HNHacker News
TopNewBestAskShowJobs

QuantumChaos

130 karma · joined March 29, 2014

submissionscomments
QuantumChaos··on I Don’t Want to Hire Women
On selective perception, how could we tell the difference between

(A) the author suffering from this bias, and women and men are equally good, and

(B) the author is correct, and you think women and men are equally good employees because you suffer from the opposite bias.

Selective perception may exist, but you've done nothing to show that the author's viewpoint is wrong and yours is right.

QuantumChaos··on How Wall Street recruits so many Ivy League grads
I think it's ironic that almost all other industries actively discriminate on the basis of appearance, and yet the tech industry is the one under attack for being prejudiced.

I think one reason for this is that anyone who complains against an industry discriminating in favor of attractive people looks like a loser.

QuantumChaos··on FCC approves plan to consider paid priority on Internet
If this were a matter of prioritizing traffic on the internet backbone, then I would be in favor. There is nothing wrong with charging congestion fees.

However, in this case, we are talking about cable companies, and the bottleneck is presumably the last mile. So what these laws are really doing is enabling cable companies to extract even more monopoly rents, in the form of discriminatory pricing (even though it is the content providers that pay, the pipeline in question is closer to the end user than the content provider, and so if the issue were congestion pricing, and not discriminatory pricing, the charge would be on the end user, who is already paying).

QuantumChaos··on The purpose of DRM is not to prevent copyright violations (2013)
This argument is completely ridiculous.

Control of how a person consumes content that they legally own is incidental. If a company can force you to buy content rather than pirating, they will make a lot more money. Controlling the exact manner in which you consume that content is the icing on the cake.

QuantumChaos··on How extreme isolation warps the mind
As a counterpoint, in "If This is a Man", Auschwitz survivor Primo Levi describes his inability to find meaning in his experiences, and a lack of triumph of the human spirit, in himself and other inmates.

As the title implies, the book claims that not only did the Nazi's attempt to dehumanize the concentration camp inmates, but that the succeeded. This was sufficiently confronting that the US title was changed to "Survival in Auschwitz"

EDIT: fixed typo

QuantumChaos··on How do hedge funds get away with it? Eight theories
In an efficient market, we would expect the after-fees returns of hedge funds to be no better or worse than any other asset class (adjusting for risk, beta, etc.)

So there really is no puzzle here.

QuantumChaos··on What’s So Scary About Smart Girls?
The article tries to fit this event into a narrative about oppression of women, and women's education. And yet Boko Haram are against education in general, and in a previous attack on a school, killed 59 school boys, while letting the girls go.

[1] http://www.thedailybeast.com/articles/2014/05/12/boko-haram-...

QuantumChaos··on Why the rich stay rich: they don’t invest like the rest
I was expecting evidence that the assets that rich people invest in actually give better returns. None was given.

There were some vague claims of "alpha" to be found in specialty asset classes. But then, if your job is to find "alpha", then you are probably going to claim that it is out there somewhere.

In the absence of any new evidence, I'm going to stick to my previous opinion, which is that there are no superior investment opportunities available to the rich. People might get rich by luck, skill, or political influence. But having lots of money doesn't guarantee higher average returns on that money.

QuantumChaos··on The Kentucky Derby Is Decadent and Depraved (1970)
The term "parody" is often misused, but I was using it correctly here. My post was a parody of what I perceived to be anti-White bias. This did initially cause some confusion, but all of the criticism I received was by people who recognized the intent of my post.

A more direct version would have gone something like "Imagine if the author had portrayed Jews, Chinese or Africans living in the US using the same insulting caricatures, or conflated their relative ethnic homogeneity with literal inbreeding..."

If you would prefer the latter style of presentation, I will try and avoid satire/parody as a stylistic device.

QuantumChaos··on The Kentucky Derby Is Decadent and Depraved (1970)
I don't think that what I wrote was off-topic, because poking fun of Southern White society was a major theme throughout the entire article, not just the part I quoted directly.

And my subsequent posts clarified my viewpoint, and weren't written in inflammatory language. It's not my fault that some people immediately associate the use of the term "White" with a crazy Stormfront posting neo-Nazi. How else am I supposed to refer to the subject matter? Using White in a negative context seems to be fine.

If a lot of people think that using terms like "White culture" makes you a neo-Nazi, then that precisely confirms that the viewpoint I was parodying in my first post is alive and well.

QuantumChaos··on The Kentucky Derby Is Decadent and Depraved (1970)
Thanks for expanding on my point. I would also add that it's not just about the act of self-selection, but the way the communities are viewed in themselves.

Exactly the same qualities are described in very different terms, e.g. a tight knit community which upholds their traditions and values in the face of modernity, vs inbred, ignorant bigots.

The main difference between my viewpoint and others who make similar arguments, is that I'm not saying this is an actual contradiction. There are many differences in context which mean that the two cannot be directly compared. However, there is what I would call a discrepancy. The author of this piece never made a logical argument, that what is good for White communities isn't good for others. He simply painted a picture, which many people might find compelling. If I can expose this discrepancy, people might find these narratives less compelling.

QuantumChaos··on The Kentucky Derby Is Decadent and Depraved (1970)
great rebuttal
QuantumChaos··on The Kentucky Derby Is Decadent and Depraved (1970)
I was posting about the double standard by which the media treats White communities vs communities of other ethnicity's. Nothing to do with genetic differences, Men's Rights, or any other group you want to associate me with for no reason.
QuantumChaos··on Snails Are Dissolving in Pacific Ocean
>major biogeochemical processes in the oceans other than calcification will not be fundamentally different

But calcification precisely the process in question here.

QuantumChaos··on The Kentucky Derby Is Decadent and Depraved (1970)
>But the breeding of humans is not so wisely supervised, particularly in a narrow Southern society where the closest kind of inbreeding is not only stylish and acceptable, but far more convenient—to the parents—than setting their offspring free to find their own mates, for their own reasons and their own ways. (“Goddam, did you hear about Smitty’s daughter? She went crazy in Boston last week and married a nigger!”)

I don't know much about marriage patters on Southern states in the 70's, but I find it amazing that Jews, Chinese, Africans etc. manage to mostly avoid race-mixing, but also avoid the opposite extreme of literal in-breeding.

What is it about White people that, unlike every single other ethnicity, who produce rich, vibrant cultures when left to their own devices, White people turn into crazy inbred rednecks? I mean, I've never read a similar article about close-knit Jewish communities in Brooklyn, or African immigrant communities. Somehow those people manage to retain a distinctive culture and lifestyle (and even some of the conservative values that the author describes), without becoming the caricature the author describes.

EDIT: this post was a parody of anti-White sentiment such as the part of the article that I quoted. I don't actually think White people are special in the way I described. What is unique is the ridicule to which White culture and White communities are subject by the mainstream media.

QuantumChaos··on Shit HN Says
>incompetent morons.

Your use of these terms is actually very offensive.

You need to attribute stuff you want to sneer at, to things like being under 30, being obsessed with fads, etc.

QuantumChaos··on Why I won’t work for Google
Think about the sociology of this: would you really expect a Google employee to say "Yes, we are almost all geniuses"?

There is a lot of social pressure to attribute one's success to hard work (except of you're a White male ;-) ), luck, good mentorship, experience, meta-skills etc. rather than intelligence.

QuantumChaos··on Shit HN Says
omg, I can't believe someone posted something inconsistent with feminism, or your old school software engineering background. What a loser.
QuantumChaos··on [dead]
nerds censor pornography => nerds are sex-negative misogynists

nerds create pornography => nerds are objectifying women

QuantumChaos··on The Internet Is Being Protected By Two Guys Named Steve
That's a consequence of being open source. All the main open source licenses mean that anyone would be able to use OpenSSL without paying a cent to the creators.

Advocates of open source often claim that creators of open source software can make money by selling services to users, like consulting services. As this article (and others) describe, this approach also didn't work that well for the OpenSSL team.

QuantumChaos··on The desperate hustle as a way of life
Just to clarify for the downvoters:

>Today there are people all over Baltimore subleasing places they don’t own, peddling without a license, hacking. This is a criminal offense. The law does not recognize the right of the people to earn enough to eat.

>All these entrepreneurs, most of them running little scams to get by, all of them held in contempt by the law and by most of society. Lyft and Uber and Air BnB face legal sanction too—but it’s just a civil matter.

The author clearly conflates the two issues of (A) not working for an employer or company, and (B) transactions that are illegal.

I already said how these may be linked in some cases. But it is unreasonable to imply that any work that is not done for an employer (preferable while working full time) must be some kind of scam.

EDIT: I'm not sure I like the new HN where I can't say something that is manifestly true (as proven by my quotes) without getting massively downvoted.

QuantumChaos··on The desperate hustle as a way of life
The author is operating under the strange notion that doing a transaction outside the context of full-time work, or operating a business, is illegal.

Maybe businesses like Lyft, Uber and AirBnB facilitate people working in legal grey areas, but they also facilitate direct individual-customer relationships. These open up markets, and are therefore bad for incumbents (e.g. people already in the taxi industry) but good for people who for whatever weren't able to work in that industry before.

And what's with referring to people as "kids"? Is this how you assert your status as alpha male?

QuantumChaos··on Pronking for Programmers
Is it dedication that is being signaled here, or intelligence? Open source can also be a signal that you get you work done quick enough that you have time for hobbies.
QuantumChaos··on For $45 Per Month, All the Coffee You Can Drink
>Those health benefits are more for people in their 80s.

What are you basing that claim on? None of the studies mentioned specifically in the wikipedia section specifically mention people in their 80's, and many of the studies look at total mortality.

>The coffee bean is actually a poison that the coffee plant uses to deter herbivores.

I prefer to base my decisions on epidemiological studies, than arbitrarily applying the label "poison" to things

QuantumChaos··on For $45 Per Month, All the Coffee You Can Drink
Coffee is good for you.

http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Coffee#General_health

QuantumChaos··on SF’s Housing Crisis Explained
That would be a boon to the honorable profession of having rent seeking ventures reclassified as technology.
QuantumChaos··on SF’s Housing Crisis Explained
SF Housing Crisis Explained: Money allows one to buy things that other people (sometimes even people poorer than oneself) might have wanted to buy themselves. From this, two things follow: (1) we should redistribute money so that the very poor can at least buy something, and (2) nerds shouldn't be allowed to have much money, since no one likes them, and so why should they be allowed to buy things that other people want to buy.
QuantumChaos··on Dozens of teenagers are now tweeting bomb jokes to American Airlines
You claim that the concepts of left and right are not useful because both sides are in fact being manipulated into fighting each other, rather than the true "responsible parties". Who exactly do you think these "responsible parties" are?
QuantumChaos··on Dozens of teenagers are now tweeting bomb jokes to American Airlines
I can't know what problem I'm part of until you're more specific.

The problem I see is that inconsistent enforcement of both laws and social norms, allow one side of politics to be more expressive than the other. Compare "if the rich don't start dealing with the problem of inequality, violence is sure to follow", with "if politicians don't start dealing with the problem of non-White immigration, violence is sure to follow".

QuantumChaos··on Dozens of teenagers are now tweeting bomb jokes to American Airlines
The funny thing is, I was flying United and even though apparently you're not allowed to say the word "bomb" on a plane, they are happy to show a movie that glorifies terrorists ("The Company You Keep") as inflight entertainment.

It seems like violent metaphors or even threats of violence, are only tolerated when they come from the far left.

← PreviousPage 5 of 6Next →