HNHacker News
TopNewBestAskShowJobs

SapphireSun

1,965 karma · joined September 4, 2008

submissionscomments
SapphireSun··on The Robots Are Coming and Sweden Is Fine
http://www.epi.org/publication/robots-or-automation-are-not-...

"Robots, or automation, are not the problem. Too little worker power is."

SapphireSun··on The Robots Are Coming and Sweden Is Fine
Let's not kid ourselves. Everyone making that much money forms a social class that works to reengineer society to protect themselves, doctors included. However, we have engineered the system to make it look as though they deserve that much money by working students to exhaustion and saddling them with debt and poor working conditions. If we changed that, it wouldn't seem necessary to let specialists earn 250-700k+ per year. It's hard to believe that any of this is necessary or wise in a medical system.

Professional guilds like lawyers and doctors also limit the number of people in the field to protect wages. The AMA has been essentially an enemy of the people that works to milk the CPT codes. The grift is that a procedure typically is X$ and takes Y hrs to perform. They recommend that some are easier and harder and create a cheap CPT code and an expensive CPT code. This seems fair. Then everyone marks all procedures that can be remotely justified as such as the expensive CPT. There are other grifts but this is one way that health care costs inflate over time.

SapphireSun··on Kids in ‘Netflix Only’ Homes Saved from 230 Hours of Commercials a Year
These guys take apart The West Wing. Sad that it's only the teaser, the full episode is excellent.

https://soundcloud.com/chapo-trap-house/episode-101-teaser-a...

SapphireSun··on Silicon Valley homes now out of reach even for big spenders
You can probably measure some of that in terms of how people would have done these tasks previously. Some of those tasks are trivial, like keeping a paper calendar instead of a digital one.

You can also interpret it in terms of jobs eliminated.

SapphireSun··on Silicon Valley homes now out of reach even for big spenders
From yesterday: http://highline.huffingtonpost.com/articles/en/poor-millenni...
SapphireSun··on Former Facebook exec says social media is ripping apart society
Seems unlikely. < 1% of the US population is engaged in agricultural pursuits. Distribution is about to get self driving cars.
SapphireSun··on Former Facebook exec says social media is ripping apart society
Why not both? :D
SapphireSun··on Former Facebook exec says social media is ripping apart society
Man, if only instead of buying a Jet ski these poor souls would find socialism.
SapphireSun··on Patreon’s new service fee spurs concern that creators will lose patrons
I didn't know that so I checked them out and when I saw their featured creators my skin started to crawl.
SapphireSun··on Universal Basic Income Explained – Free Money for Everybody? [video]
I think this question is only answerable with specific numbers. If UBI = $1 / person, then the difference in pressure is small. Also, you presume that people only work for money. I think with UBI, you'd see a revitalization of community oriented, but low profit pursuits.
SapphireSun··on Qualcomm Centriq 2400: The first 10nm server processor
I like to think of the cloud as a ski-rental.
SapphireSun··on Did American Missile Defense Fail in Saudi Arabia?
Thank you for the links.
SapphireSun··on Did American Missile Defense Fail in Saudi Arabia?
Here's a good rundown.

https://theintercept.com/2017/11/29/very-bad-men-trump-the-s...

SapphireSun··on Did American Missile Defense Fail in Saudi Arabia?
It's in large part the choice of topic rather than the details of the article. They could have chosen to highlight how Yemeni defenses work in light of a US backed Saudi bombing campaign.
SapphireSun··on Did American Missile Defense Fail in Saudi Arabia?
O.o The NYT is framing this as Saudi being attacked? The Saudi forces are executing a genocide in Yemen backed by US military targeting, weapons, and mid-air refueling (some of this was stopped but not all of it). This is on the back of Thomas Friedman's laughable piece on MBS (https://www.nytimes.com/2017/11/23/opinion/saudi-prince-mbs-...). Is the Times executing a propaganda campaign? Sickening.
SapphireSun··on What happens when patients find out how good their doctors are? (2004)
As you can see with the tax plan being rammed through, the minority of the wealthiest can ram through whatever they damn well please. We can do the same to them. We outnumber them.

Any yes, we can rationally allocate resources to ensure care is adequately delivered.

SapphireSun··on What happens when patients find out how good their doctors are? (2004)
I think this is similar to the idea of Health Justice that I've heard Tim Faust talk about. The reason the hospital will take the deal is simple, it's the only deal by law and the private insurance payers will be eliminated.
SapphireSun··on What happens when patients find out how good their doctors are? (2004)
Think carefully about what you're saying. The rich get to live longer and healthier and the poor get substandard healthcare? The poor are the ones that need to work.
SapphireSun··on What happens when patients find out how good their doctors are? (2004)
That's what I was thinking of but didn't articulate correctly. Can you elaborate? What interactions fail if the model isn't comprehensive?
SapphireSun··on What happens when patients find out how good their doctors are? (2004)
The alternative is medicare for all bundled with something that looks like per capita allocations to take care of a patient population. Patients pay nothing at the point of service. Hospitals must drive down costs to make a profit. If they start cutting corners, they lose their bonuses. If they really aren't making enough money to do their job and can prove it to an independent board, their allocations can be increased. You can imagine some kind of bonus system based on YOY improvement or maintenance of patient outcomes.
SapphireSun··on What happens when patients find out how good their doctors are? (2004)
I don't understand how this helps hospital management once it enters the feedback loop. It does incentivize them to not get there in the first place, but I bet when you analyze the tradeoffs they make to forestall it you won't be happy either.

This is especially a problem is when you have a lone hospital serving a poor area. The patients don't have money, maybe they don't have insurance. If the hospital starts cranking out bad results, it'll just deteriorate.

The market model only kinda works in theory for wealthy populations with multiple hospitals nearby.

SapphireSun··on What happens when patients find out how good their doctors are? (2004)
I the interesting thing to consider is what happens to the hospitals that do terribly, but not so poorly that they should be shut down. The publication of their rating will start causing doctors and patients to avoid them. In our fee-for-service model, this causes the hospital to starve and enter a vicious feedback loop.

Perhaps we should have an independent commission that has the ability to perform an outside investigation into these cases and attempt to understand what's going wrong. For hospitals that are under-resourced, they would have to power to increase allocations. On the flip side, it could shut down the ones that are irreparably broken that can safely be removed from a region.

Also, we should do away with fee-for-service for good. It is the worst bag of incentives this side of the line between healing and hurting.

SapphireSun··on What Bikini Atoll Looks Like Today
I was very interested to see this first person perspective. I recently wrote an article that might serve as a historical companion to this one, based on public documents rather than on the ground reporting if you're interested: https://medium.com/insane-before-the-sun/3-nuked-sinking-the...
SapphireSun··on I don’t want to be a software developer anymore
Of course, we could fight for those people instead of dividing the working class but I digress.
SapphireSun··on We Can’t Trust Facebook to Regulate Itself
He's right. NYT flips from a reasonable centrist publication to a war monger at the first hint of fighting. How many bodies do they have on them from lending legitimacy to Afghanistan and Iraq let alone Vietnam?
SapphireSun··on If Linus Torvalds got hit by a bus would Linux die (2012)
I laughed. Thank you.
SapphireSun··on If Linus Torvalds got hit by a bus would Linux die (2012)
You're right of course, but there is a reason the colloquialism takes this form as opposed to another. Colloquialisms, the intelligible ones at least, sublimate some underlying element of culture in order to communicate sensibly and easily.

This very idea of stretching logic to extremes without consideration for real world effects is very much a foundational element in programmer culture. It's born out of rationalism and certain elements of enlightenment thinking. However, this pure (im)practical reason is often applied in all circumstances irrespective of the context. After all, it's possible to reason about a person's absence without also implying the worst, and this kindness is valuable. If SV could somehow change its foundational thinking from reason + corrosive business practices to reason + kindness we'd all be better off.

SapphireSun··on If Linus Torvalds got hit by a bus would Linux die (2012)
This is petty and shallow, but I'm annoyed with programmer culture in the sense that people always phrase this sort of question in terms of "what if the person that gave us so much kicked off" rather than "what if they were unavailable or retire"? It's morbid and sort of implies that the only way that person would ever stop is if they died.

It leaves me feeling slimy. It's intended to say this person is so dedicated they would never ever abandon a software project of their own free will. In the case of free (as in beer) software projects, the author is often not even compensated. It really makes it seem like the people that are helping you are entirely subservient to the machines and the wanton desires of others. It also appeals to the serious business person that lives in the hearts of so many developers where only the harshest framing can be considered as dealing with the world in real terms.

Anyway, carry on. I just wanted to say my piece.

SapphireSun··on Carl Sagan Warned the World About Nuclear Winter
This is a very strong claim, and based on what I've read I do not believe it is accurate to say nuclear winter research was so off the mark as to be "inaccurate". Please see my comments further up the thread. Please cite the arguments you are basing this claim on.

My understanding is that the major source of confusion was the headline of a 1990 NYT article that made it look like nuclear winter was wrong, but the actual contents were much more moderate.

http://www.nytimes.com/1990/01/23/science/nuclear-winter-the...

SapphireSun··on Carl Sagan Warned the World About Nuclear Winter
I dug up the correspondence. Here's what Dr. Robock said. Again, I explicitly asked permission to quote him. Here's the relevant excerpt.

Me: "I understand that you've conducted 100 Hiroshima simulations that describe a nuclear autumn that could lead to mass starvation. Is it known where the crossover point is located between deaths due to direct effects and incidental effects of nuclear war? Furthermore, is this even a useful question to ask?"

Dr. Robock: "We simulated one case of an India-Pakistan nuclear war. We estimated 20,000,000 direct casualties, and Ira estimated 1,000,000,000 to 2,000,000,000 indirect deaths. We have a new project to do much better jobs of investigating more credible scenarios and quantifying the impacts on agriculture and food availability."

I'd recommend digging into the paper for more info. Probably in a month or two, I'll have an article that explores this question based on available credible sources in more depth.

He has a TEDx talk here: http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=qsrEk1oZ-54

EDIT: added TEDx link

← PreviousPage 2 of 30Next →