235 karma · joined August 30, 2011
I guess the question is under what circumstances do you think the pros outweight the cons ?
re: programming - we are trying to figure out what's the best model. One thing we are trying to avoid is complex timelines to make it easy for the average recreational musician.
At Bandhub ( http://bandhub.us ) we are looking for ways to integrate programmed music into our web DAW.
If you guys are up for a collaboration or want to discuss ideas, ping me osi (at) getbandhub (dot) com
Here is a demo: http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=jFCjv4_jqAY
It works best with single-instrument signals - not so much with a mix of multiple instruments.
Couple of feedback points:
1: it'd be nice if the instrument sounds were much better - they sound too synthetic to me.
2: I had a really hard time using the 'fretless' UI - i.e., everything I did sounded horrible (see my recording below). Maybe you can snap-to-note if I am close-by the actual note?
Here is the 4 tracks recording with BandHub: http://getbandhub.com/s/52fce1e87fa2ce0443000002
As I work with a lot of independent artists (mostly musicians) b/c of my startup BandHub, I can feel how this is the profession of the future - not automatable away. Everyone has something to say - and there is a huge long tail of potential ( niche? ) audiences.
Things like Patreon are really cool. I wonder how we can really make it work for anyone, anywhere in the world.
While there has been quite a few attempts at online music collaboration, clearly the average amateur musician is not using any of them.
PROs use pro-music software to collaborate with other people, and some tech-oriented amateurs hang out in collaboration forums.
But all that is too hard/annoying for the average amateur musician.
BandHub "The Internet Music Studio" - makes it easy to make music with other people over the Internet.
Is this another example of arbitrary constrains as a forcing factor for effectiveness? (as in don't raise too much money).
It looks like the increase in quality of startups is an independent factor to your ability to accept all of the really good ones.
Does this mean that you will need to figure out how to scale more aggressively or start rejecting more and more good startups?
Did you think about adding the feature of producing a combined video with the original video plus the overlaid tabs? That'd be nice so that people that transcribe can post back to YouTube.
I guess a lot of people will just search in YouTube and it'd be nice if those searchers could discover the content that the people at Soundslice are creating.
BTW (100% unrelated) - I took one of your YouTube guitar videos and added a couple of parts with BandHub: http://getbandhub.com/song.html?s=524e26a8cc8d46e238000001
I understood it wrong initially - I thought the question was asking "how do you know this will be huge?" (as in "How do you tell whether there's a path out of an idea? How do you tell whether something is the germ of a giant company, or just a niche product? Often you can't" )
Then I realized that's not the question at all, it's just "how do you know people need what you are making?" Literally. I.e., the specific / niche-y thing that you are making first.
"My advice is 3 points to communicate in your application. 1. You have revenue or a plan to make it 2. You and your co-founders are a solid team 3. You will pursue this even without getting an investment"
We do support, however, real-time production. After you record a track, it becomes almost-instantaneously available to other people, so they can record their own on top, mix it, or whatever.
(1) To be extremely fair, you can achieve real-time jamming 1:1 if you buy super low-latency specialized audio interfaces and are connected with someone that doesn't live too far away in an area of the world where the internet infrastructure is awesome. So it could work intra-city in the US or some parts of Europe for example. But it would still be 1:1 and not really for "bands" in the broader sense.
I think a github for your DAW is a great tool for an audio engineer, or a self-produced / technology-geek musician.
I think a "21st century portastudio" is the best tool for the average musician (hobbyist or pro).
What that 21st century portastudio looks like is up to be seen. But we think certainly not like a githubed-DAW
Thoughts?
after you make a first crack at your song wouldn't you like to have awesome session musicians play parts?
note I am not arguing against jamming side-by-side for real - which is awesome. i see it more as a complement
I guess iPhone qualifies as Linux :)
We'd love to find a way to let people use their tools - however, the type of UX that we are going after is 10x simpler than any DAW or recording software out there.