HNHacker News
TopNewBestAskShowJobs

SapphireSun

1,965 karma · joined September 4, 2008

submissionscomments
SapphireSun··on Daniel Kahneman “I placed too much faith in underpowered studies”
Daniel Kahneman responded to this blog in the comments section.
SapphireSun··on Dialectical Wisdom
It was pretty funny to click on that expecting something on Dialectical Materialism and finding an essay on Hegel by a VC that co-founded Palentir no less. This idea of dialectics is very powerful, and his reasoning is sensible. I wonder how he balances helping build an omnipresent surveillance state unknown in human history with the moral principles he espouses.

Unrelated, I wonder if dielectrics (a material that polarizes in an electric field) maybe were named by scientists aware of philosophy that made a pun.

SapphireSun··on As Amazon Pushes Forward with Robots, Workers Find New Roles
While I should look up a chart, I'm not able to at the moment, but I'd point out that computerization should have added a large constant factor to labor productivity starting in the 90s, you'd expect wages to rise proportionally if that's the case (and for the jobs displaced to be replaced with high wage jobs too).

I can point out banking deregulation, airline deregulation, oil extraction deregulation.... it hasn't been a uniform march in a single direction, but there has been significant deregulation in core industries. One might point out that the construction industry is now safer, as in fewer people die per building. It's not really possible to justify any deaths for construction in reasonable circumstances.

The question is has a doubling of wages kept pace with the increase in wealth in those countries? I suspect 2x is far below the wealth that was produced. It would be helpful to discuss a particular example.

SapphireSun··on As Amazon Pushes Forward with Robots, Workers Find New Roles
It kinda worked after world war two in the wake of the New Deal (which incidentally was instituted in a depression and a >90% top tax rate). In the 1970s, deregulation took over and worker wages began to stagnate and decline. Tax rates fell. Since 2007 when the banks imploded and were bailed out on the people's dime (the people weren't bailed out), we've been unable to fix the economy with monetary policy.

Demand has been slack for a decade and economists are freaking out. What's going on? Why is civil society disintegrating? Why is the fascist right rising? Why are white people's life expectancy declining?

Neoliberal reforms (deregulation, private capital, sale of nationalized industries, etc) that were instituted in central america, south america, Russia, and others basically destroyed them. In particular, the wave of desperate people arriving at our borders are in significant part due to US support of neoliberal policy and the support of violent regimes in El Salvador, Guatamala, Chile, Argentina, and on and on.

You have to ask yourself, why are we facing problems now? We're the global superpower! Even more so, why are the economic maladies present throughout the western world at a time when we should be at the peak of our civilization? This was something that stumped me for a long time. Shouldn't problems be regional? How is it possible for Donald Trump, Brexit, Geert Wilders, and Marine le Penn to occur at the same time?

There's a systemic problem. Think about it.

SapphireSun··on As Amazon Pushes Forward with Robots, Workers Find New Roles
Robots are cool. Even though amazon is hiring, they employ robots for a reason, it means that fewer employees are needed per a unit of work. In the absence of robots, more employees would be hired.

I like efficiency. I think abundance is great. Our economic system ensures that those things will not help the great mass of people in our society.

SapphireSun··on Monopoly Without a Monopolist: An Economic Analysis of the Bitcoin System [pdf]
I mean literally extracting resources: mining, logging, fishing, oil extraction. As resources become more scarce, the market system causes the price to shoot up, incentivizing the completion of the process to extinction. In the case of cryptocurrencies, it's abstracted somewhat since we use electricity, but those energy resources must come from somewhere, and right now it's not renewables for the most part.

I get what you're saying, but the entire idea of bitcoin is literally an exponential ramp. Each new technology that improves speed (CPU->GPU->ASIC) will be a linear step up, but mining will get exponentially harder. There are network effects from the banking world, but I don't think they should grow even as (N^2 where everyone is connected to everyone else) as they probably use something between than and a spoke and hub model.

SapphireSun··on This place is not a place of honor
I think it's worth adding a max width, it makes the columns easier to read if they're not too long. Other than that, it's pretty great.
SapphireSun··on Monopoly Without a Monopolist: An Economic Analysis of the Bitcoin System [pdf]
This is an interesting critique. I don't deny that other alt-coins might make use of blockchains to solve other problems that aren't currency.

The thing I'm taking away from the article is that it compares BTC to gold favorably, which is an interesting angle. I generally think that gold is an irrational investment, after all there is no intrinsic value to gold other than for jewelry electronics, and high tech science experiments but that's not what the gold bugs claim.

However, if you kind of turn the argument on its head a bit, gold is sort of like a ground up fiat currency. It has no intrinsic value and it has no army, but it forms a focal point of public consciousness that renders it deflationary fiat.

However, there are other problems with BTC even if you accept the idea of deflationary fiat. For instance, money doesn't just pool in rich people's pockets, you can literally lose a BTC wallet and the money is just gone forever. Over time, this will result in the number of BTC in circulation approaching zero. I don't know how long that will take.

The other argument against BTC is that its essentially capitalism run amok. We already destroy the environment to extract dollars, but now with cryptocurrencies, we actually have to destroy exponentially more raw energy to fuel the monetary system itself. It's a satire of capitalism in a world of environmental catastrophe.

As for the Tulips, maybe I'm interpreting the chart incorrectly, but while the options price rose to insane levels, the realized prices, for a shorter duration, still rose to 100x (options were at 200x).

SapphireSun··on Monopoly Without a Monopolist: An Economic Analysis of the Bitcoin System [pdf]
Mainly the idea of a bubble resulting in real utility to people. If bitcoin isn't used for transactions, it's a store of value. It's gold + technology people don't understand. I don't understand how that's any different from a tulip except that you don't have to wash the dirt off of it when you uproot it.

EDIT: I was also trying to make a point that CDOs were based in a kind of network effect where the risk was submerged under an ocean of statistics. Yet in the end, the underlying assumptions were faulty and the network effects lit on fire like gasoline.

SapphireSun··on Monopoly Without a Monopolist: An Economic Analysis of the Bitcoin System [pdf]
Sorry.... I had to.

"I think this is mostly correct, but I see it a bit differently. This bubble is slowly building up real housing for hard working poor and middle class people. Use cases like pay-day loans and sub-prime mortgages become more and more viable as the network size grows. Eventually enough people own mortgages that it makes sense for it to be baked into a CDO, and for it to be used in lieu of liquid assets. Bubbles are the boot loader of real utility."

SapphireSun··on U.S. House approves proposal to speed the deployment of self-driving cars
I dunno, a financially disinterested third party that appoints an expert panel of inspectors could stop a poor decision from being made. Most of the time, the internal processes within these companies will work correctly.

What can happen is if suddenly there's a race to market that throws process off the rails or a risk factor that was dismissed because of particulars of the culture that is producing the vehicles. That's where an outside inspector and premarket approval really helps.

SapphireSun··on U.S. House approves proposal to speed the deployment of self-driving cars
Tell that to the Radium Girls. :P
SapphireSun··on U.S. House approves proposal to speed the deployment of self-driving cars
"Automakers would have to submit safety assessment reports to regulators, but the bill would not require pre-market approval of advanced vehicle technologies. The measure now goes to the Senate, where a bipartisan group of lawmakers has been working on similar legislation."

You and I both know that without premarket approval, one or more companies are going to get careless and are going to kill people before the technology is ready. It's going to stain public acceptance for a quite necessary technology.

Here's a new medicine we're developing! It's gonna totally work great. The science says it's possible, we just need to work out the kinks while treating hundreds of thousands of people....

SapphireSun··on What the Industrial Revolution Tells Us about the Future of Automation
And universal basic housing and universal basic education. Then everyone would really be free to be entrepreneurs, but they wouldn't have to fixate on profit seeking at the expense of all else.
SapphireSun··on What the Industrial Revolution Tells Us about the Future of Automation
The entire idea of a gig economy is that you get random low paying clients. How could infrastructure ever make this any different from what it is?
SapphireSun··on Raddit: An open source alternative to Reddit
It's pretty confusing, but it seems to me that the uniting factor between the anarchists and the statist left is a common belief in human freedom from hierarchical structures, but each chooses different method to implement it.
SapphireSun··on Criticizing Google got me fired
Sorry I meant: Barry Lynn <=> Larry Brin O.O
SapphireSun··on Criticizing Google got me fired
There's the con. There is no independence from funding sources unless you have so many that you can ignore losing one. Now if one were to turn that critical lens to the rest of the advertising funded media...
SapphireSun··on Criticizing Google got me fired
Barry Lynn <=> Sergey Brin?!!
SapphireSun··on Low-fat diet could kill you, major study shows
It's not just academic studies, journalists very frequently don't cite their sources for many factual claims. Their editors and them knowing what or whom it is is way too often enough for them.

It rubs me the wrong way. It feels a lot like: "We know better and can tell you what to think. We don't need to show our work."

That said, it has been getting better, especially for the tech savy younger generation with Twitter links (:P), but their editors are probably trying to keep the number of hyperlinks relatively low.

SapphireSun··on Billionaires and big ag are joining venture investors to fund lab-grown meat
Tell that to farmers, grocers, restauranteurs, laboratories, chemists, and many many other industries. Those problems are real, and they need solving even if their profit margins are lower (which is not always true).
SapphireSun··on Dinosaur-Killing Asteroid Could Have Caused 2 Years of Darkness
Before decrying how wrong it is, try estimating how much those effects matter.
SapphireSun··on Single-Molecule Transistors at Room Temperature
A caveat to keep in mind, diatomic hydrogen is not 0.2.

EDIT: Actually the van der wahl diameter of Hydrogen is about 240pm. 0.12nm is about the radius.

SapphireSun··on Ask a Female Engineer: Thoughts on the Google Memo
I seriously question whether that was a minority viewpoint expressed in the memo. I went to school with loads of people like that. I think the reason such viewpoints get blowback is because they basically argue for the status quo when the system is not serving large swaths of the population.
SapphireSun··on The Last American Baseball-Glove Maker Refuses to Die
You guys almost get it. Keep going. What if instead of allowing American workers to suffer and businesses to trade capital around regulations at labor's expense, everyone, even overseas workers, were protected instead? Too misty eyed? Dream bigger.
SapphireSun··on I’m an Ex-Google Woman Tech Leader and I’m Sick of Our Approach to Diversity
You're describing the German court system in which the job of the judge is to search for the truth. The US system is adversarial, the two sides present evidence, the Jury is the finder of fact and the Judge is the finder of law. If the two sides do not wish to search for the truth, it will not be found. This is common when the prosecution refuses to consider alternative theories and the defense merely wants to get off without having the resources to find the true criminal.

Also, fwiw, that process sounds like it would be pretty good at filtering candidates to be good at the job, but broad categories like "communication skills" cover an awful lot of territory. Imagine someone from quite a different culture with wildly different (but effective within their culture) communication styles that people in your company thought was weird. That person would probably be barred from working and integrating into the corporate culture.

I'm not saying you guys are bad people, or that I would have the guts to make that call myself, but I just want to point out that process as a fig leaf for distilling conformity is just that.

SapphireSun··on Inside Patreon, the economic engine of internet culture
Ads are a good business model but a bad cultural model. If your users are paying the bills, only your users can penalize you if you do something an advertiser wouldn't like. If you make a hard hitting documentary that says mean things about powerful people, advertisers pull their funding but your audience might have wanted to see it.
SapphireSun··on Amazon's Whole Foods deal under scrutiny
I'm pretty amused that you guys think I'm advancing a pro-Trump position here. The reason he's doing this is clearly because he's a vindictive authoritarian that wants to suppress the free press. There's no way he cares at all about anti-trust law.

The point I'm trying to get across is that the independence of the free press is threatened by concentration of power. Trump should not even be able to attack the Washington Post in this indirect fashion. In this case, he's probably doing the right thing for the wrong reason. Let The Post be independent of enormous corporate interests and reduce its attack surface.

Also, I might have to watch A Few Good Men tonight. Thanks for the reminder.

"DON'T YOU KNOW THE PRESIDENT LIES?!" "SON. YOU CAN'T HANDLE THE TRUTH."

SapphireSun··on Amazon's Whole Foods deal under scrutiny
Jeff is CEO of Amazon and owns the Post. While the President is technically inaccurate, I'm not sure he is de facto inaccurate.
SapphireSun··on Amazon's Whole Foods deal under scrutiny
The crazy thing is, the deal should be getting scrutiny anyway. This would be Trump doing his job.

The thing that should worry us more is the concentration of power of a single individual owning Amazon and the Washington Post represents. Why should a corporate deal affect a newspaper watching out for the interests of the public? It seems insane. That's because it is.

← PreviousPage 5 of 30Next →