HNHacker News
TopNewBestAskShowJobs

RosanaAnaDana

2,140 karma · joined November 3, 2017

Water; land cover and land use; remote sensing of forests; biogeochemical cycling; disturbance.
submissionscomments
RosanaAnaDana··on Google denies training Bard on ChatGPT chats from ShareGPT
I mean maybe. There also might be something to this. OpenAI has been very opaque about training techniques.
RosanaAnaDana··on The EV Transition Is Harder Than Anyone Thinks
Because it takes three times for me to try and adjust the headlight fluid before the guy at the auto parts store takes pity on me.
RosanaAnaDana··on The EV Transition Is Harder Than Anyone Thinks
This is why I pay for a technician.
RosanaAnaDana··on The EV Transition Is Harder Than Anyone Thinks
I suppose you must be right but I've never even touched or had to think about that. My technician hasn't mentioned anything either. I suppose maybe because there isn't a big oily thing the coolant is moving through it isnt a bother?

(2013 leaf, btw. very basic. just kinda works.)

RosanaAnaDana··on The EV Transition Is Harder Than Anyone Thinks
Plenty of stupid EV's out there with no internet like mine.
RosanaAnaDana··on The EV Transition Is Harder Than Anyone Thinks
Number one thing I love about mine, when I press the 'go' button, it goes.

They have a lot of power and because you don't have to bring an engine up to RPM and shift, and bring up to RPM, and shift.. and on..

That power is also instantaneous. However far down I push on the pedal, I'm at that speed basically right away.

Another huge thing, is that they are quiet. There is still a bit of road noise from wind and the physical contact of the wheels with the road. But compared with almost any typical car, its basically silent.

Also, they don't stink. You might not notice it, but your car smells. It gets on you and the people around you. My car doesn't smell like gas or exhaust or anything.

Oh and not to mention, basically nothing ever goes wrong. There is so much less to go wrong on an EV. We don't have a bunch of coolant and pumps sloshing around effectively trying to cool a giant, shaking, moving lump of iron. With out all that rattling, things just don't need as much maintenence.

RosanaAnaDana··on PeerTube 5.1
This is pretty exciting.

I was recently browsing some old saved playlists of mine on youtube. Youtube had 'updated' them to be effectively the same recommended playlist it always offers me.

Its sad and scary that what amounts to an archive of a generation of creativity is effectively only being rented by the people who made it so. Relying on youtube as an archive of some of the Internets greatest content is concerning giving Googles unfortunate track record of managing, well, all of its products.

It seems inevitable that someday yt will die. However and whenever that death shapes up, I hope the creatives of the world have an opportunity to use something like this (or other alternatives like floatplane) to back up their content. Yt is an amazing thing, and too valuable to leave in the hands of google.

RosanaAnaDana··on How did Dennis Ritchie produce his PhD thesis? A typographical mystery (2022) [pdf]
I want to know about the interface of the typewriter/ printer he was working off of. Also what kinds of stencil guides were available at the time. My hot take after reading it: Did he have some way of 'setting' the stencils directly onto the printer in a very controlled way and the ability to 'pause' printing?

IE, prints prints prints, pause, some stencil required, put in stencil into controlled space, make mark, remove stencil, press space bar, prints prints prints prints...

It might also explain the '+' issues. It might have been a very small stencil and less well fit into a stencil guide.

RosanaAnaDana··on Reddit is currently down
Right? Talk a product redesign that literally nobody asked for.
RosanaAnaDana··on Reddit is currently down
Well it was for a while. Then they got someone killed during the whole Boston thing. So you know, theres that..
RosanaAnaDana··on GPT-4
Gotta pay back M$
RosanaAnaDana··on Noam Chomsky Weights in on ChatGPT and LLM’s
> one can always claim the computer is just emulating understanding.

Right? As if most of humans aren't doing just that.

RosanaAnaDana··on The False Promise of ChatGPT
In a sense, science is a zero sum game. The theories and frameworks you spend a lifetime working on, are ultimately either right or wrong.

What I read from Chomsky seems like a bit of a desperate attempt to ask people not to look over at the thing, because the thing offers a new way of looking at how and where language comes from, and even more amazingly, its testable, empirical and reproducible in a way that Chomskys theories of language can never be.

Dudes whole career is getting relegated to the dust-bin.

RosanaAnaDana··on The False Promise of ChatGPT
I was gonna say, I've been on experiments where we literally just blasted the shit out of genomes to do the knockouts and then grew up the plants and phenotyped them to compare with the knockouts.
RosanaAnaDana··on The False Promise of ChatGPT
This is what I've been repeating for months/ years. Chomsky had some interesting theories, that for a while, were very worth discussing as frameworks for the emergence of language.

Now we have chatGPT, a very very interesting framework for the discussion of emergence and language. And even more dramatically, it is in some sense empirical. We haven't yet even begun to explore it, but this imo is the allegorical to the discovery of DNA in the context of the theory of evolution.

Before Watson and Crick and Franklin, we had a coherent theory of evolution (ish). We knew all about selective breeding and it was pretty clear that descent and the transmittance of information 'happened'. Mendelian genetics was enough for that. But as useful as a teaching tool like Mendelian genetics is, the entire world changed with the discovery of the actual-particle responsible for that information. The world changed with the discovery of DNA. I don't know the zeitgeist of other competing theories for how that information was transmitted. But what we do know now, is that they were all wrong, to the extent that they don't get mentioned or discussed.

A real interesting discovery extending from ChatGPT is the apparent emergency of language from what amounts to large piles of information and sufficient complexity. It appears that Chomsky may just be entirely wrong.

RosanaAnaDana··on There’s no such thing as a tree phylogenetically (2021)
>As far as why trees don't seem to evolve into grasses

There is obviously no non-teleological answer for this, but it can be much much more straight forward than metabolism.

Think of plants as basically solar panels. We can think of the 'grass' phenotype as competing through r-type selection. Lots and lots of individuals, lots of surface area, short life cycles. Short bursty growth, convenient loss resilience, easy mobility.

'Trees' are the also optimizing for surface area (among other things), but are relying on k-type selection. Longer life-cycles, lower probability of successful reproduction, specialized pollinators, and very significantly, vertically stratified growth habit. Being an individual in a k-type species is like a very significant advantage for that individual, since its unlikely that the vast majority of k-type seeds will successfully reproduce.

Being k-type may not be more competitive for the species overall, but it may result for a selection bias at the individual member resolution, and so may be unlikely to be selected against.

There are many many advantages to lignification when your whole thing is basically being solar panels on a pole. It would seem extremely unlikely this has anything to do with metabolism other than 'doing more of it'. We already know why monocots don't make trees more significant than palms (read: vascular bundles and eusteles). My money goes to species level versus individual level selection in k versus r.

RosanaAnaDana··on There’s no such thing as a tree phylogenetically (2021)
Tell the pacific islanders that.
RosanaAnaDana··on Keep your AI claims in check
I think this is great and as a practitioner, something I've incorporated and demand in all of the contracts I work on is a clear and explicit validation and uncertainty analysis. It was always an issue when I worked at big corp that there was pressure to bury the lede when it came to uncertainty/ propagation of error. I considered it to be misleading and since then I make sure that any work that I'm a part of has in explicit language exactly how we'll analyse and approach bias and uncertainty as a part of the original work. I also try and make sure that assessments of uncertainty are 'part of the product' so there is no getting around things and every prediction also comes with an 'I told you so' layer.

I'm an absolute proponent of the kinds of products that get labeled as AI. I also think that useful predictions can be made in the face of uncertainty, because lets be real, human assessments, predictions and decisions also come with a degree of uncertainty (we usually just fail to rigorously quantify them).

RosanaAnaDana··on U.S. corn-based ethanol worse for the climate than gasoline, study finds
>Plowing the soil is a terrible thing to do. Which is why no farmer has done it since around 1980.

Thats just not true. Plenty of farmers still plough. There has been some movement to lower disturbance low-till/ minimum-till systems for commodity crops, but we're still seeing soil carbon losses in agricultural soils in general. Number isn't going up and to the right, its still going down and to the left. I appreciate the importance of these kinds of systems, but I also appreciate that its not nearly as well adopted as one would think based on a survey of youtube videos. There is a very real departure from the Internets vision of farming and real-life farming in terms of practice.

I do agree however that carbon in the soils is the answer to most problems. The closest thing I came to witnessing a fist fight at work was between two 50+ yo scientists regarding aluminium/ alumina ions and their relationship with soil carbon. If geriatric scientsits are willing to raise fisticuffs over it, you should wonder why they care so much.

RosanaAnaDana··on AWS will offer HF’s products to its customers and run its next LLM tool
for literally years I thought it was a tongue in cheek thing. The world to is now duller for the truth hath come and we found ourwelves wanting a grander fiction.
RosanaAnaDana··on AWS will offer HF’s products to its customers and run its next LLM tool
i as well.

i thought it was the principal behind the site. yiu can rip the face off of a model and retrain just the last bits.

RosanaAnaDana··on For the First Time, Genetically Modified Trees Have Been Planted in a US Forest
it's absolutely the other way. the dense rot resistant wood from older forests was basically mined away by companies, like wyerehauser and others, over the previous 3 centuries.
RosanaAnaDana··on Hugging Face and AWS partner to make AI more accessible
>Not disagreeing with your first point, but as I see it - this only enables HF to continue to spend money on making good open source tooling + doing research on open alternatives to closed source LLMs (something sorely needed), while opening them up to more enterprise customers who primarily use AWS.

This is the response/ justification every time. The issue is that it never goes that way.

>Time will tell!

It always does. What its shown me is that one step towards the slippery slope is enough to abandon hope for the project. Every good and useful open source project I've seen go this way inevitably turns their back on their customer and long outlives their usefulness.

RosanaAnaDana··on Hugging Face and AWS partner to make AI more accessible
Leadership is fungible,everyone has a price, and words are innevitably wind.

I would consider this a solid step in the direction agaisnt why huggingface is actually useful.

RosanaAnaDana··on Researchers Discover a More Flexible Approach to Machine Learning
I think chat GPT could be held up as a leg of support in this regard.
RosanaAnaDana··on Researchers Discover a More Flexible Approach to Machine Learning
i think googling it would be helpful, but in an overly general way, human exceptionalism is the idwa that there is sometjing unique or special associated with the human experience or with human experience.

The broader point i was making in the original comment is agaisnt this sentiment. Humans abiluty to unserstand why things happen bears little relevance to them happening. We now know little if anything about why the human consious experience happens or why it works, yet here we are.

Humans can make gun powder or a water wheel with no understanding of electron orbital theory or an concept of gravity that outlines orbital mechanics.

The shocking effectiveness of piling up large amounts of complexity seems to be sufficient many of the phenomena that humans seem to desure a much more mechanistic explanatiom for. In this sense, it could be that complexity is all you need.

and to bring it full circle, what about the complexity we see in non human, non animal systems? if complexity is all you need, what might be happening beyond the veil of human assumptioms around the consious experience?

RosanaAnaDana··on Researchers Discover a More Flexible Approach to Machine Learning
I mean, most people in this space don't even venture out of animalia.

There are many highly networked systems in biology where we know computation occurs, but we rarely consider it because we don't consider it intelligent. The casual example is fungal networks, but those don't hold a candle to the level of networking in a plant body thanks to plasmodesma.

the whole conversation around intelligence has been great, but it's mostly reminded me of how lacking and myopic our considerations of what intelligence actually is. The recent chapter of the saga has been great in terms of goal post movers, but I feel like we're no closer to a coherent definition of intelligence other than 'ill know it when I see it'. My prediction from this recent spat is that we'll have AGI before we know it, we won't know it as or recognize it as AGI, it won't fit convenient definitions, we'll have almost no clue how, and definitely no clue why it works, and we still mostly won't agree if it's intelligence or not. Effectively, it feels as if right now we're arguing about whether or not automobiles are horses, and laughing about how silly it is they can't do some of the things horses can do. Sure, but it all seems rather besides the point.

RosanaAnaDana··on Noam Chomsky on ChatGPT: High-Tech Plagiarism, Way of Avoiding Learning
This exactly the kind of handwringing I would expect from Chomsky.

His theories of intelligence are quickly being made irrelevant.

RosanaAnaDana··on I had ChatGPT write a Decemberists song and recorded it
I mean, if you've listened to a couple Decemberist albums, that criticism extends fully. There are plenty of dull, mediocre, and repetitive songs throughout. I'm listening and reacting to this one now. It would definately fell like a filler song. It lacks the kind of juxtoposition of positionality that Decemberist songs have. Its there but it comes in late and is a bit weak. The cord transitions are also a bit boring. But if you asked me to tell the difference between this and some other filler of theirs I know of, I probably couldn't.

Its also relentlessly positive in a way that Decemberist songs rarely are. Both acoustically and lyrically, which having played with ChatGPT a bit, seems to be a major part of its training. It avoids negativity in big ways. The Decemberists dont necessarily, and so it feels very gushy and bright in a way that it shouldnt.

RosanaAnaDana··on QGIS is the mapping software you didn't know you needed
The educational world needs to stop supporting them.
← PreviousPage 4 of 26Next →