HNHacker News
TopNewBestAskShowJobs

Pfhreak

9,045 karma · joined July 1, 2012

submissionscomments
Pfhreak··on U.S.'s Biggest Gasoline Pipeline Halted After Cyberattack
I'm surprised we don't see more attacks on pipelines - both digital and physical. There are many folks out there who take issue with them or see them as a vulnerable part of our infrastructure.
Pfhreak··on Show HN: Lovetris – Tetris which always gives you the best piece
I'm just surprised the community made the critique on this version but not the other one.
Pfhreak··on Goodwill doesn't want broken toasters
Because it implies an unequal distribution of the profits from the labor people invest in the company.

And splitting the company in two like you proposed would almost certainly result in some pretty big changes, as one company would be all workers and the other would be all bosses.

Pfhreak··on Goodwill doesn't want broken toasters
I've volunteered one offs before. A local urban farm needed to plant dozens of trees. They spent 15 minutes teaching them turned loose the group. We got them planted in like an hour. Then we moved onto weeding and litter cleanup.
Pfhreak··on Show HN: Lovetris – Tetris which always gives you the best piece
I mean, Hatetris probably wasn't using the Tetris trademarks properly, right? Aren't both just remix culture?
Pfhreak··on Goodwill doesn't want broken toasters
Cool. You've just made some low wage worker deal with your trash. The CEO will never ever be impacted by your action, but one or more people in your local community definitely will.

Have a little more respect and empathy for those around you.

Pfhreak··on Goodwill doesn't want broken toasters
This is a big problem with charities and other donation driven organizations. People want to say where their donations go, and will often leave gifts for flashy things that can't be used for general purposes. General donations can fill in any gaps and are therefore some of the highest value donations.

No one donates and says, please restrict this donation to the purchase of basic janitorial supplies. But that doesn't change the fact they still need those supplies.

Pfhreak··on Goodwill doesn't want broken toasters
Why should CEOs anywhere get significant salaries? The gap between the lowest and highest paid position always matters, non profit or not.
Pfhreak··on Goodwill doesn't want broken toasters
The parent poster provided factual information about a logical fallacy. They did not connect your post to the fallacy, they just gave readers information to draw their own conclusions.
Pfhreak··on Beyond Meat’s Beyond Burger life cycle assessment (2018)
What do cattle eat in CAFOs, and how much of their lives are spent there and how much more do they eat there than when they are younger and smaller? And where does that food come from?
Pfhreak··on Beyond Meat’s Beyond Burger life cycle assessment (2018)
You are aware of how beef is raised, right? From antibiotics to increase mass, to an unnatural grain based diet, to confinement and CAFOs. Beef you get at the supermarket is far from "natural."
Pfhreak··on Beyond Meat’s Beyond Burger life cycle assessment (2018)
There's some really great vegetarian options from world cuisine. I draw heavily on Mexican, Indian, Italian, Greek, Turkish, and southeast Asian cuisine in my home cooking. It's a nice variety and a good challenge to find the simple recipes that don't try to replace meat but instead taste excellent without it.
Pfhreak··on Beyond Meat’s Beyond Burger life cycle assessment (2018)
Health is not the reason these products exist. I buy them because I want an unhealthy treat that doesn't have the same ecological or animal rights impacts as beef.

If 10% of whopper sales switch to impossible whoppers, that's a big deal, and foods like this can provide a bridge to consumers who have never considered vegetarianism.

I do buy or grow local food, I'm a vegetarian myself. Your view is, in my opinion, too black and white. There's serious momentum around plant based meals, and that's making even more plant based foods available elsewhere.

Pfhreak··on The AskHistorians subreddit banned Holocaust deniers (2018)
You know, I could have sworn I read in the guidelines somewhere that downvotes aren't to be used just to signal that you disagree, but in diving a bit deeper I think that's just one of those things that people say, but doesn't actually ground to any specific rules/guidelines.

And in fact, an early post says the opposite -- downvoting because you disagree is fine: https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=117171

Pfhreak··on The AskHistorians subreddit banned Holocaust deniers (2018)
I feel the same, actually. I'm a Marxist. I often get downvoted for mentioning something about socialism or social justice in general. I believe many of those downvotes are because the community here is not particularly fond of that ideology.

I get it. I'm not particularly fond of lots of ideologies. But I don't have tools here to differentiate between, "I disagree" and "Your comment is structurally bad (rude/breaks the rules/is low effort/etc."

I think we'd both benefit from breaking the coupling between those two reasons to downvote. (And yes, I'm aware that downvoting because you disagree is against the rules, but I don't think that stops anyone. :D )

Pfhreak··on The AskHistorians subreddit banned Holocaust deniers (2018)
> can you honestly not understand the dangers of the path you're going down?

I downvoted you, and I consider your question here hyperbolic. I don't think you are being disingenuous, I believe that you sincerely hold your belief, I just view your concerns as a modern day Chicken Little claiming the sky is falling. I've looked at the same set of data and come to different conclusions than you.

I don't think we'll see eye to eye, and I don't think it's likely we'll convince each other of anything, so I don't know how worthwhile this comment even is, but I thought I'd pass it along as a "Here's one reason why people might be downvoting you and here's how you are being perceived."

Maybe that's not valuable, maybe you already know that's why people are downvoting. I dunno, it just felt like you were accusing your downvoters of not being rational actors, and I suspect your downvoters look at you the same way?

Pfhreak··on The AskHistorians subreddit banned Holocaust deniers (2018)
How do you propose handling the asymmetry between asking questions and answering them?

It's much, much cheaper for someone with outlandish views to shotgun you with questions than it is to answer them all in detail.

Combine this with the fact that there are fewer experts than there are trolls/people with outlandish views.

Further combine this with the fact that the trolls/outlandish views folks are not coming to get themselves educated, they are coming to try and convince others to hold their outlandish views.

How do you propose we keep a community resilient against that?

Pfhreak··on The AskHistorians subreddit banned Holocaust deniers (2018)
> The solution to bad ideas is more ideas, not less.

This is true if and only if there is sufficient bandwidth to process all those ideas AND the actors are all people who are trying to learn/seek truth.

Expertise and conversation time is limited, and it's considerably cheaper to ask questions and sow doubt than it is to fully address those questions. Given that asymmetry, it feels more than reasonable to accept certain things as ground truth and eliminate time wasted on dealing with trolls.

Pfhreak··on Why I Work on Ads
Can you advocate for doing an ethical thing like that and not have it be considered bragging? I've often wondered about how to encourage others to give more, volunteer more.

If I don't do those things (or don't claim to), people will say, "Why should I do that? You don't do that! Hypocrite."

If I do those things, people will say, "You are just bragging/virtue signaling."

Pfhreak··on Why I Work on Ads
> $10/year YT subscription disappears into the background

I used to live off of $7,000 a year. $10/year is something I'd seriously think about.

I'd be careful about generalizing a fixed cost subscription's impact. Typically, it will hit poorer communities harder than wealthy communities.

Pfhreak··on The California Exception
Good luck applying this at a place like Amazon.
Pfhreak··on 1700 Cascadia Earthquake
Reminder to folks that water, food, blankets, and tools are reasonable things to have stored away if you live in the PNW (or anywhere, really), and are relatively low maintenance to store.
Pfhreak··on 1700 Cascadia Earthquake
Add onto this that many or most of the mountains in the area are active volcanoes that are overdue for an eruption, and the Seattle area could be in for a real bad time over the next 250 years.

The projections of a moderate eruption of Mount Rainier (aka Tahoma/Tacoma) include flows reaching all the way to Renton/South Seattle.

Pfhreak··on The California Exception
Protections for workers in tech are better too. Things like moonlighting and protecting your intellectual property is easier in California than most places in the states.

In most of the country, your employer can claim 100% of your intellectual output, no matter if your work was 'on your time'. If you come up with something clever on the weekend on your own computer, your employer still owns it.

(Aside, I think this is one issue that could be a motivation for unionizing tech folks.... or at least collectively bargaining.)

Pfhreak··on Live feed of Starship SN15 flight test [video]
Fire and a few pops/pings/small explosions in the engine area, but didn't appear to destabilize the rocket, which is a good sign.
Pfhreak··on On incels, dead bedrooms and the hard problems of loneliness
> most obvious solution is to go back to enforced monogamy. Nothing repugnant about that...

And there it is. Yes, that stance is awful. Going back implies removing the right of women to choose who they partner with. Enforced monogamy removes the ability of folks to choose how many partners they have. And who gets to define 'monogamy' and who does the enforcement?

It also completely ignores the poly folks out there, or the folks who are not interested in long term relationships.

It's at best, a narrow and puritanical view of human sexuality.

Pfhreak··on Facebook's Trump ban upheld by Oversight Board, for now
I'll bite, I down voted because you seem excited about the inevitable clash between laws that are almost certainly unconstitutional/ill conceived/partisan, and social media companies.

It seems like a gigantic waste of time, at best, to try and enact and enforce those laws. Also, it's going to open a gnarly can of worms when someone weaponizes them by running for office to get themselves unbanned from a platform.

Pfhreak··on Facebook's Trump ban upheld by Oversight Board, for now
Depending on how it is set up, I could see them being considered independent. If Facebook set aside the money and legally sheltered it from their own influence via a trust or something, then that could be considered fairly independent.
Pfhreak··on On incels, dead bedrooms and the hard problems of loneliness
> Which is?

Let me use an analogy. As a manager I help my folks get promoted all the time. The folks who struggle the most are the ones who think about promotion as a set of checkbox items they have to cross off. The ones who are easily promoted are the ones who are looking less at the criteria and more at how they can be introspective and develop themselves.

Framing finding a relationship in a "I'll just check these checkboxes and then I will immediately get a relationship" fundamentally misunderstands that we aren't generally selecting partners for one trait. No one is working from a checklist when they select their partners, so why set yourself up to fail by imagining they are.

Develop a growth mindset, focus on building your skills, build rich and fulfilling friendships. Ask for feedback and accept it. Build others up. People will want to be around you.

> Did you not look at the evidence?

I did a cursory Google search, which suggested online dating results in roughly the same outcomes as in person dating.

> How is this supposed to not create a class of universally rejected men?

If you are suggesting that 80% of men will face universal rejection, I find that extraordinarily hard to believe. It's quite frankly trivially falsifiable.

> Why bother?

Because you've made vague gestures that somehow society is to blame, but won't say how you'd fix it. Either that means you aren't sure, which undermines the idea that society is actually to blame, or your ideas are so repugnant that you are afraid to show them the light of day. You do not get to claim a moral victory by claiming to be a victim and then failing to engage with even the lightest questioning of your narrative.

Pfhreak··on On incels, dead bedrooms and the hard problems of loneliness
So... Oppress women is the solution you are proposing here? Why have you gendered it at all? Why do women have to face social stigma and not men? What about gay relationships, presumably you'd apply the same thinking (en route to a marriage or married)? What about poly relationships?

> I think from society's perspective, my wife should owe me a relationship.

I'm going to assume you mean owes you a supportive, caring, platonic relationship. Eg, two married people support one another to their mutual benefit. I'm going to assume you don't mean to imply your spouse owes you sex.

← PreviousPage 3 of 34Next →