2,928 karma · joined April 12, 2019
> yes, LLM's can definitely function in an open world where the rules are fuzzy, changing, undefined, etc.
> At the very least, much better than all GOFAI approaches by far
A small number of huge corporations keeping tight control of data and access to data is not a pro-freedom stance.
Historically and culturally, Pluto is considered a planet. An IAU classification shouldn't be used to try and retroactively change that, because the IAU does not have control over history and culture. It's a fun fact (did you know that Pluto is not classified as a planet by astronomers?) not a diktat.
Similarly, a banana is 'officially' a berry, which means that it is classified as a berry by botanists. This does not mean it is considered a berry in any other contexts. If you told someone you had made a berry crumble and it was filled with bananas, you would look strange. We have countless examples of this (often focused around food): a tomato does not belong in a fruit salad no matter what botanists say.
Different terms are used with different specificity in different settings. Language and culture and [older disciplines] are not governed by the rules of [newer disciplines or bodies]. If people with 'I love space' t-shirts would stop "um actually"-ing, no one would have a problem.
The site's tagline is
> For collectors & dealers who take books seriously
But they can't even take writing one article seriously; I'm not interested in opinions on books from people who take zero care with their own output.
You can't have a functioning democracy if it's impossible to criticise the current setup. This is the whole idea behind newspeak [1]
We've all learnt that it's not really communication, and so can be dispensed with.
Then why are there no examples of this? There aren't even examples of steps towards it--the half hour film that's nearly production quality, etc.
The one takeaway I got from this article is that deepsql.ai are the last people I would trust to handle this problem, because they can't even explain it themselves.
Using the most motivated possible reasoning, you can just about stretch to an implicit call for murder but
- Definitely not an explicit one
- There are far stronger non-murder interpretations
They don't though; I have never seen this happen. I have seen many people claim that's what they do, but not convincingly.
Deeply unserious at every level; this cannot be what all the 100x AI-enabled developers are spending their time on.
Why is it a problem for you that they don't enjoy eating in canteens? Why does working with you mean signing up to be your best friend?
Every field has terms of art, and 'reasoning' is one for LLMs. But that doesn't mean it has the same properties as 'reasoning' in other contexts, because you're not referring to the same thing.
Why doesn't my asteroid belt buckle?
It's still painfully obvious when a novel was written by AI--the quality is nowhere near good enough--but that's not actually the point; the point is the sheer volume of spam which clogs up search results and harms discovery.
> those with control of the materials [...] won't share the list with AI companies.
These are definitely claims I would make if I was an AI legal company that hadn't solved hallucinations.
If I think about new tech, all the examples that immediately spring to mind are negative ones: surveillance cameras, AI-enabled spam & propaganda, autonomous weaponry.
The less flashy advances tend to be harder to get excited about, and they're also often negative. My computers get more expensive, but they also collect more data on me, and it's harder to get one without a bunch of unwanted features.
People used to be excited about new tech because it was exciting and aspirational; I think we've lost a lot of that.
Quite apart from anything else, I don't think these statements hang together, and we wouldn't accept them in any other context. Being targeted is not the same as being guilty.
I don't think this shows what you think it shows. AI output (in short clumps) looks like human output; it's designed to do that. Naturally people will sometimes prefer it to other stuff that looks like human output, but crucially this shifts when they realise they're not actually being communicated with.