HNHacker News
TopNewBestAskShowJobs

SapphireSun

1,965 karma · joined September 4, 2008

submissionscomments
SapphireSun··on Carl Sagan Warned the World About Nuclear Winter
I agree with your criticism. We'll have to read the paper to find out what that means. ;)
SapphireSun··on Trade school, not 4-year college, is a better bet to solve the US income gap
There is a fourth option, though it's longer term. I think that's okay since we've been dealing with this problem for forever. Work together with other nations to raise their standards of living and labor.

We do some of that but then we also depose governments, start wars under the banner of drugs and terrorism. Those latter effects are huge and often not considered in concert with immigration policy. I'm stealing this analogy, but keeping these people out is like setting fire to someone's home and then locking the door.

SapphireSun··on Trade school, not 4-year college, is a better bet to solve the US income gap
I don't recall. I think I did add a sentence or two, but I don't think I changed it enough to change your read of tone.
SapphireSun··on Carl Sagan Warned the World About Nuclear Winter
Thank you for the links. I'll have to read your articles very closely later, but recent climate simulations by Alan Robock at Rutgers and analysis by Ira Helfand at IPPNW and others show that a nuclear autumn, created by 100 15-kT (Hiroshima sized) nukes could cause a famine that affects up to 2B people.

I wrote to Dr. Robock and asked him about his model (explicitly on the record, so I'm not disclosing a private conversation). I asked specifically why did the Iraq oil well fires from the Gulf War not inject soot into the stratosphere and cause climatic effects. He wrote back that the difference lies in the formation of firestorms. I draw from this by implication that he believes there remains enough combustable material to start a firestorm in enough places to matter. It's worth noting that while cities have changed a lot, a firestorm did develop in one of the two Japanese cities bombed. I'll have more to say about this in a month or so once I do more research and review your materials.

Here's a link to some of their work: http://ippnw.org/nuclear-famine.html

SapphireSun··on Trade school, not 4-year college, is a better bet to solve the US income gap
You're downvoting me, and that's natural. I assume the bulk of vocal HNers are ancap libertarians (possibly some of you aligning with the Dark Enlightenment). However, you should take what I said more seriously. It represents a point of view with which you've perhaps had little contact, but is held by a significant (possibly even growing) portion of the population. It is diametrically opposed to many of the precepts you've been taught.

For instance, that process legitimizes outcomes rather than the other way around. That one is a bit weird, because the SV _thing_ is to conduct A/B testing and achieve outcomes at all costs. However, you also in your heart of hearts believe that there are institutions, such as schools, governments, and corporations that, solely on their own merits, elevate some people legitimately above others. You might also believe that hierarchy, coercion, and domination are legitimate elements of society when expressed in particular forms such as corporate officers, investors, managers, take-it-or-leave-it contracts, privatization, and denial of aid.

Here's a quick primer: https://www.currentaffairs.org/2017/06/the-difference-betwee...

SapphireSun··on Trade school, not 4-year college, is a better bet to solve the US income gap
"...with characteristic boom-bust cycles and scams." 2008 called, I told them you're available.
SapphireSun··on Trade school, not 4-year college, is a better bet to solve the US income gap
You've arrived at the unthinkable thought. Why indeed, in a very rich country, do any poor people at all exist? Why is this crime not remedied immediately? The only possible explanation in a democratic society, is that somehow the upper classes have rigged the system via political machinations, voter suppression, dividing the intermediate classes against each other, and propaganda. It's a sobering thought. We might also ask ourselves, why are billionaires allowed to persist? Is that not itself, in the face of suffering, a crime on the face of humanity?
SapphireSun··on How Firefox Got Fast Again
This argument doesn't apply if you are suddenly locked out of your account. Then your option to switch still incurs the tremendous costs of the loss of possibly years of work. The original provider must still be accountable.
SapphireSun··on Let’s improve commuter rail service between Providence and Boston
What if it actually was a high speed rail? Maybe more people would use it, or even expand towns around a highly available rapid transit resource.
SapphireSun··on A Very Long, Super-Nerdy NBA Podcast Is Making Money
I think the point is that it hasn't happened... yet. In theory, writing for newspapers shouldn't be expensive either, yet somehow it is.
SapphireSun··on Older Americans who live in RVs and drive from one low-wage job to another
I think the bigger idea is that there should be a broader system of international mutual aid. We can't drag down our own labor standards because someone else's is terrible. We need to help raise them up. Only international cooperation can prevent us from accelerating in a race to the bottom.
SapphireSun··on A Very Long, Super-Nerdy NBA Podcast Is Making Money
It really depends. The problem is that once advertising become the primary drip of financial resources, the content begins to revolve around the needs, goals, and preferences of advertisers. Content that isn't seen as monetizable gets shown the door. Content that rails against consensus opinion or is anti-corporate gets shut down. Things that earn money get promoted at the expense of all else.

You can see this lucidly in the case of Bill O'Reilly. People had already known his deal for over a decade, but it wasn't until his ad dollars were pulled (after a public pressure campaign) that he was dethroned. That's an example of the kind of media system that is fostered by advertisement.

EDIT: changed 'decades' to 'over a decade'. https://www.rollingstone.com/politics/features/a-timeline-of...

SapphireSun··on A Very Long, Super-Nerdy NBA Podcast Is Making Money
I'll be very disappointed when podcasting becomes fully metricised. The large scale introduction of advertising will be toxic and do to this beautiful indie space what has happened to the web.
SapphireSun··on DNAinfo and Gothamist Are Shutting Down
Congrats, you just added one more nail in the coffin of capitalism.
SapphireSun··on Netflix Employees Are Happier with Their Job Than Facebook or Google Employees
To be clear, I am totally on board with reimagining the economy. Sorry, that didn't come through in my post.
SapphireSun··on DNAinfo and Gothamist Are Shutting Down
If unions can see the budget sheet and negotiate accordingly, they wouldn't kill the company. They want to keep their jobs, this is nonsense.
SapphireSun··on Netflix Employees Are Happier with Their Job Than Facebook or Google Employees
I'm not against this, but it goes against the grain of a capitalist economy as it does not maximize overall profits. For this concept to work at scale, we might need to rejigger the whole economy.
SapphireSun··on Income, Poverty and Health Insurance Coverage in the United States: 2016
I don't think it's either or. We should give sober advice while acknowledging that a better future is possible. One without the other alternatively doesn't keep the door to that better future open or isn't practical.
SapphireSun··on Income, Poverty and Health Insurance Coverage in the United States: 2016
I place the burden of bare economic security on society rather than the individual. It's really reactionary to say that someone that aspires to a healthy lifestyle is asking for too much. In this incredibly wealthy country, we can afford that. Many would argue, myself included, that the failure of aspirational thinking is producing the current crisis.
SapphireSun··on Income, Poverty and Health Insurance Coverage in the United States: 2016
What about all the people that have no interest or ability to code? What happens when everyone does code? Wages collapse.
SapphireSun··on Facebook employees opened a privately shared Google Sheet
It's only unremarkable in the sense that we know in the abstract that FB can look at our stuff. This makes it concrete. That's very important as it breaks the mental model users have of Facebook, that messanger is in some sense private. Events like these can drive the point home that that is not correct.
SapphireSun··on Why Snapchat Spectacles failed
FUCK. I thought that when we attained wealth, power, and appeared on the covers of magazines people would stop dunking our heads in toilets and finally pay us SOME RESPECT. This just shows that our society isn't a meritocracy. It doesn't even matter anymore what you do, we're still undesirables to the cheerleaders and jocks and the popular kids.

We'll get our revenge though. We control everything you mfers see, hear, buy, and think. If you look down on us, get ready for your phone to be the new heroin. If you like us, you can be free and dance with us and sample the earthly delights of the real world. We will be Neo, you can elect to be Morpheus or Trinity. Or we can be the machines in zero-one. Maybe that fits better.

Enjoy your new paradise losers.

/s

SapphireSun··on Why Snapchat Spectacles failed
I regret the day I was born. :'(
SapphireSun··on Study shows the top 0.01% of Scandinavian households underpaid taxes by 30%
You are living in a pre-11/9 mentality my friend. A few years ago, it was easy to think that material possessions were enough. The yawing chasms in the fabric of society are now baldly apparent.

The old system is crashing. We need to acknowledge reality now and work as fast as possible to fix it after we figure out how.

SapphireSun··on Study shows the top 0.01% of Scandinavian households underpaid taxes by 30%
I'm unable to spend much time commenting atm, but what I will say is that unlike the Economist, you are the one editorializing. Factually, capitalism/globalization has benefited lower classes materially, but has stripped them of agency. While you are right globalization is not entirely new (e.g. mercantilism, the East India Company), what is new is private, multinational actors being able to choose which set of rules they can play by.

That is genuinely new, at least at scale. Private actors making states compete against each other to lower their taxes and sue nations for enforcing health codes a la investor rights trade agreements.

While trade is good, extractive trade is damaging. The American industrial midwest is a good example. Capitalists first moved jobs overseas, and then automated what was left. We still have strong manufacturing, but few people doing it.

This level of inequality, lack of agency, and lack of hope is incredibly corrosive to democratic values. You can see it for yourself in the election of our leader, the grievance of the pepés, and the general ascension of the right. The fact that this kind of thing is taking place globally across the trilateral powers means there's something systemic at work, it's not a quirk of American circumstance.

SapphireSun··on Study shows the top 0.01% of Scandinavian households underpaid taxes by 30%
Are any of those statements factually incorrect or otherwise misleading? A critical discussion of methodology is welcome.
SapphireSun··on Announcement: RT and Sputnik Advertising
I think you misunderstood what I meant by allowable. He can legally act using the powers of his office, but we can shun him. It's morally abhorrent and violates international law. It's only in a very limited sense that his behavior is "allowable" even if that sense is the one that ends up mattering practically.
SapphireSun··on Tesla Turns Power Back on at Children's Hospital in Puerto Rico
All I can say is I saw this headline and breathed a sigh of relief. I haven't heard anything good coming out of PR at all.

For what it's worth, while I like the idea of solar power as the revival of PR's power grid, I would not be breathing such a sigh of relief if the feds had helicoptered in with the kind of energy they reserve for invading countries and restored power and set up relief for villages far from the port.

SapphireSun··on Announcement: RT and Sputnik Advertising
The constitution makes him the commander in chief and delegates war authority to congress. The AUMF signed after 9/11 was poorly drafted, contained no expiration, and has ceded control from congress to the executive in extraordinary ways. Nuclear authorities that allow one man to destroy the world have always been egregious since we instituted them.

Nonetheless, Commander in Chief ≠ Command of Twitter. A private entity doesn't have to indulge him and such dissent is protected by the 1st amendment.

SapphireSun··on Announcement: RT and Sputnik Advertising
I think the spirit of the TOS of humanity (e.g. Article II paragraph 4 of the UN Charter) would banish offensive war and the threat of war. These threats are _worse_ coming from the president. His being the president doesn't make these things more allowable, only our deference to hierarchy does.

Mere legalism is failing us, let alone the spirits of legalism. I'm not happy about it.

← PreviousPage 3 of 30Next →