HNHacker News
TopNewBestAskShowJobs

Planktonne

2,928 karma · joined April 12, 2019

submissionscomments
Planktonne··on Copyright does more harm than good and should be abolished
Mandating that creators lose control and the ability to profit from their work almost immediately will absolutely not encourage the production of new works.
Planktonne··on We have a year to fix security everywhere
There's no logic here already; the principle you should be applying is Hitchen's razor[1].

There is no reason to assume that super intelligent evil AI with magic powers will appear; while we are purely in the realm of (hackneyed) fantasy, why stop at imagining just one thing? You can build the whole story, not just the basilisk.

The parent comment is a story, not a prediction; it should be treated like one.

[1] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Hitchens%27s_razor

Planktonne··on We have a year to fix security everywhere
You don't need to shut down open-weight models to avoid SkyNet; it's not relevant at all.
Planktonne··on We have a year to fix security everywhere
This is groundless speculation; if you're going to go that far off the map, then we don't need to worry because a good AI (blue eyes not red) will have learnt to love by then and will save us.

There is currently no reason to believe that such a superintelligence is likely or would have any of the powers people claim.

Planktonne··on An Alien Mind
Coming equipped to discuss a topic before chiming in is your responsibility.
Planktonne··on An Alien Mind
People in the past being wrong doesn't mean you have to repeat the same mistakes, and it definitely doesn't mean you should throw your hands up and declare that all similar things must be identical.

Quibbling over commonly-understood definitions is not a strong argument. If you're genuinely struggling to understand that El Ajedrecista [1] did not meet any definition of thought, then the solution is not to demand that people redefine all terms to accomodate you, but that you consult a dictionary.

You clearly have a working definition, or you wouldn't have been able to declare that tallness isn't thinking; please engage honestly.

[1] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/El_Ajedrecista

Planktonne··on An Alien Mind
The crucial distinction here is that "seem" does not at all mean the same thing as "is".

Thunder seems like the anger of the gods but it isn't. We've had chess playing programs for a long time now and despite it seeming like thinking is required for them, it isn't.

The principle you're using here isn't a scientific one but magical [1]. Abandoning empiricism and rationality is not a good way to make progress.

[1] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Sympathetic_magic

Planktonne··on An Alien Mind
That's an absurdist argument that would make 'smarter' meaningless.

A giraffe isn't smarter than me at being tall.

Planktonne··on A/I shuts down
That's a bunch of unproven allegations from an administration with a history of lies; have you got anything more concrete?
Planktonne··on The revolt of the reader
There is no group of people who put enormous amounts of effort into not putting effort in to writing.

To fully disguise LLM prose, you'd have to rewrite it entirely, and if you were going to do that, you wouldn't be the sort of person to use it in the first place.

Planktonne··on “Next-token predictor” is the wrong mental model for LLMs
To informally describe something as wrong in an article focused on how it's wrong to informally describe something is incoherent.

There's a certain irony in pointing me towards the guidelines on the grounds that I have limited patience with your comments that violate them in various ways. I'm not sure that this is a productive discussion.

Planktonne··on "Next-token predictor" is the wrong mental model for LLMs
Sure, but just because you think a colloquial meaning exists doesn't mean you're correct. It particularly doesn't mean that if you're seeing other people (that you don't like) use a term you yourself don't use, and you're jumping to conclusions about it without consideration.
Planktonne··on “Next-token predictor” is the wrong mental model for LLMs
Mostly I disagree with the article's ideas, if that helps; the AI was just a secondary factor.

> I don’t think it’s a good reason to dismiss this

AI-generated prose reads as sending a 'lack of effort' signal to a lot of people, just as no editing at all does. ; It's an effective heuristic that we've all learnt in the last couple of years.

In either case, it's not always fair: there are people who deeply care about their ideas but forget to fix basic errors, or pass it through AI.

In both cases though, the advice is the same: if you want people to take your output seriously, you need to signal that you are taking it seriously. That used to mean editing for spelling and grammar. Now it means not using AI.

Planktonne··on “Next-token predictor” is the wrong mental model for LLMs
> Describing it as a "next-token predictor" in the sense that this would mean it's fundamentally limited to just a fraction of an inferential step

I don't think anyone is doing that though; we know LLMs are not simple Markov chains, and that the prediction they make is based on more than the previous X words.

It's not minimising to describe even a complex prediction process as prediction.

Planktonne··on “Next-token predictor” is the wrong mental model for LLMs
I think you're trying to limit the meaning of both 'next' and 'prediction' in ways that don't reflect usage and that--if adopted--would severely limit our ability to discuss and evolve what LLMs are actually doing.

There's nothing inherent in either word that forces such a limit; predicting based on what will lead to success as measured by [reward function] is still a prediction.

Planktonne··on “Next-token predictor” is the wrong mental model for LLMs
It's a short article; you could read it. One example to get you started is the very first sentence:

> Strictly speaking, the statement “LLMs are next-token predictors” isn’t wrong, but it’s incomplete.

The article is about how 'next-token predictor' is the wrong mental model; it opens with the admission that it is not the wrong mental model.

Planktonne··on “Next-token predictor” is the wrong mental model for LLMs
In my experience, people who do 'AI-assisted' writing tend to be very bad at noticing how much of their work AI has changed. I'm sure you put thought into it, but passing it through AI takes a lot of that out.
Planktonne··on “Next-token predictor” is the wrong mental model for LLMs
I'm not sure what you want me to do with that information; clearly I do think that my description is accurate.

The article is littered with both AI tells and admissions that 'next token prediction' is what is happening. Hence my description.

Planktonne··on “Next-token predictor” is the wrong mental model for LLMs
I don't that's a fair description of either 'next-token predictor' or 'stochastic parrot'. Both of those terms describe mechanism, not value--the fact that people squawk that the terms are minimising is projection on their part, not inherent to the phrase.
Planktonne··on “Next-token predictor” is the wrong mental model for LLMs
I'm not going to stop describing things accurately because someone generated an article that continually undermines its own main point. Limiting the way we talk and think about LLMs to a very narrow set of terms doesn't help us.

EDIT: gentler phrasing

Planktonne··on OpenAI begins rolling out GPT-6 Astra
> For whole projects, I have a 3 page anti-bloat.md which describes what not to do

This line would be cut from a satire for being too heavy-handed.

Planktonne··on GPT-6 Astra
I'm sure it's going to do great on all sorts of benchmarks, but the video--the actual marketing video that if anything is incentivised to overstate things--is full of careful cuts just before it would do anything that still wouldn't actually be that impressive.

It's AGI, and it's going to upload photos, or change a background slide colour. Even the people hyping it up, who believe that it's really artificial intelligence in every sense of the word, couldn't get it to do more than that.

This is farcical.

Planktonne··on OpenAI begins rolling out GPT-6 Astra
The atomic bomb destroyed cities and changed the face of war.

The launch video for Astra has 'can upload a photo to Ebay' as a highlight.

Planktonne··on Any Human Ever – One life, drawn at random from all who have ever lived
Without wishing to be unkind, this reads a lot more as 'one-shot with AI' than 'many iterations'; if you truly did that much editing, you didn't put it where it showed.

You've got all the AI favourite names and rhythms at once in the second paragraph, for example.

Planktonne··on Show HN: Weedout – Safari extension that hides YouTube AI-labeled videos
Pretty much, yes. People read no visuals or poor visuals as 'hobbyist who really cares about [other aspect]'; years of experience make it a familiar schema.

They read AI as 'grifter who probably doesn't care about any aspect'.

Planktonne··on LLM Judges Verify Presence, Not Absence: Omission Blindness in AI Clinical Notes
The fact that even the abstract is very clearly AI-generated does not fill me with confidence in the rigour of the research.
Planktonne··on When Claude Code went rogue, years of Bengaluru heritage work disappeared
The user is of course responsible for this, but I don't think all the blame rests with him.

He's using a tool that he pays for, that has been sold to him as hyper-capable and autonomous (even with the small-text warning about it being able to make mistakes). The providers of the tool are also responsible, even if only for the misleading advertising.

Planktonne··on How accurate have Ed Zitron's AI skeptic predictions been?
Zitron's predictions have often been wrong; they've still been less wrong than those of the people who disagree with him.
Planktonne··on Mayor says 'large chunks' of Wellington council Deloitte report written by AI
My experience is that management consultants love AI; they're oddly blind to it compared to other professions, and they're the first to start using it everywhere. The immediate surface appearance of quality is catnip to them.

This should make everyone even more suspicious of the management consultancies claiming to employ the smartest people in the world.

Planktonne··on Ask HN: How do you survive a job you hate which is slowly making you sick?
This is not good advice. It can take a while to find medication or therapy that works for you, but developing a drinking problem is not the answer.
← PreviousPage 3 of 33Next →