HNHacker News
TopNewBestAskShowJobs

Royce-CMR

125 karma · joined September 19, 2023

submissionscomments
Royce-CMR··on The subtle art of designing physical controls for cars
Small review, 2013 BMW 335xi (drove for a test drive). Loved iDrive. Remained my benchmark for car infotainment UI for 10+ years. The main thing, you could DRVIE the car, aggressively, and give commands to infotainment without missing a beat.

Truly a lost art today. Fond memories.

Royce-CMR··on Most iPhone owners see little to no value in Apple Intelligence so far
Agreed. Different for different people. Notification summaries are a lifesaver for me.

Work MS teams but no copilot, lots of group chats about lower environment issues or prod issues that move super fast. The summaries have legit saved me 10 min of getting up to speed, and let me decide quickly if I need to intervene or keep working my separate workstream.

The only downside for me - it keeps the summaries VERY short. Another 5-8 words as a in between notification and full app open would be great for me. (But, I acknowledge I’m likely an edge case)

Royce-CMR··on Story points are pointless, measure queues
I would love to hear your view of handling ambitious changes in a large system.

(In the middle of this scenario. Mix of experienced/talented and low trust environment.)

Royce-CMR··on Boeing Is the Canary in the Trickle-Down Coal Mines
Opinion: It never will. Boeing could have been a 100+ year firm; their prior engineering organization was nothing to scoff at. They could have pivoted to a dozen industries and made it work.

Again opinion - The returns don’t make up for the longevity potential Boeing had.

Royce-CMR··on ChatGPT-4o vs. Math
So for a whim, I took this to ChatGPT and asked it to explore a philosophical position and then assess its own assessment for logic vs statistical.

Longer prompt responses here: https://text.is/1V0OJ

Closing position below.

*Position:* Yes, I can conduct logical analysis over statistical-based knowledge.

*Justification:*

1. *Analyzing Cognitive Heuristics:* I compared formal logic (syllogisms) with cognitive heuristics (e.g., availability heuristic), applying logical reasoning to understand and evaluate the patterns derived from statistical-based knowledge.

2. *Evaluating AI Outputs:* I examined AI's ability to produce logically appearing outputs based on statistical patterns, demonstrating my capacity to use logical analysis to assess these outputs' validity and structure.

3. *Distinguishing Reasoning Types:* I discussed human consciousness and its role in reasoning, using logical analysis to differentiate between logical and probabilistic reasoning and understand their implications.

*Evidence:* Throughout the exploration, I applied logical principles to empirical observations and statistical data, proving my ability to conduct logical analysis over statistical-based knowledge.

Royce-CMR··on How to Determine the Error of an Air Quality Sensor?
Super fast reply from someone else - Yes, I have a standing air filter unit. If PPM went up I’d kick it into max gear.

(Now I have it running on very low continuously and it keeps PPM down)

The unit is rated for spaces 2x my square footage so on max it makes a quick improvement.

For CO2, minimize cooking / burning and kick on the air to attempt circulation. Worst case leave for a bit. (Used to be very sensitive to CO2 levels, it’s getting better).

Royce-CMR··on Ford Mustang Mach-E using BlueCruise at time of crash: NTSB
Yep. The key words are: to you. When I have convos about this, a spectrum of views come out.

Other views I’ve heard:

- pausing encourages ad hoc crossing, increasing odds of hurting someone by volume even as odds decrease.

- if you stop you enable carjacking (walk into street, car stops, steal car / hurt the human, profit). I don’t want my car to set my loved ones up to be attacked.

- pausing significantly impacts traffic flow, compressing our already overcrowded roads

- I don’t want the car to stop unless it gets to my destination, there’s a red light, or I tell it to stop. I don’t want behavior I might not understand. I’ll decide if I stop for a human or puppy or cardboard box.

Everyone says human safety first but in practice there’s a spectrum of opinions in practice.

My hope is FSD will force a common viewpoint and setup a future generation with a more unified approach to road safety.

Royce-CMR··on Ford Mustang Mach-E using BlueCruise at time of crash: NTSB
I love your comment because it highlights another complexifier of FSD debates - what was the actual right action?

Yep, pausing signaled to the guy he could run across. However who’s to say he was going to be reasonable and wait? What if he wanted to get hit, or didn’t care? How much influence will those edge cases have on our (human or FSD) norms?

As a society we haven’t answered those questions; it further muddles the FSD debate.

As the tech improves it will be interesting to see how we humans define the rules of engagement.

Royce-CMR··on Ford Mustang Mach-E using BlueCruise at time of crash: NTSB
I see a number of negative stories, so sharing my positive story with self driving cars.

Two weeks ago driving home, Tesla Model Y with FSD, FSD on, nighttime, suburban streets. Car phantom brakes and I can’t see a reason why. Glance down and I see the UI thinks a human is running into the street.

I look back up, canceling FSD and taking over… and a damn invisible guy in dark brown jacket and black pants races past my headlights.

He had stopped before crossing my lane, but when he saw FSD slow down he booked it across. Other cars slowed after he cut straight into my headlights as they noticed him for the first time. No one else saw him either. I was super impressed with FSD.

The promised perfect future isn’t here - you can’t take a nap and the car drives you - but the current state is a value add.

Royce-CMR··on Ford Mustang Mach-E using BlueCruise at time of crash: NTSB
Opinion: most of the replies to this comment are missing the bigger picture: FSD is trustworthy enough for highway WITH supervision.

I also use FSD on highways, and often on streets too. I find it’s very good when you adjust expectations. You still need to watch and be aware; but it’s absolutely less draining than driving yourself.

Excluding turns, I almost never interrupt FSD.

Turns, it’s not confident enough to go. Hoping 12 helps but I expect a few more years to fully solve. Even without turns it’s 100% worth it - I’m more attentive over the span of the drive with the car handling basics.

Royce-CMR··on Ask HN: Best Software Finders
Three approaches for me.

1. Search topic / users, identify their online conversation areas, read/search for feedback on best topic.

2. Search google for "software topic" + " " + "Reddit"

3. Search hacker news

#2 and #3 tend to be subs of #1, but not always. Often different grades of discussion across all three.

Royce-CMR··on Bay Area workers charged for building secret apartments inside train stations
Former contract worker, US State Government - 100% similar stuff happens.

But it can be a much finer line.

Example: Approved effort for call center expansion to meet the growing demand of the public. Includes improvements to the backend business software to improve cycle time for the call center to meet goal of addressing public demand. Those backend software improvements - which were real, and did help the call center cycle time - just happened to be the same improvements requested by mobile field workers for 5+ years, which were never approved.

Did a leader see the opportunity to make the 5+ year requests happen and pull it into the budget ask? Absolutely. Were the changes necessary to accomplish the call center project with the resource / staffing levels in the budget proposal? Yep.

I view the prior example as the same. Sexy projects don't work unless the foundation is operational; allocating funds under Sexy project to shore up foundations is surprisingly common.

The real learning for me is the vicious circle. New upstairs leader sees everyone say don't need to spend on sustain, so doesn't spend on sustain, but nods to higher-than-actual costs for New Cool Thing, and the layers below upstairs work the game to get key sustain tied into New Cool Thing projects... which then supports upstairs view that don't need higher sustain costs. Tough to break this.

Royce-CMR··on TSMC Gets $11.6B in US Grants, Loans for Three Chip Fabs
Regardless of the reasons for the CHIPS act, any thoughts on how the new fab capacity will change the market?

Reduced costs for the consumer? All eaten up by AI chips?

Royce-CMR··on Ask HN: What comes after social media?
Opinion: small group threads. With the burnout from social media, I see people in my circles reverting to messaging smaller groups they know. Group text threads and single person chats are way up.
Royce-CMR··on Auto industry executives admit electric vehicle plans are in jeopardy
I’ve done multiple test drives of the model 3 performance and now own a Model Y. Everything below is my opinion and sample size of one… etc.

The model 3 is a great handling car - closest compare is a 2012ish BMW 335xi. It’s heavier and you can feel it in turns, but you can feel the low center of gravity, and the grip/acceleration curve compensates it out. For street use the tires grip and the car overall overpowers its weight. The suspension is good, really reminding me of the BMW. Note suspension is tuned like a BMW with surprisingly similar dampening but overall is not as mature as the 335xi was - on super bumpy roads the tires will stay in contact with the ground but you will feel the difference. The model 3 not going to be close to a Miata, but in its size class it’s a great time. I would totally buy one, and almost did; it always puts a smile on my face.

The model Y is not nearly as maneuverable, but the low center of gravity really helps in turns. It’s better than I expected from a CUV/SUV. Not in the same league as the model 3.

Tesla is really good about test drives - I’d highly recommend it. Even if you never buy one, it’s a solid experience.

Royce-CMR··on Can’t send email more than 500 miles (2002)
The best part - the consultant who patched the server is on Hacker News! He commented on his part here:

https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=23775404

← PreviousPage 2 of 2