2,928 karma · joined April 12, 2019
There is no reason to assume that super intelligent evil AI with magic powers will appear; while we are purely in the realm of (hackneyed) fantasy, why stop at imagining just one thing? You can build the whole story, not just the basilisk.
The parent comment is a story, not a prediction; it should be treated like one.
There is currently no reason to believe that such a superintelligence is likely or would have any of the powers people claim.
Quibbling over commonly-understood definitions is not a strong argument. If you're genuinely struggling to understand that El Ajedrecista [1] did not meet any definition of thought, then the solution is not to demand that people redefine all terms to accomodate you, but that you consult a dictionary.
You clearly have a working definition, or you wouldn't have been able to declare that tallness isn't thinking; please engage honestly.
Thunder seems like the anger of the gods but it isn't. We've had chess playing programs for a long time now and despite it seeming like thinking is required for them, it isn't.
The principle you're using here isn't a scientific one but magical [1]. Abandoning empiricism and rationality is not a good way to make progress.
A giraffe isn't smarter than me at being tall.
To fully disguise LLM prose, you'd have to rewrite it entirely, and if you were going to do that, you wouldn't be the sort of person to use it in the first place.
There's a certain irony in pointing me towards the guidelines on the grounds that I have limited patience with your comments that violate them in various ways. I'm not sure that this is a productive discussion.
> I don’t think it’s a good reason to dismiss this
AI-generated prose reads as sending a 'lack of effort' signal to a lot of people, just as no editing at all does. ; It's an effective heuristic that we've all learnt in the last couple of years.
In either case, it's not always fair: there are people who deeply care about their ideas but forget to fix basic errors, or pass it through AI.
In both cases though, the advice is the same: if you want people to take your output seriously, you need to signal that you are taking it seriously. That used to mean editing for spelling and grammar. Now it means not using AI.
I don't think anyone is doing that though; we know LLMs are not simple Markov chains, and that the prediction they make is based on more than the previous X words.
It's not minimising to describe even a complex prediction process as prediction.
There's nothing inherent in either word that forces such a limit; predicting based on what will lead to success as measured by [reward function] is still a prediction.
> Strictly speaking, the statement “LLMs are next-token predictors” isn’t wrong, but it’s incomplete.
The article is about how 'next-token predictor' is the wrong mental model; it opens with the admission that it is not the wrong mental model.
The article is littered with both AI tells and admissions that 'next token prediction' is what is happening. Hence my description.
EDIT: gentler phrasing
This line would be cut from a satire for being too heavy-handed.
It's AGI, and it's going to upload photos, or change a background slide colour. Even the people hyping it up, who believe that it's really artificial intelligence in every sense of the word, couldn't get it to do more than that.
This is farcical.
The launch video for Astra has 'can upload a photo to Ebay' as a highlight.
You've got all the AI favourite names and rhythms at once in the second paragraph, for example.
They read AI as 'grifter who probably doesn't care about any aspect'.
He's using a tool that he pays for, that has been sold to him as hyper-capable and autonomous (even with the small-text warning about it being able to make mistakes). The providers of the tool are also responsible, even if only for the misleading advertising.
This should make everyone even more suspicious of the management consultancies claiming to employ the smartest people in the world.