HNHacker News
TopNewBestAskShowJobs

PeterHolzwarth

1,043 karma · joined May 22, 2021

"For these causes we declare him traitor and miscreant, enemy of ourselves and of the country. As such we banish him perpetually from all our realms, forbidding all our subjects, of whatever quality, to communicate with him openly or privately - to administer to him victuals, drink, fire, or other necessaries. We allow all to injure him in property or life. We expose the said William of Nassau as an enemy of the human race, giving his property to all who may seize it."

- Granvelle

"I have heard that tomorrow they are to execute the two prisoners, the accomplices of him who shot me. For my part, I most willingly pardon them."

- William of Nassau

submissionscomments
PeterHolzwarth··on Can you stop beans from making you gassy?
I'm not very familiar with this topic. What is the chemical mechanism through which you feel that baking soda reduces undigestible sugars in beans?
PeterHolzwarth··on Just Put It on a Map
A minor thing - I know that article is part of a broader body of work and is not meant to solely present your ideas by itself. But nonetheless, since you linked to it, I had to scan down quite a bit to answer the question that was immediately on my mind: "tax reform for what purpose and why?"

And, an aside, I'd personally recommend getting rid of the emoji bullet-point additions: in this day and age, well, you know.

PeterHolzwarth··on Starlink militarization and its impact on global strategic stability (2023)
"annexed Hong Kong prematurely" ? I'm not sure what you mean here.

Reports I've read are that China was surprised when the UK got in touch a few years before 97, wanting to start the prep work for the handover of HK. China, it seems, just assumed the UK would call HK a historical legacy whose lease agreement was made with a now-defunct country, and leave it at that without a handover.

PeterHolzwarth··on Starlink militarization and its impact on global strategic stability (2023)
I've done so. I saw a country that is a mix of third and first, full of wonderful people who the government fear so much they have to cut them off from the rest of the world and run the place as a police state.
PeterHolzwarth··on Starlink militarization and its impact on global strategic stability (2023)
Oh my goodness, this is deeply untrue. China is facing a massive population implosion. A lot of their global strategy can be understood through that lens: they are racing to accumulate power, standing, and wealth before the implosion starts to kick in.
PeterHolzwarth··on Microsoft BitNet: 100B Param 1-Bit model for local CPUs
Interesting - the account you mention, and the GP, are both doing replies that are themselves all about the same length, and also the same length between the two accounts. I get what you mean.
PeterHolzwarth··on I'm not worried about AI job loss
Most companies won't hire people with a high degree of notoriety. They may hire those people if they have some degree of fame.
PeterHolzwarth··on Can Ozempic Cure Addiction?
Bypassing a paywall does sound a bit like piracy, if you think about it. This is what the commenter is referring to (tho in this case, I don't see a paywall on the article this end.)
PeterHolzwarth··on Surely the crash of the US economy has to be soon
The dot com crash was absolutely expected - today's "cmon, get it over with! crash!" tone we see in regards to the AI bubble is hilariously reminiscent of the late 90s dot com bubble. It was the era that spawned the famous Economist leader "Crash Dammit!"
PeterHolzwarth··on Surely the crash of the US economy has to be soon
This is a great question, and one that drives right to the key issue! (oh god, that sounds like an LLM response, sorry)

Like with the implosion of the Japanese economy, people will just not invest, instead parking their money in low-yield bank accounts. It was, in some cases continues to be, an issue for that country.

PeterHolzwarth··on Surely the crash of the US economy has to be soon
People, or organizations, but mainly people, can just refuse to invest in stuff, parking their money in low-interest bank accounts, or the old style "stuffed into mattresses."

This was the multi-decade problem Japan ran into after its hot economy imploded, and unleashed the "lost decade" (which became decades). It was not a marginal issue, and for year the Japanese government tried everything it could think of to get people to invest in things - to little effect.

PeterHolzwarth··on Surely the crash of the US economy has to be soon
The Economist front page illustration of the 90s .com stock market, with the heading "CRASH DAMMIT!"

Everyone knew there was a bubble. People began to get impatient for what obviously was going to happen, as you say.

PeterHolzwarth··on Surely the crash of the US economy has to be soon
A lot of us don't have time for all the long reads, podcasts, or in-depth videos posted in the discussion here. Able to provide a summary for us that expresses your general point? Those interested can then use your link to learn more.
PeterHolzwarth··on Surely the crash of the US economy has to be soon
>Only to a very small degree and systems like Germany THANK GOD do not have any AI exposure at all.

Well put, and it makes sobering reading to see the impact of what happened the last time Germany was deeply reliant on money from the US.

PeterHolzwarth··on Surely the crash of the US economy has to be soon
This is a profoundly important - central, even - issue that I am very surprised to not see widely understood or acknowledged.

China is in a life-or-death race against time. A good number of their decisions are explained when viewed through this demographic implosion-bomb they are facing.

PeterHolzwarth··on Surely the crash of the US economy has to be soon
Able to summarize what you mean vs just a link?
PeterHolzwarth··on Surely the crash of the US economy has to be soon
>and you have to create constant pressure to ensure that stored wealth is best re-invested in the economy at large

I have no idea if this is true (I've asked economists-in-training, they say they'll get back to me), but I've read that the huge increases in tax rates on high income during the war was less to generate revenue (tho more revenue was certainly a need - there was also a growing focus on growing the number of people who paid taxes, which prior had been quite small), but more to ensure profits were not realized and instead kept invested in the economy and the war machine.

A kind of practical "hodl" to keep the wartime economy stock with reinvestment - or really to discourage removing money from industrial investment - to benefit the war-time economy.

Would like links to things to learn more about this line of reasoning.

PeterHolzwarth··on [dead]
I appreciate people who are confident in their unique, out-of-left-field approach to things!

However, there is value also in being able to demonstrate success. Perhaps you might consider doing both things: pursuing your novel ideas, but also finishing your exams! As the internet meme goes, "why not do both?" There certainly isn't any downside!

PeterHolzwarth··on A Calif. teen trusted ChatGPT's drug advice. He died from an overdose
Ah, I see you added an edit of "I think there's also a legal perception that since AI is a new area, anything related to liability, IP, etc might be "up for grabs"."

I thought perhaps that's what you meant. A bit mercenary of a take, and maybe not applicable to this case. On the other hand, given the legal topic is up for grabs, as you note, I'm sure there will be instances of this tactical approach when it comes to lawsuits happening in the future.

PeterHolzwarth··on A Calif. teen trusted ChatGPT's drug advice. He died from an overdose
>"The models are trained on fake internet conversations where group appeasement is an apparent goal. So now we have machines that just tell us what we clearly already want to hear."

I get what you mean in principle, but the problem I'm struggling with is that this just sounds like the web in general. The kid hits up a subreddit or some obscure forum, and similarly gets group appeasement or what they want to hear from people who are self selected for the forum for being all-in on the topic and Want To Believe, so to speak.

What's the actual difference, in that sense, between that forum or subreddit, and an LLM do you feel?

<edit> And let me add that I don't mean this argumentatively. I am trying to square the idea of ChatGPT, in this case, as being, in the end, fundamentally different from going to a forum full of fans of the topic who are also completely biased and likely full of very poor knowledge.

PeterHolzwarth··on A Calif. teen trusted ChatGPT's drug advice. He died from an overdose
To sue, do you mean? I don't quite understand what you intend to convey. Reddit has moderately deep pockets. A random forum related to drugs doesn't.
PeterHolzwarth··on A Calif. teen trusted ChatGPT's drug advice. He died from an overdose
I don't yet see how this case is any different from trusting stuff you see on the web in general. What's unique about the ChatGPT angle that is notably different from any number of forums, dark-net forums, reddit etc? I don't mean that there isn't potentially something unique here, but my initial thought is that this is a case of "an unfortunate kid typed questions into a web browser, and got horrible advice."

This seems like a web problem, not a ChatGPT issue specifically.

I feel that some may respond that ChatGPTS/LLMs available for chat on the web are specifically worse by virtue of expressing things with some degree of highly inaccurate authority. But again, I feel this represents the Web in general, not uniquely ChatGPTS/LLMs.

Is there an angle here I am not picking up on, do you think?

PeterHolzwarth··on [dead]
fumi2026, I don't pretend to understand much of what you've described, but I'm fascinated by the vim, vigor, and what, tho I don't quite understand it all, is a bit of cheeky humor in your github page.

Tell us more!

PeterHolzwarth··on China Clamps Down on High-Speed Traders, Removing Servers
https://archive.ph/53A0Y
PeterHolzwarth··on Building a Quake PC
Oh the Voodoo2 - that legendary card is up there with the 1080 in terms of sheer "the future is now" impact. The 1080, of course, had the extra benefit of continuing to be a wonderful card for a truly gobsmacking number of years past when one would expect it to have been relegated to "no where near good enough."

And, I continue to be tremendously excited that Fabien is clearly working on the next Game Engine Black Book! I struggle with the conflict of wanting to save it all for when he releases his book vs following along in the short term with his blog posts!

PeterHolzwarth··on Joseph Campbell Meets George Lucas – Part I (2015)
The two rode on each-other's coat tails during their ascent. Lucas was happy to give a "yeah, I was totally thinking that!" when people would point out some classic hero stuff in his simple little wonderful space opera (not damning with faint praise here - Star Wars is a ridiculously wonderful film!).

And Campbell knew a good thing when he saw it, happy to agree that Lucas' film represented a hero's journey.

This was a time when Campbell's writing was entering broad pop consciousness and his speaking engagement schedule was starting to grow: the massive popularity of Star Wars was a great ship to catch a ride on.

People wanted to see a depth in Star Wars that caught Lucas off guard (remember that he just wanted to replicate the exciting, cliff-hanger kids serials of his 1950s childhood). He decided to go with it, saying it was all part of a big plan, "I have ten movies with their stories all plotted out" etc. The reality is he cobbled things together ad-hoc and kind of quickly, with no real overarching intent - something he only decades later finally admitted.

I feel for him: in his mind, he was just a nuts-and-bolts technology guy who loved the "how would I make that?" questions and work far far more than the story he had to come up with to tell. He freely admitted he hated writing. If he had it his way, he would have merely been the head of ILM, excitedly figuring out ways to use new technology to solve film making problems, but Star Wars blew up on him, becoming an over-the-top ultra-success.

The real connection between Lucas and Campbell was nearly non-existent, but it was a useful thing for each of them to strategically latch on to as their popularity began to rapidly grow.

PeterHolzwarth··on 2025: The Year in LLMs
I think it may be all summed up by Roy Amara's observation that "We tend to overestimate the effect of a technology in the short run and underestimate the effect in the long run."
PeterHolzwarth··on 2025: The Year in LLMs
Just an innocent bystander here, so forgive me, but I think the flack you are getting is because you appear to be responding to claims that these tools will reinvent everything and introduce a new halcyon age of creation - when, at least on hacker news, and definitely in this thread, no one is really making such claims.

Put another way, and I hate to throw in the now over-used phrase, but I feel you may be responding to a strawman that doesn't much appear in the article or the discussion here: "Because these tools don't achieve a god-like level of novel perfection that no one is really promising here, I dismiss all this sorta crap."

Especially when I think you are also admitting that the technology is a fairly useful tool on its own merits - a stance which I believe represents the bulk of the feelings that supporters of the tech here on HN are describing.

I apologize if you feel I am putting unrepresentative words in your mouth, but this is the reading I am taking away from your comments.

PeterHolzwarth··on Judge to Texas: You Can't Age-Gate the Internet Without Evidence
This is why I don't by alcohol online for delivery: the delivery person is required by their company to scan my ID. Places I order from already know enough about me - they don't also need a copy of my identification.
PeterHolzwarth··on Iron Beam: Israel's first operational anti drone laser system
They certainly have those for radars! Although the reason for using them is different.

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Corner_reflector

← PreviousPage 4 of 12Next →