HNHacker News
TopNewBestAskShowJobs

SapphireSun

1,965 karma · joined September 4, 2008

submissionscomments
SapphireSun··on America's Cult of Ignorance (1980) [pdf]
The mobilization of the ignorant doesn't really matter. If they vote randomly and both sides are equally mobilized, the ignorant votes cancel out and the biased (hopefully knowledgable) participants actually determine policy. This becomes harmful when particular factions are mobilized in isolation.... thus US politics.
SapphireSun··on America's Cult of Ignorance (1980) [pdf]
I think it has something to do primarily with things feeling like you can have an effect on them. Accessibility and policy both matter. This is something I'm still figuring out like everyone else, but I think pure disinterest and laziness is not good explanation in light of the energy that can be seen in other political campaigns throughout history, like the new deal.
SapphireSun··on America's Cult of Ignorance (1980) [pdf]
I live in Boston and I don't see much local coverage unless I look for it explicitly. Unless I subscribe to a local paper I don't really see much of their reporting. I did see some local papers with great stories in grocery store, but they were positioned poorly. It took me literally years of going to that store before I noticed them. Secondly, I feel powerless as my elected officials are basically doing what I already want them to do. A little while ago, I got a newsletter from my state senator with a photo of her hanging out in a marijuana greenhouse wearing a bunny suit. I didn't know how to respond for a moment and started laughing. It's a pretty dumb thing, and I'm certainly not one of the overly oppressed people in this country, but it felt like a crack in the door where my representatives were pushing for more civic freedom and tamping down on calls for repression and state violence.

I think people get more interested if there are ways for them to have an effect on outcomes or if they can see people they know doing things. I'm sort of embarrassed, but I joined an organization pushing for instant runoff voting in MA thanks to a friend convincing me to try it out (and I want it to happen!), but I hadn't heard from them since that introduction. Without a friend there, it's difficult for me to work up the courage to go time and time again as I'm kind of introverted.

SapphireSun··on America's Cult of Ignorance (1980) [pdf]
I love Asimov, and he's right that we should educate our population better, but why would anyone pay attention to the papers when it seems completely remote and irrelevant to people's lives? People pay close attention to stuff that they feels significant to them and that they can control. People read the sports section because they can talk about that with their friends and are invested in the outcome. You and I read the politics section for the same reason even though without popular mobilization, we have basically the same effect on outcomes as a sports game.

If policies are promoted that people actually like as opposed to barely resent, they'll start reading and talking and you won't hear the end of it.

SapphireSun··on Why Can’t Americans Get a Raise?
I'm down with that. I just cynically expect that only the part that favors businesses gets delivered and the other stuff gets ground down to nothing over time. Just look at what's happening with the AHCA and Net Neutrality right now.
SapphireSun··on Why Can’t Americans Get a Raise?
If a business was structured to deal with wages elastically, that's great for business, but can you imagine working for such a corporation? In theory, the reason we allow business to profit is because we all share in the benefits, but if a significant chunk of the market were structured like this, a large benefit to ordinary people (i.e. the ability to stabilly eat and shelter themselves) would be removed, removing a large chunk of legitimacy from the economic system.
SapphireSun··on The Facebook Algorithm Mom Problem
My guess is the point of those notifications is that it gives them an excuse to add points to the addictive little red number. It's not because they think you'll actually care.
SapphireSun··on The Konami exodus
The extractive nature of business can't be fixed without changing things more fundamentally, but basic income or another strong safety net combined with free college education and health care makes labor participation much less coercive. If you can say no to a bad deal, the ideals of the free market are realized in much greater force.

Notably, we often respect this in our colleagues. We lionize "fuck you money" and appreciate when our friends have earned their way into the ability to act according to their inclinations. However, at least on this board, I think there is an over emphasis on needing to earn or otherwise deserve that bare level of respect.

Workers saying no in greater numbers provides stronger checks on corporate behavior. A sibling comment discusses worker owned businesses, which is a stronger form of this.

SapphireSun··on WA, NY and CA Governors Announce Formation of United States Climate Alliance
Don't forget all that poor people vote at far lower rates than middle class and rich people. Rich & middle class white people and culture war evangelicals with a small but relatively unusually large smattering of poor people in a few key states put Trump over the top.
SapphireSun··on GM accused of installing devices in diesel trucks to beat emissions tests
It's not clear that they couldn't do it. The three possibilities are:

    1) They couldn't do it.
    2) Their margins would be thinner.
    3) Their competitors are cheating, and emissions controls reduce performance, 
       so everyone would buy the cheating competitor. 
       Also, everyone has dirt on everyone else.
This will be a big story all of the three cases.
SapphireSun··on Accidentally Stopping a Global Cyber Attack
I understand what you're trying to say, but think about what happens when the military strikes a hospital and calls it "collateral damage." While you're correct that these people probably did not intend to damage hospitals, they could have reasonably foreseen that an indiscriminate attack on computer networks around the globe would have deleterious effects on essential infrastructure.

This means that they knowingly or with reckless negligence unleashed such an attack on the world. If they had been more "scrupulous" criminals, they would have more narrowly tailored their attack on targets they believed deserved to be extorted or where such extortion would not interfere with life critical systems.

I'm not a lawyer, but if they were a nation state, I believe they would have violated the Geneva Convention's prohibition on attacking hospitals.

That said, I think this attack gives more weight to NSA critics that contend that their exploit research should be focused more on defense rather than offensive capabilities. Their carelessness combined with another group wanting to embarrass them is what allowed this indiscriminate attack to be inflicted on civilian infrastructure.

SapphireSun··on N.S.A Halts Collection of Americans’ Emails About Foreign Targets
The NYT story was way too friendly in my opinion. It almost took the claims at face value that the agency did this voluntarily. I liked this version better: https://theintercept.com/2017/04/28/nsa-backs-down-on-major-...
SapphireSun··on El Salvador bans metal mining in world first
I think everyone noticed Iraq. You're right, that wasn't a secret coup. :P
SapphireSun··on El Salvador bans metal mining in world first
30 years is not long enough for everyone involved to be dead and no longer influential... and that doesn't even touch on whether the reason it happened is structural.

I'm not sure I understand your second point.

SapphireSun··on Why is this little construction crane illegal in New York City? (2016)
Why would licensing be a barrier to unionizing? Surely a smaller licensed community is easier to unionize, but the whole idea is getting a lot of (skilled or unskilled) people together to bargain collectively when bargaining individually would be ineffective.
SapphireSun··on EPA gives Flint $100M to help repair pipes
America is the richest country in the world and as such attracts the best propagandists on the free market.

American culture has a long individualist streak that distrusts authorities, combined with our many entrenched sins regarding e.g. racism, leaves a significant fraction of the population vulnerable to many effective forms of propaganda... and that's just the right. Except for a few states like MA and VT, the left consistently fails to field candidates that will fight for ordinary people against monied interests because that's where their election funds come from. In the past, leftists were associated with official enemies of the state (e.g. communists, socialists) by major media organizations and trusted authorities. Now most people here distrust their gut instincts about fairness, inequality, the golden rule, and mutual caring.

Many forms of leftist organization were broken down and destroyed after the upheavals of the 60s, with especially aggressive pushes by Regan, but this has continued by both parties up to the present day with Republicans taking mainly larger digs at the integrity of the public trust. This story continues with rather emphasized savagery into the present day starting in 2017.

However, this is an interesting moment where it seems there is a big fight brewing between truly breathtakingly rapacious greed and a significant fraction of the public. It will be interesting to see who wins in the coming decades - it may determine the fate of the planet's suitability for human life.

SapphireSun··on Password Rules Are Bullshit
The last time a company had their password hashes exfiltrated. All the common passwords are quickly broken.
SapphireSun··on A neuroscience experiment failed to build a connectome for a 6502 chip
My lab is one of the reconstruction specialists. We're using electron microscopy (as referenced in the Wired article) to map the ultrastructure of the tissues. I've seen datasets with XY plane (the EM scanning plane) voxels as small as 5nm x 5nm and Z resolution as small as 23nm (though not on the same datasets).

Other labs at different phases of the pipeline are working with various kinds of physiological indicators including taking movies of GCaMP (https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/GCaMP) (a calcium activity indicator) expressing neurons under various behavioral conditions. A glut of calcium ions provide evidence for recent firing of a neuron as calcium is involved in triggering the release of neurotransmitters.

If you're interested in methods, here's a paper describing a dataset we focused pretty heavily on (that's not related to the consortium dataset, but paved the way with developing techniques): Briggman, et al. "Wiring specificity in the direction-selectivity circuit of the retina" (http://www.nature.com/nature/journal/v471/n7337/full/nature0...)

We later did some science with it ;)

JS Kim, et al. "Space–time wiring specificity supports direction selectivity in the retina" http://www.nature.com/nature/journal/v509/n7500/full/nature1...

The pipeline has evolved considerably since those papers came out. We're living in exciting times. :)

SapphireSun··on A neuroscience experiment failed to build a connectome for a 6502 chip
"Can a Neuroscientist Understand a Microprocessor?" argues several points (and is quite an enjoyable read!): 1. Current analytic approaches don't reveal much insight. 2. The authors advocate for using computer architectures as a synthetic model system for developing new analytic techniques. 3. They aren't arguing that the connectome is useless, in fact they needed the connectome to even begin their analysis.

I think the Wired title is a little overblown. I work in a connectomics lab (software, I'm not a scientist yet so take what I say with a grain of salt), and we've been having enjoyable debates about the paper. It's hardly a "war".

What's kind of interesting about the field of connectomics is that the engineering challenges have been massive enough that it's been hard for many labs to do science with their datasets until recently. Several papers have come out (e.g. a fly visual circuit, two dual mouse visual circuits, a few others), but they generally are findings on relatively small volumes. Thanks to a big grant that created a multi-lab consortium, we are getting closer to doing science with a big volume. We're one year into a five year process which will result in a petabyte size open dataset for the world to use.

Because so few datasets have been adequately reconstructed, and most labs have been obsessed with the reconstruction process, I think in the future, as we do more science, we'll discover better ways to glean insight from the neuroanatomy and physiology traces. It's a new field, so I don't think it's unreasonable to expect that there are new methods to learn. I'm happy to talk about what goes into the reconstruction process. :)

SapphireSun··on Do we really need swap on modern systems?
Thank you for the correction. I should have read more carefully. Still, we're talking 3 orders of magnitude for SSD vs RAM.
SapphireSun··on Do we really need swap on modern systems?
SSDs are only ~4x faster than magnetic last I checked. If RAM is 100ns per access, and hd access is down from say, 1ms to 0.25ms, that's still a huge huge gap. 4x isn't even an order of magnitude.

EDIT: see comment below for more accurate numbers.

SapphireSun··on Seven earth-sized planets discovered circling a star 39 light years from Earth
The black hole engines he's referring to glow very hot because they're very small, meaning that the surface of the hole is large compared with its volume. This allows for very bright hawking radiation if I understand correctly. If you stop feeding them they disappear within hours, years, or decades depending on how big they are.
SapphireSun··on Reasonable Person Principle
I agree, but if you can state the things you disagree on concretely, in my view, that is progress.
SapphireSun··on Reasonable Person Principle
Something I'm slowly coming to realize is that unless you have a logically defensible moral position, it's hard to argue with people that disagree. Terms like reasonable are so flimsy it's hard to use it as a model to communicate with people that don't already agree with you.

The successful operation of a principle like "reasonableness" requires an intake filter to suss out whether people joining the department roughly agree on what it means. If someone doesn't agree with your definition of reasonableness, it becomes a bludgeon wielded by both sides that can't be affixed to a definitive state of the world and the winner will necessarily be side that can exert more political force.

Element three is more concrete. "[3)] No one is special."This is the classic statement that all are equal before the law regardless of position in the department, which is the only way to grant popular legitimacy to rules.

"[4)] Do not be offended if someone suggests you are not being reasonable." I feel this rule is a symptom of the lax definition of reasonableness. The reason people become offended when someone accuses them of being unreasonable, is because the standard is so loosely defined that someone can (reasonably, ha!) believe themselves reasonable when others do not.

I read an interesting article the other day where the author took a moral position and reasoned it through [0], showing how it was legally reasoned through in high profile situations. This kind of cooperative principle is harder to state, but more easily defended on grounds that are still require agreement, but in principle can reference an objective reality (e.g. from the article, elements like "proportionality"). Obviously, the referenced article is not a scholarly work, so there is more that can be done, but

I guess this is the kind of thing political science majors learn about in school that I didn't get exposed to as much except through my own reading.

[0] https://extranewsfeed.com/tolerance-is-not-a-moral-precept-1...

SapphireSun··on Republicans hope to overturn internet privacy rules
Telecos are a weird example. They're more like a utility than a product one can live without. This, combined with the massive duplication of effort competition would entail, is the reason why they are so intensively regulated. Oftentimes the government provides funding & loans[1][2], and tax incentives for telecom infrastructure buildout.

For what its worth, the reason telecoms have such low margins is that they are a commodity (which in my opinion, is what they should be). Their lobbying to get the ability to give non-neutral lanes is to give themselves a way to not be a commodity. I don't really see the upside for society as a whole for them to be essentially granted a state monopoly and then decommodify themselves to make things that were cheap more expensive and risk the internet in the process.

Their profits are nearly risk free even if they're relatively low. According to your link, the average return was between ~2% and ~11%. We're not talking about fractional percentages here. A small low risk margin on a lot of money... is still a lot of money. Notice that the ROIC in exhibit 3 lines up nicely with utilities.

I'm not sure where you were getting your info from about wireline divisions, but I found this interesting report: http://marketrealist.com/2015/01/wireless-telecoms-key-indic... It looks like investment in wires has declined by about 40%, but investment in wireless has increased tremendously. I don't know what the absolute numbers are though. I imagine wireless is much cheaper to deploy.

[1] Government funding of rural infrastructure - https://www.usda.gov/wps/portal/usda/usdahome?contentidonly=... [2] Government funding of certain consumer uses (which is free money for the telecos) - http://www.gillibrand.senate.gov/imo/media/doc/Gillibrand%20...

SapphireSun··on Republicans hope to overturn internet privacy rules
You're right to some degree, but there's a practical reality too. If a regulation would make it impossible to do business, and society would like that business to continue then they'll live without the regulation even if it would be good. There's always a cost-benefit tradeoff, and good regulators work with their charges (without getting too cozy) and the public (without listening to the shrillest unsubstantiated voices) to make smart ones.
SapphireSun··on Republicans hope to overturn internet privacy rules
This sounds like a canard. If by "regulate more" you mean the available profit margins are smaller, then yes. However, if profit margins are very high, you can place quite a lot of expensive regulation (not all regulations are expensive, some of them tell you not to do injurious things) and people will still invest.

By its nature, content will drive a huge amount investment. Funneling bits at high speed is an interesting business, but the recombination of those bits has a universe of more possibility in it. I'd be surprised if (after the ecosystem reaches critical mass) content investment always dominates infrastructure investment.

In any case, the case for neutrality is stronger than an abstract argument against an arbitrary regulation. The promise of the internet is that of decentralized many-to-many content generation, i.e. the strong airing of many different opinions by large and small operations. When the people that own the pipes can pick favorites, the strong voices will over time winnow to the favored ones.

This is a pattern that happens over and over again in US media where large corporations are able to pick ideological favorites and narrow the spectrum of discourse to suit themselves. Network neutrality being knocked down is a strategy of corporate dominance over public discourse. Note that very few, very rich, cable companies provide most of the telecommunications for the entire population. Granting them this power allows small groups of individuals with many common interests to pick favorites to a startling degree.

SapphireSun··on Disqus Ads Are No Longer Free to Disable
I see this decision as good in the sense that it allows the people hosting comments sections to pay Disqus directly, allowing it to be somewhat more independent.

The more I learn about advertising, the more I find arguments against it compelling. Disqus is a comment system that facilitates the free exchange of ideas. If it relies significantly on ads, then advertisers can begin to police it by threatening to pull sponsorship. This eliminates productive discussion that threatens the interests of advertisers. For instance, advertisers don't like placing ads alongside people that care too much about things, they prefer people to be lightly entertained and in a buying mood. They also don't like placing their ads alongside controversy, as it can negatively impact their brand.

Thus reliance on advertising introduces an interdependency on a relatively small set of giant corporations' goodwill, even for niche activities and will, which when push comes to shove, substitute their positions for the managers' of Disqus. Allowing advertisements to be turned off actually immunized Disqus somewhat from this problem, but having advertisements on everywhere enables it. Allowing users to pay to turn them off probably more than offsets this, though it does impact exceptionally poor users (who, for some reason, are probably more likely to dissent controversially). That could be ameliorated by case-by-case ad waivers if the issue comes up, though it does come close to Disqus endorsing a controversial issue.

Maybe this seems like a minor issue, but Disqus provides a platform for debate, and advertising can act to bound the limits of debate for better or worse. I would prefer if the Disqus managers could act according to their own moral compass when under pressure.

SapphireSun··on Joining a billion rows 20x faster than Apache Spark
My lab works with multi-terabyte datasets on a regular basis. We have big machines to do machine learning on, but when they're not in used, I can tell you that it's way easier to provision and write a single or multi-threaded script that just loads everything into memory rather than deal with networking and partitioned data.

Imagine the difference between setting up a spark cluster and writing a for loop. For instance, for reasons someone created a 1TB hdf5 file. Luckily, we had a computer with 500GB+ of ram and lots of swap, so instead of having to hack the file apart and figure out how to chunk or parallelize it, we loaded it into memory for a one time batch job and did other useful things in the mean time.

SapphireSun··on Welcome, ACLU
The difference isn't entirely rational, it's that one is a sudden shock and one is (a horrifying) normal.

When something is new and shocking, immediate extensive resistance can blunt the impact of new policies. That would work in the case of horrifying normal situations too, but there's no universal focal point, and focal points around which people can gather matter a lot. Given the existence of a focal point, it becomes rational to protest since others will join you.

← PreviousPage 6 of 30Next →