1,448 karma · joined October 1, 2019
We share the same biology, regardless of Ideology
The monthly fee I can understand (but also feel there is a bit of mark-up on it to nudge customers towards IPv6).
I guess since it's their service, they have an absolute right to charge what they like (and let the competition decide) but the set up fees are just not going market rates.
Point I'm trying to make is - charging € 435.20 per month for a /24 is expensive but sort of ok ... but the € 4864.00 set-up fee?
Seriously? It costs € 152.00 for a /29 subnet but it costs 32x MORE to set up a /24 subnet? Is it really 32 times more work to set up?
How often have politicians of all countries said and promised to enact or revoke certain policies during their election campaign and then developed amnesia, stalled until outrage dies down or simply shrug until re-election time?
People don't always get the government they deserve.
Never been to the place but looks like one of those cool places to go to when in the area so it's a shame about it shutting down.
So - in a theoretical situation you are looking at what is known as a re-play attack.
Ping the same message to all cell numbers in a block (discovering who does and does not have Telegram installed)
Once you have that, ping a message to a group of interest that has an invite only policy.
Ping that message to all in that group of numbers to see who has read/received that message. You now have a list of active in that group list of numbers.
Once you have that - delay some messages so they appear out of order to some (but not all) users in that group.
Create FUD re security (omg, did we just get hacked??? Coz messages are turning up crazy out of order aka WTF?)
Target group falls back to fall-back comms method.
Profit.
The "My Server, My Rules" point of view is absolutely 100% valid ( and also why I commented about asymmetrical ftth).
But, What I am also saying is this -
At what point did the Google that was the 'Do No Evil' version pivot in to a position such as they are currently taking?
When did the ethos of 'Let's do good things for good reasons for the good of humanity' pivot to what is potentially a Section 230 nightmare?
To repeat my question - Who judges (and adjudicates) what is or is not misleading or confusing?
I mean - Who gets to define 'misleading and/or confusing'? Google? A court case?
If they (Google) want to impose restrictions such as "Do not distribute content that deceives, misleads, or confuses users" - Might I suggest that they apply those very same standards to their own behavior.
* But who can watch the watchmen? *
I am grateful that I have a symmetric ftth connection. Information (correct or incorrect) needs to be free - as in Free to be expressed; Free to be ridiculed; Free to be disseminated; Free to be discussed; Free to be exposed to the light of day.
It is for the people themselves to decide what they do or do not believe.
Do I want Google to decide what is or is not misleading or confusing? Eh??? Say Whhaaatttt!!! Ever read a contracts terms and conditions? They can be as confusing AF… so uhhmm Yep – Let’s Ban ‘em! Woot!
Google, Eat Your Own Dogfood.
"In particular, Telegram encrypts acknowledgement messages, i.e. messages that encode that a previous message was indeed received, but the way it handles the re-sending of unacknowledged messages leaks whether such an acknowledgement was sent and received. "
That ^ bit is indeed of interest. Having this ability could be useful in two ways that immediately spring to mind if I were a 'james bond villain'
I am currently taking a skim through the paper which for the curious is available at https://mtpsym.github.io/paper.pdf (52 pages)
[Edit] Will leave it to those better qualified regarding the math but uhhmm yeah, A good summary is yes, there were somethings that could have been exploited and were patched by the Telegram team and a bug bounty awarded (as noted in the article). The thing I found of interest bit turned out indeed to be in the 'highly theoretical' realm. As in "only on a wet Wednesday when the wind is blowing from the west at a precise angle way"
When person X buys item Y from company Z, company Z is unlikely to broadcast that fact. Ergo, the 'system' doesn't know that you have now brought item Y and that you no longer have an active interest in purchasing Y.
*Things may have changed in 20 years so the above is just an outdated observation based on a brief stint at a turn of the century B2B marketing start-up.
Excerpt from their KB
Navigator.sendBeacon() .... It’s intended to be used for sending analytics data to a web server, and avoids some of the problems with legacy techniques for sending analytics, such as the use of XMLHttpRequest.
https://developer.mozilla.org/en-US/docs/Web/API/Navigator/s...
Seems enough reason to me to not want your name plastered all over the internet.
Do you make it clear to your customers that you are selling a product that uses a cheap knock-off board?
I would hope the answer to that is 'yes' so I'm curious about what their reaction/responses have been?
Do the "Arduinos" you use in your device have any markings that are different from a genuine Arduino?
https://text.npr.org/1012317032
(for some reason the usual trick of substituting the www with text didn't work and kept on redirecting to their cookie pop-up)
(note I'm just using mcD & walmart as place-holder company names, have no idea if they operate their public wi-fi that way)
1400 / 24 (hours per day) = ~58 per hour (round up to 60)
60 / 60 (seconds) = 1 per minute so nope, he was hammering at it 24/7 (unless my maths is totally wrong which is always possible).
Appologies if this has already been asked & answered - a quick skim didn't show anything related to the "why?"
None in particular stood out enough to provide as an illustration but I certainly detected a general tone of confusion.
I must confess that after reading the original announcement I was still none the wiser until well past the 3/4 page mark and by that point my eyes had glazed over slightly. That might be more to do with that Kubernetes isn't something I use so possibly for someone that did have an active interest in the topic may have had their interest/curiosity piqued earlier enough in the release announcement to reach the ‘reveal’.
All of the above is obviously a personal opninion so is entirely subjective.
https://www.telegraph.co.uk/technology/news/8438461/BT-and-P...
Because I stick to the 'mental rules' of only rubbing it off once the task is completed, if I'm uncertain if I've done the thing / task I can look down to my hand to see if that mark is still there or not. If it is - U-Turn time!
It Works pretty well (as always, mileage may vary) even for multiple things if needed although the random letters/marks on the back of your hand can make people curious but if it does I simply say - It's a list of stuff I need to do.
Rather than downvoting your comment I opted to reply to it since it may provide a bit more information for you to base your judgement on about "things being muddier".
As for your last comment about their abilities - forgive me but that sounds incredibly unfair and unwarranted and verges on being a personal attack.
Posted this because of a recent “Ask HN” from a few days ago asking for any low-cost, high impact start-up ideas for low-skilled tech-workers.
When I came across this today I immediately thought - Wow, this is an idea that could exponentially scale - Think graduates/high grade course completer's then being recruited to work for your start-up to be mentors then progressing to graders then up to tutors as a Win-Win – They get their first ‘real job’, Company gets employees loyal to the idea/concept. Career progression built right in to the buisiness plan as you expand your pool of mentors,graders,tutors etc as they progress upwards/onwards/outwards in to other (new to them) courses.
Perhaps Exercism already do this - but in terms of achieving a self-perpetuating growth perhaps part funded initially by local grants, VC etc it struck me as a possibly valid business model that seemed a reasonable fit with his ask HN.
It's the principle of it that I object to. So on the basis of "...fair, Your server/service, Your rules" I just avoid pinging those hosts that do this out of pure principle.
(Am pretty certain that Shodan is another one that does it, especially from IPv6 sources and from memory maybe bbc.com/bbc.co.uk does it too (it's been a while and can't remember the other few that I've seen that do this when checking firewall logs) Other HN'ers might know of some others that do this too.
I mean - Why? It's just darn rude.
[Edit, meant to add that I know why Shodan does this and it is too help them map the IPv6 address space, so Doubly F.U.]
O.T. Alert: Out of habbit I always ping a known i.p address first then pinging a $.com to double check. It's always a head-desk moment when you've spent X minutes checking the code (I mean, it pinged out ok so that can't be the source of the timeouts and errors right?) before trying a ping to a $.com. The head-Desk moment was of course realising the network errors weren't in the code but that the FW dropping any traffic on port 53. Lol (not).
Uhmm ok so far - but then I read this ... "He is also a co-founder of Agragene, a biotech company"
Uhmm ok so no possible conflict of interest there then right? And I’m sure he is in a position to provide a non-biased analysis of the "Risks and Rewards" of the program. /s
A further quote at the end of the article has this from him .. "We’re excited about this because we were able to eliminate the populations in experimental cages in the lab. And we think this technology might be a next-generation technology that can be used alongside the Oxitec technology. The outcome is very similar."
Well, that is doubly reassuring about his impartiality on the subject. /s
TFA then continues with the rather not-so re-assuring ... "The EPA has done its due diligence and tested many of the potential side effects of this technology." Uhmm yeah, the EPA have a great track record (rolls eyes). And the ‘many’ in that quote just gave me a ‘we tested a huge & bigly number of things’ vibe.
This sort of thing has been tried elsewhere and I’ve never heard of one being successful over the long term (5+ years). Sure, I’ve seen of a few reports at the 2 -3 year trial period exclaiming remarkable results but then everything sort of goes a bit quiet and some idle digging turns up either nothing or perhaps a local newspaper report about the trial being discontinued and not expanded to other areas.
I’m sure there must be at least some some trials that are able to demonstrate that this sort of approach works in the long term (10+ years) and if so if anyone here is aware of such research I would gladly take an idle read but so far all I’ve ever seen is the ‘ah – that was the OLD method, Our sooper-dooper new technology is absolutely gonna nail it this time’.
I mean on the one hand - if you don’t try you will never succeed or solve any problem. But the part of me that grew up watching insects morph in to super villains after landing in “green glowing gloop” would much rather that Scientific America had tried a little harder to find an expert to interview that was much more able to not feel any commercial, financial or academic pressure and was therefore much more likely to be able to provide an objective and nuanced opinion.
I mean – how on earth do you put the genie back in the bottle? Erect giant mosquito nets around the whole state?
I would suggest that going that route is better than polluting the HN submission queue with these and similar ‘Eternal September’ ask HN type postings.
Karma be damned, It needed to be said.