HNHacker News
TopNewBestAskShowJobs

PeterHolzwarth

1,043 karma · joined May 22, 2021

"For these causes we declare him traitor and miscreant, enemy of ourselves and of the country. As such we banish him perpetually from all our realms, forbidding all our subjects, of whatever quality, to communicate with him openly or privately - to administer to him victuals, drink, fire, or other necessaries. We allow all to injure him in property or life. We expose the said William of Nassau as an enemy of the human race, giving his property to all who may seize it."

- Granvelle

"I have heard that tomorrow they are to execute the two prisoners, the accomplices of him who shot me. For my part, I most willingly pardon them."

- William of Nassau

submissionscomments
PeterHolzwarth··on U.S. bombs Iranian nuclear sites
Nothing odd about that. I'm thinking of photos of Obama and Hillary in the situation room, observing the strikes on Bin Laden in realtime.
PeterHolzwarth··on U.S. bombs Iranian nuclear sites
In the American body of law and legislation, strikes such as these aren't illegal. Honestly, we've been doing stuff like this for decades.
PeterHolzwarth··on U.S. bombs Iranian nuclear sites
This is absolutely the case. We've been collectively fighting to stop Iran from getting nukes for decades. In much of the middle east, Iran is considered a serious enemy. Iran getting nuclear weapons would mean the rest of the middle east would instantly feel compelled to get their own.
PeterHolzwarth··on U.S. bombs Iranian nuclear sites
I understand what you mean, but we've been in this conflict for decades already. America and loads of other countries have been working to stop Iran from achieving nuclear weapons. Remember that in much of the middle east, Iran is considered an enemy. A nuclear armed Iran would result in the rest of the middle east rapidly pursuing nukes by way of defense against Iran - a country most of the middle east views as a combatant and an enemy.

I won't comment or discuss who you voted for - that isn't germane here. What is important is that America has been working for decades - often quite blatantly, sometimes with the thinnest veneer of deniability - to stop Iran from getting nukes. We're now just saying the quiet part out loud.

PeterHolzwarth··on U.S. bombs Iranian nuclear sites
No, it is not illegal for a US president to authorize strikes like this. American hasn't formally declared war since WWII.

Iran has been pursuing nuclear weapons for decades - and no one, especially no one in the middle east - wants a nuclear armed Iran. America and its partners - and quite often its not-partners - have been working to stop Iranian uranium enrichment for a very long time.

As for "guarantees they will pursue nuclear weapons by all means" -- that's the point: they've already been doing so nonstop for decades.

In much of the middle east, Iran is detested, and a nuclear armed Iran is deeply feared throughout the region. Iran with nukes means the rest of the middle east will feel compelled to pursue nuclear weapons as well. Again, in vast swaths of the middle east, Iran is considered an enemy.

PeterHolzwarth··on U.S. bombs Iranian nuclear sites
On the contrary, nobody wants a nuclear armed Iran. It's been an open not-even-secret for decades that America is very active, on many fronts, in trying to delay or remove Iran's growing capability to create nuclear weapons.
PeterHolzwarth··on U.S. bombs Iranian nuclear sites
By the body of American legislative tradition, no this is not an act of war. In fact, we haven't declared one since WWII.
PeterHolzwarth··on U.S. bombs Iranian nuclear sites
It turns out (and I didn't realize this until I looked back into it just a few years ago) that the 70s/80s concept of nuclear winter is discredited and believed not to be something that would arise from a global thermonuclear holocaust.
PeterHolzwarth··on U.S. bombs Iranian nuclear sites
Well put, and an important - and often either overlooked or fully unknown - point, especially in the west.

Many in the west see the middle east as a broadly similar unit, not realizing that there Iran represents a frequently highly-disliked section in the broader area. The neutralization of Iraq definitely has had an impact on that front as well (the two being hard core enemies for a long time).

PeterHolzwarth··on U.S. bombs Iranian nuclear sites
A country doesn't acquire nukes to use them. They acquire them to freeze specific layers of conflict. Actually using them among peers invites annihilation.
PeterHolzwarth··on U.S. has bombed Fordo nuclear plant in attack on Iran
I don't think this makes much sense, due to the scale of the two parties: Iran somehow figuring out how to get a nuke onto a US city would invite complete and total annihilation of Iran -- and the world would largely support it. Iran knows this.

Nukes among peers aren't there to be used. They are there to immobilize and freeze a layer of conflict.

PeterHolzwarth··on Dead Hand automatic nuclear weapons control system
It's an interesting look into the philosophy of America vs the USSR: distributed and resilient decision-making vs extreme centralization.

The proto-internet was conceived in no small part as a nuke-tolerant command and control system allowing communication to continue even if, say, Chicago or Seattle (with its nearby ICBM-submarine pens) got glassed by thermonuclear weapons (route around damage). Responsibility and operational capability distributed to survive a number of locations removed from a command and control network. If you squint in a certain way, you can see a touch of democracy there.

On the other hand, the Soviet fail-deadly doctrine represents extreme totalitarian centralization where no external node is trusted: if the center goes down, that is considered complete failure and zero-sum "make sure the other side gets fully torched if we do" is the standing order.

I know this is an excessive interpretation of the sensibilities of the west vs the USSR, but I've always felt the two sides broader ideologies are encapsulated in their respective approaches to the impact of nuclear warfare.

However, thank goodness calmer heads prevailed in the USSR among the rank and file. See:

(Avoided triggering WWIII during the Cuban Missile Crisis) https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Vasily_Arkhipov

(Avoided triggering WWIII during the height of the Cold War in the 80s) https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Stanislav_Petrov

PeterHolzwarth··on BBS: The Documentary [video]
Itself a great callback to the days of the perpetually feisty Derek Smart!
PeterHolzwarth··on BBS: The Documentary [video]
From the wonderful Jason Scott, now of the Internet Archive. I wonder if this post of the documentary on youtube is alright with him? (I guess it's been on youtube for quite some time.)
PeterHolzwarth··on The State of Rideshare and Autonomous Vehicles
Largely flat (SF not withstanding) and largely sunny.
PeterHolzwarth··on Adaline
Is it really necessary to have your site also use:

+ ahrefs.com

+ attributationapp.com

+ getkoala.com

+ googletagmanager.com

+ hs-scripts.com

+ plausible.io

+ redditstatic.com

?

PeterHolzwarth··on I have discovered a new number (with Mathematical Proof)
Despite sometimes difficult side-effects, it is generally wise to stay on one's medication. And, on another front, it's also generally wise to avoid the internet, or at least your keyboard, when on hallucinogens.
PeterHolzwarth··on Novo Nordisk's patent on Ozempic expired in Canada over unpaid $450 late fee
If this is legitimate, it will create a very interesting prescription situation in North America.
PeterHolzwarth··on To fuel AI, US Congress moves to fast-track nuclear plant approvals
An unexpected way for pro-nuclear-power fans to get the ball rolling on accelerated approvals for new reactors, but I'm sure they will gladly accept it.
PeterHolzwarth··on Britain's biggest companies are preparing for a third world war
Practical.
PeterHolzwarth··on South Korea votes for new president after failed martial law bid
This, my friends, is quite a relief.
PeterHolzwarth··on GM's New Hybrid Patent
I continue to feel that hybrid represents the best of both worlds in the medium term as we continue an ongoing trend that ultimately ends in fully electric vehicles.
PeterHolzwarth··on Why Space Radiation Matters
I feel compelled to mention the issue of non-space-based flight attendants and aircraft pilots experiencing significantly elevated radiation, career-wise, vs us terrestrial working stiffs, too. Tho I vaguely recall a banana comparison that puts, if not aircraft time - at least cigarette smoking, into perspective.
PeterHolzwarth··on Meditation can be harmful – and can even make mental health problems worse
I don't feel like you are responding to the points made in the article. Which parts of the article and the quoted research do you find are"a joke" ? What do you base your refutation on? Links appreciated!
PeterHolzwarth··on ChatGPT misquoted Neil Armstrong – our governed agent corrected it
Your "we" link is to twitter? Surely there's better ways to link to yourself.
PeterHolzwarth··on My AI skeptic friends are all nuts
Wow, I'm surprised this post hasn't gotten hit by the HN flame-war detector: We have threads downvoted into forced-collapsed that are headed by completely innocuous comments. It really is strange how people here are not able to accept different viewpoints in a discussion: I've three times now returned to the comments to just blanket-upvote everything that's starting to turn grey.
PeterHolzwarth··on Microsoft to finally stop shoving Edge down your throat
... in the EU.
PeterHolzwarth··on GenAI Is Our Polyester
I like the polyester metaphor, but this phrase:

"Our era's particular neoliberal hyper-connected, hyper-capitalist economy is creating a lot of profit for a few people.."

I feel is off base: the last 20 years has seen the absolute carpet-bombing of the very definition of American middle class. An entire new layer of workers (tech workers in their tens upon tens upon tens of thousands) make salaries that blow the old-trend / old-trajectory middle class out of the water.

I understand that the modern tech world has created billionaires in astonishing numbers, but I dislike skipping over the part where vast numbers of people in America are making in some cases full-on double what a without-them income trajectory would see for our middle class. FAANG salaries aren't representative - I get it. But those FAANG salaries are being paid to vast numbers of people - and salaries that what I'll call a "conventional" middle class person blanches at.

Tech cities are experiencing massive inflation in no small part due to this entirely new explosion of what we have to now call the new "upper middle class," at a scale that is unprecedented in the moderate-range past.

Tech has created a wild number of billionaires - I understand that. But it has also created an entirely new, and substantially large, additional income-demographic slice that didn't exit much before.

So to disagree with the author, tech has created unprecedented wealth for a very large number of people.

PeterHolzwarth··on My AI skeptic friends are all nuts
"I got into this profession precisely because I wanted to give precise instructions to a machine and get exactly what I want."

So you didn't get into this profession to be lead then eh?

Because essentially, that's what Thomas in the article is describing (even if he doesn't realize it). He is a mini-lead with a team of a few junior and lower-mid-level engineers - all represented by LLM and agents he's built.

PeterHolzwarth··on My AI skeptic friends are all nuts
I see no straw men in his arguments: what i see are pretty much daily direct quotes pasted in from HN comments.
← PreviousPage 8 of 12Next →