HNHacker News
TopNewBestAskShowJobs

PontifexMinimus

608 karma · joined January 7, 2021

https://pontifex.substack.com/
submissionscomments
PontifexMinimus··on Google Titans Model Explained: The Future of Memory-Driven AI Architectures
If true, it's got its grammar wrong:

>At its core, Titans merge two powerful mechanisms:

Should be "merges", since "Titans" as used here is a singular proper noun.

PontifexMinimus··on Meta claims torrenting pirated books isn't illegal without proof of seeding
Maybe Trump will legalise internet-based copying.

After all, the main people hurt would be Hollywood, which is run by people supporting the Democrats. And it would be popular with many voters (not an issue for Trump but it is for Republicans).

PontifexMinimus··on No one is disrupting banks – at least not the big ones
I (for one) prefer video chats to phone calls.

There is a reason why "face to face communication" is a phrase.

PontifexMinimus··on Yi Peng 3 crossed both cables C-Lion 1 and BSC at times matching when they broke
Helping Russia
PontifexMinimus··on We’re receiving about 3,000 reports/hour
Then unsubscribe from that blocklist.
PontifexMinimus··on We’re receiving about 3,000 reports/hour
> Who is going to do that job as a volunteer

There could be a system whereby if you see something bad in your feed you can report it.

PontifexMinimus··on Seer: A GUI front end to GDB for Linux
You call it haskish but it's something I've done in the pasty and find useful.

I don't find debuggers all that useful, because I often find I'm spending more time thinking about how to use the debugger rather than how to fix the bug; since debugging is hard I want tools that I don't have to think about at all, as they distract me from thinking about the bug.

Maybe that's because I don't have enough experience with a particular tool. If I used a debugger more often it would come naturally to me. But I find most of my bugs are simple enough that that doesn't happen, because I write modular code and TDD.

PontifexMinimus··on Seer: A GUI front end to GDB for Linux
> With the printf you might not have considered all the variables you need, so you have to go back, insert, and recompile

In some languages, such as Python, it's fairly easy to write a debug-print function that prints all the local variables (as well as the function name and line number it was called in).

PontifexMinimus··on Seer: A GUI front end to GDB for Linux
> the ability to isolate areas of functionality

This is the key. You need to be able to narrow down where the bug is.

PontifexMinimus··on Seer: A GUI front end to GDB for Linux
I've also used both GUI-based debuggers and printf, and I prefer printf. But the most important thing it to write your code so there aren't many bugs and when there are they are easy to find. I do this using modular code, unit tests and regression tests.
PontifexMinimus··on Students paid thousands for a Caltech boot camp that Caltech didn't teach
> a way to exchange credibility for short-term profits

Immediately on reading this I thought "ah yes, Hewlett-Packard's business model for the last few decades".

PontifexMinimus··on Hacker trap: Fake OnlyFans tool backstabs cybercriminals, steals passwords
> the language isn't an abstraction of the hardware

Programming languages were designed to do useful stuff. They can't do this without hardware. There are always concerns of practicality.

> as if this were some kind of computational atomism

NAND gates are computationally atomic, IMO, since to go a level below them you get to the level of physical processes (e.g. electronics) that implement them.

PontifexMinimus··on Bioaccumulation of Microplastics in Decedent Human Brains
> You can’t do a double-blind randomized control trial.

You could on animals.

PontifexMinimus··on How we migrated Gov.uk notify to AWS elastic container service
You should also add GCHQ, MI5 and MI6 who all use AWS to host top secret material (https://archive.md/n2cNB).

As an IT professional, I would question whether that makes sense.

But what do I know? I'm sure the people who run the country -- people of the calibre of Liz Truss, no less -- know what they're doing!

PontifexMinimus··on OpenStreetMap Is Turning 20
It'd be really nice if all these services auto-federated with each other.

A lot of the images are too dark or low-contrast, so another nice feature would be to auto-adjust the image for brightness (maybe make this a user-level default).

PontifexMinimus··on Show HN: Simple Mbtiles Server – Self-host the entire planet of OpenStreetMaps
> incredibly vague and unhelpful

As is very common with projects on Github. They should have a paragraph at the start explaining simply what they do.

PontifexMinimus··on Server Mono: A Typeface Inspired by Typewriters, Apple's SF Mono, and CLIs
> Whoops; someone pointed out that 1 and l are indistinguishable. That's a major failing.

Agreed.

PontifexMinimus··on OpenStreetMap Is Turning 20
Google Maps used to have geolocated pictures taken by users (IIRC this was called Panoramio). If OSM had an app that allowed you to take photos and they'd be automatically uploaded with location, that'd be great.
PontifexMinimus··on Deep Live Cam: Real-time face swapping and one-click video deepfake tool
And backed off from blocking Onlyfans.
PontifexMinimus··on Cars Are Now Computers, So How Long Will They Get Updates? Automakers Can't Say
Why not mandate that the car must still work if you take the computers out?
PontifexMinimus··on Ladybird Web Browser becomes a non-profit with $1M from GitHub Founder
Will it have multi-account containers, like Firefox? If not, I won't be using it.
PontifexMinimus··on The EU regulates that by 2027, all phones be equipped with replaceable batteries
> Because in my original reply I said “alerts” and not “blocks using drm”?

And how soon before manufacturers move from the first to the second, if they are not stopped by law?

I have no objection to alerts per se, as long as it is done in a non-obnoxious way.

PontifexMinimus··on The EU regulates that by 2027, all phones be equipped with replaceable batteries
> Letting people know if a part is genuine empowers the user.

And putting DRM on hardware to prevent people using third-party peripherals disempowers the user, and should be illegal.

PontifexMinimus··on How to get root access to your Sleep Number bed
> Sounds like the problem isn't Linux, it's insecure development practices.

No, it's making devices "smart". There doesn't need to be a wifi-connected computer inside a washing machine, cooker, or fridge. In fact all these things can run without a computer in them at all, and they're arguably better for it.

PontifexMinimus··on HyperCard Simulator
It's a shame Apple doesn't do something like this today. (Or maybe they do and I don't know about it?)
PontifexMinimus··on AI Search: The Bitter-Er Lesson
Indeed. It's obvious what search means for a chess program -- its the future positions it looks at. But it's less obvious to me what it means for an LLM.
PontifexMinimus··on ARC Prize – a $1M+ competition towards open AGI progress
> Now, is it 10k examples? No, but I think it was on the order of hundreds, if not thousands.

If I was presented with 10 pictures of 2 species I'm unfamiliar with, about as different as cats and dogs, I expect I would be able to classify further images as either, reasonably accurately.

PontifexMinimus··on ARC Prize – a $1M+ competition towards open AGI progress
The website gives an example:

    {
      "train": [
        {"input": [[1, 0], [0, 0]], "output": [[1, 1], [1, 1]]},
        {"input": [[0, 0], [4, 0]], "output": [[4, 4], [4, 4]]},
        {"input": [[0, 0], [6, 0]], "output": [[6, 6], [6, 6]]}
      ],
      "test": [
        {"input": [[0, 0], [0, 8]], "output": [[8, 8], [8, 8]]}
      ]
    }
But why restrict yourself to JSON that codes for 2-d coloured grids? Why not also allow:

    {
      "train": [
        {"input": [[1, 0], [0, 0]], "output": 1},
        {"input": [[0, 0], [4, 0]], "output": 4},
        {"input": [[0, 0], [6, 0]], "output": 6}
      ]
    }
Where the rule might be to output the biggest number in the input, or add them up (and the solver has to work out which).
PontifexMinimus··on ARC Prize – a $1M+ competition towards open AGI progress
No, I don't think it does. I think that the ideas in a system that could solve this type of problem would be highly generalisable to other tasks.
PontifexMinimus··on ARC Prize – a $1M+ competition towards open AGI progress
> Why doesn't Chollet just make a challenge that reads like "Solve cancer", surely there is no solution in any books.

Why doesn't a baby just run a marathon before it learns to walk? Because you've got to learn to walk before you can run.

> But not even the whole human society can do it in one go, it's a slow iterative process of ideation and validation.

So you break it down into little steps, which is what is being done here.

← PreviousPage 2 of 9Next →