HNHacker News
TopNewBestAskShowJobs

PaulJoslin

340 karma · joined May 10, 2010

http://twitter.com/PaulJoslin
submissionscomments
PaulJoslin··on Ask HN: Please help a virgin blogger.
I think your posts have good content, the key issue here currently is delivery and audience.

Normally creating good content would be the first challenge, but you seem to have good content already. Perhaps you should look to change it to fit the blog audience / open it up further for discussion.

They key problem is that currently your audience is 0 (or very close to 0). It is unlikely that your audience will go from 0 to big numbers over night. So it is something you will have to work on and grow over time.

Firstly, think about what streams you can use to gain new audience members per post (submission to content aggregators / forums / guest posts on other blogs).

Then think about building a consistent schedule for releasing new content. Currently you are doing this daily, but I would suggest weekly (to spread the content further). Make this known to the audience so they know when to check back for new content.

Finally once you start having an audience, you'll want to keep it. Use platforms such as twitter and email lists to help inform that audience when new content is released so they keep coming back.

Slowly over time this should start making your blog a success.

PaulJoslin··on Ask HN: How to be successful online without SEO bullshittery?
Think about it in the context of if your business was an offline shop.

Think about the SEO / Organic search as being how busy the highstreet is that your shop resides.

Then think about the amount of transport links (roads / trains / airports) that are nearby being the incoming links.

Finally, think about the competition for the keywords on search, as being similar shops on the high street.

Currently you may have a great shop with lots to offer, but it's stuck out in the middle of no where, with no transport links and hardly any passing traffic. What's worse, is that you have many shops just like yours in the area and no unique selling point. You wouldn't expect that shop to thrive.

The technique many use these days, is to work on the keywords / SEO from the start - placing their shop in a busy place with existing traffic passing through. Looking for a niche which doesn't have too much competition. Then they contact similar blogs / media providers and try to get as many links as possible coming in.

They now have the traffic, they just need to provide a good service and convert it to revenue somehow.

'SEO bullshitery' - is the wrong way to think of it. Along with 'SEO' being black art or magic. Ok, there are people out there that are 'gaming' the system, but it doesn't change the fact that for a web product SEO / market competition online for the niche is an extremely important thing to consider.

PaulJoslin··on Ask HN: Review my app, LayoutGenerator
Strangely, I was writing some CSS the other day and thought 'why doesn't something like this exist'.

Glad to see you've produced a working version.

Perhaps the business model should be, free for simple use, but chargeable for more complex sites / designs.

PaulJoslin··on I have well over 10 customers. I want to take my startup to the next level
There is at least one premium app there, brain tuner premium. That has 87,000 'new customers' (whatever it means by new?) so around $87,000 revenue.
PaulJoslin··on Hey, Guys, It's Totally Okay If You Don't Get Rich
This is so true.

When I dream of 'winning the lottery', I don't dream of laying on sandy beaches. I dream of starting a new start up, knowing that I can have enough FU money to take risks and make it great.

PaulJoslin··on Ask HN: What if nothing works out?
If you don't try you never know. I'd prefer to be old looking back thinking 'at least I gave it a shot', than constantly sitting in my office cubicle thinking to myself 'what if'.
PaulJoslin··on New Website Builds Minimum Viable Products for Startups
An excellent concept. The reality is, most 'ideas' can be tried out in it's minimum form fairly quickly - with the added benefit that from day one, you are getting ranked in google, getting feedback, collecting email addresses and taking sign ups.

My personal approach, is to use word press on cheap hosting. I know how to customize word press to do almost anything I want and can get something up in a few hours to test the market (check for validity of my keyword analysis). Obviously not everyone knows php / how to customise word press, so your solution is ideal for those founders with the idea but no technical knowledge.

Once the idea has been tested, I'll then spend longer building the better product (if needed), knowing that the initial feedback I got from launching early will save me from building the wrong thing.

PaulJoslin··on “Ugly” Sites that Make Millions (and What We Can Learn from Them)
As has been said. Match / eHarmony were not free services. That was what made PlentyOfFish unique at the time.

If you go and find the founders blog you can track the entire process of the site (like BingoCreator), including his girlfriend holding a (2 month) paycheck from google adsense for $450,000

PaulJoslin··on “Ugly” Sites that Make Millions (and What We Can Learn from Them)
There is a difference between 'clean' and simple, like hacker news (which is good) and ugly / cluttered like many of the sites shown as examples in the post.
PaulJoslin··on “Ugly” Sites that Make Millions (and What We Can Learn from Them)
While I agree with the author's points of keeping things simple and the importance of a good product / functionality underneath the aesthetics.

Plentyoffish was one of the first / earliest online dating site which went free, when all competitors charged a fee. Thus making it the first / earliest in that category.

These days the internet is saturated with free dating services.

I just felt, that the author mistakenly picked a bunch of sites which had an edge (of being in the early web) and therefore aesthetics didn't matter to get a following.

I feel there are plenty of examples of modern sites / services that are new and demonstrate the keeping it simple / clean design perfectly well!

There was also the fact that he says Google's biggest selling point was its simple design. Yes Google's simple design was a breath of fresh air compared to the cluttered yahoo portals of the world. However Google's biggest selling point was that it's search algorithms were undeniably brilliant.

The quality of the searches you got in Google beat any competitor and that's why many (including myself) made the switch!.

PaulJoslin··on “Ugly” Sites that Make Millions (and What We Can Learn from Them)
It's worth noting, that all of the sites shown share another thing in common.

They were all established / founded in the early web. I'm not saying that there was not competition, or that their success was because they were first - they still gave superior products which beat any rivals at the time.

However, trying to draw parallels with these site's design and success today is not totally relevant. If you launched either of them today as they were / are, they may not succeed (despite as we know, the core product / service / functionality being great).

Rob Walling writes in his book that these days: 'It's Market(ing) First, aesthetics second and functionality third'.

Firstly you need to have a market for your product and hopefully be able to market it well enough to get people to 'want your product' / know you exist.

Then when they look at your site, you need the aesthetics to give a first impression of your product and gain trust from your customers in your product. It doesn't matter if your service / functionality is brilliant. If you can't get the user to even try you over any competitor, then you've wasted your time.

Then thirdly, if you're lucky to achieve the top two - give your customers a good user experience / functionality they want, so hopefully they pay / keep coming back.

The reason the sites given in the example can happily remain ugly, is because they already have the user's trust and are a known 'experience'. Therefore the aesthetics don't need to work as hard to make an impression as say a newly formed start up today.

- EDIT... I'm not saying that a site which is kept basic in design can't be successful. Infact, I agree quite heavily with the principle of keeping things simple and have blogged about it in the past.

Perhaps the original author should've done the article on one of the many great sites over the last few years, which have embraced this 'Keep it simple and clean' attitude. Hacker news being a perfect example.

PaulJoslin··on Ask HN: I want to start a web company what books should I read?
While I'm at it. I'll tell you about some other's I have read.

- Getting Real by 37 Signals http://gettingreal.37signals.com/ - Rework by 37 Signals http://37signals.com/rework/

These are great and really get your mind thinking about alternatives to what most people believe.

- Sarah Lacy's Once your lucky, twice you're good. http://www.amazon.com/Once-Youre-Lucky-Twice-Good/dp/1592403...

This isn't a technical book, but can really get you motivated to succeed reading the stories of previous successes! It also gives a bit of an insight into the internal workings of a start up in the early stages. It highlights networking as an important factor!

- Start up success guide - http://www.amazon.com/Startup-Success-Guide-Books-Profession...

This book was quite good, but felt a bit dated in comparison to Rob Walling's 'Start up book'.

Finally 'Founders at work' is definitely worth a read. http://www.amazon.com/Founders-Work-Stories-Startups-Problem...

PaulJoslin··on Ask HN: I want to start a web company what books should I read?
In my opinion this is the best book out there I've read relevant to starting your own start up!

http://www.startupbook.net/

I've read quite a few and where some are in sightful / useful when scaled or when funded, this book is the best I've read for a typical software developer to have a successful start up business!

It is also written by a fellow HN'er Rob Walling - so you know it'll be full of great information! Check out his blog 'SoftwarebyRob' for a taster.

http://www.softwarebyrob.com/

PaulJoslin··on Inception's Usability Problem
It's the fact it takes the relatively simple concept. 'We are exploring their dreams for data' and pushes it to a unnecessary level of complexity.

A limbo state within a dream, within a dream, within a dream, (within a dream?).

It reminded me of recursion in programming, waiting for it all to unwind.

Not to mention all the rest of the things which just added to the complexity of the whole experience. Don't get me wrong, I enjoyed it and could follow the plot, but it constantly felt like it was adding complexity just for the sake of it, not necessarily improving the experience.

I don't really understand why they had an entire training montage where she learnt to bend the world, experimented with physics, limits of dreams, even taught her some clever tricks such as 'penrose stairs'. Yet, when it came to her utilisation in the film, she was not seen to do anything? (I know she designed the levels, but ultimately her role in doing that seemed to be ignored. I was awaiting her to use her 'amazing skill' to do something great to help save the day.

PaulJoslin··on Inception's Usability Problem
This was exactly how I felt when I left the cinema. Although it was a good film, I felt the execution of the idea felt sloppy. It had promise to be truly amazing, but often purposely became confusing in the aim of seeming to be clever.

I think in Inception they took things too far, multiple dream levels, weird limbo states, etc. They could've just built a far simpler movie and it would've flowed a lot better.

It's comparable to software. Often the most enjoyable user experience is one with very few features executed extremely well. Compared to a piece of software with every single feature or idea plugged in, executed fairly sloppily.

Inception was lucky it had a great core concept, cast and good effects to hold up for the on going confusion throughout the film.

The comparison I feel is Matrix compared to Existence, where 'Existence' in this scenario is Inception.

PaulJoslin··on Rats trained to play the forex market
You mean, like they're noticing a 'bearish gartley' pattern (in audio) and acting appropriately?

My point was, that although these can be 'indicators', you still require a human mind to determine whether the trade should be made. If it was as simple as matching patterns and trading, anyone would be able to do it.

PaulJoslin··on Rats trained to play the forex market
If you take 80 people and tell them to randomly play the stock market, buying or selling - you will always have some that succeed and some that fail over the short term.

The question is, if the same people who 'succeeded' are put back to the start again and play randomly with a new batch of 80 people - would they still rise to the top, or perhaps this time have worse luck.

Comparing this to the rats, the long term testing / new rounds with a new set of 80 rats (including the elite) would help determine whether these rats are the best, or if it was chance.

If I understand this correctly, the decision the rat makes is based solely on hearing a certain frequency (pattern of trading emerge), unfortunately even if this is the case - trading by patterns could be extremely risky without the common sense / experience of a real trader to see what is really happening to the market.

PaulJoslin··on How We Got Rejected from YC and Moved into the SpeakerCave
At first I was thinking that youtube's recent sub title mod must of been a bit of a hit to their idea, but then I saw the functionality of quoting and sharing hyper linked quotes.

That's quite a cool feature and could be handy for stopping 'mis quoting' / 'quoting out of context' being used in many media's.

PaulJoslin··on Ask HN: Does reading HN ever make you feel like shit?
He may not be the 20th fastest driver. F1 is determined greatly by the car the driver is given. He may be the best driver (which I think would hurt even more).

Kubica and Nico Rosberg are good examples of this. Both used to race against Lewis Hamilton in lower levels of motorsport and both used to beat him. However neither Kubica or Nico have been given a truely championship winning car yet to prove themselves.

PaulJoslin··on Ask HN: Does reading HN ever make you feel like shit?
In reference to point 2 and 'I've always been told I'm a smart kid and that I'll be a millionaire one day'

It's worth reading this recent thread and the comments. http://www.reddit.com/r/AskReddit/comments/crywg/dear_reddit...

The post is entitled 'Dear reddit, did you believe that one day you'd all be millionaires, rockstars and moviestars?' - taken from the quote in Fight Club. It raises some interesting points about how we are brought up to believe the dream is achievable and often it takes a lot more hard work than we originally perceive.

I personally wouldn't compare myself to anyone else. I've worked with some of the smartest guys I know from a technical point of view, but they have lacked in other areas such as ideas and execution.

(Often the best technical people neglect important things like marketing, design and user experience - expecting the 'amazing product' to equal success).

PaulJoslin··on Ask HN: Loosing Faith - the startup killer
One reason I believe for this could be because often in these cases your project is a 'side' bootstrapped thing.

This causes the lack of motivation / reduces the chances of reaching success for a few reasons.

- The first is that you do not need it to succeed.

Don't get me wrong, you would love it to succeed and make money, however you are most likely doing it after your day job and the reality is, you've not risked enough to 'HAVE' to succeed. Therefore it is very easy to fail / decide to try again when things get tough or haven't yet been as successful as you had hoped.

- Another key reason is that, while bootstrapping time is tight. You find you spend hours / days / weeks / months of your spare time on something (while working full time at a job) and the reality is, you just burn out / want free time again. This is not unreasonable, especially if you have a family to look after, or your health is being affected.

- Ultimately every idea goes through a dip, 'a hard' section. The fun idea / initial build has started (if you're a software developer like me, this is the best part), but now you must focus on the other elements such as sales / marketing / support, etc. We can easily diagnose and fix a problem in our code if our product is running inefficiently, but it's often far harder for us hackers to say exactly why the traffic is not pouring in, why the traffic is not converting to user sign ups or why the sales aren't increasing. At this point we think how much fun it would be to work on another exciting idea, doing the fun part again.

- Finally (I already realise this is quite an essay), the idea may not have been so great to start with. It is a common thing to have 'great' ideas, which at first seem brilliant, but after a week seem weak. I always try to give any idea I have at least 3 days of thought before jumping in. Similarly I always ask other people for their thoughts and whether they would use this service?

Ultimately, there is nothing more demotivating than working on a project realising that no one actually wants it.

PaulJoslin··on Ask HN: What proficiency does one need to start freelancing?
I've read a lot of interesting comments on here, but what is everyone's stand point on support. Do you offer free support? Do you charge? Do your clients ask for it? Obviously a change request is chargeable, but what about a bug?

I used to do freelance work face to face, I made a nice chunk of money from it - but in the end the support I had to give was exhausting. Most of it was neither a bug to be fixed or a request requiring a change, often in fact the support query was completely unrelated to my freelance work.

This is one problem with freelancing in general. At the start it is easy, fun, creative and you are printing money. However, the more clients you have, the more work you do and the more money you make, is counter balanced by the increase in support duties.

I decided to join a software consultancy instead, doing roughly the same role as when I was freelancing. The only difference is, now I get paid a salary (which is a lot less) and our support team handle the support of clients. (Something which many clients actually are happy to pay a premium / service fee for).

This said, I see how much money things cost clients compared to my salary (for my work) and get the temptation to just go freelance again.

So HN freelancers, what is your standpoint on ongoing support?

PaulJoslin··on OnLive's Gaming-on-Demand Service Demoed on an iPad
Who decided to have the virtual controls up there on the screen?

It seems A ) it would go against the normal way you would hold the ipad and B ) the controls / your hands block half the screen.

Would it've been too hard to have the controls lower (more natural position for hands) and semi transparent?

PaulJoslin··on The Toughest Developer Puzzle Ever
clue is in the colours and image name.
PaulJoslin··on The Toughest Developer Puzzle Ever
Yeah I'm on 8. Then I realised I was at work and I should really save it for later.
PaulJoslin··on Flow.io: Lean project management based on kanban. Please review.
For anyone wondering what a 'Kanban' board is or wanting to know how it can be used - I suggest viewing this cool slideshow:

http://www.slideshare.net/marcusoftnet/kanbanboards

Really opens the mind on how to use one. I showed this to our development team today and one of them said 'Surely you could just make this into a computer program?'.

The reason I think this doesn't work as well as a computer program (and take this as feedback to your project), is as following:

- Having a physical board on a wall is visible to the team, all of the time. A computer system has to be checked, it has to be opened or at least brought to the front of your windows to think 'What am I supposed to be doing? What is there to be done'. Having a real physical board in your office allows you to easily get distracted and get back on track.

- The other advantage of this, is that it is seen by everyone in every department. I've worked in places where support teams use one internal system and development use another and despite being linked are often only viewed internally in department. Although this works fine, by having a physical Kanban board on your wall, it is visible by everyone in your company all the time! Everyone will know what people in their department and outside will be up to ... this helps manage work load for people and stops people having to constantly ask 'what's happening with A or B?'. It also stops people ignoring difficult tasks, or urgent bugs - as everyone knows it's there and needs to be done asap.

- Having a real board that you stick post it notes on is quite a fun task to do. Especially looking at the added fun from the slides (e.g. little character people and cartoons).

- Having a real hand drawn board is flexible, you can change the way you use it depending on how your company is run / departments are set up.

However,

There are many disadvantages of having a hand drawn one which a computerised one would improve. The key and biggest off the top of my mind is integrating with existing source control / project management solutions.

e.g. TFS has a work item number. If you have a hand drawn board with a post it note with the TFS number in the corner, you'd still have to look up what that item is in TFS. Where as in a computerised system you can easily access that information perhaps from clicking the work item.

However, all this said, I still think you've made a good start and have a nice product. Your best bet would be to approach different real development teams early and see how they would use it and what pain / gains can be made.

- Visibility and fun are key deal breakers here. If something is a chore, boring or painful - then people won't want to do it. Make it fun and they'll happily do it and it adds motivation to the team moral!

PaulJoslin··on Distributed Facebook replacement Diaspora pledged 2x the funding it requested
I would value the overall 'y combinator' experience and expertise as a higher benefit than just the money in the program.

Even if I had an idea which I could self fund, I would still consider applying to Y Combinator, as the experience and networking you would receive would definitely benefit a project greatly.

The only thing that gets on my wick a bit about Kick-starter is that the funders essentially get nothing (other than see the product get created). I.E. This product could go on to be valued at millions and you're initial $1000 contribution to the seed funding would be unrewarded.

PaulJoslin··on Crapmania
Why charge per picture?

Pictures = More likely to get sale, Less likely to disappoint the customer.

I like the idea of making the initial listing of the item easy (although I'm still not sure on the benefits over just making an extremely simple, sell this form with 3 boxes (title, description, price).

What is wrong with taking a small charge for the successful sale? The advantage of this is that everyone wins. The seller will only pay an amount (relatively small) when they have completed a sale and made money (and thus don't mind paying the small fees).

← PreviousPage 3 of 3