HNHacker News
TopNewBestAskShowJobs

Santosh83

9,718 karma · joined January 20, 2016

submissionscomments
Santosh83··on The Vale Programming Language
Comparison of Vale with C++, Javascript and Rust, with detailed explanation of how it aims to do things differently in the three categories of speed, safety and ease of use.

https://vale.dev/comparisons

Santosh83··on Fyne, a cross-platform GUI toolkit written in Go
Does GTK work for targetting mobile platforms, like your parent wanted?
Santosh83··on The Helios microkernel
The SerenityOS team are building a browser from scratch and it is even passing some of the ACID tests. The pretty significantly along. So it is possible with enough dedication, but whether you can be competitive with Chrome is a different matter.
Santosh83··on The Helios microkernel
Fuchsia is by Google. This is a one man effort (at this point). Also it is just begun... Fuchsia is already used in some devices by Google. It is simply too early to make any kind of comparison except the implementation language. Fuchsia uses C++ while Helios is using its author's own Hare lang.
Santosh83··on The Helios microkernel
Linus is not a great believer in the microkernel architecture. Quite apart from that while certain things like FS can be shifted to userspace through FUSE, a ground-up rearchitecting into a microkernel may be extremely difficult for Linux at this stage. It would be more or less a rewrite of most of the core kernel I guess... and then the question of changes to the syscalls, which also Linus doesn't encourage.
Santosh83··on The Helios microkernel
Another thing not specifically mentioned in the post is this project will be a good workout for the brand new language (Hare) as well. I remember a post on it not too long back on HN that garnered a lot of scathing remarks. Good luck to the authors.

However I just want to add a personal comment. In my view, programs will come and go. They can be written and rewritten. But what is really important if we want to ensure free computing for all is not gradually eroded is to work on as many open standards for interoperability as possible to serve as alternatives for proprietary protocols. Also open, community developed languages. However the hardware situation is out of the hands of software developers, yet critically important. Open software and protocols on closed hardware is unsustainable. Lets hope someone like Musk takes the initiative in this area.

Santosh83··on Computers are an oppressive technology
> It doesn’t necessarily have to be this way. We could develop local manufacturing techniques that could be controlled and operated by individual people. But it’s hard to see how we climb down to that level from where we are.

How would that work? Unfortunately computers depend on a slew of mining industries plus advanced lithography, all heavily protected by IP. No existing player is incentivised to open up their techniques or make them more accessible. I could however imagine that it's fairly simple to build 1970s level computers today by any significant private or nation state entity. Sadly they'd be totally outcompeted by modern systems and won't be able to peer with them, and won't be attractive to the general public.

Santosh83··on Computers are an oppressive technology
Computers are fine but total computerisation of human society may not be so. That's actually what the article should have explored in my opinion. Computers are neither ruthless nor kind, its controllers, humans, are. So the question then becomes, who controls them and how sophisticated they (the computers) become, and how much they infiltrate our world. A simple thought... should everything that can theoretically be controlled by computer algorithms, made so? Should computers use ML for as many as tasks as possible, even though that can lead to wrong decisions on occasion?
Santosh83··on Data Race Patterns in Go
Memory safe, excellent tooling, excellent base std library, no manual memory management, static binaries, trivial cross compilation, trivial concurrent programming etc. These advantages are still not inconsiderable over C, although not C++. Yes, however, it is not as "safe" as Rust. But downside is C++ & Rust are harder to design for upfront.
Santosh83··on Always Own Your Platform (2019)
One of the simplest combination of solutions that I know in this space is to use Publii CMS to compose your blog and push it to GitHub Pages, which automagically makes your SSL enabled site live. Of course something as trivial as adding your custom domain leads you down a rabbit hole of nameservers, CDN etc. There is probably a simpler path here I'm missing.

But the bigger problem is the non-tech world simply doesn't know about any of this. When they want a site, they straightaway consider Blogger vs Wordpress vs SquareSpace vs Wix vs Shopify. Or just a FB/Instagram Page. In fact the latter often comes before the dedicated sites since you depend on them for networking.

It's a hard problem: how to be fully decentralised, yet connected/indexed/searchable, secure, yet flexible... and all this with sensible defaults and point-and-click to onboard lay people without scaring them away.

Santosh83··on Always Own Your Platform (2019)
They haven't shown up because non-tech people don't demand it. They cave in and use one of the managed solutions like wordpress dot com, squarespace etc. A group of devs need to create a solution even without demand & set about popularising it, which is very hard, when most people are satisfied with cloud solutions and don't see the danger that their data could be lost or vendor captured or censored arbitrarily. The second issue is network effects, where these cloud services provide exposure to your content and provide you exposure to related content, which as a self hoster, you must do for yourself.

Combined, both problems seem to be remarkably hard when viewed at closeup detail, especially when pitched to "point and click" users with minimal willingness to hack at the command line.

Santosh83··on Sunsetting Atom
In this case a community of devs seem to have picked up the code base, forked it, and is actively developing. So its not exactly dead.
Santosh83··on Sunsetting Atom
MS poured developers at VS Code which resulted in it blowing away Atom pretty soon in terms of performance. Soon devs started migrating to VSC, plugin ecosystem started accreting, and gradually people just forgot about Atom. It is not that Atom did anything horrendously wrong. If the same dev effort had been put into it that VSC got, am pretty sure it could've become almost as good now. Maybe even better in certain respects.
Santosh83··on Rust Is Hard, Or: The Misery of Mainstream Programming
> but I'll take C over C++ anyday.

Did you mean the opposite?

Santosh83··on Rust Is Hard, Or: The Misery of Mainstream Programming
Don't all languages hide OS API under their own libraries and abstractions? How is Rust special in this? IMO Rust is hard because it (the borrow checker) forces you to keep track of data and state manually. If you were aiming for practically bugless C/C++ I believe you'd have expend pretty much the same effort, but Rust forces you to do it, while C/C++ leave it up to you.
Santosh83··on Top-500 NPM package maintainers now require 2FA
The difference is people have become conditioned to trust corporations and organisations, so the software/hardware you mentioned have people or addresses who must answer if they get compromised. Whether they answer is a different thing, and whether this is a good model for everyone is another question. NPM packages on the other hand are dependent on random individuals for integrity and society doesn't trust individuals as much as registered entities, especially profit making ones.
Santosh83··on Twitter is using its embedded JavaScript to hide tweets that have been deleted
Twitter itself can always prove an individual user said something. I assume they never actually delete any tweet from their system, so a proper law enforcement request can require them to verify that a particular tweet actually did originate from a handle at such and such a time & IP.
Santosh83··on What happens if you try to download and install Firefox on Windows
I get the banner notification mentioned in OP's post too. It happens through bing on MS Edge, but does not happen through bing on Firefox.

https://imgur.com/a/SOgqBW0

Santosh83··on About Safety Mode and autoblock by Twitter
No precise definition of what constitutes repetitive, spammy or abusive replies. They even say "indiscriminate" following & unrelated hashtags can get the user autoblocked, which sounds like overreach. Considering some replies far exceed the silly Twitter character limit necessitating multiple replies, will those be struck down by autoblock as "repetitive"?

Twitter seems to be slowly moving in the direction of FB, which is already a moribund graveyard. Shooting themselves in the foot by diluting their key strengths? Seems sensible.

Santosh83··on Popular Tibetan singer Tsewang Norbu dies of self-immolation protest
Tibet has never been under the control of India as far as I know. It was an ethnically independent region in the past and now comes under the govt of China. So major Himalayan rivers originating in Tibet is a big gain for China and a strategic problem for India, considering China has already built several huge upstream damns across these rivers which irrigate much of N India.
Santosh83··on I wound up causing a major outage of my services and destroying my home dir
Non-tech end users are expected to backup everything to the Cloud. Not just backup but even store working copies. In fact non-technical users can, at most, plug in an external HDD/SSD and backup their files to it, but unless they take pains to keep a 2nd copy (and both copies in sync), it is no better than having your files on the system drive. Anything beyond this is too technical at the moment for laymen to use. I don't know why that is so. Many programs are more difficult/technical to use than they have to be. It's like some kind of unconscious gatekeeping.
Santosh83··on Ask HN: Why doesn't HN alert users in some manner to new replies?
This is my biggest beef with HN, along with the presence of up/downvote buttons.
Santosh83··on Heart-disease risk soars after Covid, even with a mild case
Am unvaccinated and recovered too. Heart is fine, as far as I can tell.
Santosh83··on GNU Doesn't Care About Your Agency
Linux itself is niche in the consumer space (not counting Android, Steam Deck and such)... fully-libre distros are ultra-niche. An average user migrating to Linux is very unlikely to even come across them, so most of the arguments made in the article don't apply in practice. As for technically aware users, again, nothing stops them from nuking their Parabola install and replacing it with Ubuntu in less time than it would take to write this article.

Let niche projects be. They serve people who seek them out. They don't aspire for the general case, and this rant is misplaced. Seems to be motivated by Stallman hate, frankly.

Santosh83··on The data are clear: The boys are not all right
Effect of dwindling & non-existent male role models and more importantly, fathers.
Santosh83··on Apple unveils contactless payments via Tap to Pay on iPhone
Cash decentralises power to the extent possible. E-currency centralises it to an absurd degree. That's the point. The slope of convenience though is gradual and slippery indeed. Institutions we've had for centuries crumbling in a matter of decades is a matter of concern. They worked more or less. There is no guarantee what is replacing them will work but we seem to have blind faith they will, since we're throwing the baby & the bathwater very gleefully out the window.
Santosh83··on Tell HN: You can see your vouched and flagged items
I think the reasons are pretty simple. HN is focused around tech folk & they are expected to write or use other frontends or tweak the output themselves. Also I get the feeling that no one wants to touch the working code to rewrite it. What's the incentive? It works and is lightweight. The number of people complaining is just not big enough. They probably don't have a dedicated dev because the site is that simple, and they want to keep it that way.
Santosh83··on Retrospective and technical details on the recent Firefox outage
What happened to the famed intelligence level of Hacker News? Every single person (almost) in this thread is blaming telemetry while it was clear even when the bug was ongoing that it was unrelated to telemetry. I for example had had telemetry disabled and still hit the bug through other traffic and had to temporarily disable HTTP3 from about:config.
Santosh83··on State of the Web: Static Site Generators
BlueGriffon?
Santosh83··on Essence: Desktop operating system built from scratch
So many interesting/fascinating concepts and ideas that will remain relegated to niche communities because of basically one problem: lack of drivers. This is the problem that must be solved if we ever want to move away from the dominance of a few OSes "too big to fail" and their million compromises to a thriving field where competent programmers can create new OSes as easily as now they can create new apps.
← PreviousPage 4 of 34Next →