HNHacker News
TopNewBestAskShowJobs

Planktonne

2,928 karma · joined April 12, 2019

submissionscomments
Planktonne··on How to Write with an LLM
> But most of the writing is usually, these are the ideas, this is how the idea are structured together, now let's review them and then let's get a nice prose out of it.

I know lots of AI-enabled writers believe this, but I've never actually seen it be true.

Planktonne··on Why I'm still bearish on LLMs after Navier-Stokes
But then the human should also get Stockfish, and we're back at a stalemate.
Planktonne··on An interactive world map of the stories cultures have told
I think projects like this--feeding a bunch of incomplete information into AI and making a glossy-but-shallow output--do more harm than good.

How stories and created and shared and transmitted is a vast and complex field, something well worth diving into and addressing properly. Reducing that to a single output made without care presents beautiful richness as a solved and simple detail.

Planktonne··on Why I'm still bearish on LLMs after Navier-Stokes
That would mean we should consider any human with coding knowledge a chess grandmaster, which is obviously not the case.
Planktonne··on A rough guide for going back to the Moon
That's part of my complaint. More and more money is poured into 'innovation' across our society, but what do we have to show for it?
Planktonne··on A rough guide for going back to the Moon
It's hard not to see this as a consolation prize. In 1969, we went to the moon.

In 2026, with all the benefits of a tech industry that has become ever more powerful, with endless money poured into innovation, our 'rough guide back to the moon' is an AI model that maps it. It's powerful and impressive, of course, and doubtless very useful to researchers, and space exploration is not a priority--all of that is true, sure.

But to have the fruits of 50+ years of technological progress result not in going back to the moon, or onto other challenges, but just a refinement in looking at the moon. Is this the best giant leap we can muster now? So much innovation and yet we lack a capability we used to have.

I know there are all sorts of ways to explain this away, but it still makes me sad.

Planktonne··on XCancel service is suspended until further notice
> Xcancel scrapes and then competes directly with X, whereas LLM labs scrape the internet to make an agentic intelligent bot, a transformative use of the scraped content.

It seems unreasonable to stop there though; the agentic bots are designed and marketed as able to compete with the initially-scraped sources.

I'm not convinced that a competitive use at one remove should be treated as not competitive.

Planktonne··on Don't be the out of touch Kung Fu master
Would that really count as a 'massive benefit' then?
Planktonne··on Don't be the out of touch Kung Fu master
I don't agree that people do see that, and if they do, it's hardly an overwhelming trend.
Planktonne··on Don't be the out of touch Kung Fu master
> those who learn to use AI effectively are seeing massive benefits

The massive benefits should be visible to outside observers as well, but where are they?

Planktonne··on The worst spam emails: iLands AI agent hustle
AI can be very helpful in lots of ways, but I think it's fair to say that it is most powerful as an enabler for bad actors.
Planktonne··on Navier-Stokes Announcement
> The statement is so sterile they don't even mention who solved it.

Possibly because of the ongoing debate about who actually deserves credit.

Planktonne··on google.com/goto: Google's anti-scraping update
If the query is just 'python', then both you and your neighbour should get some links for the language and some for the animal.

If it only gives you the one you already know about, it's a useless tool.

Planktonne··on Resist "AI"
There's nothing more thought-suppressing than dismissing all equation to fascism as thought suppression.

If we actually agreed on the principle, you wouldn't be engaging in the behaviour.

Planktonne··on Resist "AI"
You're engaging in worse faith; dismissing all criticism because it draws a parallel you don't like isn't reasonable.

Sometimes, it will be fascism. "It's never fascism" is not a good heuristic.

Planktonne··on Resist "AI"
That's a lot of leaping to conclusions based on a small criticism.

I'm rather tired, personally, of the HN trope of people saying that AI is bad for/mis-used by everyone except a carefully-defined group that consists of exactly them.

If you're curious now only with AI, I'd say that makes you less curious--"intellectually hungry"--than the people who were curious before, without AI. It's great that you feel you can be more curious now, but I wouldn't be so quick to declare yourself superior to others with no more evidence than that you use AI the same amount.

Planktonne··on Resist "AI"
> I do think that for the atypical user that is "information-hungry,"

> Prior to AI, I would have just... not spent the time looking them up.

You're putting yourself in the group of people who are 'information-hungry', but your own evidence suggests that's not the case.

Planktonne··on Resist "AI"
I don't think that's a reasonable read; you can't dismiss a specific criticism on the (unsupported) ground that the person making it would totally have dismissed anything at all.
Planktonne··on Resist "AI"
> feel no need to differentiate themselves from other anti-technology arguments

Why should they? Other "anti-tech" arguments include

- Concern about global warming/pollution

- Resistance to nuclear/chemical warfare

It's not just, or even primarily, that anti-tech arguments are the equivalent of 'cameras will steal souls'.

Planktonne··on More questions about whether researchers can trust OpenAI with unpublished math
I answered your initial question in good faith, but it's increasingly clear each time you shift the goalposts that you're more interested in JAQ than discussing.

As before, despite your prevarication, I've provided examples of

- Massive lawsuits

- Risks to consumer trust

That's what was asked for; your assertion that it will totally all be fine doesn't invalidate that.

I know you are excited to quibble endlessly over this, but it's transparently disingenuous each time you jump to a new point and pretend it was there originally.

Consider: if your point was defensible, you would have been able to make it honestly.

Planktonne··on More questions about whether researchers can trust OpenAI with unpublished math
They're being sued for several issues that resulted in the deaths of users; that's not fraud, but it is against their users.

The parallel still holds, and the information is still on the page I linked.

Planktonne··on Amazon pilots ad services in ChatGPT
The smartest minds in advertising convinced everyone they were in tech.
Planktonne··on More questions about whether researchers can trust OpenAI with unpublished math
Nonsense; the claim was that they wouldn't do anything that would mean they'd be

> risking massive lawsuits and a total loss of trust

Evidence of the massive lawsuits and lack of trust seems pretty relevant.

Planktonne··on More questions about whether researchers can trust OpenAI with unpublished math
You can read their Wikipedia page [1].

[1] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/OpenAI#Governance_and_legal_is...

Planktonne··on More questions about whether researchers can trust OpenAI with unpublished math
They've done similar things with similar risks repeatedly.
Planktonne··on Copyright does more harm than good and should be abolished
The industrial revolution and the British empire are both extremely clear proof that Britain was in no way 'crippled'. Particularly not in the world of knowledge, given the countless inventions involved.

If the creation of copyright was so harmful to the nation, why was there no harm?

Planktonne··on Flock Wants a Closely Surveilled World with No Exit
It's not clear that it actually does help solve crimes. It might even exacerbate them.

There's been a lot of stalking enabled by Flock cameras.

Planktonne··on Copyright does more harm than good and should be abolished
> in 1710, that crippled the world of knowledge in the United Kingdom

How do you account for the industrial revolution under this framing, or the global dominance of the British Empire?

Its really hard to argue that 1710 onwards marked the downfall of Britain, given everything that happened in history after that.

Planktonne··on Copyright does more harm than good and should be abolished
I know this is a popular take on HN, but it's very much one that collapses the moment you think about it. Abolishing copyright would only enable the large corporations further.
Planktonne··on Copyright does more harm than good and should be abolished
> A possible first step could be giving copyright owners a single obligation: you have to sell what you own

This would be wildly unreasonable and totally unethical. Every picture taken by a photographer has to be available on the market immediately?

Think through the ethical implications of that.

← PreviousPage 2 of 33Next →