semantics is extremely difficult, involves specialized skills which are not possessed by most programmers, and generally just doesn't happen very often. Although one could also make this an argument in favor of source code availability, in any case this is a very common occurrence.

So, I don't think at all that the problem is this culture of foolishly thinking that we actually know how to write programs - the problem is that we can't. The solution then, at least in the long term, is learning how to write complete programs that do not require constant adjustments in order to ensure clearly defined semantics, not to just figure out how to stay afloat better in this horrifying quagmire of shifting quicksand that we've built the foundations of computer software on.

Oxitendwe··on While you pay into your 401k, CEOs collect $250k in monthly pension payments
I found this comment very fascinating and would love to learn more about the recent history of the two major American political parties, do you have any suggestions for literature on this topic?
Oxitendwe··on Toward a Predictive Theory of Depression
>I don't know. Depression has been recorded for thousands of years, so either society has always been insane (quite likely), in which case it's not likely to turn around any time soon, or there are other causes of depression. Some people can also fall into a depression for no identifiable reason (I can vouch for that from experience).

Of course there have always been depressed people, but the modern phenomenon where supposedly 10% of the population will have it in their lives, or where entire countries experience skyrocketing suicide rates, is certainly not related - I find it very difficult to believe that they all have a biological problem, instead of a cultural or societal problem.

>SSRIs and SNRIs and other medications have saved my life and some of my sanity, and I have high confidence that it's not a placebo - for me - having tried and failed with probably a dozen of these over the years, before hitting on a workable combination.

I don't doubt this - I only said that the vast majority of sufferers of depression do not seem to suffer from a biological problem. From my personal experience, I have seen that most of the depressed people I have known have gotten better not through medicine or medical procedure, but by consciously trying to make their lives better and be the best person they can be. Obviously this won't work for everyone - there really is such a thing as biologically-caused mental illness (see: schizophrenia, for example), but I think it is much rarer than people are willing to admit.

>But that's just me, so this is anecdata.

All data is anecdata. It's not worthless just because it happens to be your actual life and not collated and tallied by some detached scientist, it has meaning and value even without being a part of some anonymous dataset you can take confidence intervals on.

Oxitendwe··on Toward a Predictive Theory of Depression
What I have found through my experiences with depressed people is that the vast majority of them are not insane people in a sane society, but perfectly sane people in an insane society, people who have maladapted to their environment but would otherwise (if they had a better one) be perfectly healthy individuals. Many of them internalize their sadness and helplessness and make it a part of their identity, further reinforcing the common belief among depressed people that they are ill at a biological level (and are not merely healthy people in an unhealthy environment). I don't think the solution to this is ever going to lay in the hands of psychologists, and certainly not psychiatrists (SSRI's and SNRI's work only slightly better than chance in most people, and taking other antidepressant/mood-stabilizing medication is a hellish experience all its own) - it lays in the hands of the people who construct the environment we live in, the people in charge of its development and health, the people who have the most power over society. These are the people who have destroyed it and made the environment we all have to live in such a hellish place, and their successors will certainly be the only people who can fix it.
Oxitendwe··on Suicide prevention: large scale and small details
I don't really agree. I think inclusivity is actually part of the problem - when society welcomes anyone and everyone, people sometimes end up feeling alone or alienated because they aren't around people like themselves, who they share a common culture or upbringing with. This leads to less of a sense of belonging and community among people at large (not just depressed people), which leads to a more suspicious and distrustful atmosphere in general.
Oxitendwe··on Borderlands' sponsorships came about as an alternative to closing the store
Everyone is going on about a "living wage", but what about the illegal aliens who live in America who make substantially less than that, and come here illegally with great effort to get it? Why would they do that unless it was profitable? They seem to have no problem living on what most people would not consider a "living wage". It seems obvious then that the goal in mind with raising the minimum wage is to make it even more difficult to employ Americans, leaving those jobs to illegal aliens and punishing businesses who try to follow the law and only hire citizens. This gives those who hire illegal aliens more leverage by the fact that doing away with illegals would mean a substantially higher price hike for their products given that they would have to pay their employees that much more.
Oxitendwe··on FRACTRAN
Worst, or best?
Oxitendwe··on An extra-uterine system to physiologically support the extreme premature lamb
That's not a situation "we" as a culture/civilization/species face, it's a situation they face. The rest of us are perfectly capable of doing what our bodies are designed to do without doctors and scientists and other forms of assistance.
Oxitendwe··on An extra-uterine system to physiologically support the extreme premature lamb
What kind of infrastructure will this require? You'll need researchers to learn how such an object can be feasible, engineers to design it, people to construct it, parts must be ordered (some of which you might not even have the capability to make yourself), raw materials to make the parts must be mined, logistics must be done to make sure all of these parts are in the right place at the right time, enterprises must be constructed around building, selling, and marketing these devices.

What kind of power dynamics does that create? It involves the work of hundreds of thousands of people across every sort of country spanning the entire globe, many of whom hold a vast amount of power over you and the rest of whom have no obligation except financial to cooperate with you.

What exactly do we gain from giving so many people such vast power over us?

Oxitendwe··on Bangkok plans to ban all street food by year′s end
>there is definitely some degree of exploitation at play, just given the exchange rate alone.

Arbitrage isn't exploitation. Why should someone pay more than the local rate just because they are a (relatively) more wealthy foreigner? That's racist.

Oxitendwe··on What Is the Male Marriage Premium?
Is your imaginary kid going to pay into social security? Pay taxes for the roads you drive on? Take up arms to defend your country? If not, then you have no standing to complain when people who contribute more than you are rewarded more than you.
Oxitendwe··on Bangkok plans to ban all street food by year′s end
>Many sex workers have little choice

But some do, why would you take away their ability to make money? Do you think they'll thank you for taking away their livelihood?

> It also legitimises sex as a labour asset, increasing gender inequality

The vast majority of sex workers are female, meaning there is a much smaller market for males and so it is more difficult for them to make money. Is that what you meant by inequality? In any case, why shouldn't sex be a labor asset? This goes back to my original comment - what DO you have against female autonomy?

Oxitendwe··on Bangkok plans to ban all street food by year′s end
What do you have against female autonomy? How is sex work inherently in conflict with "concern for human welfare"?
Oxitendwe··on What Is the Male Marriage Premium?
Of course you were denied, he has standing to ask for time off (his kid) and you don't. Having children is incredibly important to society at large and it makes sense incentivize it, especially at the expense of people who don't have any yet. When you have kids, you will also have access to these perks.
Oxitendwe··on Bangkok plans to ban all street food by year′s end
Why do you assume they should care? They clearly have a different value system than yours. If you don't like it, don't go.
Oxitendwe··on How YouTube’s Shifting Algorithms Hurt Independent Media
It really tells us a lot about their values and priorities when they celebrate (by making doodles) people like that instead of, for example, Easter.
Oxitendwe··on How YouTube’s Shifting Algorithms Hurt Independent Media
Terrorist sympathizers are equivalent to racists now?
Oxitendwe··on US dismantles forensic science commission
This was only established 4 years ago. It's not a big deal.
Oxitendwe··on “Women invented computer science. WWhy are they behind?”
>Women invented computer science.

Please stop pinkwashing history. Women did not invent computer science. Also, the gender gap only needs to be "fixed" if it is true that women have an equal interest and potential in computer science, this has not been proven. The push for more women in positions of power in tech (who will thus displace men, and know to whom/what political faction they attribute their success) is a power grab by the American left to seize control of a power and influential industry they can use a tool to advance their interests. This is why there no real push for gender equality in female-majority fields, or non-lucrative/influential male-majority fields, e.g. offshore oil rigging or construction.

Oxitendwe··on Ten years with DragonFly BSD network stack [pdf]
Yes, surely a couple of years from now will be the year of "IPv6 on the desktop".
Oxitendwe··on [dead]
I think you're forgetting a little something: Russia. /s
Oxitendwe··on Scala Native v0.1
One might argue the same point based on the fact that there even exists a book called "JavaScript: The Good Parts".
Oxitendwe··on Study: Immigrants Founded 51% of U.S. Billion-Dollar Startups
>What are the things that affect the case for open immigration?

People worry about losing their cultural and ethnic identity. Nobody wants to be made a minority in their own country, no matter how much cheap labor they get out of it.

>What is the harm in them living in my society?

They bring their values and culture with them, and by sharing a society they change it, to a degree relative to how many of them there are, to be like theirs. The places many these people come from often have much different values than the American leftists who lobby for them to be here. I am particularly scared of this as an LGBT individual, as in a lot of immigration, particularly from Muslim majority countries, comes from places where public attitudes towards homosexuality are extremely negative and often violent (see: Omar Mateen).

>Don't give immigrants the right to vote or full citizenship then. Problem solved.

This won't work. Sure, the push now is just for them simply to be here, but creating an underclass of unrepresented people without the same rights as everyone else is a recipe for disaster. It will be easy for people seeking power to inspire hatred in them for their countrymen who are first-class citizens due to their unfair treatment, and then to incite them to violence for their political gain. A much better solution is simply to not let them in at all.

>Source for constitutional reforms being needed? I think the U.S. constitution only says the government can't discriminate based on race, ethnicity, etc.

No one can refuse to let people of a certain ethnicity live among them. This is racial discrimination, which was made illegal by the Fair Housing Act under the Civil Rights Act of 1968. You're right, this is not technically a constitutional amendment, but the result is the same: you cannot stay with your ethnic group. If someone from another ethnic group wants to live in your society, you are obligated by law to let them.

Oxitendwe··on Preact: Countering the Perception That Open Source Must Be Free
I think you have a really good idea! It doesn't just solve the problem with open versus closed source, it also solves a different and much more fundamental problem, which is that people who work on free and open source software do not get rewarded proportional to the value they provide to others. People who work on free software generally do so in their spare time, and work on proprietary software to pay the bills. This should be a sad state of affairs to anyone who actually cares about free software, that the only way to do it is to make proprietary software to keep the lights on. If one of them makes a program that is of great value and utility to others, how might they expect to be rewarded? If they are lucky, they can expect a few donations. If they are very lucky, a reasonably paid position maintaining their program paid for by a company that probably produces proprietary software.

How much are Linux kernel devs paid? How much value does Linux provide to others? On the other side of the coin, how much does the CEO of Snapchat make, and how much value does Snapchat provide to the world at large? This is unacceptable, people who make truly useful things should be rewarded appropriately, it's not fair that people can profit off the work of others while giving none of it back. Pull requests do not put food on the table, when people are able to make a living off of open source software, we'll see a lot more of it than we ever did when they relied on charity, goodwill, and a day job writing proprietary software.

Oxitendwe··on Study: Immigrants Founded 51% of U.S. Billion-Dollar Startups
>You assume some people have a right to the infrastructure of a particular country, for example competing for certain jobs, while others don't. It's very hard or even impossible to make that case without referring to very subjective morality standards.

Would these "subjective morality standards" be any different from the ones that you use to define "humane or inhumane behavior"? In any case, I'd like to see a subjective moral framework where citizens of their own country don't have a right to the infrastructure that they and their ancestors created. What incentive is there to have made our society a better place by the time we die than it was when we were born, if our descendants don't even have a birthright to what we intend to leave them?

Oxitendwe··on Iron law of prohibition
Yes, well spotted, it's also the same argument you can use for literally anything else, until all you're left with is a state's right to decide on whether to enact a plastic bag tax or not.
Oxitendwe··on Study: Immigrants Founded 51% of U.S. Billion-Dollar Startups
The "material conditions" that lead to illegal immigration in the US are lax enforcement of immigration and labor laws. If we had enforced our laws from the beginning, it would not be a problem. The solution then, is to enforce the laws we have, and remove their incentive to be here, not to go over there and make their country better. We have our own country to make great (again!).

>Because apparently the only humans who matter are those on this side of the line in the sand.

Everyone has a right to act in their best interests. Charity is never obligatory.

Oxitendwe··on Study: Immigrants Founded 51% of U.S. Billion-Dollar Startups
It's really not as complicated as you make it out to be. Everyone has a right to put the interests of themselves and their group first and foremost. Given that, the "solution" to immigration is to just not bother with it when it isn't in your interests. The reason the left wants immigration is because they overwhelmingly vote left. The reason the right doesn't is because they don't want to lose their cultural and national identity. Nowhere along the line does anybody care about why people want to be here - it's not their concern.
Oxitendwe··on Study: Immigrants Founded 51% of U.S. Billion-Dollar Startups
>Economics research says low wage immigrants are a net economic benefit, so it is in the interest of its citizens

Economics is not the only factor to factor into someone's interests. Everyone has things they value more than money.

>Also, I think the extreme poverty in parts of the world can justify help, just like how 1000$ is more to a poor person than a millionaire.

How does that justify help? It's not just like you help them to get on their feet and you're done. They and their descendants will live in your society for generations. Nobody is obligated to give them this at the expense of their citizens.

>No, immigration alleviates poverty as Americans are much richer than the average person. Why do you think so many people want to immigrate?

They want to immigrate here because wages are higher. However, there are only a limited number of jobs, and so flooding the job market with more people prevents natives from being able to find work, which is against their interests.

>I don't think it's a power grab by the left (open borders are not popular, as you can see right here) and that's irrelevant to the merits of open borders.

It's exactly like Roosevelt's Judicial Procedures Reform Bill of 1937, where he tried to pack the supreme court with justices favorable to his political faction, except this time they are trying to pack the US electorate. These people and their descendants overwhelmingly vote left.

>Well, I am against forcing racial diversity, so you can stay with your ethnic group/society in my proposal.

That's illegal in the United States. Every ethnic group has to live among every other ethnic group. Nobody can create societies that only allow people of their ethnic group to live among them, so it's not true that anyone can stay with their ethnic group, barring some serious constitutional reforms.

← PreviousPage 2 of 5Next →