HNHacker News
TopNewBestAskShowJobs

Oxitendwe

291 karma · joined August 14, 2016

submissionscomments
Oxitendwe··on Study: Immigrants Founded 51% of U.S. Billion-Dollar Startups
>Apart from the idea of sorting people into useful and useless being inhumane

How do you think it would affect a country to suddenly have a very large amount of low-skill immigrants? How would the native citizens, the people by which their government is held accountable and to whose interests their government's purpose is to advance, be affected? The answer is probably that they would be very adversely effected, in which case however "inhumane" it is to sort people like this, it is also inhumane to do wrong by the native citizens who built the country that those immigrants would be living in. Immigration is not a human right, nobody has a right to immigrate anywhere and no country has an obligation to accept any particular person or group of people as immigrants.

Oxitendwe··on Study: Immigrants Founded 51% of U.S. Billion-Dollar Startups
>In my opinion, even if it may harm some natives, due to the poverty alleviating effects of immigration, we should open immigration to anyone who doesn't have a criminal record.

What is the point of government if not to act in the best interests of its citizens? Why are our governments now apparently obligated to act in the best interests of foreign nationals? This has nothing to do with alleviating poverty or humanitarian ideals. It's blatantly obvious that this advocacy for open borders is part of a power grab by the left to ensure that they stay in power for decades to come, at the expense of the people who actually built the society that they want to invite everyone else to live in. What party do they think these people are going to overwhelmingly vote for? I don't understand how people can openly advocate for destroying our society just for political gain.

Oxitendwe··on They were guillotined 72 years ago today. And they deserve remembering
What does that have to do with Trump? Who are you concerned he is going to go to war with?
Oxitendwe··on AT&T allegedly “discriminated” against poor people in broadband upgrades
I agree completely, AT&T should absolutely honor their legal obligations.
Oxitendwe··on AT&T allegedly “discriminated” against poor people in broadband upgrades
That's a separate issue though, and something I am quite strongly against. The article was about "discriminating" specifically against the poor, and unless you'd like to argue that their collusion is willfully and knowingly done specifically to discriminate against poor people, I don't think it applies.
Oxitendwe··on Physical location of live stream found using flights patterns and astronomy
>an administration with actual white nationalists as advisors

Citation needed. You're probably talking about Bannon - can you explain in your own words why you think this?

Oxitendwe··on AT&T allegedly “discriminated” against poor people in broadband upgrades
Is this even news? If they thought there was a profit to be made by offering them upgrades, they would do it. They haven't, so you can probably assume that there is no profit in doing so. Last I checked, AT&T was not a charity and does not have an obligation to give people things at cost. This isn't discrimination, it's business. Nobody has a right to a fast internet connection.
Oxitendwe··on Iron law of prohibition
It's not about abortion. The states where a majority of people support abortion already have it. It's not enough, however, for the states that the American left controls to have abortion - they must have it in states controlled by Republicans as well. The fight is about to what extent are states allowed to self-govern, to what extent can people who live in them create the kind of society and culture that they want to live in. One side thinks states should be allowed to do what they think is right in their own jurisdiction, so that different groups with diverse values can peacefully coexist in the same country. The other thinks they should decide what is right for everyone, so that all groups conform to their values, which they perceive to be universal.
Oxitendwe··on They were guillotined 72 years ago today. And they deserve remembering
Why does Trump's agenda need resistance? Why do you think you might need to die for it? Be specific, what threat does he pose that is so great that you are willing to die to stop it?
Oxitendwe··on Set up a cheap cloud hosted adblocker in an hour for $2.50 a month
What kind of insane world do we live in where we can't block ads on our own devices?
Oxitendwe··on I invented the web. Here are three things we need to change to save it
Could you elaborate? I've never heard of web assembly being related to DRM before.
Oxitendwe··on I invented the web. Here are three things we need to change to save it
If Tim Berners-Lee really wanted to save the web, he wouldn't support DRM in our web standards.[1] It's absolutely disgusting as well that they would argue that "fake news" is somehow a threat to the internet, provide no evidence whatsoever to explain why, and then link to a panel run by a media company considered untrustworthy by about half of American voters.[2]

[1] https://www.w3.org/blog/2017/02/on-eme-in-html5/

[2] http://www.rasmussenreports.com/public_content/politics/gene...

Oxitendwe··on Rust's Type System Is Turing-Complete: Type-Level Programming in Rust
>Idris won't reduce partial functions at the type level, in order to keep type checking decidable.

Totality precludes Turing-completeness. Specifically, functions that don't terminate are by definition partial, and if you can't express functions that don't terminate then it isn't Turing-complete.

Oxitendwe··on Rust's Type System Is Turing-Complete: Type-Level Programming in Rust
Haskell's type system isn't Turing-complete or even particularly sophisticated. There are extensions to its type system implemented in GHC that in theory give you unbounded computation, but a) those aren't actually Haskell and b) nobody does any real work with them and c) it gives up trying to typecheck if it takes too long. I don't know much about Idris but a few seconds of searching tells me its type theory is not Turing-complete either.[1]

[1] http://cs.stackexchange.com/questions/19577/what-can-idris-n...

Oxitendwe··on Working While Female
You don't think we're at war? Think again: https://www.nytimes.com/2017/01/26/opinion/president-trumps-...

Every day is a struggle for our fundamental human rights.

Oxitendwe··on Why Women Don’t Apply for Jobs Unless They’re 100% Qualified (2014)
Do you have any idea how insulting and dismissive you sound? You know nothing about the circumstances of his hiring, how can you possibly say his real and concrete experience was easier than that of some hypothetical woman?
Oxitendwe··on 94-year-old Lithium-Ion Battery Inventor Introduces Solid State Battery
Perhaps I should have clarified: by "literally nobody" I meant "virtually nobody", as in "the number of people who believe that we should accept no immigrants whatsoever is very small and statistically negligible".
Oxitendwe··on 94-year-old Lithium-Ion Battery Inventor Introduces Solid State Battery
I don't think it's right to equate expressing unpopular opinions with murder, no matter what you believe. If he's wrong, prove it, there's no need to resort to such ad-hominem attacks.
Oxitendwe··on 94-year-old Lithium-Ion Battery Inventor Introduces Solid State Battery
Literally no one is arguing to the contrary. The problems people have with immigration into the US typically involve the sheer scale of it, the fact that many people who come to the United States do so illegally, difficulty with integrating, and difference in values from native citizens. Nobody is arguing against small-scale immigration of highly skilled scientists, there aren't even enough of them to make a demographic difference.
Oxitendwe··on I Challenge You to Debug These 7 Lines of Code Under 9 Minutes
It's mystifying to me that the author comes to the conclusion that the solution to this is to educate people on debugging tools and edge-case semantics. The reason the code is difficult to debug is because the "bug" is that functions are apparently completely broken and violate every reasonable assumption anybody is likely to make about them without a priori knowledge about this specific edge case. Why isn't the conclusion then, that Python is broken, and has a serious and fundamental problem? Why doesn't anybody see this as a "broken window", that leads us as a culture to believe that this sort of thing is acceptable and to be expected and not an ugly, horrible, and utterly unnecessary problem? Is this really the language we're supposed to teach to beginners? How many combined hours have been wasted on solving problems generated by this behavior, and for what purpose? I don't understand why people accept this.
Oxitendwe··on Ask HN: How would you turn Twitter around?
Well, for one I would stop banning and restricting people for expressing their opinions. Your phone company wouldn't disconnect your service for leaving nasty messages on someone's mailbox, so Twitter shouldn't ban people for writing nasty messages to people. It's not their responsibility and I think society suffers from their judgement of what is allowed and what isn't - how can you promote understanding and bring people closer together when one side of the argument is being silenced and marginalized? People who break laws should be dealt with by the legal system. People that do not shouldn't have to worry about their ability to communicate with people being curtailed.

If you think this sort of thing doesn't happen, read this: http://blog.dilbert.com/post/157826468646/nothing-to-see-her... , or http://blog.dilbert.com/post/157201503761/freedom-of-speech-... . He's had problems with this for months, because of his political blogging, and this is just one example. If it can happen to the guy who made Dilbert, it can happen to anyone.

Oxitendwe··on I Challenge You to Debug These 7 Lines of Code Under 9 Minutes
It's absolutely insane that this is apparently the expected behavior. It makes no sense whatsoever except to give people who know this an ego boost when they can successfully work around Python's unintuitive semantics while inexperienced people cannot. It completely breaks functions, the most fundamental unit of encapsulation and abstraction in every modern programming language.
Oxitendwe··on The Cultural Purge Will Not Be Televised
The issue here is that Shopify are being judged not for their actual stances, but for who they do business with. This is different from boycotting something because of their actual positions. What if no one would rent a building to Breitbart, or provide their offices and employees with internet access, or sell vehicles to their employees, or provide web hosting for them, because of the threat of boycotts against them for doing business with Breitbart? The practice of boycotting people for association rather than actual opinions is seriously bad news if you actually care about free speech, because it means that any group with enough buying power to affect the bottom line of anyone you do business with now is in control of whether or not you're allowed to exist.
Oxitendwe··on Show HN: Poxi – A Hackable Pixel Art Editor
Umm... is it supposed to look like this?

https://aww.moe/wosyo0.png

I'm using Tor Browser 7.0a1-hardened (based on Mozilla Firefox 45.7.0).

Oxitendwe··on The Cultural Purge Will Not Be Televised
It's especially ironic because one of the other posters mentioned about how he'll only believe it (your claim that there is a cultural purge) if it actually happens to you.
Oxitendwe··on The Cultural Purge Will Not Be Televised
>If there's a real "cultural purge", we should expect EasyDNS to go bankrupt for defending groups alleged to be "white supremacist", "racist", and "Nazi".

So, for his claim that there are often unpleasant consequences for being vocally on one side of the cultural divide to be true, they have to specifically happen to him? This is a ridiculous assertion, whether he is correct has absolutely nothing to do with whether he himself faces those consequences.

Oxitendwe··on The power of role models
Well, it's nice at least that you recognize this for what it is - a power grab by the left to seize control of a powerful and influential industry with which they can impose their agenda on everyone else.

I don't agree, however, with your statement "Society owes equal opportunity (minimally) and representation (ideally) to all of its constituents into the halls of power". This is an industry. Nobody is owed equal representation in every field of employment. They have to earn it the same as everyone else or you're playing favorites, and since it's a zero-sum game, by doing so you put another group at a disadvantage.

Oxitendwe··on The power of role models
>To those expressing concern that this proposal represents "reverse sexism" or is anti-meritocratic:

Nobody is arguing that this is "reverse sexism", merely sexism. If you don't think disadvantaging men in particular is sexism, then I don't think it's possible for us to have meaningful discourse on this if we can't even agree on what words mean.

>"Pushing women into positions of influence" can also be interpreted as identifying high-performers capable of filling senior roles and then helping them get there.

He specifically used the phrasing "It may take proactive behavior, like choosing a women over a man when growing your team". That is not consistent with your interpretation - yours is that he is advocating for identifying people who are fit for management roles, who happen to be women, and then using their resources to make it easier for them to get there. Instead, his phrasing quite unambiguously advocates selecting women over men when hiring. I would love to hear your argument for why this is both not sexist and also valuable to society at large.

>This does mean giving them an unfair advantage, but only in the sense that life is unfair in general. Ultimately they are the most capable individuals for the roles they assume, and lifting them to that level pays dividends for our entire industry.

So, unfairly discriminating against people makes them "the most capable individuals for the roles they assume"?

>If you believe in both bolstering the meritocracy and furthering gender equality (as I do), this should be your reaction. Positioning a meritocratic ideal as in opposition to equal representation is just veiled misogyny.

As I have said in innumerable other comments, that equal representation is even desirable, much less possible, rests on the assumption that all demographics have equal interest and potential. This has not been proven, and to advocate intentionally disadvantaging people based on their sex when you don't even know if the group to whose benefit this is all for even wants to be here I find naive at best and bigoted at worst.

Oxitendwe··on The power of role models
>If it comes down to the flip of a coin, why not add more diverse opinions if the team is male-heavy. Likewise if the team is female-heavy.

What is the value of having an equal number of men and women? What is a "diverse opinion"? If you hire a woman over a man because of the "diverse opinion" you expect her to bring, and her opinions end up being the same as the men on her team, will you be disappointed at the lack of ideological diversity you expected her to provide? Will she feel marginalized for her opinions not being "diverse" enough?

These feel like reasonable questions - you are implying having gender diversity will bring ideological diversity, that is, men have different ideas than women, and that this difference is valuable. However, won't that assumption also lead to women feeling that their value is diminished if their opinions aren't different enough from men, if that is the basis upon which you hire them?

Oxitendwe··on The power of role models
If such a problem exists, then its solution does not involve institutionalizing discrimination.
← PreviousPage 3 of 5Next →