HNHacker News
TopNewBestAskShowJobs

RjQoLCOSwiIKfpm

633 karma · joined May 5, 2022

submissionscomments
RjQoLCOSwiIKfpm··on Ask HN: Why are 5 comments/day “posting too fast”, what precisely is “too fast”?
Thanks.

For context, here is your original comment:

> If you look back at the GPs comments you can see some that were flagged/closed recently, a few that were downvoted and also a good number of threads that turned into meta threads with others posters that get downvoted. So looks like someone who has been targeted for limiting or additional moderation.

Talking about me in the 3rd person in a subthread (I am here, would you talk about someone in the 3rd person if they are in the same room standing next to you?), to purport vague, unproven statements, which IMHO are exaggerated, and which imply that I'd be someone who "had it coming" is not really "providing" something here, at least not providing help IMHO.

It's rather feels like condescending gossip and badmouthing to me.

I was asking for the numerical limits, not judgement of my character.

But to be honest, I am appalled by the attitude of the comments in this thread as a whole, so take what I say to you personally with a grain of salt, it is biased by the condescending behavior of the other people in here.

RjQoLCOSwiIKfpm··on Ask HN: Why are 5 comments/day “posting too fast”, what precisely is “too fast”?
> I'm starting to see the absurdity of this post.

It certainly is absurd to ask some simple questions which could be answered numerically for the most of them ... and then people go into some kind of field day to judge my character based on digging through 10s (!!!) of my comment history pages of 600 comments (someone said that number here, I didn't even know, did they write a script to compute it?), to judge my "emotional investment", and to judge me for not wanting to hand out my phone number to email providers, and finally they block my post by "flagging" it so it won't be seen by the moderation team and won't get an actual answer.

It could have been as simple as telling me "The limit is N posts per M minutes", but no, we must have some kind of public character execution instead.

RjQoLCOSwiIKfpm··on Ask HN: Why are 5 comments/day “posting too fast”, what precisely is “too fast”?
I'm sorry, I posted some questions about Hackernews, on Hackernews.

I do not see how I should suddenly become customer to some unrelated external services which could literally cause my phone to ring all day just in order to be entitled to ask some questions?

It seems you're escalating the tone here, which I do not intend to participate in.

RjQoLCOSwiIKfpm··on Ask HN: Why are 5 comments/day “posting too fast”, what precisely is “too fast”?
Thanks but I think how I allocate my personal time is my personal decision to make ;)

I was asking simple factual questions - e.g. the numerical value of "too fast". So I would appreciate if it could be answered primarily in a numerical fashion, not with life advice.

Rest assured that I do take care of my mental health in a fashion which I deem appropriate.

RjQoLCOSwiIKfpm··on Ask HN: Why are 5 comments/day “posting too fast”, what precisely is “too fast”?
Can you please imagine this was not the Internet but real life:

If you talk to your friends, and one of them is forbidden to speak, how high would the probability be that their emotional state is NOT affected?

Ordering someone to be quiet is an action which surely will have some kind of effect on their emotional state, isn't it?

This is nothing about me personally, it's just how humans work. Block them in some way and they will get frustrated.

RjQoLCOSwiIKfpm··on Ask HN: Why are 5 comments/day “posting too fast”, what precisely is “too fast”?
Can you please tell me what the the "good number" is you're talking about?

I do not have time to regurgitate my own history, but I scrolled over it once and it does not seem as controversial as you're portraying it here.

E.g. I only see one flagged comment, how is that "some"?

RjQoLCOSwiIKfpm··on Ask HN: Why are 5 comments/day “posting too fast”, what precisely is “too fast”?
I'm not going to hand out my phone number to internet services, I get enough phone spam already.

Sorry :)

RjQoLCOSwiIKfpm··on Ask HN: Why are 5 comments/day “posting too fast”, what precisely is “too fast”?
> If you felt you needed to post this question you should step away from the site and maybe the internet.

Would you mind reading up on the word "gatekeeping" so I don't have to elaborate it here? :)

> HN posts aren’t important. None of this matters. Take care of yourself.

HN is the only place where it is possible to talk to the people who build the tech infrastructure which dominates and changes our daily lives.

Try talking to e.g. a human at Google elsewhere, it's just not possible.

Internet politics is made here.

RjQoLCOSwiIKfpm··on Ask HN: Why are 5 comments/day “posting too fast”, what precisely is “too fast”?
> My guess - the "too fast" is for activity from your IP # or block, not for activity from your account. But the error message was never updated to reflect the actual code.

I'm on residential dialup, not some kind of company network, so it is unlikely that my IP subnet has a high number of HN users.

RjQoLCOSwiIKfpm··on Ask HN: Why are 5 comments/day “posting too fast”, what precisely is “too fast”?
> The exact rate limit, to my understanding, is tuned by the moderators. So one of them presumably thought you were making some inflammatory comments and made a conscious choice to slow you down.

I have read my comments before the timeout again multiple times before posting this thread here and IMHO they are just stating facts about software, not much of making an opinion about the facts themselves.

I had intentionally left room for other commenters to have their own opinion.

Quote: "As with all things in life, a golden rule applies: If you don't like it then don't use it, that's ok!"

> Reach out to hn@ycombinator.com to find out more and make an appeal.

Uhm, are you actually a human who has read my thread or are you some kind of chat AI?

Because the first line literally says: "Some suggest emailing HN, but I do not have an email address anymore (because they all want phone numbers nowadays)."

Anyway, considering the large number of upvotes this Ask HN has gained, seems more people in the community are interested in clarity. Considering the search function also does not yield clarity it would probably be beneficial for the moderation team and overall peace to make things more clear here?

RjQoLCOSwiIKfpm··on Binance halts deposits and withdrawals for customers in the UK
I don't care that the industry uses someone's tomatoes :)

I merely care about the fact that the tomatoes are being called non-industrial even though they are 100% factory grown.

I.e. Binance is not "crypto".

RjQoLCOSwiIKfpm··on Binance halts deposits and withdrawals for customers in the UK
Yes that sucks - which is why I had used the full word "cryptocurrency" in the non-quote parts of my replies :)
RjQoLCOSwiIKfpm··on Binance halts deposits and withdrawals for customers in the UK
Sure, but then don't call it "crypto" industry if it is not about cryptocurrencies.

I don't care what you call it, calling the centralized Binance exchange "crypto" is just not accurate.

They don't deserve to co-opt the word.

RjQoLCOSwiIKfpm··on Binance halts deposits and withdrawals for customers in the UK
Cryptocurrencies were meant as a "grow your own food" thing in the first place, they are supposed to be decentralized.

Hence it does not seem logical to go to a "grow your own food" subthread and wonder why it makes a point about store-bought food not being grown at home.

As with all things in life, a golden rule applies:

If you don't like it then don't use it, that's ok!

RjQoLCOSwiIKfpm··on Binance halts deposits and withdrawals for customers in the UK
Binance is not a cryptocurrency.

Binance is a centralized service which allows people to buy cryptocurrencies, but which is not strictly necessary to use in order to use cryptocurrencies.

People can use decentralized exchanges like Bisq if they want to avoid these issues.

EDIT: Remember how Hackernews was supposed to be a community which has a focus on software development, and thus finding technical solutions to problems of users?

Now it seems we're more about bashing people for using the wrong technology? Advocating for a technical solution to their problems is disapproved of?

RjQoLCOSwiIKfpm··on Nokia launches DIY repairable budget Android phone
Having to use a custom ROM is the same annoying amount of work as having to upgrade to a new phone every 2-3 years.

Because custom ROMs usually update to the latest Android version ASAP, which moves tons of things around all over the OS, and breaks a lot of stuff.

It's super annoying to update custom ROMs.

And frankly some people just want their phone to work most of the time, not to have the responsibility to install and maintain some pocket-sized server. That's also a reason against using custom ROMs.

RjQoLCOSwiIKfpm··on Dancing is stupid
> So people try to convince you for a bit, and if you still refuse, then they leave you alone. It seems like a workable compromise.

And what they forget while doing that is that they are not the only person existing in the universe:

Others will also attempt to convince the very same non-dancing person to dance.

So if you are at a party, sitting at the bar not dancing, you will have to have this discussion like 5 times in a single evening.

And if you enjoy going to parties even though you don't dance and therefore go regularly, then over the decades you will have to have the discussion thousands of times - which isn't a workable compromise anymore but just an annoyance.

RjQoLCOSwiIKfpm··on Dancing is stupid
In my experience, if you tell one of the dance people that you have tried for over 10 years and still don't like it, they will very likely not even accept that.

They will believe they can show you better and make you like it, and thus will try to obnoxiously persuade you to dance with them.

It's just rude.

And the attitude of yours is also part of the problem:

Believing that somehow grown up people are incapable of learning the very basic fact "dancing can be fun" on their own and need to be told about it and nudged towards it.

No, they don't, they know it can be enjoyable, and they have tried, and it isn't for them, and they don't need to be educated any further.

RjQoLCOSwiIKfpm··on Meta to ask many managers to become individual contributors or leave
Thank you for taking the time to answer my question! :)

I suppose it's a matter of weighing "a set of many small utilities which make life a bit easier for N people" against "two big dangerous social networks which make life a lot harder for M people". Because the money from the former helps the latter as well.

How you decide to judge this is up to you :)

RjQoLCOSwiIKfpm··on Meta to ask many managers to become individual contributors or leave
> Okay I'll feed the troll.

I'm not trying to troll.

I just genuinely don't understand why someone would consider working there as a positive thing.

So I would like to know!

But I have no way to figure it out as I know zero people who work there, and talking to a human who works at these companies is impossible because their websites are geared towards not allowing you to talk to them.

So now that I just saw someone in the wild to ask, I figured I should use the opportunity to figure something out which I absolutely do not understand.

> There are only a few places where if you implemented, for example, an effort to reduce "body dysmorphic disorder", it could instantly improve the lives of 3 billion users worldwide. Meta is one of those places.

It surely is a zero-sum to fix the problem which your company has created in the first place???

RjQoLCOSwiIKfpm··on Diff Models – A New Way to Edit Code
We already have these.

They're called humans.

We had built computers also to overcome the human limitations of fuzziness and imperfection.

Now apparently we think putting these limitations back into computers is a good thing.

RjQoLCOSwiIKfpm··on Diff Models – A New Way to Edit Code
Failure is an extremely common and accepted thing in biological systems - your offspring may just die if you have incompatible genes.

Software on the other hand is a logical environment with clear, logical requirements. It ought to work, not just fall apart randomly.

There is no guarantee that sticking the average of one software into a completely different one will satisfy the logical requirements by any means whatsoever.

RjQoLCOSwiIKfpm··on Diff Models – A New Way to Edit Code
I don't think there is adherence to safety regulations.

The majority of electronics gets produced in foreign nations far far away.

Do you really think they obey the regulations?

RjQoLCOSwiIKfpm··on Diff Models – A New Way to Edit Code
You are comparing things which are not equal.

The currently semi-bad low-grade coders will get pushed out and replaced with even WORSE ones.

The worse ones will be the ones responsible for choosing and approving the code which was generated by AI.

So let's say there is a "Q(c)" which measures worst possible quality of code c.

If the person who monitors this things has a bad worst possible quality Q(c), the code will also have a bad worst possible quality Q(c).

RjQoLCOSwiIKfpm··on Diff Models – A New Way to Edit Code
If my house burns down due to random bugs in a big appliance, do you think the random underpaid 3rd world developers which will be used do care about that?

I think this will lead to extreme cost cutting measures in choice of the developers which are used.

People who would have previously been totally ineligible to develop software will happily be chosen.

And they won't care about the garbage code they produce as long as it somehow seems to work from the outside.

They'll care about feeding their families in the dire situation they are in, not more.

RjQoLCOSwiIKfpm··on Diff Models – A New Way to Edit Code
Prepare for household appliances - washing machines etc. - doing strange things randomly.

Prepare for the same thing with electronics which you didn't consider as containing much software before - central heating units, AC units, fridges, stoves, light switches, LED light bulbs, vacuum cleaners, electric shavers, electric toothbrushes, kids toys, microwave ovens, really anything which consumes electricity.

Prepare for the support of the vendors of those appliances not taking phone calls anymore, only text communication.

Prepare for the support not understanding the random problems you encounter.

Prepare for the answers you get from support being similarly random.

And maybe, with an unknown probability, prepare for your house burning down and nobody can tell you why.

RjQoLCOSwiIKfpm··on GPT is all you need for the back end
Lena aka MMAcevedo seems very relevant:

https://qntm.org/mmacevedo

RjQoLCOSwiIKfpm··on Show HN: Music Audio Search Engine Using OpenAI's Embeddings on GPT Descriptions
This cannot be used without a government ID card in some countries:

- You require a Google account to use it.

- To create a Google account, the user needs a phone number.

- SIM cards are in some countries only allowed to be sold if you show your ID card. Landline phones require a bank account, and those also require an ID.

Now, call me old fashioned, but even considering that I have nothing to hide about my music taste, I am appalled at needing government approval to search for music :)

And yes, I know I am a party pooper here, but this pattern has already creeped all over all Internet services, so at which point in time should we start to point it out everywhere if not now?

Anyway, to be constructive: If you want me to be human I will happily solve dozens of captchas or have my CPU run hot for a while to generate hashcash :) No need to involve daddy Google.

RjQoLCOSwiIKfpm··on Ask HN: Which sites do you spend your evenings on? Where is the “real” Internet?
I was trying to answer your question what people use bookmarks for, not to mock you :)
RjQoLCOSwiIKfpm··on Ask HN: How do you keep track of your medical history?
This may sound odd, but: Paper.

If the day comes where you have to call an ambulance because you feel like you have a heart attack, you should not have to rely on your OS not being busy with rebooting for updates, or the cloud not having locked you out of your account with the files, or any other of the shenanigans computers do, or yourself still being physically capable of entering your password.

And even if all of the above work fine - then what? Do you think the EMTs will wait for your printer to boot and spew out its ink?

Create a physical folder called "For emergencies", put all the relevant documents for doctors in it, nothing else.

If an emergency happens, shove it into the hands of the EMTs, done.

(And ideally have two copies of this folder in case they lose the one you hand out.)

← PreviousPage 2 of 4Next →